Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92630 (KAR)
RAJKUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.RP/200045/2024 · 2025-12-12
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92630 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92630 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $
%&'
%()*&+%)) ,
! "#$ %
& '
(
)
! *(
) ! (*$
#
#
! "#$ %
&
) (+
) #'
)
",$&' *( )&'"!&'
)
'
"**"#*#
)
*"# #*##
)
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*"# #*##
) )
-
& -
'
./ 0123456/7 8/94:456 2/343456 4: ;4</7 => 100?:/7 51::14<46@3./587/8713/7"**"#*#21::/7=>3./ </186/7 77434561< 4:38403 167 /::456: ?7@/ 4718 :43346@131:191A1<>16465 *"# #*##B./8/=>3./ </186/7 /::456: ?7@/ .1: 7/0<46/7 35 /63/83146 3./ 74:0.18@/ 122<4013456 ;4</7 => 3./ 2/343456/8 ./8/46 167 056:/C?/63<> 8/D/03/7 3./ 122<4013456 B.40. 4: 65B 4E2?@6/7=/;58/3.4:5?83
# )103:</1746@353./01:/18/1:?67/8
1:/7 56 1 05E2<1463 <57@/7 => 3./ :/0567 8/:2567/6356"** #*(,131=5?3(**.5?8:3./;48:3 8/:2567/63F5<40/8/@4:3/8/7101:/1@146:3&4'81=.?&44' 1.?< 167 &444' 13181D : 2/8 3./ ) 3./ :/0567
- 3 -
8/:2567/63 B.5 4: 3./ ;13./8 5; 3./ 7/0/1:/7F 16@1E/:. 1<</@/7 3.13 3./ :147 100?:/7 2/8:56: .17 3.8/13/6/7 167 133/E23/7 35 2/8:?17/ 3./ 7/0/1:/7 35 .16759/8.4:784946@<40/60/167357/0<18/.4E:/<;1:3./ 7849/8 5; 3./ 9/.40</ =/<56@46@ 35 100?:/7 5# 81=.? 4695<9/7 46 8517 381;;40 10047/63 ./ 05E2<146163 ;?83./8 1<</@/7 3.13 3./ 28/:/63 2/343456/8G: E4658 :56 B1: 46 ;103 784946@ 3./ 9/.40</ 167 .17 E/3 B43. 16 10047/63 8/:?<346@46.4:5B67/13.0058746@353./05E2<146163 3./ 3.8// 100?:/7 2/8:56: 61E/7 46 3./ ) /H/83/7 28/::?8/ 56 .4: :56 35 ;1<:/<> 10A65B</7@/ 3.13 ./ B1: 784946@ 3./ 9/.40</ 61=</ 35 =/18 3./ 1<</@/7 28/::?8/ /H/83/7 => 100?:/7 5# 81=.? 3./ 7/0/1:/7 4: :147 35 .19/ 05EE433/7 :?4047/ 6 3./:/ 1<</@13456: ) 46 84E/ 5 " #*(, 01E/ 35 =/ 8/@4:3/8/7 ;58 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</?67/8/03456"*8/17B43./03456"5;3./
" ./ 69/:34@1346@
;;40/8 0567?03/7 469/:34@13456 167 6/18<> 3B/63>56/ &#(' E563.:
- 4 -
3./8/1;3/8 =1:/7 :5</<> 56 3./ ;?83./8 :313/E/63 5; 3./ :/0567 8/:2567/63F05E2<146163 3./ 2/343456/8 .1: =//6 1881>/7 1: 100?:/7 5 167 4: 65B ;1046@ 3841< ;58 3./ 5;;/60/?67/8/03456"*5;3./
/186/7 05?6:/< ;58 3./ 2/343456/8 8/43/81346@ 3./@85?67:?8@/7463./2/343456:?=E43:3.133./;?83./8 :313/E/63 5; 3./ 05E2<146163 B1: 8/0587/7 1;3/8 16 465874613/7/<1>5;56/1671.1<;>/18:B./8/46;583./ 9/8> ;48:3 34E/ 3./ 61E/ 5; 3./ 28/:/63 2/343456/8 .1: :?8;10/7 / 0563/67: 3.13 =1:/7 56 3./:/ 91@?/ 167 =/<13/7 1<</@13456: 3./ 2/343456/8 .1: =//6 852/7 46 1: 100?:/7 5 46 3./ 0.18@/ :.//3 ;4</7 ;58 3./ 5;;/60/ ?67/8 /03456 "* 8/17 B43.
