Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92662 (KAR)
MANAPPAGOUDA S/O HANAMAGOUDA BIRADAR v. ISHAPPA YALAGURDAPPA ILAKAL AND ANR
MFA/201058/2016 · 2025-11-17
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92662 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92662 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$ %& $
%& "&#" $$
'#( )* $$
$$
)
*
! "
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
# $%&"'" (
)*+))&'++! *
( $%&,"'" *'"'-""-"',**-%-& (*,"**'"-*%"**'"! (". (*! ( (
"- "! (
*'"'''')
( (
/
*+-*'",
"%,*'" (
)
*
! - 3 -
"
# $%&"'" (
)*+))&'++! *
( $%&,"'" *'"'-""-"',**-%-& (*,"**'"-*%"**'"! (". (*! ( (
"- "! (
","'''')
( (
/
*+-*'",
"%*'" (
)
*
'
- 4 -
! "
# $%&"'" (
)*+))&'++! *
( $%&,"'" *'"'-""-"',**-%-& (*,"**'"-*%"**'"! (". (*! ( (
"- "! (
","'''')
( (
/
*+-*'",
"%&*'" (
(0 (
1
1
- 5 -
& 1
! " 2343 5663574 89:3; 3<=>?9 "- "! ?@ ?=?;
32><734 <= "+&& 23;3>95@=3; ;3@3;;3: =? 54 A=23 <=0! 25B3C339@>73:CD=23<75>E59=4<257739F>9F=23<?EE?9 G8:FE39= :5=3: *+'-*'", 65443: CD =23 ::>=>?957 >4=;><= #
344>?94 8:F3 # 3EC3; )/ >G5D568;5 >9
?4"%,*'"
"%*'" 59:
"%&*'"
* (5<=4 F>B>9F ;>43 =? =23 @>7>9F ?@ =23 5663574 C;>3@7D 4=5=3: 5;3 =25= "'*'" 5= 5C?8= "*'' 9??9 ?9 3C5F3;>) 3B??; ;?5: 935; =23 759: ?@ ?93 5775665 595F> ?@
59?42> >775F3 H239 =23 <75>E59=4 H3;3 =;5B37>9F >9 8E 8E 8=? ;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ =?H5;:4 3B??; 4>:3 =23 :;>B3; ?@ =23 45>: B32><73 :;?B3 =23 45E3 >9 J>FJ5F E5993; >9 5 ;542 59: 93F7>F39= E5993; 7?4= <?9=;?7 ?B3; =23 45>: B32><73 59:=23;3CD=2345>:B32><73=8;9=8;=73?9=23;?5:4>:3
- 6 -
4 5 ;3487=?@ =23 5@?;345>: 5<<>:39= =23 <75>E59=4 >9 577 =23 <75>E 63=>=>?94 484=5>93: F;>3B?84 >9G8;>34 59: H3;3 2?46>=57>J3:
- 23<75>E59=4@>73:63=>=>?9489:3; 3<=>?9",,?@=23 <=433I>9F<?E63945=>?9=H546735:3:=25==23D4639= 4>F9>@><59=5E?89==?H5;:4E3:><573K639434<?9B3D59<3 <25;F34 59: ?=23; ;375=3: <?4=4 = H54 @8;=23; 6735:3:
=25= =23 5<<>:39= ?<<8;;3: 4?737D ?9 5<<?89= ?@ ;542 59: 93F7>F39=:;>B>9F?@=23?@@39:>9FB32><73CD>=4:;>B3;
6?9 43;B><3 ?@ 9?=><3 =23 ;346?9:39= ?4" 59: * 56635;3: =2;?8F2 <?89437 59: @>73: H;>==39 4=5=3E39=4 :39D>9F=235B3;E39=4E5:3>9=23<75>E63=>=>?94
% 9 =23 C54>4 ?@ =23 6735:>9F4 ?@ =23 65;=>34 =23 75>E4;>C8957@;5E3:=23>4483459:=23;35@=3;;3<?;:3:
=23 3B>:39<34 23 ;>C8957 CD >E68F93: G8:FE39= 59:
5H5;:254:>4E>443:=23<75>E63=>=>?94
3>9F5FF;>3B3: =236;3439=566357425B3C339@>73:
- 7 -
, 23735;93:<?8943756635;>9F@?;=23<75>E59=4>9577 =23566357425448CE>==3:=25==235<<>:39=?<<8;;3::83 =? =23 93F7>F39= :;>B>9F ?@ =23 58=?;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ 23 <?E675>9= 7?:F3: CD =23<?E675>959=>3?93 59F5665
>;5:5;>4>99?H5D ;375=3: =?
