Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92652 (KAR)
YALLAPPA S/O PARAVVA NATEKAR 9HARIJAN) v. SMT. TANGAMMA
RSA/200248/2018 · 2025-12-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92652 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92652 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! %%
&'$( )
!!"
# $
%%%&$ '
& !!"
# $ %( ( % %%
® Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ))(
( *%
+!)! (
%( !) (
%( & $
%
% !),!) !) ( %
%
! )!) +!)! $ %( %
(
(($ (
(-
-$ % (
( %
(
$ ( %
"))!)! %
( . %
( %
/
(&
- 3 -
% -$
%
%%
*$! 012 344536 12 78 905 :5;5<:3<9 3==>15?5: 78 905 @A:=B5<93<::5C>55:395:!),!) 43225:1< 5=A63> 44536 D !) D< 905 ;165 D; 905 5<1D> 1?16 A:=5 03034A> 05>51<3;95> >5;5>>5: 9D 32 .(1>29 44566395 DA>9/ 78 E01C0 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 E0165 25991<= 321:5 905@A:=B5<9 3<::5C>55:395: ! )!) 43225: 1<D+!)!D<905;165D;::191D<361?16A:=53<:
%( 03034A> 05>51<3;95> >5;5>>5: 9D 32 .>136 DA>9/ :5C>55:9052A19:5C63>1<=9054631<91;;9D75905372D6A95 DE<5>D;9052A194>D45>91523<:032362D=>3<95::5C>55 D;45>B3<5<91<@A<C91D<322DA=09;D>
! 052A7@5C9B3995>D;9052A193>5905;D66DE1<= 4>D45>9152
- 4 -
!"" # $ %""
&&$ '"( )& *
*
+&
& " $ $ ,*
%
" 0537D?52A191<D+!)!12;165:78905 4631<91;; 3<=3BB3 &D 6395 $323443 ;D> 905 >5615; D;
:5C63>391D< 3<: 45>B3<5<9 1<@A<C91D< CD<95<:1<= 1<95> 36139039F
" 052A192C05:A654>D45>9152756D<=5:9D05>0A273<:
$323443 05 03?1<= 1<05>195: 905 23B5 90>DA=0 012 3<C529D>205231:$32344343225:3E38:A>1<=905 853>++653?1<=7501<:9054631<91;;3<:05>2D<32 012D<6865=36051>2
?5>21<C5905<4631<91;;3<:05> 2D< 03?5 755< 1< 4D225221D< 3<: 5<@D8B5<9 D; 905 2A192C05:A654>D45>9152
"!
1<C5 905 2D< D; 905 4631<91;; 12 2A;;5>1<= ;>DB 428C0D6D=1C36 :12D>:5> 4631<91;; 3;95> 905 :5B125 D;
05> 0A273<: 03: 5<=3=5: 905 25>?1C52 D; 905 :5;5<:3<99DCA691?39590563<:D<C>D4203>1<=73212 78 4381<= CD29 3<: 5G45<252 1< 9039 >5=3>: 039
- 5 -
21<C537DA9853>24631<91;;36D<=E19005>2D<032 755< >521:1<= 39 $03:>3E391 3<: 03?1<= 905 63<:
CA691?395: 90>DA=0 905 :5;5<:3<9 32 37D?5 039 5GC549 905 231: 3>>3<=5B5<9 905>5 032 755< <D 9>3<23C91D< D; 3<8 <39A>5 E0392D5?5> 759E55< 905 4631<91;; 3<: 905 :5;5<:3<9 1< >5245C9 D; 905 2A19 2C05:A654>D45>9152
"" 0399054631<91;;751<=:521>DA2D;25661<=34D>91D<D;
2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 9D B559 05> ;1<3<C136 CD<29>31<92D7931<5: 5G9>3C92:A>1<=905BD<90 D; C9D75> H !) D 05> 20DCI 3<: :12B38 205 :12CD?5>5: 905 <3B5 D; 905 :5;5<:3<9 03?1<= 755< 5<95>5:1<905>5?5<A5>5CD>:2<5<JA1>8205B59 E1903<5?321?5>546878905:5;5<:3<9D;0503?1<= 4A>C0325: 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 039 905 :5;5<:3<9 032 =D9 012 <3B5 5<95>5: 1<9D >5?5<A5 >5CD>:2C631B1<=9D759057>D905>D;9050A273<:D; 9054631<91;;78=1?1<=;36251<;D>B391D<
"'052A192C05:A654>D45>9152751<=372D6A954>D45>9152 D; $323443 A4D< 012 :5B125 3>5 2ACC55:5: 78 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< E0D 3>5 012 D<68 65=36 051>2 039 905 1665=36198 CDBB1995: 78 905 :5;5<:3<9 1< D7931<1<= 012 <3B5 5<95>5: 1< 905 >5?5<A5 >5CD>:2 032 =1?5< >125 9D C3A25 D; 3C91D< CD<29>31<1<= 905 4631<91;;9D;1659052A19;D>:5C63>391D<3<:1<@A<C91D<
- 6 -
' < >524D<25 905 :5;5<:3<9 ;165: E>1995< 29395B5<9F ':B1991<= 905 2A19 2C05:A65: 4>D45>9152 9D 75 905 3<C529>36 4>D45>9152 D; 905 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;; DE5?5>:5<15:9054631<91;;-2C631BD;205751<=1< 4D225221D< 3<: CA691?391D< D; 905 23B5 9 12 362D :5<15: 9039905 2D< D;905 4631<91;; 122A;;5>1<=;>DB 428C0D6D=1C36 :12D>:5> 05 C631B D; 905 4631<91;; D;
205 5<=3=1<= 905 :5;5<:3<9 9D CA691?395 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 63<: D< C>D4 203>1<= 73212 78 4381<=905CD293<:5G45<2529DE3>:2905CA691?391D< D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>915212362D:5<15:
'! 9 12 3 245C1;1C C325 D; :5;5<:3<9 9039 05 03: 4A>C0325:63<:1<8D'!B532A>1<=)3C>5 =A<932 95B D!
