Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92709 (KAR)

RAMLINGAPPA S/O SANNA SABANNA KAKALWAR v. BASAMMA D/O SIDDAPPA KAKALWAR SINCE DECD.BY LR AND ANR

RSA/200146/2014 · 2025-10-13

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#"" $$ %&#' ( ! ! "# " $ " % ! "& Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! ' ( " %& " ( " ! ! "#(" !! " ! ! "#(" )* " + ! ! "#(" )* "" "%&)++++ $ " % !" "%&, "++ ""%&(%& -- "& " - " ++- """ " "*++ + " " - " " - 3 - - " " - - " , " " " +++ + ++ " " - " " " " " "-- - " " , " " " " " """-" "-- " - - " " " ." ! #" % ." ! & "/01 233425 01 67 8/4 9:19;;411<95 =4<4:=2:8 > 19614?94:8 8@2:1<4@44 ;520A0:B 80854 8/@>9B/ =4<4:=2:8 > 2112050:B 8/4 ;>:;9@@4:8 C9=BA4:81 2:= =4;@44 @4:=4@4= 67 8/4 >9@81 645>D D/4@40: 6>8/ 8/4 >9@81/2E0:B=4;52@4=8/283520:80<<12:==4<4:=2:8 > 2@48/4C>0:8>D:4@1/2E4B@2:84=8/4@4504<><32@8080>:8> 8/4 3520:80<<1 =4;52@0:B 8/28 8/4 1254 =44= >6820:4= 67 =4<4:=2:8 >8/@>9B/=4<4:=2:8 >01:>860:=0:B>: 3520:80<<1' C>0:8 /25< 1/2@4 0: 8/4 1908 1;/4=954 3@>34@87 - 4 - ;;>@=0:B57 8/4 1908 D21 =4;@44= />5=0:B 8/28 8/4 3520:80<<12@44:80854=<>@32@8080>:2:=1432@2843>114110>: >< 8/40@ 4?925 1/2@4 /45= 67 8/40@ <28/4@ 0: 8/4 1908 1;/4=954 3@>34@87 >:14?94:857 =4<4:=2:8 > 19614?94:8 8@2:1<4@44 D21 @418@20:4= <@>A 0:84@<4@0:B D08/ 8/4 3520:80<<1' 342;4<95 3>114110>: "/4 -0@1833455284>9@8/21;>:;9@@4=D08/8/4<0:=0:B><8/4 "@025>9@82:=8/4233425D21=01A0114= ->@ 8/4 12F4 >< 6@4E087 @2:F >< 8/4 32@8041 01 @4<4@@4=8>2134@8/40@@2:F64<>@48/4"@025>9@8 "/4<2A0578@4401219:=4@ "2AA2332 2:A2:8/9%=04=&0==2332%=044=& 2@212332%=04=& "0AA2332 %4<8)&2112AA29BB2AA2 %520:8 >&%520:8 >& 2552AA2 %=04=& - 5 - "/4 3520:80<<1 D/> 2@4 8/4 =29B/84@1 >< >:4 0==2332 8/4 14;>:= 1>: >< "2AA2332 0:1808984= 8/4 3@414:8 1908 144F0:B 2 =4;52@280>: 8/28 8/47 2@4 8/4 C>0:8 >D:4@1><8/419081;/4=9543@>34@8725>:BD08/=4<4:=2:8 >>:14?94:8025578/471>9B/82=4;52@280>:8/288/4 @4B0184@4= 1254 =44= =284= +++ 4G4;984= 67 =4<4:=2:8 > 0: <2E>9@ >< =4<4:=2:8 > 01 :955 2:= E>0=2:= :>860:=0:B 93>: 8/40@ 1/2@4 "/43520:80<<1 251> 3@274= <>@ 2 =4;@44 >< 34@348925 0:C9:;80>: @418@20:0:B =4<4:=2:8 > <@>A 0:84@<4@0:B D08/ 8/40@ 342;4<95 3>114110>:2:=4:C>7A4:8><8/4190852:=2114@80:B8/40@ @0B/88>C>0:83>114110>: 3>: 14@E0;4 >< 19AA>:1 6>8/ =4<4:=2:81 4:84@4= 23342@2:;4 2:= <054= 2 ;>AA>: