- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " # $ "" %& ' $$ " ($ " ( "! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "$$ $$ ) "* $ " %& $ ( ! " $ "" %& " " " " $" " " %& '$" ( "+ ( """ $ "! "+ + !+( "$ " + " " " )&& $ " ( " $ + ( && " $"" " $ " " $ + """+" *" " $$ + " " (" # # ,"$ - 3 - $ $#,"$ ! "-./ 011203 ./ 4.325 060.7/8 8-2 090:5 50825 )&& 10//25 .7 ( ;&& <= 8-2 27.;: .>.3 ?562 075 55.8.;703 "-;:01?:"-252@20/250-2<;;</0<0625 0<;?8=20:/A289.8-070@@.5278;7B)0755.25 "-2 9.42 075 @-.35:27 ;4 8-2 52@20/25 4.325 @30.A 128.8.;7 @30.A.76 @;A127/08.;7 ;4 /% 9.8- .782:2/8 "-2 ":.<?703 @;7/.52:.76 8-2 2>.527@2 ;7 :2@;:5 6:07825 @;A127/08.;7;4/B%9.8-.782:2/808)C12:077?A 4:;A8-25082;4128.8.;78.33:203.D08.;7 66:.2>25 <= 8-2 /0.5 ;:52: 8-./ 011203 ./ 4.325 /22E.7627-07@2A278;4@;A127/08.;7.79-.@-.8./@;7827525 8-08 8-2 52@20/25 90/ 5;.76 @;;3.2 9;:E 075 20:7.76 /%12:A;78-?88-2":.<?703-0/80E27-./.7@;A2 0//)%12:A;78-075.782:2/803/;./8;<26:0782508 8-2:082;4BC12:077?A 20:58-20:6?A278/;4<;8-/.52/ - 4 - "-2 52@20/25 90/ 0625 =20:/ 08 8-2 8.A2 ;4 0@@.5278 8 ./ /80825 8-08 8-2 52@20/25 90/ 20:7.76 /%12:A;78-<?87;5;@?A278/-0>2<2271:;5?@25 8; 1:;>2 -./ .7@;A2 "-2 52@20/25 A28 9.8- 07 0@@.5278 ;7 B) 075 8-2:24;:2 0/ 12: 8-2 6?.523.72/ ;4 8-2 0:7080E0 8082 2603 2:>.@2/ ?8-;:.8= -./ .7@;A2 ./ 8; <2 80E27 0/ /&% 12: A;78- "-2 52@20/25 ./ 278.8325 4;: C;4.7@;A28;90:5/4?8?:21:;/12@8/0/12:8-2F?56A278 ;4 8-2 ;7,<32 ?1:2A2 ;?:8 .7 8-2 @0/2 ;4 0758-./ 8; <2 525?@825 8;90:5/ -./ 12:/;703 2G127/2/ 0/ 12: 8-2 F?56A278 ;4 8-2 ;7,<32 ?1:2A2 ;?:8 .7 8-2 @0/2 ;4 /8-252@20/25 90/ 0625 =20:/ 8-2 A?38.13.2: 90/ :.6-83= 80E27 <= 8-2 ":.<?703 0/ 075 .8 7225/ 7; .782:42:27@2 ; 8-2 3;// ;4 52127527@=@;A2/8;/)% &HC%8-G G! 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 5 - /12:8-2F?56A278;48-2;7,<32?1:2A2;?:8.7 8-2 @0/2 ;4 ! " # " $ % 075 & ! ' ( )' *128.8.;72:;<2.768-29.42 ;4 8-2 52@20/25 ./ 278.8325 4;: /1;?/03 @;7/;:8.?A ;4 /&% 075 128.8.;72: ;/ 8; <2.76 8-2 @-.35:27 0:2 278.8325 4;: 10:27803 @;7/;:8.?A ;4 /&% 20@- "-?/ 8-2= 0:2 278.8325 4;: 3;// ;4 @;7/;:8.?A ;4 /% &IJ%! 075 /)% ./ 6:07825 ?752: 8-2 @;7>278.;703-205/0/12:8-2@.808.;7.7 )70338-2@30.A078/0:2278.83254;:8-2@;A127/08.;7 ;4 /% 9.8- .782:2/8 08 )C 12: 077?A 0/ 060.7/8 /B%090:525<=8-2":.<?703 "-2090:5;4@;A127/08.;710//25<=8-2":.<?703./ A;5.4.250/?752:# 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 6 - 205/ A;?78.7/ ;//;42127527@= )% ;//;4;7/;:8.?A % ";90:5/;7>278.;703205/ )% *+, - &78-2:2/?388-24;33;9.76;:52:./10//25# .! 11203./033;925.710:8 ..! "-2 30.A078/ 0:2 278.8325 4;: 8-2 8;803 @;A127/08.;7;4/%9.8-.782:2/808)C 10 4:;A 8-2 5082 ;4 128.8.;7 8.33 8-2 5082 ;4 :203.D08.;7 ...! "-2 :2/1;75278 .7/?:07@2 @;A107= -0/ 03:205= 521;/.825 8-2 090:5 0A;?78 <24;:2 8-2 ":.<?703 075 8-2:24;:2 8-2= 0:2 5.:2@825 8; 521;/.8 8-2 27-07@25 @;A127/08.;7 9.8- .782:2/8 08 )C 12: 077?A9.8-.7;72A;78-4:;A8-25082;4@;1=;4 8-./;:52: >! 7 /?@- 521;/.8 8-2 4.:/8 128.8.;72:%9.42 ;4 8-2 52@20/25 03;72 ./ 12:A.8825 8; 9.8-5:09 8-2 - 7 - 27-07@25@;A127/08.;703;769.8-.782:2/80@@:?25 ;7.88-2:/;7/;452@20/250:2A0F;: ./- &% ( $ ./8;#3;#