D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 ;>DB 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< 01?3>3@ D< )")!++ ;D> 3 2AB D; 2)))) 1<C5 905 :5;5<:3<9 03: 36>53:8 431: 2))) 9DE3>:2 3:?3<C5 05 431: 2'))) D< 905 :395 D; 905 3=>55B5<93<:>5B31<1<=CD<21:5>391D<D; 2))) E32 431: D< )'++ 9D 905 2D< D; 905 4631<91;; ?5>21<C5905<905:5;5<:3<9032755<1<4D225221D< 3<: 5<@D8B5<9 D; 905 231: 63<: 32 372D6A95 DE<5>
- 7 -
905>5D; CCD>:1<=68 012 <3B5 032 755< BA9395: 1< 905>5?5<A5>5CD>:2 '" 039905BD905>D;905:5;5<:3<903:4A>C0325:63<: 1<8D!!B532A>1<=)3C>5=A<9323<:63<:
1< 8D," B532A>1<= ) 3C>5 =A<932 95B D2 3<: " D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 3<: D905>2A194>D45>9152;>DB9050A273<:D;4631<91;;39 3< 1BB5BD>136 4D1<9 D; 91B5
?5> 21<C5 905< 905 BD905> D; 905 :5;5<:3<9 032 755< 905 DE<5> 1< 4D225221D<D;905231:63<:23<:3;95>05>:5390905 :5;5<:3<92ACC55:5:9D90523B53<:032CD<91<A5: 9D751<4D225221D<32DE<5>905>5D;053=>55B5<9 D; 2365 12 71<:1<= D< 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< 3<:
9058 3>5 <D9 CD<C5><5: E190 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>91525<C52DA=09;D>:12B12236D;9052A19
$325: D< 905 4653:1<= 905 >136 DA>9 ;>3B5: 905;D66DE1<=122A52
-& & & $"** $ % & & & . $
*
& " $ $ /
-& & & $"** * & $ % & *
"" ""
&
$ $ & /
-& & & * $ % & & & &$ & & " $ $
* & $"**/
- 8 -
-& & & $"** "
" * *
" 0&* /
-&
/
631<91;; 5G3B1<5: 05>256; 32 & 3<: 9ED E19<5225232&!3<:&"3<:5G017195::DCAB5<92 B3>I5: 32
G 9D 5;5<:3<9 5G3B1<5: 01B256; 32 &3<:9EDE19<5225232&!3<:&"3<:5G017195:
!":DCAB5<9232
G9D!"
, <344>5C1391D<D;9055?1:5<C5905>136DA>9 90DA=0 03?1<= ;DA<: 4631<91;; 9D 03?5 5293761205: 05> DE<5>2014D?5>9052A192C05:A654>D45>91520DE5?5>056:
9039 19 E32 <D9 C653> E05905> 905 4631<91;; E32 1< 4D225221D<D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>915232D<905:395 D; 905 1<2919A91D<D; 2A19 3CCD>:1<=68 >5;5>>1<=9D 5C91D<
"'D;90545C1;1C 5615;C9+":12B1225:9052A19
$51<=3==>15?5:4631<91;;;165:>5=A63>3445361< D !) 75;D>5 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 D<21:5>1<= 905 =>DA<:2 A>=5: 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 ;>3B5:905;D66DE1<=4D1<92;D>192CD<21:5>391D<
- 9 -
! "#
$%# &'( )*(+,
-*( -. /012 3
045* 6*(+,
# 7 8+
+ < >5344>5C1391<= 905 5?1:5<C5 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 3<2E5>5: 4D1<92 D 3<: !
