- 1 - !" ## $#%#& ' !" # $ # $ % & # % $ !"% ' () * $ * $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * % & * $ !" + $ " $ !,%" $ ! $ !,%" $ $ +- $ ++ , $ + $ !" ! & $ $ !" ' & "" & ) $ ) & "" %","% & && & & & $- "$ - 3 - & $ . " /0 1203045 611067 83 9870: ;< 5/0 :0904:6453 ;084= 6==280>0:;<5/0?@:=A04564::0B200:650:%","% 16330: 84 C "" C4 5/0 9870 C9 ::7 0338C43 @:=0&63526BD10B867C@25658?6<61@26(9C23/C25 E5/0 &8235 11077650 C@25F) ;< G/8B/ G/870 677CG84= 5/0 6110679870:;<5/017684589935/0&823511077650C@25/63 305 638:0 5/0 ?@:=A045 64: :0B200 :650: "-""" 16330: 84 C- "% ;< 5/0 048C2 8>87 @:=0 H &636>6466=0G6:864:/07:5/65176845899C35C 6200458570:9C2 !5/3/62064:176845899C830458570: 9C2 !5/ 3/620 84 3@85 3B/0:@70 12C1025803 ;< A0503 64: ;C@4:3 /020836:076<C9!:6<38498784=5/06;C>0 611067 /0 6998:6>85 6BBCA164<84= 5/0 61178B658C4 84:8B65035/65 5/0 6110776453/02084 G020176B0: ;09C20 5/0 &8235 11077650 C@25 64: 5/65 5/0< /6: 4C - 4 - D4CG70:=0C95/0?@:=A04564::0B20016330:845/0&8235 11077650C@2558775/0<20B08>0:4C58B0845/098467:0B200 12CB00:84=3 5/65 G020 84858650: ;< 5/0 2031C4:0453 1768458993 84 & C- "+ 64: 3CC4 5/02069502 6 8>87 83B077640C@3 05858C4 G63 9870: G/8B/ 83 35877 104:84= BC438:02658C44>80GC95/0B6@303/CG4845/06998:6>85 6BBCA164<84= 5/0 61178B658C4 :076< 83 BC4:C40: C " 83 677CG0: /0 611067 83 56D04 @1 9C2 6:A8338C4 % /0 6;C>0 3@85 83 9870: ;< 5/0 1768458993 2031C4:0453 /02084 9C2 1625858C4 64: 30162650 1C330338C4 9C2 5/082 +5/ 3/620 84 5/0 3@85 3B/0:@70 12C1025803 BC4504:84= 5/65 C40 6736; 6:6D0 G63 5/0 CG402 C9 3@85 12C1025803 46A07< /C@30 ;06284= C, 64: 764: ;06284= <C%+ A063@284= + 6B203=@4563385@650:65DD678>8776=0 + /65 /0 /6: 0990B50: 5/0 1625858C4 C9 5/0 3@85 12C1025803:@284=/83789058A0G85/648450458C45/6536A0 - 5 - 5C;0:0>C7>0:0I@677<@1C4677/83B/87:2046736;:80: C4 +"-- >02 384B0 5/04 5/0 1768458993 64: :0904:6453 /6>0 ;004 84 ?C845 1C330338C4 64: 04?C<A045 C9 5/0 3@85 3B/0:@70 12C1025803 /C@=/ 84858677<1768458993 G020=8>043/6203845/012C:@B0:0904:645376502:0480: 63302584=5/0820JB7@38>028=/5C>020458200J5045C95/03@85 12C1025803203@7584=8498784=C95/06;C>03@85 0=67 201203045658>0 C9 :0904:645 C 9870: G285504 35650A045 6:A85584= 5/0 207658C43/81 ;05G004 5/0 1625803 673C 5/0 1625858C4 C9 -! CG0>02 85 83 :0480: 5/656736;/6:8450458C4C95/012C10258035C;0:0>C7>0: 0I@677<@1C4/83B/87:204583BC450450:5/656736;/6: 84504:0:5/012C1025<5C;0:0>C7>0:C47<@1C4:0904:645 C3 64: 3 3@B/ 6 A@5658C4 0452< 84 C-",+ G63B0258980:768458993/6:3C7:5/0823/620C912C1025<84 C, 64: /6>0 9870: 5/0 3@85 3@11203384= 5/0 A6502867 96B5 /0< 620 4C5 5046453 84 BCAAC4 3 3@B/ 3C@=/59C2:83A83367C95/03@85 - 6 - /02867C@25/63926A0:5/09C77CG84=833@03 !"