Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92636 (KAR)

THE UNION OF INDIA v. KALYANI AND ORS

MSA/200074/2018 · 2025-08-20

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! !" # $%% !&& '( ) ! !" # $%&%'( " ) * $%&%'( ( $%&%'" + " ( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %," # - "&"'! - "."'" - "&'!"''/ - ,!("''" - # - 0 - $! 123 345678 9::49; 23 <2;48 :=9>27? @6 34@ 93284 @14 -A8?B47@ 978 9C9=8 89@48 "&"'! :93348 D> 882@2679; 23@=25@-A8?49;9DA=9?2<6=316=@E@149::4;;9@4 6A=@F276"."'"978567<2=B@14-A8?B47@978 9C9=889@48"&'!"''/:93348D>@142G2;-A8?4= 7 489B <6= 316=@ E@14 4<4=4754 6A=@F 27 6,!("''" " 49=8 @14 ;49=748 56A734; <6= @14 9::4;;97@D474<2529=> ;49=748 56A734; <6= @14 =43:67847@ - 3 - 65;92B97@ 978 ;49=748 2?1 6A=@ 6G4=7B47@ ;4984= <6==43:67847@63"978( ( 14 ;978 D49=27? A=G4> 6," B493A=27? " 95=43 (( ?A7@93 6< 9=@A= G2;;9?4 6< 12@@9:A= @9;AH C93 95IA2=48 D> @14 @9@4 <6= @14 :A=:634 6< E 6AD;4 92;C9> =95HF <6= @14 9::4;;97@ D> 233A27? , 6@2<259@267 89@48 ('%..' 14 :4529; 978 5IA232@267 <<254= 193 <2J48 @14 56B:4739@267 6< 3%%''* :4= 95=4 <6= @14 8=> ;978 14=43:67847@682339@23<248C2@1@149C9=89B6A7@193 3ADB2@@489=6@43@4@2@267A784=45@267&6<@14978 5IA232@267 5@ D4<6=4 @14 =43:67847@ 6" 344H27? =4<4=4754 @6 2G2; 6A=@ <6= 4719754B47@ 6< 56B:4739@267 14 :4@2@267 <2;48 D> =43:67847@ 6 C93 =4<4==48 @6 4<4=4754 6A=@ 24 4726= 2G2; -A8?4 489B <6= 47IA2=> 978 84523267 14 4<4=4754 6A=@ 9<@4= 47IA2=> 978 9::=4529@27? @14 4G284754 67 =456=8 193 84@4=B2748 @14 B9=H4@ G9;A4 9@ @14 =9@4 6< 3/"''* :4= 95=4 C2@1 9;; 3@9@A@6=>D474<2@314=43:67847@6519;;47?48@143928 -A8?B47@9C9=8 6< @14 4<4=4754 6A=@ 27 6"."'"D4<6=4@149::4;;9@46A=@149::4;;9@46A=@ - 4 - 9<@4= 149=27? @14 9=?AB47@3 978 =4*9::=4529@27? @14 4G284754 67 =456=8 193 47197548 @14 B9=H4@ G9;A4 @6 3&%,&'*:4=95=4939?9273@ 3/"''*:4=95=49C9=848 D>@14 4<4=47546A=@C2@19;;3@9@A@6=>D474<2@3??=24G48 D>@143928-A8?B47@6<@149::4;;9@46A=@@14D474<2529=> 193<2;48@14:=4347@9::49; , 49=748 56A734; <6= @14 9::4;;97@ C6A;8 567@478 @19@ @14 95IA232@267 76@2<259@267 193 D447 233A48 67 ('%..'978@14:=2546<@14>24;8193D447@9H47D>@14 9::4;;9@46A=@<6=@14>49=..'*..DA@2@6A?1@@619G4 @9H47 @14 :=254 6< @14 >24;8 <6= @14 >49= .&.*..' 2@1 @123 14 :=9>3 @6 9;;6C @14 9::49; 978 =48A54 @14 B9=H4@ G9;A493<2J48D>@149::4;;9@46A=@ % 49=74856A734;<6=@14=43:67847@65;92B97@ C6A;8567@478@19@@14B9=H4@G9;A4<2J48D>@149::4;;9@4 6A=@23:=6:4=97856==45@ ! 9G27?149=8@14;49=74856A734;3@1236A=@193 :4=A348@142B:A?748-A8?B47@978@14@=29;6A=@=456=83 - 5 - / 14 ;978 6< @14 =43:67847@ 65;92B97@ 193 D447 95IA2=48 A784= 76@2<259@267 89@48 ('%..' 673284=27? @14 3928 93:45@ @14 >24;8 <6= @14 >49= .&.* ..'193@6D4@9H4727@65673284=9@267149::4;;9@46A=@ 193@9H47@14:=2546<@14>24;8<6=@14>49=..'*..978 2@2376@:=6:4=97856==45@14:=254*;23@B9=H489@J( 278259@43 @19@ @14 B9J2BAB :=254 6< -9C9= 23 3(&'* <6= @14 >49= .&.*..' :4= IA27@9; 978 3&/&* 93 :=254 6< 66=149::4;;9@46A=@193=2?1@;>@9H47<6A=59=@;69836< -9C9= <6884= 9@ @14 =9@4 6< 3"%'* :4= 59=@ ;698 673284=27?@14392893:45@@1456B:A@9@2676<@14B9=H4@ G9;A46<@14;9786<=43:67847@62393<6;;6C3 -9C9=!IA27@9;3 3(&'* 3""&'* " 66=&IA2@9;3 3&(&* 3/'",* 6@9; 3.(',* ( 433,'K5A;@2G9@267519=?43 3(/"* 6@9; 3%%&(* , -9C9= 6884=, 3"%'* 3'''* 6@9; 3!%&(* % A;@2:;24=6<' ' 9=H4@G9;A4 *+,- - 6 - & 7 G24C 6< @14 9D6G4 @14 B9=H4@ G9;A4 <2J48 D> @14 9::4;;9@4 6A=@ 9@ 3&%,&'* :4= 95=4 =4IA2=43 @6 D4 =48A548@6 3!%&('*:4=95=4 . 7@14=43A;@@14<6;;6C27? ! 2 149::49;239;;6C4827:9=@+ 22 14-A8?B47@9789C9=86<@14<2=3@9::4;;9@4 6A=@ :93348 27 6"."'" 89@48 "&"'! 23 B682<248 67;> @6 @14 4J@47@ 6< B9=H4@G9;A4+ 222 14 B9=H4@ G9;A4 93 <2J48 D> @14 9::4;;9@4 6A=@ 9@ 3&%,&'* :4= 95=4 193 D447 =48A548@6 3!%&('*:4=95=4+ 2G 14 =43:67847@ 65;92B97@ 23 47@2@;4 @6 56B:4739@267 9@ @14 =9@4 6< 3!%&('* :4= 95=4C2@19;;3@9@A@6=>D474<2@3 .- '%%( $! 23@6 ;6 (.