1< 905 3;;1>B391?5 3<: CD<25JA5<968 366DE5: 905 344536 259 321:5905@A:=B5<93<::5C>5543225:78905>136DA>9 3<::5C>55:9052A191<1925<91>598=>3<91<=905>5615;32 2DA=09;D>
) $51<= 3==>15?5: 905 :5;5<:3<9 12 75;D>5 9012 DA>91<901225CD<:344536
012DA>978D>:5>:395:)"!)!3:B1995:
905 344536 ;D> CD<21:5>391D< D; ;D66DE1<= 2A7293<9136 JA5291D<D;63E
- 10 -
1 &05905> A<:5> 905 ;3C9 3<: C1>CAB293<C52 D; 905 C325 3 :5C>55 D; :5C63>391D< C3< 75 2DA=09 >5=3>:1<=91965E190DA9255I1<=>5615;D;4D225221D< 5?5< 32 3:B1995: 78 905 4631<91;; 9039 905 :5;5<:3<92 3>5 1< 45>B1221765 4D225221D< ;D> BD>5 903<')853>2905>5;D>52A19;165:;D>255I1<=>5615; D;:5C63>391D<12B31<931<3765E190DA9255I1<=>5615;
D; 4D225221D< 32 45> 5C91D< "' D; 905 45C1;1C 5615;C9K
11 &05905>A<:5>905;3C923<:C1>CAB293<C52D;905 C325 905 2A19 ;165: 78 905 4631<91;; 12 73>>5: 78 61B19391D<3245>>91C65'D;9051B19391D<C9K
! >101?3<3<:3916653><5:CDA<25634453>1<= ;D> 905 :5;5<:3<9 >5195>391<= 905 =>DA<:2 A>=5: 1< 905 B5BD>3<:ABD;3445362A7B1995:9039F
! 05 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 =>D2268 5>>5: 1< <D9 344>5C1391<= 905 5?1:5<C5 D< >5CD>: 1< 9039 5?5< 3CCD>:1<= 9D 905 4631<91;; :5;5<:3<9 032 755< 1< 4D225221D< 3<: CA691?391D< D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 5?5> 21<C5 905 :5B125 D; 05> 0A273<: 0A2E05<9054631<91;;05>256;0323:B1995:1<905 4631<9 >5=3>:1<= :5;5<:3<9 751<= 1< 4D225221D< D;
2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 3 2A19 ;D> :5C63>391D< E190DA9 255I1<= 4D225221D< 12 C653>68 <D9 B31<931<37651<90561=09D;4>D?121D<2D;5C91D<"'
- 11 -
D;90545C1;1C 5615;C9+"3<:90563E631:78 905D</765A4>5B5DA>91<9012>5=3>:
!! 039 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 ;3165: 9D 344>5C1395 905 ;3C9 9039 905:5;5<:3<912 1< 4D225221D<D; 905 4>D45>98 7325: D< 905 3=>55B5<9 E01C0 05 03: 5<95>5:1<9DE1909054631<91;;3<:05>2D<3<:362D D<90573212D;9053=>55B5<9E01C0012BD905>03: 5<95>5:1<9DE1909050A273<:D;9054631<91;;039 05 032 755< 1< 4D225221D< 3<: 5<@D8B5<9 D;
4>D45>98 1< 8D!! 3<: 8D," ;D> 37DA9 ) 853>2 3<: 8D'! ;D> 37DA9 853>2 5 >5;5>29D905:54D2191D<D;9054631<91;;>5CD>:5:D< !)!!) 3<: 2A7B192 9039 905 4631<91;; 032 C395=D>1C3668 3:B1995: 9039 :5;5<:3<9 751<= 1< 4D225221D<D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>9152
!" 039
?5< 1; 19 12 322AB5: 9039 905 :5;5<:3<9 12 CA691?391<= 905 63<: ;D> 3<: 75036; D; 905 4631<91;;
205 C3<<D9 C631B 9D 75 1< 5GC6A21?5 4D225221D< D; 4>D45>915205(1>2944566395DA>9032<D9=1?5< 3<8>532D<1<=D>;1<:1<=E190>5=3>:9D<3B5D;905 :5;5<:3<9 751<= >5;65C95: 1< 905 >5CD>:2 D; >1=09 0A2905@A:=B5<93<::5C>5543225:78905(1>29 44566395 DA>9 2A;;5>2 ;>DB 45>?5>2198 5 >56152
- 12 -
A4D< 905 ;D66DE1<= @A:=B5<92 1< 2A44D>9 D; 012 CD<95<91D<2 ! 1
+,+-.