D@0884: 18284A4:8D/4@40:8/47;284B>@0;2557=4:04=8/43520:80<<1' ;520A >< C>0:8 >D:4@1/03 4<4:=2:8 > 134;0<0;2557 ;>:84:=4= 8/28 8/4 1908 52:= /2= 644: 255>884= 8> /01 <28/4@ 2:A2:8/9 0: 2 3@0>@ <2A057 32@8080>: 8 D21 <9@8/4@ 2E4@@4= 8/28 93>: 8/4 =428/ >< /01 <28/4@ 8/4 - 6 - 3@>34@87 D21 A98284= 0: /01 :2A4 8/4@467 A2F0:B /0A 8/4261>5984>D:4@D08/<955@0B/88>2504:2848/43@>34@87 : 8/01 3@4A014 =4<4:=2:8 > C9180<04= 8/4 1254 0: <2E>9@>< =4<4:=2:8 > 2114@80:B 8/288/4 12A4 D21 2 E250= 2:= 52D<95 ;>:E472:;4 "/4 =4<4:=2:81 8/4@4<>@4 1>9B/8=01A01125><8/41908 "/432@8041D4:88>8@0252:=2==9;4=>@252:= =>;9A4:82@7 4E0=4:;4 0: 1933>@8 >< 8/40@ @4134;80E4 ;520A1 3>: 4E259280>: >< 8/4 4E0=4:;4 >: @4;>@= 32@80;952@57G/060818>8/4"@025>9@8>614@E4=8/28 8/43542><=4<4:=2:8 >:2A4578/288/419083@>34@87 D21255>884=8>/01<28/4@2:A2:8/9D219:1933>@84=67 2:7 =>;9A4:82@7 A284@025 "/4 >9@8 :>84= 8/28 >: 8/4 ;>:8@2@78/4@4;>@=1@4E4254=8/288/4 1908 3@>34@87D21 >@0B0:2557255>884=8> 2@2123320:2<2A05732@8080>:<84@ 2@212332'1 =4A014 8/4 3@>34@87 D21 0:/4@084= 67 /01 D0=>D 2552AA2 D/> 251> =04= 011945411 : 8/28 62;F=@>3 8/4 "@025>9@8 /45= 8/28 8/4 3@>34@87@4E4@84= 8> 8/4 8D> 19@E0E0:B 6@2:;/41 >< 8/4 <2A057 :2A457 8/4 - 7 - 6@2:;/ >< 0==2332 2:= 8/4 6@2:;/ >< 2:A2:8/9 >:14?94:857 8/4 "@025 >9@8 ;>:;59=4= 8/28 8/4 19614?94:8A98280>:0:<2E>9@><=4<4:=2:8 >4<<4;84= 2<84@8/4=428/><2552AA2=0=:>8;>:<4@2:74G;5910E4 >D:4@1/0393>:/0A:>@;>95=/42114@88/288/43@>34@87 D21255>884=1>54578>/01<28/4@ 2E0:B@4;>@=4=2<0:=0:B8/288/43520:80<<12:= =4<4:=2:8 > D4@4 C>0:8 >D:4@1 >< 8/4 1908 52:= 8/4 "@025>9@8A>95=4=8/4@4504<2:==4;@44=8/4190832@857 67 =4;52@0:B 8/28 =4<4:=2:8 > /2= :> 298/>@087 8> 2504:284 8/4 4:80@4 4G84:8 >< 8/4 3@>34@87 0: <2E>9@ >< =4<4:=2:8 > 9:=4@ 8/4 @4B0184@4= 1254 =44= =284= +++4G4;984=<>@2;>:10=4@280>:><1*+++ )8 D212;;>@=0:B57/45=8/288/4120=1254=44=01:>860:=0:B 93>:8/43520:80<<18>8/44G84:8><8/40@/25<1/2@40:8/4 1908 3@>34@87 := 2;;>@=0:B57 B@2:84= /25< 1/2@4 0: 8/4 190852:= - 8 - * 4<4:=2:8 > 640:B 2BB@04E4= 67 8/4 C9=BA4:8 2:= =4;@44 >< 8/4 "@025 >9@8 3@4<4@@4= 2: 23342564<>@48/4-0@1833455284>9@880110B:0<0;2:88> :>848/28D/0543@4<4@@0:B8/4233425=4<4:=2:8 >=0= :>8 0A3542= 8/4 54B25 @43@414:8280E41 >< =4<4:=2:8 > D/> /2= 10:;4 4G30@4= 3>: @4)233@4;0280>: >< 8/4 4E0=4:;4 2:= 8/4 @421>:0:B >< 8/4 "@025 >9@8 8/4 -0@18 33455284 >9@8 <>9:= :> 0:<0@A087 >@ 34@E4@1087 0: 8/4 <0:=0:B1 @4;>@=4= 2:= 2;;>@=0:B57 =01A0114= 8/4 233425 "/4 120= ;>:;9@@4:8 <0:=0:B1 2@4 :>D 2112054= 0: 8/01 14;>:=233425 H "/01 >9@8 67 >@=4@ =284= ++ 2=A0884= 8/4 2334252:= <@2A4= 8/4 <>55>D0:B 196182:8025 ?94180>:1><52D<>@;>:10=4@280>: - 9 - + 42@= 8/4 542@:4= ;>9:145 23342@0:B <>@ 8/4 2334552:8 =4<4:=2:8 > 2:= 8/4 542@:4= ;>9:145 23342@0:B<>@8/4@413>:=4:81 3520:80<<1 "/01 >9@8 /21 B0E4: 081 2:G0>91 ;>:10=4@280>: 8> 8/4 3542=0:B1 8/4 >@25 2:= =>;9A4:82@7 4E0=4:;4 352;4=>:@4;>@=2:=8/4;>:;9@@4:8<0:=0:B1@4;>@=4=67 6>8/8/4>9@81645>D D/054=4;@440:B8/43520:80<<1'1908 "/4 @4;>@=1 /2E4 644: A480;95>9157 4G2A0:4= 0: 8/4 62;F=@>3><8/4196182:8025?94180>:1><52D<@2A4=288/4 80A4><2=A0110>:><8/01233425 )*+,-./*0123+/3.+450)23./+6 ;5>14 1;@980:7 >< 8/4 D@0884: 18284A4:8 <054= 67 =4<4:=2:8 > @4E4251 8/28 :> 3542 >< 50A08280>: D21 4E4@@2014=67/0A0:8/43542=0:B164<>@48/4"@025>9@8 "/4 ;>@4 =4<4:;4 2=E2:;4= 67 =4<4:=2:8 > D21 8/28 - 10 - 8/4190852:=/2=644:255>884=8>/01<28/4@2:A2:8/9 0: 2 <2A057 32@8080>: 2:= 93>: /01 <28/4@'1 =4A014 8/4 3@>34@87 =4E>5E4= 93>: /0A 21 2 5211) /40@ 9:=4@ 8/4 0:=9 9;;4110>: ;8 "/4 ;214 >< 50A08280>: D21 :408/4@ 3542=4=:>@41826501/4= "/4 542@:4= ;>9:145 23342@0:B <>@ 8/4 2334552:8 =4<4:=2:8 >/>D4E4@1>9B/88>2=E2:;42: 2@B9A4:8 8/28 10:;4 8/4 :2A4 >< =4<4:=2:8 > D21 A98284=0:8/4@4;>@=><@0B/8134@820:0:B8>8/4190852:= 0AA4=028457 2<84@ 8/4 =428/ >< 2552AA2 0: 8/4 742@ H** 8/4 12A4 ;>:1808984= 2: 2;8 >< >9184@ 2:= 8/4@4<>@4 8/4 3520:80<<1' 1908 <054= A9;/ 5284@ >9B/8 8> /2E4644:62@@4=6750A08280>: "/01 ;>:84:80>: 0: 8/4 ;>:10=4@4= E04D >< 8/01 >9@8 01 D/>557 A01;>:;40E4= 2:= 9:191820:2654 0: 52D 4@4A98280>:><8/4:2A4><>:4;>)1/2@4@>@;>)/40@0: 8/4@4E4:94@4;>@=1=>41:>8 67 08145< ;>:1808984 >9184@ >@ 41826501/ 4G;5910E4 3>114110>: 98280>: 4:8@041 2@4 - 11 - A20:820:4=3@0A2@057<>@<01;2539@3>1412:==>:>8;>:<4@ 80854:>@4G80:B901/8/452D<95@0B/81><>8/4@;>)/40@1"> ;>:1808984 >9184@ 8/4@4 A918 64 ;542@ 9:4?90E>;25 2:= />18054 2;81 >: 8/4 32@8 >< >:4 ;>)>D:4@ D/0;/ 2@4 0:;>:10184:8 D08/ 8/4 C>0:8 >D:4@1/03 >< >8/4@1 ;>9354= D08/ 2;8925 3/710;25 =013>114110>: >< 8/4 ;>)/40@1 2:= 2: 2114@80>:><4G;5910E4>D:4@1/038>8/40@F:>D54=B4 : 8/4 3@414:8 ;214 8/4@4 2@4 :> 3542=0:B1 D/281>4E4@ 2554B0:B 19;/ 2;81 >< >9184@ >@ 4G;5910E4 