- 1 - !"#$# %$ && '' (&) * ! " # $%$&'& "' ())"&" ##$ "$"&" #$%# ())"& "%%)*+# &*$&"$&" &%$&"$& #, Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! ## "'%"!# # "'&"&* +&'&" # # # # - $ ./00123423 56738129 /27 /:/;7 7/917 "'&"&* </==17 >? 77494@2/0 124@; 4A40 6731 /27 /0/>6;/34 B@; =.@;9 -9;4>62/0-! 42 2@+&'&" 9.4= /<<1/04=B4017 ;4 /2511A /940 01/;217 C@62=10 B@; /<<100/29 =6>849917 /<<1/0 :/= >? C0/48/29 B@; 12./2C18129 @B C@8<12=/94@22&*&*&":.12C0/48/29$D/=./27.4= B;4127 /;0423:1;1;47423@28@9@;C?C012@$%$)%'@2 17/8$/0/>6;/34;@/77;4A1;@BC/;2@$%$&'&7;@A149 42 ;/=. /27 213043129 8/221; /27 7/=.17 /3/42=9 8@9@;C?C01 C/6=423/CC471292=/47/CC47129C0/48/29$ /;0423=6=9/4217 3;41A@6=4256;41=01/74239@/8<69/94@2@B.4=;43.9013/>@A1 - 3 - D21171=<4919/D4239;1/98129 .1;1B@;1.1B4017C0/48<19494@2 6271; 1C94@2 "EE @B @9@; 1.4C01= C9 /3/42=9 @:21; /27 42=6;1;@BC/; % 2 C@291=9 :.1;142 C0/48 <19494@2 :/= @<<@=17 712?423 /31 @CC6</94@2 /27 42C@81 @B C0/48/29 /= :100 /= /0013423C@29;4>69@;?21304312C1/3/42=9;471;@B8@9@;C?C01/27 A4@0/94@2 @B 91;8= /27 C@27494@2= @B <@04C? 9;4>62/0 B;/817 4==61=/27;1C@;7171A4712C10/48/291F/84217.48=10B/27 ;/A4 .4A/;/?/ /= =" /27 /27 3@9 8/;D17 F=" "'1=<@27129=7472@901/71A4712C1 * 2 C@2=471;/94@2 ;4>62/0 .107 /CC47129 ./7 @CC6;;177619@;/=./272130431297;4A423@BC/;>?49=7;4A1; C0/48/29 ./7 =6=9/4217 <1;8/2129 <.?=4C/0 74=/>4049? /27 0@=9 1/;2423 C/</C49? /27 :/= 12949017 B@; C@8<12=/94@2 /==1==17 >?49/3/42=942=6;1;/=B@00@:=$ " /42/27=6BB1;423 *&&&&$ 174C/01F<12=1= "E**$ % @==@B1/;2423=76;4230/47$6<<1;4@7 )&&$ * @==@BB696;11/;242374=/>4049? '"&&$ ) 69;494@6=B@@7/27/99127/29C./;31= &&&&$ E @==@BB696;1/8124941=/270@==@B./<<421== &&&&$ +,- !!. / - 4 - @9=/94=B417:49./:/;7C0/48/29:/=42/<<1/0 ) 9 :/= B4;=90? =6>849917 C0/48/29 ./7 =6=9/4217 /8<69/94@2@B;43.9013/>@A1D211 .1;1B@;19;4>62/0:/=2@9 56=94B417/:/;7423@20?*&&&&$9@:/;7=</42/27=6BB1;4239 :/= =6>849917 9;4>62/0 /0=@ 1;;17 42 2@9 /77423 B696;1 <;@=<1C9= 9@ 8@29.0? 42C@81 :.4C. :/= 42 A4@0/94@2 @B ;/94@ 0/477@:2>?@2G>016<;181@6;942C/=1@B " 9 :/= =6>849917 9.1;1 :/= /69@ /8<69/94@2 @B ;43.9 048> />@A1 D211 /==1==17 >? :.4C. ./= ;1=60917 42 <1;8/2129 <.?=4C/0 74=/>4049? @B &H @:1A1; 9;4>62/0 /==1==17 B62C94@2/074=/>4049?/9%&H:.4C.:/=2@956=94B417/27=@63.9 B@;12./2C18129 E 9 :/= =6>849917 C@8<12=/94@2 /:/;717 9@:/;7= 0@== @B 1/;2423 76;423 0/47$6< <1;4@7 9@:/;7= 2@6;4=.8129 /99127/2C1 /27 0@== @B /8124941= /9 &&&&$ :/= @2 0@:1; =471 /27 =@63.912./2C18129 9 :/= =6>849917 9;4>62/0 ./7 /0=@ 1;;17 42 2@9 /:/;7423 /2? C@8<12=/94@2 9@:/;7= B696;1 8174C/01F<12=1= 1 &%!&''* - 5 - ' 2 @9.1; ./27 ;4 6>./=. /00/<6; 01/;217 C@62=10 B@; ;1=<@27129(42=6;1; @<<@=17 C0/48/29G= /<<1/0 B@; 12./2C18129 1/;7 01/;217 C@62=10 /27 <1;6=17 48<63217 56738129/27/:/;7 + #;@8 />@A1 @20? <@429 9./9 :@607 /;4=1 B@; C@2=471;/94@24= /814=/2=:1;17</;90?42/BB4;8/94A1B@;B@00@:423;1/=@2= "& #;@8 />@A1 @CC6;;12C1 @B /CC47129 42A@0A423 42=6;17A1.4C017619@;/=./272130431297;4A423@BC/;>?49= 7;4A1; C0/48/29 =6=9/42423 <1;8/2129 <.?