1
+,+-. 2
3
4 +,+-
../
5
!"" #
$ %& ' (& ) $
%& H .F 3<:
6 **
+$& 1
0+1
" 7
905 653><5: CDA<256 34453>1<= ;D> 9054631<91;;@A291;81<=905@A:=B5<93<::5C>5543225:78 905(1>2944566395DA>92A7B1995:
" 0399054631<91;;032<5?5>3:B1995:9039:5;5<:3<9 751<= 1< 4D225221D< D; 905 4>D45>98 5 2A7B192 90399054631<93?5>B5<925G461C1968B3I5DA93C325 9039 905 4631<91;; 03: 5<=3=5: 905 25>?1C52 D; 905 :5;5<:3<9 9D CA691?395 905 63<: 78 4381<= 905 CD29 D; CA691?391D< D< C>D4 203>1<= 73212 9 905 BD29 :5;5<:3<9 C3< 75 CD<21:5>5: 32 3< 3=>1CA69A>36 637D>5> D> 905 C3>593I5> D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65
- 13 -
4>D45>9152AC03<3>>3<=5B5<9EDA6:<D93BDA<9 9D 4631<91;; :561?5>1<= 3<: 03<:1<= D?5> D; 905 4D225221D< D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 9D 905 :5;5<:3<922AC0:5;5<:3<9C3<<D9C631B9D751< 4D225221D< D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 05 4D225221D< 751<= C631B5: 78 905 :5;5<:3<9 12 <51905>5GC6A21?5<D>372D6A95631<91;;3<:05>2D< CD<91<A5: 9D 75 1< 905 CD<29>AC91?5 4D225221D< D; 9052A192C05:A654>D45>9152
"! 05 73212 D< E01C0 905 :5;5<:3<9 12 C631B1<= 012 >1=09 751<= 3665=5: 3=>55B5<92 E01C0 05 C631B5: 9D03?55<95>5:1<9DE1909054631<91;;3<:05>2D< 32 E566 32 012 BD905> E190 905 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;; 3<: 905 :5;5<:3<9 <D9 03?1<= 5293761205:
3<: 4>D?5: 2AC0 9>3<23C91D< 032 <D 73212 9D CD<95<:90390124D225221D<125GC6A21?53<:63E;A6
""5>5;5>29D>5?5<A5>5CD>:24>D:AC5:39
G2 ! "' 3<: " 3<: 2A7B1995: 9039 :5;5<:3<9 032 =D9012<3B51665=36685<95>5:1<9D>5?5<A5>5CD>:2 78E>D<=6820DE1<=01B256;9D759057>D905>D;905 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;; E0D 12 3:B1995:68 905 .43995:3>/D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>91520392AC0 3;36255<9>81<905>5?5<A5>5CD>:2EDA6:<D9=1?5 3<8 >1=09 91965 3<: 1<95>529 1< ;3?D> D; 905 :5;5<:3<9
- 14 -
"'05>512<D4>D017191D<A<:5>63EBAC06522A<:5> 5C91D< "' D; 905 45C1;1C 5615; C9 +" ;D> 905 4631<91;;9DB31<931<9052A1932;165:0A29052A19 32 4>385: 3<: ;165: 78 905 4631<91;; 12 ?5>8 E566 B31<931<3765 5<C5 255I2 ;D> :12B12236 D; 905 344536
" 5 >56152 A4D< 905 ;D66DE1<= @A:=B5<92 1< 2A44D>9 D;012C325 ! ,
,$ - . & & +
-
&$ & 1
+,+- /
3 ?2
/ !4
..2
5 & ?2
& 0121334%%5637
6 /
$
?2 1
+,+-
' 53>:5>A25:905>5CD>:2
2 >5=3>:2 905 DE<5>2014 4631<91;; C631B2 9039 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 372D6A9568 756D<=5: 9D 05> 0A273<: $323443 05 03?1<= 1<05>195: 905 23B5 90>DA=0 0123<C529D>2039$32344343225:3E38:A>1<=905853>
- 15 -
++653?1<=7501<:4631<91;;3<:05>2D<9D2ACC55:9D905 4>D45>9152
5;5<:3<9D<905D905>03<::D52<D9:124A95 9039 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;; 9D 75 905 372D6A95 DE<5> D; 9052A192C05:A654>D45>9152DE5?5>05C631B5:9D751< 4D225221D<3<:5<@D8B5<9D;9052A194>D45>915232DE<5> 905>5D; 4A>2A3<9 9D 3=>55B5<9 D; 2365 3665=5: 9D 03?5 755< 5G5CA95: 78 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< 1< >5245C9 D;
63<: 1< 8D'! 95B D! D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>91523<:BD905>D;:5;5<:3<903?1<=4A>C0325:63<:
1< 8D!! 3<: 8D," 95B D2 3<: " D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 3<: D905> 2A19 4>D45>9152 ;>DB 9050A273<:D;9054631<91;; , 05>136DA>9E01653<2E5>1<=122A5D032 ;DA<: 9039905:5;5<:3<9032 <51905> 4653:5: <D> 4>D?5:
32 9D 0DE 012 BD905> 4A>C0325: 905 63<: 753>1<= 8D2!!
