- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %&'%()*&%)) + !" # # $ %& % " ' " " #& " & && %# () * !" )& "' + # $ & ' (* ' !$('"! %$ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !$ ! & ' %& $ ' '' " , % (!$ ' " ( , ' * ' " ' & , " ' ) & ' %& & -" & ) && ./0123456/72/3434564894:/7;<100=8/75=67/> /03456 ( 59 3./ ".1>134<1 1?1>4@ =>1@8.1 16.431 ( 8//@46? >/?=:1> ;14: 46 2/041: 18/ !$ 5 1>4846? 5=3 59 >4A/ 5 59 140.=> %5A/65:40/313456 140.=>483>403>/?483/>/795>3./ 599/60/8 2=648.1;:/ =67/> /03456 , >/17 B43. /03456 (!$593./".1>134<1<1<116.431(/034568,167 593./>53/0345659.4:7>/69>5A/C=1:99/60/803 167 /034568 * 167 59 3./ >5.4;43456 59 .4:7 &1>>41?/ !1>6131@1 A/67A/63$ 03 , 2/6746? 56 3./94:/593./77434561:483>403167/884568)=7?/167 2/041:)=7?/ 140.=> - 3 - ./018/5>4?4613/89>5A105A2:1463:57?/7;< 3./ 160.1<13 /D/:52A/63 9940/> !$ :/1746? 35 >/?483>13456 59 >4A/ 5 3 48 1::/?/7 3.13 3./ 2/343456/>95>04;:<A1>>4/73./D4034AB.5B1895=6735;/ 1A465>7=>46?164682/034560567=03/7;<3./1:56? B43. 3./ .4:7 %/:91>/ 9940/> 256 46D/834?13456 3./ 2>/8/632/343456/>B.5488313/735;/3./.=8;167593./ A465> D4034A .18 ;//6 0.1>?/8.//3/7 95> 3./ 195>/A/63456/7 599/60/8 167 48 46 E=74041: 0=8357< 8460/ ( ./ :/1>6/7 05=68/: 95> 3./ 2/343456/> >/43/>1346? 3./ ?>5=678 =>?/7 46 3./ 2/343456 2:10/8 >/:4160/ 56 3./ E=7?A/63 59 3./ "5A;1< 4?. 5=>3 !=>16?1;17 "/60.$ 46 ! / 8=;A438 3.13 46 8=;8316341::< 84A4:1> 04>0=A83160/8 B./>/ 16 100=8/7 B18 1::/?/7 35 .1D/ A1>>4/7 1 A465> ?4>:;14:B18?>163/7;<95::5B46?3./2>46042:/8:14775B6 ;<3./56F;:/=2>/A/5=>346"#$%$& - 4 - ' (() (* $+ * , A2.184846? 3.13 46D/834?13456 48 05A2:/3/1670.1>?/8.//3.18;//694:/743480563/67/7 3.13 056346=/7 0=8357< 59 3./ 2/343456/> B5=:7 8/>D/ 65 =8/9=: 2=>258/ 167 3.13 3./ 5=>3 A1< /C/>048/ 438 7480>/34561><25B/>84691D5=>59;14: ./ :/1>6/7 05=68/: 9=>3./> 8=;A438 3.13 3./ D4034AF8 1?/ 48 7482=3/7 167 >/G=4>/8 7//2/> E=74041: 80>=346< / >/:4/8 56 3./ 17.11> 1>7 488=/7 46 B.40. >/9:/038 3./ D4034AF8 713/ 59 ;4>3. 18 ,( 0563>1>< 35 3./ 713/ 59 ;4>3. 8.5B6 46 80.55: >/05>78 18 ,*3483./7/9/60/3.133./2/343456/>;561947/ ;/:4/D/7 3./ 1?/ A/63456/7 46 3./ 17.11> 1>7 167 0563>103/7 3./ A1>>41?/ =67/> 8=0. ;/:4/9 133>10346? 3./ 2>53/03456=67/>/03456*593.//1:852546385=3 3.133./D4034AF8A53./>105100=8/7.18;//6/6:1>?/7 56 ;14: 167 A14631468 3.13 B./3./> 3./>/ B18 1 D1:47 A1>>41?/ 167 B./3./> 3./ >4?5=>8 59 3./ 03 1>/ 133>103/71>/A133/>835;//831;:48./77=>46?3>41:63./ :4?.3 59 0569:40346? 750=A/631>< /D47/60/ >/?1>746? 3./ - 5 - D4034AF81?