- 1 - !" #$%$$ $ &' &()* &)) + ! " # $ % $ &' % ' % Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( &' ! $ # $ )& $ ! # & $ !%# % ( '*' + ' , ( % $ )'& $ !))& $ '# , " $ $ -''' ! $ &' $ # $ $ $ " " $ $ $ " $ " % *' $ % . " ! . " # /01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 <5=28>06>64 733806? >??@03A39:;4/35@93@2>1139:;4/383>@639@8014@0<4 >69 3110561 5B@4 >8>:B@>?0 56 >6 >2280<>4056 70839 B693@ 3<4056 )'& 57 @ C/3@306 234040563@1 15B?/4 4@>6173@ 57 <@0=06>8 2@5<33906? 236906? 06 - 3 - 5-''' 56 4/3 7083 57 " $ 5B@4 /06</5880 45 998 014@0<4 >69 3110561 "B9?3 >8>:B@>?0 3>@639 3110561"B9?3/>1@3D3<4394/3>2280<>4056/58906?4/>404 01654=>064>06>:83 /3 234040563@ 5 C/5 01 4/3 <5=28>06>64 06 @0=3 5'*' 133E1 4@>6173@ 57 2@5<33906?1 06 5-''' 236906? :375@3 4/3 83>@639 @06<02>8 0A08 "B9?3 >69 " $ /06</5880 45 4/3 5B@4 57 4/3 83>@639 3110561 "B9?3 56 4/3 2@3=013 4/>4 :54/ =>443@1 <561404B43 > <>13 >69 <5B643@ <>13 4 01 4/3 123<070< <564364056 57 4/3 234040563@1 4/>4 106<3 :54/ 1341 57 >883?>40561 >@013 5B4 57 4/3 1>=3 06<09364 4/3 <>131 >@3 @3FB0@3945:34@039:;563>694/31>=35B@4065@93@45 >A509 <56780<406? DB9?=3641 >69 45 361B@3 > 7>0@ >69 <5=2@3/3610A3>9DB90<>4056 380>6<30128><39564/3$B88 36</ DB9?=364 57 4/01 5B@4 06 C/0</8>;195C64/>4 06 <>13 >69 <5B643@ <>13 104B>40561 :54/ <>131 =B14 :3 1 68063' & - 4 - 4@039 10=B84>635B18; :; 4/3 1>=3 "B9?3 563 >743@ 4/3 54/3@>69132>@>43DB9?=3641=B14:3@3693@39 5C3A3@ 4/01 5B@4 70691 4/>4 4/3 1>09 <564364056<>6654:3><<393945>44/0114>?3/3@3<5@9 @3A3>81 4/>4 06 @0=3 5'*' C/0</ 01 @3?0143@39 56 4/3 <5=28>064 57 234040563@ 5 75@ 4/3 57736<31 2B601/>:83B693@3<40561!#!@#574/3</39B839>1431 >69</39B839@0:31!@3A364056574@5<04031#<4*&* >69 3<40561 ') >69 ' 57 4/3 6A3140?>406? 770<3@/>170839>G+@325@4520606?4/>465<>1301=>93 5B4 34040563@ 5 C/5 01 4/3 <5=28>06>64 4/3@306 />1 069339 70839 > 2@54314 =3=5 >69 /01 1C5@6 14>43=364 01 >815 @3<5@939 /B1 4/3 =>443@ 01 14088 >4 4/3 14>?3 57 <561093@>4056574/3G+@325@4>6965<5?60H>6<3/>1;34 :3364>E36:;4/323<0>8"B9?3B693@4/34@5<04031<4 68311 >69 B6408 4/3 83>@639 3110561 "B9?3 C/5 01 4/3 23<0>85B@4@3D3<414/3G+@325@4>692@5<3391454>E3 <5?60H>6<3 57 4/3 57736<31 >883?39 :; 4/3 <5=28>06>64 4/3@3<>6654:31>09453I014>J<>13KC04/064/3=3>606? - 5 - 57><@0=06>82@5<33906?<>2>:8357:306?<8B::395@D50648; 4@039C04/4/3<5B643@<>13236906?:375@34/3 >?014@>43 ) /3 $B88 36</ 93<01056 06 51>E3@0 06?>22> !1B2@># <5643=28>431 > 104B>4056 C/3@3 </>@?3 1/3341 />A3:3367083906:54/4/3<>13>694/3<5B643@<>13>69 <5?60H>6<3/>1:3364>E3606:54/=>443@1/32@06<0283 5710=B84>635B14@0>8:;4/31>=3"B9?301>2280<>:83568; C/3@3:54/<>131>@3236906?4@0>8>693A0936<30145:3 83906@3123<4574/31>=306<09364 6 4/3 2@31364 <>13 >1 56 9>43 06 @0=3 5'*'4/3@30165</>@?31/3345@<5?60H>6<3568; > G+ @325@4 01 1B:=04439 /3@375@3 4/3@3 01 65 4@0>8>:83 2@5<33906? :375@3 4/3 23<0>8 5B@4 C/0</ <5B89 :3 <8B::39C04/5-'''236906?:375@34/3" $ /3 >2280<>4056 133E06? 