3<: ," 95B D2 3<: " D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 1B163>68 5?5< 905 E19<52252
- 16 -
5G3B1<5: 1< 9012 >5=3>: 03?5 <D9 2A44D>95: 905 C325 D; 905:5;5<:3<9
G" 12 905 5G9>3C9 1< >5245C9 D; 63<:
8D!! <9>1521<905231::DCAB5<91<:1C3959039905 <3B5D;905:5;5<:3<903?1<=755<BA9395:20DE1<=01B 9D759057>D905>D;$3234439050A273<:D;9054631<91;;
G! 12 3<D905> 5G9>3C9 D; 905 63<: 753>1<= 8D," 5?5< 1< 905 231: :DCAB5<9 <3B5 D; 905 :5;5<:3<9032755<20DE<329057>D905>D;$323443 + 2>1=096893I5<<D95D;905>136DA>91912<D9 905 C325 D; 905 :5;5<:3<9 9039 05 12 905 7>D905> D; 0A273<:D;9054631<91;;3<:;A>905>1<9053725<C5D;3<8 4653:1<=3<:4>DD;>5=3>:1<=905BD905>D;905:5;5<:3<9 3665=5:684A>C0321<=90563<:8D2!!3<:,"95B D2 3<: " D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 :5;5<:3<9 C3<<D9C631B9D75905DE<5>D;905231:63<: !) 1B163> 12 905 219A391D< 1< >5245C9 D; 63<:
8D'! 95B D! D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152
- 17 -
E01C03CCD>:1<=9D905:5;5<:3<9054A>C0325:90523B5 78 5<95>1<= 1<9D 3=>55B5<9 D; 2365 E190 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< D901<= 12 7>DA=09 D< >5CD>: 78 905 :5;5<:3<9 4>D?1<=905231:3665=5:3=>55B5<9D;2365D>438B5<9D;
2365 CD<21:5>391D< D; 2)))) 9D 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D<05>5?5<A5>5CD>:2>5615:A4D<789054631<91;;EDA6: 2A44D>9905C325D;9054631<91;;
! ?5< 32 >1=0968 93I5< <D95 D; 905 >136 DA>9 E190 >5;5>5<C5 9D 5C91D< ' D; 905 >3<2;5> D; >D45>98 C9 ! 322AB1<= :5;5<:3<9 03: 1<:55: 5<95>5: 1<9D 3=>55B5<9 9D 4A>C0325 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 32 C631B5:90523B5EDA6:<D9C>53953<:CD<?583<8>1=09 91965 3<: 1<95>529 1< 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 1< 012 ;3?DA> E190DA9 905>5 751<= 5G5CA91D< 3<: >5=129>391D< D;
905 :55:2 D; CD<?583<C5 78 905 4631<91;; 3<: 05> 2D< 1< ;3?DA>D;905:5;5<:3<91<905B3<<5>I<DE<9D63E !! 05 >136 DA>9 3<: 905 (1>29 44566395 DA>9 03?5CD<CA>>5<968CDB59D905CD<C6A21D<90390A273<:D;
905 4631<91;; 751<= 905 DE<5> D; 905 2A19 2C05:A65
- 18 -
4>D45>9152 3<: :5;5<:3<9 03?1<= ;3165: 9D 529376120 012 C631B D; 05 751<= 905 DE<5> 78 ?1>9A5 D; 3665=5: 3=>55B5<92D;23655<95>5:1<9D7801B3<:012BD905> !" 05 <5G9 JA5291D< 905>5;D>5 9039 3>1252 ;D> CD<21:5>391D< 12 E05905> 905 4631<91;; 03: 5<=3=5: 905 :5;5<:3<9 9D CA691?395 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 78 4381<=9055G45<252D<C>D4203>57321232C631B5:1<905 4631<9K !' 631<91;; C631B5: 9D 03?5 5<95>5: 1<9D 3>>3<=5B5<9 E190 905 :5;5<:3<9 <3B568 5<=3=1<= 905 :5;5<:3<99DCA691?3959052A192C05:A654>D45>9152D<C>D4 203>1<= 73212 78 4381<= 905 5G45<252 9DE3>:2 CD29 D;
CA691?391D< ?5>B5<92 1< 9012 >5=3>: 3>5 B3:5 39 3>3=>3402"3<:'D;9054631<9E01C0>53:32A<:5>
! "
#
$"%&
'
(
! "
#
)*
+ ' ,
-
.
- ( /0 1 2
3)4
- 5$1
6+ )
-
6)
78
6' ,#
9
:: /0
;
-
6) ,
;
- )*
- 3)4 1 2
1
6+
78
6'
< , ) =>
? ,
* 1
&@
. @< ,
)*
- +
;
- 19 -
-
"<) # (
"< A &
B*
-
*C1
6+ @ 1
B1
6C ,
B *+ @
D! & - 1
6+
'
8
/ /0 8 &
- 1
6+
' B ,
"<)*
-
B*
-
*C1
6+
-1
@ 1 2
8 &8
@ -
1
6 E< ,
F
)* 9 +
* G A &
H
-
I
6
78
" <
6' @ , /0
"< A &
B*
! J
- 1
6+
"<)*
6)
?*
-/1
6+ ) #
< DK')* <LM3
-
"<)LA *
/0 6) ,
"< A & N< 8
/ /0
- 8 & @ -
1
6+ OB) , - )
1
6+
< , - 9 (<*
K
P
* )
"<)*
+ NQR
)4 # * * (<*
K
P
#@0
1
#),
)@0
"<)* )*
1
2 #@0
)4 1
@ 1
"
- *C , 6@1
) 7
6
- *C , 1 ;12' )* S
K* *@* 1
29
*
- /0 < ,
T
