Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92643 (KAR)
THE BRANCH MANAGER v. SYEDSHABANAM AND ANR
MFA/201773/2022 · 2025-10-31
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92643 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92643 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!""!#
$ "%"&""! ""&&
'() *+
""&&
'()
*
+
! ! "
#
$% % &&
" #
' (! & !!! )
! ! *
& +"#! + * &!#
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
! ! +"#! + * ! ( )
' (! , *
-
)
.-()
! & ! &! ! & &
&! "*# ! *
+
! *
& +""! + * &! '
(! )
! *
! ! +""! + * ! ( )"#
- 3 -
' (! & !!! , *
)
.-()
! ! ! &
! & &
&! "*#
! .*
* /
0
! & +
+
% &
%! 123324 5678394: ;<= ><==97 24 ?4
2-.*# <47 2"*# @A :B9 C?41?><D 94?2C ?E?D&6789F & <47 93@9C ?5<A<>6C< (G2C=B2C:H:B9C?@64<DI) 2..-*?=G?D97@A :B94=6C<419 23><4A<47 2""*?=G?D97 @A:B91D<?3<4:<8<?4=::B95678394:?4 2"*#
- 4 -
B9 G<1:= 2G :B9 1<=9 <C9 :B<: 24 - ;B?D9 :B9 1D<?3<4: <D248 ;?:B 249 &<8<7?=B ;9C9 >C21997?48 ?4
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
" 88C?9E97@A:B9=<?75678394:<47<;<C7:B9 4=6C<419 23><4A B<= >C9G9CC97 2..-*
- 5 -
G2CC9761:?242G:B9123>94=<:?24<47:B9?456C971D<?3<4: B<=>C9G9CC97 2""*G2C94B<419394:
9<C497 1264=9D G2C :B9 4=6C<419 23><4A 124:94797 :B<: :B9C9 ;<= 1<D16D<:?24 9CC2C, ?4=:9<7 2G 394:?24?48:B9123>94=<:?24<==""":B9C?@64<D B<= 394:?2497 ?: <= =.* 9CC24926=DA <47 ?4:9C9=: ?= 8C<4:97 <: / >< <47 ?: ?= :2 @9 C976197 :2 #/>< # 9<C497 1264=9D G2C :B9 1D<?3<4: 124:94797 :B<::B91D<?3<4:=>94:32C9:B<4=-*:2;<C7= 397?1<D 9L>94=9= @6: :B9 C?@64<D B<= 8C<4:97 39<8C9 <3264:,42<3264:=<C98C<4:97G2CD2==2G9L>91:<:?242G D?G9 G6:6C9 >C2=>91:= G6:6C9 397?1<D 9L>94=9= ?4124E94?94197?=123G2C:9:1,:B9123>94=<:?248C<4:97 @A :B9 C?@64<D ?= ?4<79M6<:9 <47 :B6= C9M69=:97 G2C 94B<419394:2G:B9123>94=<:?24 .
= >9C :B9 ;2647 19C:?G?1<:9 N L :B9 1D<?3<4:B<==6=:<?497 13L13L@249799>2E9C
- 6 -
C?8B:GC24:><C?9:<DC98?24@D2271D2:=>C9=94:,D9G:><C?9:2 211?>?:<D =6@76C<D B<932CCB<89 9L:947?48 <D248 >2=:G<A, 12C>6= 1<DD6=63 <>>9<C= :B?4 <: @27A, 19C9@C<D <47 19C9@9DD<C <:C2>BA ;B?1B <C9 8C?9E26= ?4 4<:6C9 B9 1D<?3<4: 9L<3?497 :B9 21:2C <= <47 B9 <==9==97 :B97?=<@?D?:A<=:2-/:2:B96>>9CD?3@B?= 26C:
G?47= ?: C9<=24<@D9 :2:<K9*-C72G -/ <= / :2;<C7= 7?=<@?D?:A2G:B9<>>9DD<4:B9<>>9DD<4:G<?D97:2>C2E9B?= ?41239 B9C9G2C9 :B9 C?@64<D B<= :<K94 B?= 42:?24<D ?41239 <: =* >9C 324:B <= >9C :B9 86?79D?49= 2G :B9 <C4<:<K< :<:9 98<D 9CE?19= 6:B2C?:A =?419 :B9 <11?794: 2116CC97 ?4 :B9 A9<C ;B?1B ?= 56=: <47 >C2>9C B9 36D:?>D?9C 2G H-I <72>:97 @A :B9 C?@64<D ?= <D=2 56=: <47 >C2>9C B6= :B9 D2== 2G G6:6C9 9<C4?48= 1239=:2=LL-L/O="*