# $ %&'&$()) *$ # * +,, * * * '& - # , /0 2867 C@25 69502 926A84= 5/0 833@03 64: 20BC2:84=5/00>8:04B09C@4:5/655/0:CB@A04565J+ G/8B/83A@5658C40452<20>0670:5/656736;84504:0:5/0 12C1025< 5C ;0 :0>C7>0: @1C4 /83 5GC B/87:204 /0 368: A@5658C4G63B0258980:845/0<062--%64:5/036A0/63 4C5;004B/67704=0:;<5/016258035/63673C9C@4:5/65 5/0 368: :CB@A045 ;084= %" <0623 C7: /6: 6 70=67 - 7 - 1203@A158C4C98536@5/0458B85<BBC2:84=7<12CB00:0:5C :83A8335/03@85C91768458993/C7:84=5/655/0<:8:4C5/6>0 64<3/62028=/558570845/03@8512C1025803 ! /0 &8235 11077650 C@25 C4 5/0 C5/02 /64: 9C@4:J+4085/025C;061625858C4:00:4C2>654816526 ;@56A02035650A0456770=0:7<=8>04;<6736;;09C205/0 8776=0 BBC@45645 @::0;8/67 /0 &8235 11077650 C@25 673C2090220:5C5/0?@:=A045C95/0CC2:8465004B/C9 5/83 C@25 84 5/0 B630 C9 84 K (L64:85673C2090220: 5/012C>838C43C9 1284B81703 C9 C/6AA0:64 6G 12C>8:84= 9C2 :0>C7@58C4 C9 84/028564B0 64: BC430I@0457< 12CB00:0:5C677CG5/061106764::83A8335/03@85/C7:84= 1625803;084=0458570:9C2 +5/3/62006B/ - 062:02@30:5/020BC2:3 " 5 83 305570: 6 1C3858C4 C9 76G 5/65 @4:02 C/6AA0:646G:@284=5/0789058A0C95/0CG402C95/0 - 8 - 12C1025< 5/0 /0823 /6>0 4C 1200J83584= 28=/5 64: 5/0 3@BB0338C4C1043C47<@1C4/83:0A83033@B/I@0358C4 C90990B584=1625858C4:@284=/83789058A0GC@7:4C562830 /0?@:=A045C95/010JC@25845/0B630C9 !"#$% !"#&'( $%:06784=G85/5/08:0458B6796B5385@658C4/63/07: 651626=261/C3,!64:-63@4:02 ./& 0 & 1 * 2 3%4 0 5 0 6 7#8) & $ %&9&: *+ '' $% ;* 4 ./&%: .< * 0 =&#) )" 4 .> , ; * ? 0 : 6 * &&&&&&&&& * &< ; * 8 % < &5&&<&! 7 -!/""- ? < < $-# ""!& 1 4 - 9 - * * &== 6 0 2 2 &% @ &<&'&:A& ' ' , 4 .)&B 0 2 2 0 &1 0 , & 1 * * 0 * &= "& , * C D ?; D& & 1 * , * * & 1 D 2 * & 1 @ ( * & 1 7$D < 2'&1 4 .$4< * * 4 & 2& E 2 & 6 2 *&E 2& E * 2 @ &E , &1 * < &% < < 2F *< & $4G &E 2 - 10 - C @ &< 2 &E 2* C @ &< H 2 2 C @ &1 < & < < < 2 F *0> *& $4/#1, *I5&%.< * * * * &= 2 & * 2 & E * H @ & < , *&< < , * *&= !&: * J H J H J H * & 1 , &= 45/08435645B6305/C@=/8583BC4504:0:5/65 6736; :@284= /83 789058A0 /6: 0990B50: 5/0 1625858C4 5/0 36A0 G63 @45046;70 64: BC@7: 4C5 /6>0 B20650: 64< 3/62028=/55857064:845020358496>C@2C95/0/0823C9368: 6736;:@284=/83789058A0 % 0>025/07033 384B0 5/0 &8235 11077650 C@25 69502 61120B86584= 5/0 BC450453 C9 5/0 :CB@A0453 /63 - 11 - BCA05C5/0BC4B7@38C45/650>045/0:CB@A04565J+83 4085/0261625858C44C2>654816526;@5A0207<635650A045 =8>045C5/08776=0BBC@45645/0&823511077650C@25 61625 92CA 5/0 96B53 /63 673C 6:>0250: 5C 5/0 1C3858C4 C9 76G 65 1626=261/ C3 64: C9 5/0 8A1@=40: ?@:=A045 + /0 2867 C@25 C4 5/0 C5/02 /64: 63 28=/57< 56D044C50C9;<5/0&823511077650C@25/637C3538=/5C9 5/8370=671C3858C4G/8B//63;0043056528=/5;<5/0&8235 11077650C@25 4 5/0 78=/5 C9 5/0 69C20368: 12C>838C43 C9 76G 64:5/096B5384>C7>0:845/0A655025/83C@25:C4C5984: 64< 022C2 C2 8770=6785< BCAA8550: ;< 5/0 &8235 11077650 C@25 C 3@;35645867 I@0358C4 C9 76G GC@7: 62830 9C2 BC438:02658C4BBC2:84=7<5/061106783 - 12 - , /0 ?@:=A045 C9 5/0 &8235 11077650 C@25 84 C "" C4 5/0 9870 C9 ::7 0338C43 @:=0 &635 26BD10B867C@258?6<61@2683BC4982A0: )% $& " -