/ 3./ ;=>7/6 :4/8 563./ 2>58/0=3456352>5D/ 3.133./2/343456/>@65B46?:<A1>>4/71A465> />0563>13./:/1>6/74?.5=>35D/>6A/63 :/17/> >/:<46? =256 3./ 80.55: >/05>78 8=;A438 3.13 2>4A1 9104/ A13/>41: /831;:48./8 3.13 3./ D4034A B18 1 A465> 56 3./ 713/ 59 A1>>41?/ 3./>/;< 133>10346? 3./ 83>46?/63 2>5D484568 =67/> 3./ 03 167 3./ >5.4;4345659.4:7&1>>41?/03/3./>/95>/2>1<83.13 3./ 5=>3 A1< 653 /C/>048/ 7480>/3456 46 91D5=> 59 3./ 2/343456/> , .1D/ 056847/>/7 3./ >4D1: 8=;A4884568 167 01>/9=::< /C1A46/7 3./ 17.11> 1>7 2>57=0/7 167 3./ 0.1>?/8.//3 A13/>41:8 ./ 95::5B46? 25463 1>48/8 95> 056847/>13456 H%./3./> 3./ 2/343456/> .18 A17/ 5=3 1 018/ 95> ?>16359>/?=:1>;14:167B./3./>3.48481943018/95> /C/>048/ 59 E=74041: 7480>/3456 46 .48 91D5=> ;< 4A25846?83>46?/630567434568IJ - 6 - 3 48 ;53. 7483=>;46? 167 748./1>3/646? 35 653/ 3./ >/0=>>46? 3>/67 46 140.=> 483>403 1>4846? 5=3 59 438 85045/0565A40 ;10@B1>76/88 167 4::43/>10< B./>/ A465> ?4>:8 1>/ 593/6 05A2/::/7 4635 A1>>41?/ ;< 3./4> 91A4:4/8 /8243/:/?48:134D/133/A238357/3/>8=0.2>10340/8018/8 59 0.4:7 A1>>41?/ 056346=/ 35 8=>910/ ./ 2>/8/63 018/ 1:85 122/1>8 35 ;/ 1 A1649/8313456 59 850450=:3=>1: 4?65>160/ 167 25D/>3< >/8=:346? 46 D45:134568 59 3./ >5.4;43456 59 .4:7 &1>>41?/ 03 167 0568/G=/6341::< 133>10346?2>5D484568593./03 ./ 91038 >/D/1: 3.13 653 56:< B18 3./ D4034A 1::/?/7:< 1 A465>;=3/D/63./ 100=8/7 122/1>8 35;/ 1 <5=6? A16 1?/7 ;1>/:< </1>8 ./ 7/9/60/ 0563/678 3.13 3./ 2/343456/> ;561947/ ;/:4/D/7 3./ 1?/ >/9:/03/7 46 3./ 17.11> 1>7 %./3./> 3./ 80.55: >/05>78 1>/ 1=3./6340 167 B./3./> 3./ 2>58/0=3456 016 8=;83163413/ 3./ 1::/?/7 A465>43< 59 3./ D4034A >/G=4>/8 /C1A4613456 7=>46?3>41:"/1>46?46A4673./2>46042:/3.13H;14:483./ >=:/ 167 E14: 48 16 /C0/23456J 167 056847/>46? 3./ 85045 - 7 - /0565A40 0563/C3 59 3./ 018/ 1>4846? 9>5A 1 ;10@B1>7 >/?456 3.48 5=>3 48 460:46/7 35 056847/> 3./ >/G=/83 95> ;14: * ./56F;:/=2>/A/5=>346"#$% ') .18 ./:7 3.13 ;14: A1< ;/ 7/64/7 56:< B./>/ 04>0=A83160/88=??/83125884;4:43<593./100=8/79://46? 9>5A E=8340/ 31A2/>46? B43. /D47/60/ 5> /6?1?46? 46 84A4:1> 2>/E=74041: 0567=03 6 3./ 2>/8/63 018/ ;53. 3./ 2/343456/>1673./D4034A;/:56?351D=:6/>1;:/;10@B1>7 0:188 167 3./ 2/343456/> .18 ;//6 46 0=8357< 8460/ %43. 3./ 46D/834?13456 .1D46? 0560:=7/7 167 3./0.1>?/8.//31:>/17<94:/7056346=/74601>0/>13456131 831?/ B./>/ 3./ D4034AF8 1?/ 48 8/>45=8:< 7482=3/7 A1< 2>/E=740/ 3./ 2/343456/>F8 >4?.38 =67/> >340:/ 59 3./ 568343=3456 2>1?A1340 167 8/68434D/ 122>510. 48 B1>>163/7 46 018/8 83/AA46? 9>5A 850450=:3=>1::< 74817D1631?/7 ;10@?>5=678 ./>/95>/ 3.48 5=>3 94678 3.13 /6:1>?46? 3./ 2/343456/> 56 ;14: B43. 83>46?