= >9C :B9 7?=1B<C89 =633<CA :B9 <>>9DD<4: ;<= <73?::97 :2 :B9 B2=>?:<D 24 - <47 7?=1B<C897 24 <47 :B6= B9 ;<= B2=>?:<D?=97 <=<4?4><:?94:G2C.7<A=9G?D97#397?1<D@?DD=<47-
- 7 -
397?1<D >C9=1C?>:?24= 6479C L= <47 <47 :2:<D <3264: 2G :B2=9 @?DD= ?= ="#"* B9 =<39 ?= <;<C797@A:B9C?@64<D@6:?:?=42:C9GD91:97?4:B9:<@D9 2G1<D16D<:?24B6=<=124:94797@A:B9D9<C4971264=9D G2C:B9<>>9DD<4::B9C9?=<49CC2C?4394:?24?48:B9:2:<D <3264:<==.*<47:B9=<39?=C91:?G?97
24=?79C?48:B94<:6C92G?456C?9=<47>9C?272G B2=>?:<D?=<:?24 :B?= 26C: G?47= ?: C9<=24<@D9 :2 8C<4: <4 <3264:2G=*G2C><?4<47=6GG9C?48=* G2C D2== 2G <394?:?9= <47 =-* G2C :C<4=>2C:<:?24 9L:C<426C?=B394:<47<::947<4:1B<C89= B91D<?3<4:3?8B:42:B<E9<::94797<4A;2CK <: D9<=: G2C < >9C?27 2G :BC99 324:B= 769 :2 :B9 ?456C?9= =6=:<?497 B9C9G2C9 :B?= 26C: G?47= ?: C9<=24<@D9 :2 8C<4:<4<3264:2G="*(=L-)G2CD2==2G ?4123976C?48D<?76>>9C?27 9419:B91D<?3<4:?=94:?:D97G2C:B9327?G?97 123>94=<:?246479C7?GG9C94:B9<7=<=@9D2;+
- 8 -
<?4<47=6GG9C?48 =*
97?1<D9L>94=9= ="#"* C<4=>2C:<:?24 9L:C< 426C?=B394: <47<::947<4:1B<C89= =-* 2==2G?4123976C?48D<?76>>9C?27 ="* 2==2GG6:6C99<C4?48= ="* 2==2G<394?:?9= =* 2:<D 9==+<;<C797@AC?@64<D 4B<419394: =-#""* =.* ,
*
B9 4=6C<419 23><4A B<= P 79>2=?:97 :B9 <3264: <;<C797 @A :B9 C?@64<D B6= :B9 <>>9DD<4: ?= 94:?:D97G2CP 123>94=<:?242GP ;?:B ?4:9C9=: <:#/>9C <4463 112C7?48DA @2:B :B9 <>>9<D= 79=9CE9:2@9<DD2;97?4><C: 4:B9C9=6D::B9G2DD2;?482C79C?=><==97+ (?) 2:B:B9<>>9<D=<C9<DD2;97?4><C: (??) B9<>>9DD<4:?4 2""**1D<?3<4:
?= 94:?:D97 G2C P 123>94=<:?24 2G P
;?:B?4:9C9=:<:#/>9C<4463GC23:B97<:92G>9:?:?24:?DD :B9 7<:9 2G C9<D?J<:?24 2;9E9C <= >9C 2C79C 24 2* 7<:97 - :B9 1D<?3<4: ?= 42: *Re-typed and replaced v/c/o dated 02.12.2025
- 9 -
94:?:D97G2C?4:9C9=:G2C:B979D<A97>9C?272G--7<A=?4 G?D?48:B9<>>9<D (???) B9 <>>9DD<4: ?4
2..-* 4=6C<419 23><4A ?= 7?C91:97 :2 79>2=?: :B9 <G2C9=<?7 123>94=<:?24 <3264: P ;?:B?4 249 324:B GC23:B97<:92G:B?=5678394:
(?E)
4 =61B 79>2=?: :B9 1D<?3<4: ?= >9C3?::97 :2 ;?:B7C<; :B9 94:?C9 <3264: <D248 ;?:B ?4:9C9=: <11C697 24?: (E) B9 =:<:6:2CA <3264: 79>2=?:97 @A :B9 4=6C<419 23><4A @9G2C9 :B?= 26C: ?= 2C79C97 :2 @9 :C<4=3?::97:2:B9C?@64<D
,-* '&""!) %! ?=:2+D2+
**Re-typed and replaced v/c/o dated 02.12.2025