4@>6173@ 5@ <8B::06? 01 4/3@375@3 2@3=>4B@3>6983?>88;B6436>:83>44/01DB6<4B@3 />4>2>@4040110?6070<>644565434/>44/34C5 2@5<33906?1 >@3 >815 4@0>:83 :; 5B@41 57 901406<4 - 6 - DB@0190<4056>8 <5=23436<3 /3 57736<31 >883?39 06 @0=3 5'*' 06A58A3 06A5<>4056 57 4/3 2@5A010561 57 4/3 </39B839 >1431 >69 </39B839 @0:31 !@3A364056 57 4@5<04031#<4C/0</>@33I<8B10A38;4@0>:83:;4/323<0>8 5B@4 <561404B439 B693@ 3<4056 ) 57 4/3 1>09 <4 6 <564@>14 4/3 <5B643@ <>13 06 @0=3 5'&' <B8=06>406? 06 5-''' 23@4>061 45 57736<31 B693@ 4/3 690>6 36>8 593 C/0</ >@3 4@0>:83 :; > >?014@>43683114/323<0>85B@4>11B=31130106574/3 <>13:;@3D3<406?4/3G+@325@4>694>E06?<5?60H>6<34/3 FB314056 57 4@>6173@@06? 4/3 >?014@>43+1 <>13 45 4/3 23<0>8 5B@4 9531 654 >@013 >1 04 C5B89 >=5B64 45 4@>6173@@06? > A>8098; 061404B439 2@5<33906? :375@3 > <5=234364 >?014@>4345>5B@4C/0</9531654;34/>A3 ><5@@31256906?<5?60H>6<3236906?:375@304 - 6 A03C 57 4/3 >:5A3 83?>8 >69 2@5<39B@>8 0=2390=36414/015B@401574/3<561093@39A03C4/>44/3 2@31364 @3FB314 45 C04/9@>C >69 <8B: 4/3 2@5<33906?1 06 5-''' C04/ @0=3 5'*' 01 C/588; - 7 - 2@3=>4B@3 /3 2@523@ <5B@13 >4 4/01 14>?3 01 75@ 4/3 83>@639 3110561 "B9?323<0>8 5B@4 45 3I2390405B18; <561093@ >69 93<093 56 4/3 G+ @325@4 70839 :; 4/3 6A3140?>406? 770<3@ 7 4/3 83>@639 "B9?3 B256 <561093@>4056574/32@54314=3=5>69=>43@0>856@3<5@9 @3D3<414/3G+@325@4>694>E31<5?60H>6<3574/357736<31 >883?39:;234040563@5568;4/36C5B894/32@06<028357 10=B84>635B1 4@0>8 06 > <>13 >69 <5B643@ <>13 104B>4056 <5=30645523@>4056 & <<5@906?8; C/083 4/01 5B@4 01 654 06<80639 45 ?@>64 4/3 2@>;3@ 75@ 4@>6173@ >4 4/01 14>?3 > 90@3<4056 01 011B39 45 4/3 83>@639 3110561 "B9?323<0>8 5B@4 45 3I239043 <561093@>4056 57 4/3 G+ @325@4 06 @0=3 5'*'>69452>11>22@52@0>435@93@14/3@356C04/06 > 23@059 57 75B@ C33E1 7@5= 4/3 9>43 57 @3<3024 57 4/01 5@93@2@5A09394/3<5=28>06>64/>1657B@4/3@3A0936<345 :3 @3<5@939 6 4/3 3A364 4/3 G+ @325@4 01 @3D3<439 >69 <5?60H>6<3 01 4>E36 80:3@4; 01 @313@A39 45 4/3 234040563@1 45=5A3>6>2280<>4056B693@3<4056)'&57@:375@3 - 8 - 4/3 3110561 "B9?3 133E06? C04/9@>C>8 >69 10=B84>635B1 4@0>8 57 :54/ <>131 06 ><<5@9>6<3 C04/ 4/3 ?B09380631 8>09 95C6:;4/3$B8836</0651>E3@006?>22>!1B2@># * 088 1B</ 40=3 4/3 G+ @325@4 01 93<0939 >69 <5?60H>6<3 07 >6; 01 4>E36 4/3 <@0=06>8 2@5<33906?1 06 5-''' 236906? :375@3 4/3 @06<02>8 0A08 "B9?3 >69 " $ /06</5880 1/>88 2@5<339 069323693648; >69 1/>88 654 :3 C04/9@>C6 5@ <8B::39 C04/ >6; 54/3@ <>13 ' %04/ 4/313 5:13@A>40561 4/3 23404056 14>691 >1:306?2@3=>4B@3 ,* &$$) % " 014585