- 1 - !" #$# %$!&&! !!'' (&) * ! " #$!%! " & '$'(%)* * && !)'*'*+( '$!%! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " & '$'(%)* && ' & !,! " & & '$, & - ! * " && !)! & & " & " %!**%** &' )*%*! & & & " . $ /011234534 6784923: 038 0;0<8 80:28 %!**%** =0>>28 ?@ 881 235A< 5B51 7842 038 &'580< C 580<DA<>/A<:.<5?7301. 533A)*%*!:/5>0==2015> D5128 * <5 0>0B0<06 0:/ 120<328 EA73>21 >7?95::28 :/0: 0==201 ;0> D5128 ?@ E105903: DA< 23/03E2923: AD - 3 - EA9=23>0:5A3 : ;0> >7?95::28 A3 !$%,*%*! E105903: ;0> <585349A:A<E@E123A'$ '+(*%A3580<'03302F/215<A08 ;/23<582<AD9A:A<E@E123A'$'(%)*<A825:53<0>/038 32415423: 90332< 038 80>/28 04053>: E105903:G> 9A:A<E@E12 E07>5340EE5823:3>0580EE5823:E105903:>7>:053284<52BA7> 5367<52> 038 ;0> 0895::28 :A A>=5:01 2>=5:2 :0F534 :<20:923: /2 858 3A: <2EAB2< D711@ 038 >7>:05328 =2<90323: =/@>5E01 85>0?515:@1A>> AD 20<3534 E0=0E5:@ /2<2DA<2 /2 D5128 E1059 =2:5:5A3 7382< 2E:5A3 !(( AD E: 04053>: <582< A;32<>AD9A:A<E@E1203853>7<2< 3EA3:2>:;/2<253E1059=2:5:5A3;0>A==A>28A3 0114<A738>53E17853401124534EA3:<5?7:A<@32415423E2B5A10:5A3 AD =A15E@ EA385:5A3> 038 E1059 ?2534 2HE2>>5B2 2:E <5?7301 D<0928 5>>72> 038 <2EA<828 2B5823E2 105903: 2H095328 /59>21D0>"!038<0115F0<6730>"*H>!:A!* ;2<24A:90<F282>=A3823:>8583A:120803@2B5823E2 , 3 EA3>582<0:5A3 <5?7301 /218 0EE5823: /08 AEE7<<28872:A<0>/03832415423:<58534AD9A:A<E@E12?@<582< AD 53>7<28 9A:A<E@E12 E105903: >7>:05328 =2<90323: =/@>5E01 - 4 - 85>0?515:@1A>> AD 20<3534 E0=0E5:@ 038 ;0> 23:5:128 DA< EA9=23>0:5A3D<A953>7<2<0>DA11A;> 1 A 208> 9A73: ! A>>ADD7:7<253EA92 !,*%%' * 053C>7DD2<534 %%%%' 285E012H=23>2> +%**+' , A>>AD53EA9287<5341058'7==2<5A8 **%%%' &AA8 038 3A7<5>/923: EA3B2@03E2 0380::23803:E/0<42> !%%%%' ( A>>ADD7:7<209235:52> *%%%%' +,- . / 5>>0:5>D528;5:/>092=<2>23:0==201;0>D5128 ( :;0>D5<>:1@>7?95::28E105903:>7>:05328D<0E:7<2 AD 12D: :5?50 038 D5?710 0=0<: D<A9 D<0E:7<2 AD 12D: <0857> 7130 382<>7E/E5<E79>:03E2>0;0<8AD>%%%%':A;0<8>=053 038>7DD2<534;0>53082I70:2/A74/E105903:/08>:0:28:/0: /2 ;0> ;A<F534 0> 04<5E71:7<5>: 038 20<3534 >!%%%' =2< 9A3:/ :<5?7301 0>>2>>28 5: 0: >!!%%%' =2< 9A3:/ >092 <2I75<28 23/03E2923: : ;0> >7?95::28 :/0: "* 0>>2>>28 =2<90323:=/@>5E0185>0?515:@0:J:A0DD2E:28159?<5?7301 EA3>582<28 0: !%J D73E:5A301 85>0?515:@ ;/5E/ ;0> A3 1A;2< >5825F2;5>20;0<8AD>*%%%%':A;0<8>1A>>AD09235:52> ;/23E105903:/08>7>:05328=2<90323:=/@>5E0185>0?515:@;0> A31A;2<>582:;0>>7?95::280;0<8ADEA9=23>0:5A3:A;0<8> - 5 - 1A>>AD53EA9287<53410587='=2<5A8;0>01>AA31A;2<>582038 >A74/:23/03E2923: ) 3 A:/2< /038 <5 780<>/03 120<328 EA73>21 DA<<2>=A3823:3A*53>7<2<A==A>280==201 $ 20<8 120<328 EA73>21 038 =2<7>28 59=74328 6784923:0380;0<8 + 53E2 E105903: 5> 53 0==201 DA< 23/03E2923: AD EA9=23>0:5A3=A53::/0:;A7180<5>2DA<EA3>582<0:5A35> K"/2:/2< E105903: 5> 23:5:128 DA< 23/03E2923: AD EA9=23>0:5A30>>A74/:DA<LM !% &<A9 0?AB2 AEE7<<23E2 AD 0EE5823: 53BA1B534 53>7<28 B2/5E12 872 :A <0>/ 038 32415423: <58534 ?