3>114110>: 67 =4<4:=2:8 > : 8/4 ;>:8@2@7 8/4 4E0=4:;4 >: @4;>@= ;542@57 41826501/41 8/28 8/4 1908 3@>34@87 >@0B0:2557 645>:B4= 8> 2@212332 2:= 93>: /01 =4A0148/412A4D210:/4@084=67/01D0=>D2552AA2 D/>=04=011945411>:14?94:8578/43@>34@87@4E4@84=8> 8/4 8D> 19@E0E0:B 6@2:;/41 >< 8/4 <2A057 :2A457 8/4 6@2:;/><0==23322:=8/46@2:;/><2:A2:8/96>8/>< D/>AD4@45211)/40@14:80854=8>19;;44=8>8/4418284 ><2552AA2D/>/2==04=0:8418284 - 12 - 801251>@454E2:88>:>848/288/43520:80<<12@4 8/4 =29B/84@1 >< 0==2332 >:10=4@0:B 8/4 3@4E2050:B 1>;025;0@;9A182:;4108;2::>864>E4@5>>F4=8/28A2@@04= =29B/84@1><84:@410=42D27<@>A8/42:;418@25/>A42:= A27 :>8 64 2D2@4 >< 19614?94:8 A98280>:1 4<<4;84= 9:05284@2557 67 A254 A4A64@1 >< 8/4 <2A057 4:;4 19;/ 9:05284@25 @4E4:94 4:8@041 ;2::>8 64 ;>:18@94= 21 />18054 2114@80>:><>D:4@1/03>@21;@4280:B2;2914><2;80>:<>@ 50A08280>:8>@9: "/4 @4;>@=1 0:;59=0:B G/06081 8> ;284B>@0;25570:=0;2848/288/43@>34@8718>>=0:8/4:2A4 >< 2@212332 2:= 8/4@42<84@ 0: 8/4 :2A4 >< 2552AA2 8/4@467:4B280:B8/4=4<4:;435428/288/452:=D214E4@ 255>884=8>2:A2:8/9"/419614?94:84:8@70:8/4:2A4 >< =4<4:=2:8 >2<84@8/4 =428/ >< 2552AA2 D218/91 D08/>98 54B25 <>9:=280>: 2:= ;>95= :>8 4G80:B901/ 8/4 54B080A284@0B/81><8/43520:80<<10:8/419083@>34@87 - 13 - * :E04D><8/4<>@4B>0:B=01;9110>:8/01>9@801 >< 8/4 ;>:10=4@4= >30:0>: 8/28 :> 3542 >< 50A08280>: >@ >9184@/21644:A2=4>98>:8/462101><8/43542=0:B1>@ 4E0=4:;4>:@4;>@=>:14?94:85796182:8025#94180>:>< 2D > =>41 :>8 2@014 <>@ ;>:10=4@280>: 0: 8/01 233425 2:=012;;>@=0:B572:1D4@4=0:8/4 )*+,-./*20123+/3.+470)23./4+6 H 4<>@4 8/01 >9@8 3@>;44=1 <9@8/4@ =44A1 08 <08 8> ;955 >98 8/4 3@274@ ;>59A: >< 8 /4 3520:8 A>@4 32@80;952@57 3@274@ > 8/4 12A4 01 4G8@2;84= D/0;/ @42=1219:=4@ ! " # $%%& '' '(! $(#'$# ''(! " # $%%& '' '(! $(#'$# ''(! " #$ ) " # #* + : 2 ;2@4<95 @42=0:B >< @274@ > 0: 8/4 3520:8 08 01 4E0=4:8 8/28 8/4 3520:80<<1 /2E4 1>9B/8 2 - 14 - =4;52@280>: 8/28 8/4 @4B0184@4= 1254 =44= =284= +++ 4G4;984= 67 =4<4:=2:8 > 0: <2E>9@ >< =4<4:=2:8 > 01 :955 2:= E>0= 2:= :>8 60:=0:B 93>: 8/4A "/4 <>9:=280>: >< 8/01 @4504< @4181 >: 8/4 2114@80>: 8/288/43520:80<<1640:B8/4=29B/84@1><0==2332/2E4 2: 0:=434:=4:8 2:= 54B080A284 1/2@4 0: 8/4 1908 1;/4=954 3@>34@87 "/4 120= @0B/8 <5>D1 <@>A 8/40@ 182891 21 ;>) 1/2@4@10:8/42:;418@25418284@43@414:80:B8/46@2:;/>< 0==2332 D/> D21 >:4 >< 8/4 