/03456 " 5; 3./ 3 4: ;?83./8?8@/73.133./</186/7/::456:?7@/.1:8/D/03/7 3./ 74:0.18@/ 122<4013456 B43.5?3 /H1E4646@ B./3./8 3./ 0.18@/:.//30563146:16>46084E461346@E13/841<:?;;404/63 35 2850//7 1@146:3 3./ 2/343456/8 ./ 2/343456/8 43 4:
18@?/7 05?<7 653 /9/6 8/E53/<> .19/ 2183404213/7 46 2/8:?1746@3./7/0/1:/716@1E/:.357/0<18/.4E:/<;1:
- 5 -
3./7849/85;3./9/.40</1:3./2/343456/8.171=:5<?3/<> 653.46@35@146;85E16>:?0.;1<:/:313/E/635E5349/ 58 =/6/;43 4: 13384=?31=</ 35 3./ 2/343456/8 167 3./8/;58/ 3./8/4:65E13/841<354674013/3.13./2<1>/716>85</46 3./1<</@/71=/3E/635;:?4047/
/186/705?6:/< ;?83./8 781B: 133/6345635 3./ 8/0587: 35 25463 5?3 3.13 /9/6 3./ 69/:34@1346@ ;;40/8 .4E:/<;B1:1881>/71:100?:/75(463./0.18@/:.//3 5B/9/8 3./ 55874613/ /60. 5; 3.4: 5?83 46 5#*((# #*## .1: C?1:./7 3./ 2850//746@: 1@146:3 .4E34:1<:5:?=E433/73.133./:565;3./5B6/85;3./ 5;;/6746@ 9/.40</ 167 1 74:3163 8/<1349/ 5; 100?:/7 5# 81=.? B.5 B/8/ /18<4/8 4E2<4013/7 .19/ =//6 78522/7;85E3./0.18@/:.//3
/;/8846@353./0.18@/:.//3E13/841<:</186/7 05?6:/<B5?<7:?=E433.13/9/64;3./285:/0?345601:/4:
31A/6 13 43: ;10/91<?/3./46@8/74/63: 5;/03456 "*5; 3./18/B.5<<>1=:/631673./8/4:65E13/841<35814:/
- 6 -
/9/6 1 28/:?E23456 3.13 3./ 2/343456/8 1=/33/7 3./ 7/0/1:/73505EE43:?4047/
$ /8 056381 </186/7 4@. 5?83 59/86E/63 </17/8122/1846@;583./;48:38/:2567/63F313/0563/67: 3.133./:?=:/C?/63;?83./8:313/E/635;3./05E2<146163 74:0<5:/: 3./ 2/343456/8G: 4695<9/E/63 167 3./8/;58/ 3./ 2/343456/84:653/6343</735=/74:0.18@/7
! /186/7 05?6:/< ;58 3./ :/0567 8/:2567/63F 05E2<14616318@?/746:1E/9/46167:?=E43:3.1343B1:
3./ 2/343456/8 .4E:/<; B.5 .17 <57@/7 3./ 05E2<1463 46 84E/ 5( #*(! 46 8/<13456 35 3./ 7/13. 5; .4: E4658 :560058746@35.4E3./2/343456/8.17:/33./084E461< <1B 46 E53456 => 8/258346@ 3./ 10047/63 167 3./ E/8/ B856@E/6345646@5;3./05E2<146163G::56G:61E/463./ ) 75/: 653 /H56/813/ 3./ 2/343456/8 / 3./8/;58/ 0563/67: 3.13 3./ 2/343456/8 .1: 35 ;10/ 3841< 167 ://A: 74:E4::1<5;3./28/:/632/343456