@ 5:> <582< E105903: >7>:053534 =2<90323: =/@>5E01 85>0?515:@1A>> AD 20<3534E0=0E5:@03853>7<2<?2534150?12:A=0@EA9=23>0:5A3 0<2 3A: 53 85>=7:2 105903: 5> 53 0==201 DA< 23/03E2923: 3>AD0< 0> 9A3:/1@ 53EA92 E105903: >:0:28 :/0: /2 ;0> ;A<F534 0> 04<5E71:7<5>: 038 20<3534 >!%%%' =2< 9A3:/ A;2B2< >092 ;0> 3A: >7?>:03:50:28 3 0?>23E2 AD >=2E5D5E 90:2<501 :<5?7301 ;0> 67>:5D528 53 0>>2>>534 5: 3A:5A3011@ 7: 3A:5A30153EA92DA<@20<*%*!?2534>!,*%'0>08A=:28?@ 0<30:0F0 :0:2 2401 2<B5E2> 7:/A<5:@ DA< >2::12923: AD - 6 - E0>2> ?2DA<2 AF 8010:/ :<5?7301 ;A718 3A: ?2 67>:5D528 53 :0F534 0: >!!%%%' =2< 9A3:/ : /0> :A ?2 EA3>582<28 0: >!,*%' !! > =2< "* E105903: >7>:05328 =2<90323: =/@>5E0185>0?515:@ADJ:A12D:1A;2<159?3H'85>0?515:@ E2<:5D5E0:20>;2110>5382=A>5:5A3/282=A>280?A7:<2>:<5E:5A3 AD9AB2923:ADF322:2382<32>>AB2<F3220380?A7:1A>>AD 97>E12>:<234:/A;2B2<85>0?515:@A3>0580EEA73:5>3A:28:A ?20:(J2/0>EA3>582<2885>0?515:@E79710:5B21@:A0<<5B20: J 85>0?515:@ 382< >7E/ E5<E79>:03E2> 0>>2>>923: AD D73E:5A301 85>0?515:@ 0: !%J ?@ :<5?7301 ;A718 ?2 67>:5D528 <5?7301/0>EA3>582<28/5>0420:@20<>0380==1528EA<<2E: 971:5=152<AD!!/7>1A>>ADD7:7<253EA92;A718?2 >!,*%'H!%JH!*H!!N>!$$!%%' !* "/23 E105903: /0> >7>:05328 D<0E:7<2 AD :5?50 038 D5?710 0=0<: D<A9 <0857> 038 7130 ;/5E/ 0<2 :;A 906A< D<0E:7<2> 0;0<8 AD >%%%%' :A;0<8> =053 038 >7DD2<534 ;A7183A:?267>:5D528:;A718?20==<A=<50:2:A23/03E25::A >(%%%%' - 7 - ! <5?7301/0>0;0<828>+%**+':A;0<8>9285E01 2H=23>2> 04053>: ?511> =<A87E28 53E2 :/2<2 5> EA9=12:2 <2' 59?7<>2923:/2<2;A718?23A>EA=2DA<23/03E2923: !, A<9011@ D<0E:7<2> :0F2 0?A7: :/<22 9A3:/> :A /201 /2<2DA<2 E105903: ;A718 ?2 23:5:128 :A >,*)%' :A;0<8> >092 A3>582<534 87<0:5A3 AD 53'=0:523: :<20:923: :<5?7301 0;0<828 >!%%%%' :A;0<8> DAA8 3A7<5>/923: EA3B2@03E2 038 0::23803: E/0<42> ;/5E/ 0==20<> 67>: 038 =<A=2</2<2DA<23A23/03E2923: ! "/23 E105903: /0> >7>:05328 =2<90323: =/@>5E01 85>0?515:@ 0;0<8 AD >*%%%%' :A;0<8> 1A>> AD 09235:52> ;A718?2A31A;2<>582:5>DA7380==<A=<50:2:A23/03E25::A >%%%%' /7> E105903: ;A718 ?2 23:5:128 DA< :A:01 <20>>2>>28EA9=23>0:5A30>DA11A;> 1 A 208> 9A73: ! A>>ADD7:7<253EA92 !$$!%%' * 053C>7DD2<534 (%%%%' 285E012H=23>2> +%**+' , A>>AD53EA9287<5341058'7==2<5A8 ,*)%' &AA8 038 3A7<5>/923: EA3B2@03E2 0380::23803:E/0<42> !%%%%' ( A>>ADD7:7<209235:52> %%%%' +,- . / - 8 - !( A53: DA< EA3>582<0:5A3 5> 03>;2<28 =0<:1@ 53 0DD5<90:5B20>0?AB2A3>2I723:1@DA11A;534 5 ==201 5> 6784923: 038 0;0<8 80:28 %!**%** =0>>28 ?@ 881 235A< 5B51 7842 038 &'580< C 580<533A)*%*!5>9A85D528 55 105903: 5> /218 23:5:128 DA< <2'0>>2>>28 EA9=23>0:5A3 AD >,*!%)+' 0> 04053>: >!),*+' 0;0<828 ?@ <5?7301 ;5:/ 53:2<2>: 0: (J =2< 03379 D<A9 80:2 AD E1059 =2:5:5A3:511<2015O0:5A3 555 2>=A3823:'53>7<2< :A 82=A>5: >092 ?2DA<2 <5?7301;5:/530=2<5A8AD>5H;22F> 5B 3 82=A>5: 23:5<2 23/03E28 EA9=23>0:5A3 09A73:>/011?2<2120>2853D0BA7<ADE105903: !0/ (&&!) $ 5>: A!1 A+