=23 <75>E59=4 23 <?E675>959= E39=>?93: =23 B32><7398EC3;54)*&%-+"3@8;=23;48CE>==3:=25= 4>9<3 =23 <75>E59=4 H3;3 43;>?847D >9G8;3: 59: 25: C339 42>@=3:=?=232?46>=57=23DH3;39?=>956?4>=>?9=?7?:F3 =23 <?E675>9= >EE3:>5=37D 5@=3; =23 5<<>:39= 9
"+'*'" H239 =23 ?7><3 :;3H 5 525J5; =23D E39=>?93: =23 B32><73 >9B?7B3: >9 =23 5<<>:39= 54 ) *+)&'++ 23 ?7><3 5@=3; >9B34=>F5=>?9 43>J3: =23 B32><73 ?9 "%'%*'" 59: ;3L834=3: =23 @@><3; =? <?9:8<= 59 >9463<=>?9 @=3; =2?;?8F2 >9B34=>F5=>?9 =23 ?7><3 @>73: =23 <25;F3 4233= 5F5>94= =23 :;>B3; ?@ =23 58=?;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ 23;3@?;3 >= >4 B3;D <735; =25= =23 45>: :;>B3; ?@ =23
- 8 -
58=?;><I425H H54 >9B?7B3: >9 =23 5<<>:39= 23 ;>C8957 ?97D ?9 =23 C54>4 ?@ =23 <?E675>9= 7?:F3: CD =23 <?E675>959= H2? >4 >9 9? H5D ;375=3: =? =23 <75>E59=4 :>4E>443: =23 <75>E 63=>=>?94 3 @8;=23; 48CE>==3: =25= =23;346?9:39=$948;59<3?E659D2549?=3K5E>93:59D H>=934434 ?; 6;?:8<3: 59D :?<8E39=4 =? 42?H =25= =23 B32><73 >9B?7B3: >9 =23 5<<>:39= >4 )*&%-+" 59: =23D 25B39?=3K5E>93:=23:;>B3;?@=23?@@39:>9FB32><73574? 39<3234?8F2=@?;577?H>9F=235663574
9=23?=23;259:=23735;93:<?8943756635;>9F@?; =23 948;59<3 ?E659D 254 48CE>==3: =25= =23 58=? ;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ H54 9?= >9B?7B3: >9 =23 5<<>:39= 23 <75>E59=4 =? E5I3 @5743 <75>E 25B3 >E67><5=3: =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 >9 =23 5<<>:39= 3 @8;=23; 48CE>==3: =25= =23 <?E675>959= 254 463<>@><577D 4=5=3: >9 =23 <?E675>9= =25= =23 B32><73 >9B?7B3:>9=235<<>:39=54)*&%-+"23?H93;?@=23 ?@@39:>9FB32><73254574?@>73:H;>==394=5=3E39=:39D>9F =23 >9B?7B3E39= ?@ =23 58=?;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9
- 9 -
?)*+)&'++@=3;<?94>:3;>9F577=23435463<=4=23 ;>C8957 254 ;>F2=7D :>4E>443: =23 <75>E63=>=>?94 39<3 234?8F2=@?;:>4E>4457?@=235663574
& 35;: =23 735;93: <?89437 @?; =23 65;=>34 59: 63;843:=23G8:FE39=59:5H5;:?@=23;>C8957
+ =>49?=>9:>468=3=25==23<75>E59=425B3484=5>93: >9G8;>34>9=23;?5:=;5@@><5<<>:39=?<<8;;3:?9"'*'" :83=?;54259:93F7>F39=:;>B>9F?@=23?@@39:>9FB32><73 CD>=4:;>B3;