! (3C9D;4631<91;;>521:1<=39$03:>3E39121<C5 853>2 3;95> :5B125 D; 05> 0A273<: 12 3:B1995: 78 905 :5;5<:3<9236>53:8<D95::5;5<:3<90323:B1995:905 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;; 9D 75 905 372D6A95 DE<5> D; 905 2A192C05:A654>D45>91525;5<:3<903?1<=;3165:9D4>D?5 012 DE<5>2014 3<: 4D225221D< 90>DA=0 3<: A<:5> 905 3665=5:3=>55B5<92D;23653<:1<9053725<C53<8D905> 4653:1<=259A478905:5;5<:3<9@A291;81<=0124D225221D< <5C5223>8CD>D663>83<:1<;5>5<C5>5JA1>529D75:>3E<9D
- 20 -
3CC549 905 C325 D; 905 4631<91;; 32 4653:5: 37D?5 D; 205 03?1<= 5<=3=5: 905 25>?1C5 D; :5;5<:3<9 9D CA691?395 905 63<: (A>905> 4631<91;; 03?1<= 4653:5: 1< 905 4631<9 32 5G9>3C95: 37D?5 032 362D >5195>395: 905 23B5 1< 05> 5G3B1<391D<1<C015; 05 032 E19029DD: 905 C>D22 5G3B1<391D< 3<: <D901<= 032 755< 561C195: :A>1<= 05> C>D225G3B1<391D<9D:12C>5:1905>D>3695291BD<805032 >545395:68 >5195>395: :A>1<= 905 :54D2191D< D; 905 ;3C9 D;
205 03?1<= =1?5< 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>9152 9D 905 :5;5<:3<9 ;D> CA691?391<= D< C>D4 203>1<= 73212 D D905> 1<;5>5<C5D905>903<E039124653:5:789054631<91;;EDA6: @A291;8A<:5>905;3C923<:C1>CAB293<C52D;905C325 ! 055<9>1521<905>5?5<A5>5CD>:2
G9D 1<:1C395 <3B5 D; $323443 905 0A273<: D; 905 4631<91;;
751<=905DE<5>3<:1<4D225221D<D;9052A1963<:2
G" 12 905 1< >5245C9 D; 8D!! ;D> 905 853>2 + + +9D++!++"
G!12905 1<>5245C9D;63<:
1< 8D," ;D> 905 853> + + + 9D ++++!
< 905 231: 5G017192 39 CD6AB< D+ <3B5 D; $323443
- 21 -
0A273<: D; 4631<91;; 032 755< >DA<:5: D;; 3<: <3B5 D; :5;5<:3<93663443BD905>3>3BB3032755<20DE< < CD6AB< D) 19 12 20DE< 32 U
R
V
&
7>D905> D; 905 43995:3> :395: )+),++! 1< >5245C9 D; 7D909052A>?58<AB75>28D2!3<:,0A2905231:
5<9>152 >5?536 9039 905 <3B5 D; 905 :5;5<:3<9 032 755< 5<95>5:1<9D20DE1<=01B329057>D905>D;9050A273<:D;
905 4631<91;; 05 231: 5<9>152 3>5 <D9 D< 905 73212 D;
:5;5<:3<9 03?1<= 4A>C0325: 905 4>D45>98 D> 05 03?1<= 5<95>5: 1<9D 3<8 3=>55B5<9 05 231: :DCAB5<92 >A< CD<9>3>89D905?5>8C325D;905:5;5<:3<9D;05751<=1< 4D225221D<D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>9152D<90573212D; 3665=5:4A>C032578012BD905>E3873CI0A2;>DB905 37D?519C3<751<;5>>5:90399054631<91;;03:<D943>95: E1909054D225221D<D;9052A192C05:A654>D45>91529D905 :5;5<:3<9 7325: D< 3<8 3=>55B5<9 9D 2566 D> 905 2365 9>3<23C91D< !, 45G DA>9 1< 905 C325 D;
' . 8 & &
2( . - 22 -
2 :5361<=E1909054>52AB491D<D;CD>>5C9<522D; >5?5<A55<9>1523943>32'3<:032056:32A<:5> 8 9 & & & %
&
"" $ & * %"
&" ( $ $$ "" : &
3& $ $*
$$"" *
*
" '& *
" '& & &"" &
* .& & & %
& $ & ( & . *
" "
$" ; *
* "" " " ** * " $
" 9/%/9&&(1)< 55.& "&5 &
*& =7 !*< : $ **"$ & $ $ " : $ $ $ * & & #&
#&*;"-&" & & 5
% &'
%
1)<
5> && 5%"5 0"*$ &
& *
"" $ ( :
.& & & ".""$ *& "
& "& &$? &""*&
&
"
" %- &% $$" & $&
&. & &
" $ $ *
&
& %
.&& ". % *
" "" $" $ ***
0A2 ;3C92 D; 905 C325 E190 >5=3>: 9D 5<9>8 D; <3B5 D;
:5;5<:3<9 1< 905>5?5<A5>5CD>:2>53:1<905 61=09D; 905 3;D>5231: @A:=B5<9 D; 905 45G DA>9 1<
' 2A4>3 EDA6: B3I5 19 C653> 9039 905 :5;5<:3<9
- 23 -
C3<<D9 C631B 3<8 4D22522D>8 91965 D?5> 905 2A19 2C05:A65 4>D45>915251905> ! 1<C5 905 91965 D; 905 4631<91;; D?5> 905 2A19 4>D45>9152 032 >5B31<5: A<1B453C05: ;D> :5;5<:3<9 03?1<=;3165:9D4>D?5012C325D;0503?1<=4A>C0325:905 2A194>D45>91523<:1<9053725<C5D;:5;5<:3<9@A291;81<= 0124D225221D<783<8D905>63E;A6B53<23<:B3<<5>905 3225>91D<D;9054631<91;;D;2055<=3=1<=90525>?1C5D;905 :5;5<:3<99DCA691?39590563<:D<C>D4203>573212293<:2 4>D?5: !+ 5;5<:3<9 D< 905 D905> 03<: C3< <51905> 75 CD<21:5>5:32395<3<9<D>361C5<2553<:0124D225221D< 1;3<8C3<D<68759039D;3<3=5<9D>325>?3<92056:
78905D</76545GDA>91<905C325D;
$
&"/&
( L@$ * $ $ $
% & * .