=4C/0 74=/>4049? /27 0@== @B 1/;2423 C/</C49? /27 42=6;1; >1423 04/>01 9@ </? C@8<12=/94@2/;12@94274=<6912=@B/;/=8@29.0?42C@8149 :/= =9/917 9./9 C0/48/29 :/= :@;D423 /= 7;4A1; 1/;2423 "&&&$<1;8@29.@:1A1;9;4>62/0C@2=471;17.4=8@29.0? 42C@81/9"*)&$42C1=/814=42C@2=@2/2C1:49.2@94@2/0 42C@81/7@<917>?B@;=199018129@BC/=1=>1B@;1@D$ - 6 - /7/0/949:@607>156=94B4170/48/29./=/78499170?=6=9/4217 /8<69/94@2 @B ;43.9 048> />@A1 D211 @;8/00? 42 C/=1 @B /8<69/94@2 <1;4@7 @B =4F 8@29.= ./= 9@ >1 9/D12 /= 0/?@BB .6=C0/48/29:@607>1129490179@))&&$9@:/;7=0@==@B 42C@8176;4230/47$6<<1;4@7 ;4>62/0./=/:/;717*&&&&$ 9@:/;7= </42 /27 =6BB1;423 2 A41: @B 71C4=4@2 @B @2G>01 6<;181 @6;9 42 C/=1 @B !"# :.1;142 ")&&&&$ :/= /:/;717 42 C/=1 @B /8<69/94@2 /:/;7 >? 9;4>62/0 :@607 2@9 >1 56=94B417 =/81 4= 12./2C17 9@ ")&&&&$ ;4>62/0 ./= /:/;717 "E**$ 9@:/;7= 8174C/0 1F<12=1= /3/42=9 >400= <;@76C17 42C1 9.1;1 4= C@8<0191 ;148>6;=18129 9.1;1 :@607 >1 2@ =C@<1B@;12./2C18129 /D4232@91@B42</94129<1;4@7@B912 7/?=9;4>62/0./=/:/;717&&&&$9@:/;7=B@@7/99127/2C1 /27 C@2A1?/2C1 C./;31= :.4C. /<<1/;= 56=9 /27 <;@<1; 2@ 12./2C18129 ;4>62/0./=/:/;717&&&&$9@:/;7=0@==@B /8124941=2A41:@B71C4=4@242$%& '$(%& ) ' =/81 4= 12./2C17 9@ ")&&&&$ 2 F+ $ 74=/>4049? C1;94B4C/91 9.1;1 4= ;1B1;12C1 9@ /;94B4C4/0 048> C@=9423 ")&&&$ /D423 2@91 @B =/81 ;1I64;18129 @B <1;4@74C/0 2 &" 3 &""!"%*% - 7 - 8/42912/2C1 /27 ;1<0/C18129 49 :@607 >1 /<<;@<;4/91 9@ /:/;7 "&& 0/D. 9@:/;7= B696;1 8174C/0 1F<12=1= .@63. /==1==17048>74=/>4049?/9&H9/D4232@91@BB/C99./9 C0/48/29 :/= E ?1/;= @B /31 /27 .4= /A@C/94@2 /= </4291; /==1==8129 @B B62C94@2/0 74=/>4049? /9 %&H :@607 2@9 >1 56=94B4179:@607>1/<<;@<;4/919@C@2=471;49/9E&H=<1; 71C4=4@2 G= C/=1 =6<;/! *&H ./= 9@ >1 /7717 9@:/;7=B696;1<;@=<1C9=9@8@29.0?42C@81=42C1C0/48/29:/= E ?1/;= /27 =10B 18<0@?17 .6= C@8<12=/94@2 9@:/;7= B696;10@==@B42C@81:@607>1 "*)&$J*&H!F"F"'FE&HK**"&$ /814=/:/;7179@C0/48/29 "" .6= C0/48/29 4= .107 12949017 B@; ;1$/==1==17 C@8<12=/94@26271;9.1B@00@:423.1/7= " /42/27=6BB1;423 ")&&&&$ 174C/01F<12=1= "E**$ % @==@B1/;2423=76;4230/47$6<<1;4@7 )&&&$ * @==@BB696;11/;242374=/>4049? **"&$ ) 69;494@6=B@@7/27/99127/29C./;31= &&&&$ E @== @B B696;1 /8124941= /27 0@== @B ./<<421== ")&&&&$ ' #696;18174C/01F<12=1= +,- !!!!/ - 8 - " @429 B@; C@2=471;/94@2 4= /2=:1;17 </;90? 42 /BB4;8/94A1@2=1I61290?B@00@:423 4 <<1/04=/00@:1742</;948<6321756738129 /27 /:/;7 7/917 "'&"&* </==17 >? 77494@2/0 124@; 4A40 6731 /27 @9@; CC47129 0/48= ;4>62/0 /0/>6;/34 42 2@+&'&" 4= 8@74B417 C0/48/29 4= .107 12949017B@;9@9/0C@8<12=/94@2@B%""""&*$ /= /3/42=9 ""***$ /:/;717 >? ;4>62/0 :49. 4291;1=9 /9 ;/91 @B EH <1; /2268 /= /:/;717>? ;4>62/0 44 2=6;1; 4= 74;1C917 9@ 71<@=49 =/81 >1B@;1 9;4>62/0:49.42/<1;4@7@B=4F:11D= 0/ (&& ) $ 4=9@"0@*