- 7 -
, 1946@ ./187 3./ </186/7 05?6:/< 167 ?256 2/8?:1< 5; 3./ E13/841< 56 8/0587 3./ ;5<<5B46@ 25463: 184:/;58056:47/813456
! "
#
$
% &
$
(* ./</@1<25:434568/<1346@35/03456"*5; 167463/8;/8/60/133./.167:5;3./5?835;;48:346:3160/ 13 3./ 3.8/:.5<7 ?67/8 /03456 ##$ 5; 8 18/ B/<< :/33</7/03456"*5;2/61<4I/:1=/3E/635;:?4047/ ./ 56G=</ 2/H 5?83 .1: 056:4:3/63<> ./<7 3.13 ;58 /03456 "* 5; ;5<<5B46@ 46@8/74/63: :.5?<7 =/ :134:;4/7
- 8 -
4 ./8/ E?:3 =/ 0</18 E/6: 8/1 35 46:34@13/ 581473./05EE4::4565;:?4047/
44 ./8/ E?:3 =/ 1 285H4E13/ 167 <49/ <46A =/3B//63./1<</@/71035;3./100?:/7167 :?4047/
444 /8/.181::E/63585874618>74:0587B5?<7 653:?;;40/
49 1@?/1675E64=?:1<</@13456:58E13/841<:
<10A46@3./:2/04;40103: B587:5;46:34@13456 18/46:?;;404/63/9/635;81E/0.18@/:
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
- 9 -
100?:/7 5#G: 9/.40</ 167 35 .167 59/8 .4: 784946@ <40/60/ 3.5?@.
3./ 9/.40</ 46 ;103 B1: 7849/6 => 3./ 2/343456/8G:E4658:56=.4:./A
(# 4@64;40163<> /9/6 10058746@ 35 3./ 05E2<146163G: 5B6 618813456 3./:/ 3.8// 4674947?1<: .17 94:43/7 .4: .5?:/ 167 1<</@/7<> 3.8/13/6/7 .4: :56 46 .4: 28/:/60/ /3 7/:243/ :31346@ 3.4: 46 3./ /18<4/:3 05E2<1463 3./ 05E2<146163 747 653 61E/ 3./ 28/:/63 2/343456/8131<<./2/343456/8.1:=//64E2<4013/7;583./ ;48:3 34E/ 6/18<> 3B/63>56/ E563.: <13/8 :5</<> 56 3./ =1:4:5;3./;?83./8:313/E/63713/7#$*(#*#(018/;?< /H1E4613456 5; 3./ /6348/ 0.18@/:.//3 8/9/1<: 3.13 3./ 2/343456/8G: 4E2<4013456 8/:3: /H0<?:49/<> 56 3.4: =/<13/7 ;?83./8 :313/E/63 B.40. 4: 7/9547 5; 16> 8/;/8/60/ 35 :2/04;40103:B587:0567?035816>59/8310313384=?31=</ 35 3./ 2/343456/8 3.13 05?<7 056:343?3/ 46:34@13456 463/634561<14758056:24810>B43.463./E/1646@5;/03456 (*$5;3./
- 10 -
(" ./1<</@134563.133./7/0/1:/7B1:05/80/735 17E433.13./B1:784946@3./9/.40</4:46;10313384=?3/7 56<> 35 100?:/7 5# 81=.? 46 3./ 05E2<1463 <57@/7 13 3./ /18<4/:3 25463 5; 34E/ ./ 05E2<1463 75/: 653 /9/6 8/E53/<>:?@@/:33./28/:/60/21834042134565885</5;3./ 28/:/632/343456/84616>:?0.1<</@/71035;05/80456