."" " $&"$ A
- 24 -
") 05 D</765 45G DA>9 1< 905 C325 D; , ,$ - . $ 032C>8293661M5: 9054>1<C1465D;63E1<905C325D;9012<39A>5E01C01232 A<:5> 8 7 $" * ". .&& &
""B ?4 :
" & $ $ *& & . "". & $
"C%
" $ *
& $
." :
&
& $ $
5 ( .&
% % :
& $ $
$ % * & " $ '& (
% & % $ * &.& '& 5
0* $ & $ * (
% $ .& . "". "% & $ *
& *
"% (
% '& $ * & 5
"
D & $ .&&%"
"
"
&*%
'& (
&"$ $ *& $ $"
" &"**& $ $"E :
&
.& % * & "* & $ $
$ % *&" $ A
" D9E190293<:1<=90537D?521<C5905>136DA>9 :12B1225:9052A19D<9054>5B125D;4631<91;;<D9751<=1<
- 25 -
4D225221D< D; 905 4>D45>9152 3<: 1< ?15E D; 905 ;1>29 2A7293<9136 JA5291D< D; 63E ;>3B5: 32 37D?5 >5=3>:1<= B31<931<3716198 D; 905 2A19 1< ?15E D; 5C91D< "' D; 905 45C1;1C 5615; C9 +" 12 CD<C5><5: 19 12 <5C5223>8 9D 3:?5>99D5C91D<"'D;90545C1;1C 5615;C9+"E01C0 >53:232A<:5> 8
4 &&"%&& &&" &
$4 ! $
" " " &
& $ $
$
&" &&
&& 5
( &
" &&
" & $"** &(*
* &
" *
7 % & 5 &"" ( & "
.& & $"** " (* &
" *&
" *"
CD$"4! *$ $ 8$
A" % & " * .& D * .&* D & ."
A
"! 05 D</765 A4>5B5 DA>9 1< 905 C325 D; & 2A4>393>3D29D!032 056:32A<:5> 83: '& $ &
$ % *& <! & " *& & & & $" * 9* & $" " *
"
" *" : "
" *& *
- 26 -
*0&."" * (
"& " * & $ % & * 9* % & $"** *" : "
" * &
* $" * : "
" *
": 9%( & $ %
*& <!9*& $"** & . & "
" *&
" *" @&.
$ & * & # ( E& 5 0 & * ! "$$ )$
". 9 & & & "?4 F C% * & $"** 5
&& $ &* * *
" & & . $ & *& % & &
*
"
$
0 ""
" * $
0 *& $"** $ & *& 9 &
* & $"** & $" * & 0 (
" **$ '& * *
" * " $ 0 & $"**.&$ & *& .& & " (* &
" * * % * $ " & 5 &"" ( &
" & ""
" F 36
* &
" * " & * .&& & $$ " $
*
" . & . * * .& & $ *"*& $"**0%
" **
*
* .& & $ $ . "
" 3 $ * & $ $ &
"$"**. "& '& " %
" * &
" * & . " * $" * * &
* " '& & * * & * & $"** & . *"
""$ .&& *4*5
0 &&
- 27 -
"" 3&* &
*
" * . &$ & $"**'&
&
$ *> " *!<
" "
'& '
"5
$% * & &
" $"** . & . *& 4$ $ 3& "& * " *
" * * $ & $"**
" * " - &% "
D$
.&&" * 9
*& $ %* * & < ! '& '
" 5 & E& 5
&% $ & && D$ F* &
" *F $" &$ %" ""&
" * & & &% " & &%
3 % . & & : * & $ %'&( &
"" : .& & & < " &% & "
& $ $" @
99>" * & 5 *5%"7
<9 $& $ %*& 5 ."$$"& **& & " * " " & & < $ .