"' EE3:>5=37D 5@=3; =23 5<<>:39= =23 <75>E59=4 H3;3 42>@=3: =? =23 2?46>=57 9 =23 :>4<25;F3 48EE5;D 6;?:8<3: 54 K& >= >4 <735;7D E39=>?93: =25= =23 <75>E59=448@@3;3:>9G8;>34>9=23;?5:=;5@@><5<<>:39=23 <?E675>959= 7?:F3: =23 <?E675>9= E39=>?9>9F =23 B32><73 >9B?7B3:>9=235<<>:39=54)*&%-+"
"" 23 463<>@>< <543 ?@ =23 <75>E59=4 >4 =25= =23 <?E675>959= >4 >9 9? H5D ;375=3: =? =23E 59: =23
- 10 -
<75>E59=4F5B3=23<?;;3<=B32><7398EC3;?9"+'*'" 239=23?7><3:;3H=23525J5;>=>4<735;7DE39=>?93: =25==23B32><73>9B?7B3:>9=235<<>:39=>4)*+)&'++ 59: >= >4 574? =23 <543 ?@ =23 <75>E59=4 =25= =23 ?7><3 5@=3;=2?;?8F2>9B34=>F5=>?9@>73:=23<25;F34233=5F5>94= =23 :;>B3; ?@ =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ 3>=23; ?@ =23 65;=>34 3K5E>93: =23 <?E675>959=?;=239B34=>F5=>9F@@><3;B394?E3?@=23 654439F3;4H2?25:=;5B3773:57?9FH>=2=23<75>E59=4>9 =23 58=?;><I425H C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ 59: =23 ?7><3 H2? :;3H =23 525J5; 54 63; K- H2? 5;3 =23 3D3H>=934434 =? =23 5<<>:39= 4=5=>9F =25= =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?)*+)&'++ H54>9B?7B3:>9=235<<>:39=H3;3574?9?=3K5E>93:23 ;>C8957?97D?9=23C54>4?@=23<?E675>9=7?:F3:CD=23 <?E675>959=:>4E>443:=23<75>E63=>=>?94
"* 9B>3H?@=235C?B3H35;3?@=23?6>9>?9=25==23 E5==3;4 ;3L8>;3 =? C3 ;3E>==3: C5<I =? =23 ;>C8957 @?; @;342<?94>:3;5=>?9=?F>B359?66?;=89>=D=?3K5E>93=23
- 11 -
?=23; <?)654439F3;4 H2?
=;5B3773: 57?9F H>=2 =23 <75>E59=4 >9 =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 =23 9B34=>F5=>9F @@><3; =23 :;>B3; ?@ =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9?)*+)&'++59:=23<?E675>959=
"- <<?;:>9F7DH365443:=23@?77?H>9F?;:3;
5! 2356635745;3 C! 23<?EE?9G8:FE39=:5=3:*+'-*'",65443:CD =23;>8C957>9?4"%,*'""%*'"59:
"%&*'">423;3CD43=54>:3 <! 23 E5==3;4 5;3 ;3E>==3: C5<I =? =23 ;>C8957 H>=2 7>C3;=D =? =23 65;=>34 =? 5::8<3 5::>=>?957 3B>:39<3 59: =? 6;?:8<3 5::>=>?957 :?<8E39=4 59: 574? =? 3K5E>93 =23 <?E675>959= <?)654439F3;4 :;>B3; ?@ =23 ?@@39:>9F B32><73 C35;>9F 3F>4=;5=>?9 ?) *+)&'++59:=239B34=>F5=>9F@@><3;
:! 23 ;>C8957 >4 :>;3<=3: =? ;3<?94>:3; =23 E5==3;4 5@;342>95<<?;:59<3H>=275H
- 12 -
3! 2365;=>34>9577=23<75>E63=>=>?945;3:>;3<=3:=? 56635;C3@?;3=23;>C8957?9
H>=2?8= 59D@8;=23;9?=><3
+) '$ ( &
+) '"&#"( &
>4=?" 7?'