- 1 - ! "#!$ # % &%'() *&%(( + ! "# # $ # % # # # & ## % #&'( ! ") ## #$ #% * %( # # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # *( % # %% # '( '+( % ( # % % ) ") $ )% # % # , # # -) # "# -) # $ #./0102324/5/51/66/573.6628./05.19:;57.8<:0 63. =.6262:5.0 /51 02 )/>/1/0 3/3/?;1125 8./05.1 #2@3 :;06:4.05>.568./1.0<:063.0.7=:51.56&6/6. 327 =.6262:5 27 <28.1 ;51.0.962:5 * :< A26363.<:88:A25@=0/B.0 !" #$%& ' " (%) (*% '" %+ , - .- / 0 - 1 '2 ' 3 4 - 3 - %/967 25 ?02.< A3293 /0. ;6>:76 5.9.77/0B <:0 127=:7/8:<63.=0.7.56=.6262:5/0./7;51.0 ' >6 55/=;05/ ,: .42510/==/ 3.C5::0 0.721.56 :< :325:0 4288/@. <28.1 / 9:>=8/256 A263 /563/8/ :829. 6/62:5 9:56.5125@ 63/6 3.0 3;7?/51 .42510/==/ =:77.77.1 /59.760/8 8/51 >./7;025@ /90.7 ' @;56/7 25 ;04.B:* 25:325::04288/@.259.63.B3/15:277;.7 63.200.8/624.7?B5/>.)/B/C;>/0/D/C;>/0/:3/5/?/2 42726.1 63.> /51 6:81 63/6 >/730.. ,: /E>/5 .4/==/5/4/0 >/B ?. 60./6.1 /7 63. <:76.0 1/;@36.0 /51 63. 8/51.1 =0:=.06B >/B ?. 7.668.1 25 3.0 </4:;0 /51 73. A:;818::C/<6.063.>628863.2082<.62>. /6.0 63.B 9/>. 6: C5:A 63/6 >/730.. 25 63. @;27.:<3/425@/@2<61..1.E.9;6.190./6.1/7/8.1..125 3.0 5/>. ,3.5 63. 7/>. A/7 F;.762:5.1 63.0. A/7 /5 /86.09/62:5 5 6327 0.@/01 63.0. A/7 / =/593/B/6 3.81 25 /B(*2563.=0.7.59.:<63.9:>=8/25/563.03;7?/51 >/730.. .81.07 /51 0.8/624.7 3.0. A/7 /87: /5 /==829/62:5<28.1A26363. /3/7281/0 <<29.0<:09/59.88/62:5:< 63.7/217/8.1..1 - 4 - 563/60.@/01=.6262:5.0/51:63.073/4./?;7.1 63. 9:>=8/25/56 /51 3.0 3;7?/51 63/6 63.B 3/4. ?.9:>. :81/5163.B73:;815:6824./5B8:5@.0/5163.B73:;8112. /7.1 :5 63:7. A:017 ?.25@ <0;760/6.1 25 63. 82<. :5 ((/6/?:;6 ((/>3;7?/51:<63.9:>=8/25/56 A.56:;6721.63.3:;7./511215:60.6;05 * 3.0.8/624.7A3:7.56257./093:< .42510/==/ 9/>. /51 2562>/6.1 63. 9:>=8/25/56 63/6 3.0 3;7?/51 3/7 9:>>266.1 7;2921. ?B 3/5@25@ /51 63.0.<:0. 7:;@36 <:0 /962:5/@/2576>/730../51:63.07 :829. /<6.0 0.@276.025@ 63. 9/7. /00.76.1 63. =0.7.56=.6262:5.0:5((( G 3. /66.>=6 >/1. ?B 63. =.6262:5.0 6: 7..C /5 :01.0 <:0 @0/56 :< ?/28 27 0.D.96.1 ?B 63. 8./05.1 .772:57 );1@./5163.0./<6.063.=.6262:5.027?.<:0.6327:;06 * 02 324/5/51 /66/573.662 A:;81 9:56.51 63/6 63.=.6262:5.0?.25@63.3;7?/51:< >/730..3/15:6325@ 6:1:A26363.25921.56/5163.7/8.1..13/7?..5.E.9;6.1 - 5 - 4:8;56/028B25</4:;0:<63.A2<.:<63.=.6262:5.0/51/7=.0 63. =/593/B/6 63.0. A.0. 7:>. ;51.076/5125@ 63/6 3/7 0./93.1 /51 A263:;6 63.0. ?.25@ /5B =0:4:9/62:5 A3/67:.4.063.1.9./7.1<:07:>.:63.00./7:59:>>266.1 7;2921./51/</87.9:>=8/2569/>.6:?.8:1@.1/@/257663. =.6262:5.0 /51 7:;@36 <:0 @0/56 :< ?