/63 0567434568B5=:765317D/>8/:<199/033./2>58/0=3456 - 8 - ./ D4034AF8 A53./> !100=8/7 5($ 48 2>/8/63 ;/95>/ 3.48 5=>3 167 .18 /C2>/88/7 >/1746/88 35 /68=>/ 3.13 3./ D4034A >/A1468 B43. ./> =634: 13314646? A1E5>43< 167 3.13 3./>/ 8.1:: ;/ 65 05.1;4313456 ;/3B//6 3./ 2/343456/> 167 3./ D4034A ./ 48 B4::46? 35 94:/ 16 =67/>31@46? ;/95>/ 3./ >41: 5=>3 9 ;53. 3./ 2/343456/> 167 3./ D4034AF8 A53./> =67/>31@/ 653 35 >/8=A/ 05.1;4313456 =634: 3./ D4034A 1331468 A1E5>43< 167 9=>3./> =634:./>/D47/60/48>/05>7/7658/>45=82>/E=740/B5=:7 ;/ 01=8/7 35 3./ 2>58/0=3456 6 D4/B 59 3./ 1;5D/ 3./ 25463 9>1A/7 95> 056847/>13456 48 168B/>/7 46 3./ ,-.(/-0.123 '5>3./95>/?546?>/185683.485=>32188/83./ 95::5B46? 4 ./2/34345648 % 44 ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: ;/ /6:1>?/7 56 ;14: 46 2/041: 18/ !$ 5 1>4846? 5=3 59 >4A/ - 9 - 5 59 140.=> %5A/6 5:40/ 313456 140.=> 483>403 >/?483/>/7 95> 3./ 599/60/8 2=648.1;:/ =67/> /03456,>/17B43./03456(!$593./".1>134<1<1<1 16.431 ( /034568 , 167 59 3./ >53/03456 59 .4:7>/6 9>5A /C=1: 99/60/8 03 167 /034568 * 167 59 3./ >5.4;43456 59 .4:7 &1>>41?/ !1>6131@1 A/67A/63$ 03 , 2/6746? 56 3./ 94:/ 59 3./ 77434561:483>403167/884568)=7?/1672/041:)=7?/ 140.=>8=;E/03353./95::5B46?0567434568 1$ ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: /C/0=3/ 1 2/>8561: ;567 95>18=A59 8B43.3B58=>/34/895> 3./ :4@/ 8=A 35 3./ 813489103456 59 3./ E=>4874034561:5=>3+ ;$ ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: 122/1> ;/95>/ 3./ >41: 5=>3561::713/859./1>46?=6:/88/C/A23/795> D1:47>/18568+ - 10 - 0$ ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: 653 74>/03:< 5> 4674>/03:< 3.>/13/6 467=0/ 05/>0/ 5> 31A2/> B43. 16< 59 3./2>58/0=3456B436/88/8+ 7$ ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: 653 46D5:D/ .4A8/:9 46 599/60/859184A4:1>613=>/469=3=>/+ /$ ./ 2/343456/> 8.1:: 653 :/1D/ 3./ 3/>>435>41: E=>487403456 59 3./ >41: 5=>3 B43.5=3 438 2>45> 2/>A488456=634:7482581:593./018/+ 9$ ./ A53./> 59 3./ D4034A100=8/7 5( 8.1:: 94:/16=67/>31@46?;/95>/3./>41:5=>3831346? 3.13 3./ D4034A 8.1:: >/847/ B43. ./> =634: 8./ 1331468A1E5>43<167/68=>46?3.133./>/8.1::;/ 65 05.1;4313456 ;/3B//6 3./ 2/343456/> 167 3./ D4034A =634: 3./ D4034A 1331468 A1E5>43< 18 >/9:/03/7463./0.1>?/8.//3>/05>78+ ?$./2/343456/>8.1::94:/16=67/>31@46?;/95>/ 3./>41:5=>33.13./B4::653188/>316<A1>431: - 11 - >4?.38 5D/> 3./ D4034A =634: 8./ 1331468 A1E5>43< 167 /D/6 3./>/193/> ./ 8.1:: 653 133/A23 35 469:=/60/05/>0/5>2>/D14:=2563./D4034A=634: ./> /D47/60/ 48 9=::< >/05>7/7 ;/95>/ 3./ >41: 5=>3 0/>3494/7 052< 59 3.48 5>7/> 8.1:: ;/ 95>B1>7/7 35 3.//0>/31><483>403/?1:/>D40/8=3.5>43< 140.=>35 5>?1648/ 1B1>/6/88 2>5?>1AA/8 167 B5>@8.528 56 2>/D/63456590.4:7A1>>41?/83.>5=?.5=3 140.=>483>403 4* %!!) $ ) 4835:5,