"" * & & ;
< '& "" %
" *
" .&&%"" & <'& "*
"
". ""
0 & & " %(& $ $" $ @
99 >" *& 5 *< 34 '& E& 5 & $ & * & & 0 4 &
" $"** &% & ( *
" * *
% * $ &% ( & " *
" $ 3 . &% "
% & $ %
* & < ! : ( $
*
" . "" : "
" * 9 & * &
" * *" * &
" & & *""% .** $ & $
*& <! 3; E% $
& $ *
". $ *& <!. &""
& **& $ '& * .*
$ $ "0.&&&
"$"**"*
- 28 -
*" "& $ 9 & )& <
" *. " *
"
"" * : & 0%
" * . ( * '& $"** " *
$ &. % *" '& 0
"
& * *
* .& &
" $"**G $ *& "3& '
"5 * . &$*&
"$"**.$ % % . &
" $"** . " " & & .& " . *& $ $ '&
& *
" &
"
" & & $ $ ." % %& " H & "
." 4 D " & * * & * &
" &
" & $"** !** % * & % & '
" 5
. &$ * &
" $"** % & 0 4 $ $ '&*& & E& 5 & 5 * ; !$$ " 9 &
$
"
. &$ D
& 5 &
" *& " &&
"$"**&*" "&& * &
: "
" * 12 9 & . & 0 * & E& 5 & & $"** . " 0%
" * $ *
" &
0 *& $"**$" *
*
" **
$ 3& .
&$
* & 0 .&& & & " & & $"** . " " * . &$ * & $ $ -
" &" & & $"**
" " & & . * & $ $ & &"" & ** 13'& $$ "$
"". & % A
- 29 -
"" 1B163>68 1< 905 C325 D; <
& &" = =/
<
0 1231 4 %% 3>4 39 43>3=>340 D29D 032056:32A<:5> 8?? '& $ % & &%
" *
&&. %
% D $& &""( & " *
&.& & $"
" (* &
" *&
"
*"
?: 9 > % I 6 % J)<
55 K&5 &
""& "&& ( *
" *" *. &$.& $ & & & $ % *
* & $ * > " * ! < & " 9 L # & % # &% 5& J<<
$$ )
55 <K & 5
" .& " .& & $"** . D"% $ * $ $
&*" ( " *" *. &$
" % . &
% & & ." *
& $ % * &
$ * > " * ! )
" I # % >& &J)
55
?69% .*& % & ". "
" & $
" " &
" * *
" .& ( : "
" *
?49& & *
" *
" *. &$& *" &&> $ 4 $"** . " $ * & $ $ '& & . & $ % * *&
$ *> " *!& * & &% " " & '& E& 5 &&*
": &$ * (.
$ $
& F
- 30 -
"' 0A2 905 9>136 CDA>9 E32 <D9 @A291;15: 1< :12B1221<=9052A19D;9054631<91;;344681<=9054>D?121D<2 D; 5C91D< "' D; 905 45C1;1C 5615; C9 9D 905 ;3C92 3<: C1>CAB293<C52D;905C32532<3>>395:05>51<37D?5
" (>DB 905 37D?5 :12CA221D< 905 ;D66DE1<= 5B5>=52 1 039 905 4631<91;; 12 905 372D6A95 DE<5> D; 2A19 2C05:A654>D45>9152 11 039 905 :5;5<:3<9 90DA=0 C631B5: 9D 03?5 4A>C0325: 905 4>D45>98 032 ;3165: 9D @A291;8 012 91965 D?5>90523B5 111 1<C5 905 4653:1<= 3<: 5?1:5<C5 D; 905 4631<91;;
>5=3>:1<= 205 03?1<= 5<=3=5: 905 :5;5<:3<9 9D CA691?395 905 63<: D< C>D4 203>5 73212 032 <D9 755< >57A995:D>:124>D?5::5;5<:3<9C3<<D9C631B9D75 1< 4D225221D< D; 905 4>D45>98 1< 3<8 B3<<5> D905> 903< 751<= 3=5<9 C3>593I5> D> 3=>1CA69A>36 637D>5> A<:5>9054631<91;;
1? 05 >5?5<A5 5<9>152 >5;65C91<= 1< 905 <3B5 D; :5;5<:3<9 <D9 7325: D< 65=3668 3CC5493765 9>3<23C91D< D7931<5: 2A>>549191DA268 C3<<D9 CD<;5> 3<8 4D22522D>8 >1=09 D> 91965 1< ;3?DA> D; 905 :5;5<:3<9
- 31 -
? 1<C5 4631<91;; CD<91<A52 9D 75 1< 4D225221D< D; 905 4>D45>98 2A19 ;D> :5C63>391D< 3<: 1<@A<C91D< E190DA9 255I1<= >5615; ;D> 4D225221D< 1< 905 ;3C92 3<: C1>CAB293<C52D;905C32512B31<931<3765 ?1 05 25CD<: 2A7293<9136 JA5291D< D; 63E >5=3>:1<= 61B19391D<A<:5>>91C65'D;9051B19391D<C9+" EDA6:75D;<DCD<25JA5<C521<?15ED;9053<2E5> 9D905;1>292A7293<9136JA5291D<D;63E
CCD>:1<=68905;D66DE1<=
1 0534453612
11 A:=B5<9 3<: :5C>55 :395: ! )!) 43225:1<D+!)!D<905;165D;905 ::191D<36 1?16 A:=5 3<: %( 03034A> 3<: 905 @A:=B5<9 3<: :5C>55 :395:
!),!) 43225: 1< D !) D< 905;165D;5<1D>1?16A:=503034A>3>5 CD<;1>B5:
3' &!!( $
129D6D!! 94I