/28 #. /87: =:256.1 :;6 63/6 63. :63.0 /99;7.1 =.07:57 3/4. ?..5 @0/56.1 /56292=/6:0B ?/28 /51 63.B 3/4. 9:&:=.0/6.1 A263 63. 254.762@/62:5 #.<;063.0 9:56.517 63/6 7259. 63. /00.76 :< 63. =.6262:5.0 27 :5 ((( 63. 254.762@/62:5 A:;81 3/4. =0:@0.77.1 6: 9:5721.0/?8. .E6.56 /51 9:5625;/62:5 :< 63. /99;7.1&=.6262:5.025D;1292/89;76:1B275:8:5@.0A/00/56.1 G #. /87: 9:56.51.1 63/6 >.0. ;66.025@ :< 63. A:01763/6H@:/5112.IA:;815:6 >/C.:;6/9/7. :< /?.6>.56 6: 7;2921. /7 =.0 63. 7.668.1 =02592=8.7 :< 8/A /517:;@36<:0@0/56:<8/A ! 8./05.1 #2@3 :;06 :4.05>.56 8./1.0:==:7.763.?/28=.6262:5?B9:56.5125@63/62563. - 6 - @;27.:<@.6625@/@2<61..1A2<.:<63.=.6262:5.0@:6/7/8. 1..1 <0:> 63. 1.9./7.1 6/C25@ /14/56/@. :< 63. </96 63/6 63. 1.9./7.1 /51 63. 9:>=8/25/56 121 5:6 3/4. 932810.5 :< 63.20:A5#./87:9:56.51.163/67;<<292.56>/6.02/873/4. ?..59:88.96.1?B63.254.762@/62:5/@.59BA3.0.?B63.0.27 /120.965.E;7?.6A..563.25921.56/5163.=.6262:5.03.0.25 /5163.0.<:0.7:;@36<:00.D.962:5:<63.?/28 #/425@3./0163./0@;>.567<0:>?:63721.76327 :;06=.0;7.163.>/6.02/8:50.9:01>.629;8:;78B + 5 7;93 =.0;7/8 :< 63. >/6.02/8 :5 0.9:01 6327 :;0627:<63.9:5721.0.1:=252:563/67259.63./00.76:<63. =.6262:5.0 3/7 6/C.5 =8/9. :5 ((( 254.762@/62:5 A:;813/4.?..5=0:@0.77.1/9:5721.0/?8..E6.56 '( %/96 :< @0/5625@ /56292=/6:0B ?/28 6: 63. 9:& /99;7.1 =.07:57 /51 A3: 3/4. 9:&:=.0/6.1 A263 63. 254.762@/62:5 /@.59B 27 6/C.5 5:6. :< ?B 6327 :;06 A328. 9:5721.025@63.?/280.F;.76:<63.=.6262:5.0 - 7 - '' ,3.63.0/6/88>.0.;66.025@:<63.A:017H@:/51 12.I A:;81 />:;56 6: /?.6>.56 6: 9:>>26 7;2921. :0 5:6 9/55:6 ?. 1.921.1 ?B 6327 :;06 /6 6327 76/@. ?B 3:8125@ / >252602/8 ' ;<<29. 6: 7/B 63/6 63. 9:5625;/62:5 :< 63. =.6262:5.0 25 D;1292/8 9;76:1B 27 5: 8:5@.0 A/00/56.1 3/425@ 0.@/016:63.=.9;82/0</967/519209;>76/59.7:<63.9/7.:5 3/51 ' 63.0 /==0.3.572:57 :< 63. =0:7.9;62:5 9/5 ?. >.6A263?B2>=:725@7;26/?8./5176025@.569:51262:5 '* 99:0125@8B63.<:88:A25@:01.0 "2$ .6262:5/88:A.1J "22$ 3.=.6262:5.027120.96.16:?..58/0@.1 :5?/28:56/C25@/?:5125/7;>:<7((((& A263:5.7;0.6B<:063.82C.7;>6:63.7/627</962:5 :<63.602/8/@2760/6.J "222$ 3. =.6262:5.0 73/88 /66.51 63. :;06 0.@;8/08BJ - 8 - "24$ 3. =.6262:5.0 73/88 5:6 630./6.5 63. =0:7.9;62:5A265.77.725/5B>/55.0J "4$ 3. =.6262:5.0 73/88 5:6 8./4. 63. D;02712962:5:<21/012760296A263=02:0=.0>2772:5J "42$ 2:8/62:5 :< /5B:5. :< 63. 9:51262:5 ?B 63.=.6262:5.0A:;81.56268.63.=0:7.9;62:56:7..C <:09/59.88/62:5:<?/28 ,) %$( ! # 276:'8:'(