8D> 1>:1 >< 8/4 >@0B0:25 3@>3>10891"2AA2332 8 01 8/91 A2:0<418 8/28 =4<4:=2:8 > D/> @43@414:81 8/4 >8/4@ 6@2:;/ >< 8/4 <2A057 8/@>9B/ 2:A2:8/9 ;>95= :>8 /2E4 52D<9557 ;>:E474= 8/4 4:80@4 4G84:8 >< 8/4 1908 52:= 8> =4<4:=2:8 > 21 /01 @0B/81 D4@4;>:<0:4=>:578>/019:=0E0=4=1/2@4:72504:280>: A2=4 67 >:4 ;>)>D:4@ 0: @4134;8 >< 8/4 4:80@4 C>0:8 3@>34@87D08/>988/4;>:14:8><8/4>8/4@;>)>D:4@1;2: 28 6418 >34@284 >:57 8> 8/4 4G84:8 >< /01 >D: 1/2@4 2:= - 15 - ;2::>8 =0E418 8/4 52D<95 >D:4@1/03 >< 8/4 @4A20:0:B ;>) 1/2@4@1 "/4 3520:80<<1 8/4@4<>@4 D4@4 C9180<04= 0: 144F0:B 2 =4;52@280>: 8/28 8/4 2504:280>: A2=4 67 =4<4:=2:8 > 0: <2E>9@ >< =4<4:=2:8 > D21 :>8 60:=0:B>:8/40@54B080A2841/2@4"/43@274@0:8/43520:8 D/4:@42=0:0813@>34@;>:84G8;542@570:=0;28418/288/4 3520:80<<1D4@4:>8144F0:B8>2E>0=8/44:80@41254=44=0: 0814:80@487698D4@4;>:<0:0:B8/40@;/2554:B4>:578>8/4 4G84:8 >< 8/40@ 9:=0E0=4= 0:84@418 0: 8/4 3@>34@87 "/4 4G3@4110>:I:9552:=E>0=2:=:>860:=0:B>:8/43520:80<<1J 914= 0: 8/4 3520:8 A918 8/4@4<>@4 64 ;>:18@94= 0: 2 @418@0;84= 14:14 21 2 ;/2554:B4 8> 8/4 1254 =44= >:57 8> 8/44G84:8><8/43520:80<<1'1/2@42:=:>8212:261>5984 =4;52@280>:0:E250=280:B8/41254258>B48/4@ "/4 "@025 >9@8 D/054 A>95=0:B 8/4 @4504< @0B/857 0:84@3@484= 8/4 3520:80<<1' 3@274@ 0: 8/01 50B/8 2:= /45=8/288/41254=44==284=+++D21:>860:=0:B - 16 - >: 8/4 3520:80<<1 8> 8/4 4G84:8 >< 8/40@ /25< 1/2@4 D/054 542E0:B 8/4 1254 0:82;8 0:1><2@ 21 8/4 1/2@4 >< =4<4:=2:8 > D21 ;>:;4@:4= "/4 -0@18 33455284 >9@8 /21 251> ;>:;9@@4= D08/ 8/01 @421>:0:B 2:= 2<<0@A4= 8/28 8/4 =4;52@280>: 1>9B/8 D21 50A084= 0: :289@4 2:= D/>557 C9180<04= : 8/01 E04D >< 8/4 A2884@ 8/4 ;>:84:80>: 2=E2:;4= >: 64/25< >< 8/4 2334552:8 =4<4:=2:8 > 8/28 8/4 3520:80<<1 /2= :>8 1>9B/8 2: 261>5984 =4;52@280>: 2B20:18 8/4 4:80@4 1254 =44= 01 D08/>98 A4@08 "/4 @4504< 1>9B/8 2:= B@2:84= 67 8/4 >9@81 645>D 1?92@457 250B:1 D08/ 148854= 3@0:;03541 B>E4@:0:B ;>)>D:4@1/03 2:= 2504:280>:67>:4;>)1/2@4@ ;;>@=0:B57 8/01 >9@8 <0:=1 8/28 96182:8025 #94180>: >< 2D > =>41 :>8 2@014 <>@ ;>:10=4@280>: 0: 8/4 3@414:8 233425 2:= 8/4 12A4 01 2:1D4@4= 0: 8/4 - 17 - ->@8/4<>@4B>0:B@421>:18/01>9@83@>;44=8> 32118/4<>55>D0:B "/423342501=4E>0=><A4@082:=2;;>@=0:B57182:=1 =01A0114= 42@:4= ;>9:145 @0 2:=443 0C272F9A2@ 2805 01 34@A0884=8><054E2F2528/0:8/4><<0;4D08/0:8D>D44F1 -& %""' # " 018 >5 >* "