( ./?6/H2<146/77/<1>4661E46@3./2/343456/8 ;583./;48:334E/ 1;3/816/H3/6:49/2/84575;3B/63>56/ E563.: B43.5?3 ;?864:.46@ 218340?<18: 58 05885=5813456 :/9/8/<>?67/8E46/:3./08/74=4<43>5;3./1<</@13456/9/6 133./:31@/5;;81E46@5;0.18@/5?83:.19/056:4:3/63<> ./<7 3.13 25:3 ;1035 /E=/<<4:.E/63: =/8/;3 5; 05@/63 :?2258346@ E13/841< 016653 :/89/ 1: 3./ :5</ ;5?6713456 ;58;81E46@1:/845?:0.18@/?67/8/03456"*?0. =/<13/7 167 91@?/ :313/E/63: 0188> 46./8/63<> B/1A 285=1349/91<?/167016653=>3./E:/<9/:@49/84:/351 @819/:?:240456
- 11 -
( ./ 0567?03 5; 3./ 2/343456/8 167 3./ :?885?6746@ 0480?E:3160/: ;?83./8 6/@13/ 16> 3./58> 5;
1=/3E/63 ./ 2/343456/8G: 5B6 E4658 :56 <5:3 .4: <4;/ 46 3./:1E/10047/633B1:3./2/343456/8B.54EE/7413/<> :/3 3./ 084E461< <1B 46 E53456 => <57@46@ 1 05E2<1463 46 84E/ 5( #*(! ;58 3./ 5;;/60/: 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /03456:#$,167"*167/03456(!$5;3./5358 /.40</:03./63./2/343456/8.4E:/<;B1:1=/8/19/7 ;13./81673./05E2<146163463./584@461<10047/6301:/43 4: .4@.<> 4E285=1=</ 4; 653 4E25::4=</ 3.13 ./ B5?<7 7/849/16>=/6/;43=>05E2/<<46@3./05E2<146163G::5635 ;1<:/<> 17E43 =/46@ 3./ 7849/8 46 1=:/60/ 5; 0<14E ;58 05E2/6:13456=/;58/
( 9/61::?E46@;583./:1A/5;18@?E/633.13 3./8/ B1: 28/::?8/ 56 3./ 7/0/1:/7 B43. 8/:2/03 35 5B646@ 8/:256:4=4<43> ;58 784946@ 3./ 9/.40</ 3./ 285:/0?3456 E13/841< 75/: 653 74:0<5:/ 16> :2/04;40 85</ 2<1>/7 => 3./ 2/343456/8 ./ 0.18@/:.//3 <10A: 218340?<18: 5;
34E/ 2<10/ B587: :25A/6 58 103:
- 12 -
05EE433/7 => 3./ 2/343456/8 8?041<<> 3./8/ 4: 65 1<</@13456 5; 16> 103 58 46:34@13456 => 3./ 2/343456/8 285H4E13/ 35 3./ :?4047/ :147 35 .19/ 500?88/7 13 ,"* 1E56"** #*(,./1=:/60/5;:?0.E13/841<8/67/8: 3./ 1<</@13456 46./8/63<> 46:?;;404/63 35 056:343?3/ 1=/3E/63
($ 3 4: 1<:5 :4@64;40163 3.13 3./ 2/343456/8 B.4</ 8/258346@3./10047/6374765361E/3./05E2<146163G::56 13 1<<+ 813./8 ./ E/63456/7 3./ 61E/ 5; 56/ E/:.
3 B1:56<>?256469/:34@134563.133./69/:34@1346@ ;;40/8 4E2<4013/73./05E2<146163G::56 ./:1E/69/:34@1346@
;;40/8B1:1881>/71:100?:/75(463./0.18@/:.//3 =?33./2850//746@:1@146:3.4E.19/=//6C?1:./7=>1 55874613//60.465#*((# #*##.4</21843>4:
653 E/0.16401< 167 /10. 100?:/7 E?:3 =/ 1::/::/7 56 3./=1:4:5;.4:5B685</1:384A46@1:2/038/E146:4;3./ 69/:34@1346@ ;;40/8 B.5 463857?0/7 3./ 61E/ 5; 3./ 05E2<146163G: :56 4635 3./ 01:/ .1: =//6 @8163/7 8/<4/;
3./8/ 4: /9/6 </:: D?:34;4013456 35 056346?/ 2850//746@:
- 13 -
1@146:3 3./ 2/343456/8 B.5:/ 85</ 4: 653 /9/6 E18@461<<> :?22583/7=>284E1;104/E13/841<
(! ./63./0.18@/:.//3E13/841<:18/3/:3/756 3./2846042</:/E=574/746/03456##$5;3./8/9/6 4;31A/613;10/91<?/167100/23/746/6348/3>3./>;14<35 74:0<5:/ 3./ /::/6341< 46@8/74/63: 5; 1=/3E/63 ?67/8 /03456 (*$ :5 1: 35 :?:3146 1 0.18@/ ?67/8 /03456
"* ./ 2/343456/8G: =/<13/7 4E2<4013456 3.85?@. 1 91@?/ 167 ?605885=5813/7 ;?83./8 :313/E/63 8/0587/7 1;3/8 6/18<> 3B/63>56/ E563.: 4: B.5<<> 46:?;;404/63 35 814:/3./7/@8//5;:?:2404568/C?48/7;58;81E46@10.18@/ 5;:?0.@81943>
(, ./</186/7/::456:?7@/B.4</8/D/0346@3./ 74:0.18@/ 122<4013456 .1: 59/8<55A/7 3./ B/<<:/33</7 2181E/3/8: @59/8646@ /03456 ##$ 8 .5?@. E/340?<5?:/91<?134565;/947/60/4:653B188163/7133.4: :31@/ 3./ 5?83 4: 656/3./</:: 7?3>=5?67 35 1:0/83146 B./3./8 3./ E13/841< 56 8/0587 @49/: 84:/ 35 1 @819/
- 14 -
:?:2404561@146:33./100?:/7./8/3./E13/841</9/64; ?60.1<</6@/775/:653056:343?3/3./=1:4046@8/74/63:5; 3./1<</@/75;;/60/3./100?:/74:/6343</73574:0.18@/6 3./ 28/:/63 01:/ 3./ 4E2?@6/7 587/8 2850//7:
E/0.16401<<> B43.5?3/H1E4646@ B./3./83./ ;5?67134561< /</E/63:5;1=/3E/6318/:134:;4/7
#* 63./1;58/:147=10A@85?673.4:5?834:5;3./ 056:47/8/7 94/B 3.13 3./ 4E2?@6/7 587/8 :?;;/8: ;85E 2/89/8:43> 167 4<</@1<43> ./ 2850//746@: 1@146:3 3./ 2/343456/8 8/:346@ :5</<> 56 1 91@?/ =/<13/7 167 ?6218340?<184I/7 ;?83./8 :313/E/63 3.13 4: 1 :46@</<46/ 100?:13456016653=/2/8E433/735056346?/56346?13456 5;285:/0?345646:?0.0480?E:3160/:B5?<71E5?633516 1=?:/ 5; 3./ 2850/:: 5; <1B ./ 2/343456/8 4: 3./8/;58/ /6343</73574:0.18@/
#( )583./;58/@546@8/1:56:3.4:5?8321::/:3./ ;5<<5B46@
- 15 -
4 ./2/3434564:./8/=>1<<5B/7 44 ./ 4E2?@6/7 587/8 713/7 "**"#*# 21::/7=>3./</186/777434561<4:38403 167 /::456: ?7@/ 4718 :43346@ 13 1:191A1<>16 46 5 *"# #*## 4: ./8/=>:/31:47/
444 ./ 2/343456/8 4: 74:0.18@/7 5; 3./ 5;;/60/ 2?64:.1=</ ?67/8 /03456 "* 8/17 B43. /03456"
-* % ) #
4:35#<5"