- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %& %'() %(( * ! " "" " # $ " % & ' $ "( ! ) * Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " % & + , ' $ &' $ &' - " " !&' #$$&' & ' & ' " " . / + 0 1, + 2345673738934:3;6<=9<6> 6?7389$8:7268<68: >3@39A;>8?6<=>6466B39CD=A4239C8:726>6C3476>6< 39>3@68" "EF7268BAF=B7A8;3?6A;AE=>AC3 :8> 726 8::69?6 5=9342AE;6 =9<6> 6?7389 !&A' 8: 726 >6G697389 8: 8>>=57389 ?7 #$$ 98H 569<39C E6:8>6 - 3 - 726 >39?35A; 347>3?7 A9< 6443894 8=>7 & 56?3A; 8=>7' A;AE=>AC3 26 567373896> 34 A 5=E;3? 46>GA97 <34?2A>C39C <=7364 =9<6> 726 3C27 78 9:8>@A7389 ?7 64589<697 8 34A9 A?73G347 A9< I8=>9A;347 H28 ?;A3@4 78 2AG6 :3;6< 46G6>A; A55;3?A73894 E6:8>6 726 ?8@567697 A=728>37364265>8?66<489726EA4348:A?8@5;A397 ;8<C6< 89 !"(" A;;6C39C <6@A9< 8: 3;;6CA; C>A73:3?A7389 EF 726 567373896> 39 ?8996?7389 H372 726 <34584A;8:?6>7A39A556A;4 ( 64589<697 8 47A764 72A7 26 2A< :3;6< A ;A>C6 9=@E6> 8: A55;3?A73894 46G6>A; 8: H23?2 ?=;@39A76< 39 A556A;4 569<39C E6:8>6 726 9:8>@A7389 8@@344389=78:72646 !A55;3?A73894H6>6>6I6?76< EF 726 7A76 9:8>@A7389 8@@3443896> 89 "" A9< 234 9A@6 HA4 39?;=<6< 39 726 E;A?B;347 26 - 4 - ?8@5;A39A97 ?;A3@4 78 2AG6 :3;6< $ A55;3?A73894 E6:8>6 726567373896>H28<34@3446<726@ ??8><39C 78 726 ?8@5;A397 726 567373896> 344=6< 9873?6 ?A;;39C =589 726 ?8@5;A39A97 78 A556A> E6:8>6 23@ 89 "(" >6CA><39C :>642 A556A;4 7 34 A;;6C6< 72A7 89 "(" 726 ?8@5;A39A97 @67 726 567373896>A9<48=C27;6CA;C=3<A9?639726EA?BC>8=9<8: 726 >6?697 >6I6?7389 8: 234 A556A;4 7 34 :=>726> A;;6C6< 72A7 <=>39C 7234 @66739C 726 567373896> <6@A9<6< 4(""""" :8>6J769<39C;6CA;26;5A9<3947>=?76<72A7 726 A@8=97 E6 7>A94:6>>6< 78 726 A9B A??8=97 8: 896 A3 A>42A H28 34 A;;6C6< 78 E6 ?8996?76< 78 726 567373896> 26?8@5;A39A97A556A>6<E6:8>6726567373896> 89"("A9<234A556A;4H6>6>646>G6<:8>8><6>4 6A;;6C6472A7726567373896>39:8>@6<23@78@667ACA39 ;A76> 72A7 6G6939C 66;39C ACC>36G6< 726 ?8@5;A39A97 A55>8A?26<8BAF=B7A8;3?6897264A@6<AFA9<48=C27 - 5 - AG83?6>6?8><6>78?8;;6?76G3<69?6734726?8@5;A39A97/4 8H9?A4672A726<3<9879A@6726567373896>A772A758397 A9<7268BAF=B7A8;3?62A9<6<8G6>726<6G3?6H3728=7 >6C3476>39CA9 9 !"(" >64589<697 8 ;8<C6< A :8>@A; ?8@5;A397 26 8BAF=B7A 8;3?6 <=>39C 5>67>A5 5>8?66<39C4 <3>6?76< 726 ?8@5;A39A97 78 7>A94:6> 4 """"" 78 726 A??8=97 8: A3 A>42A 26 7>A94A?7389 HA4 ?8@5;676< 6;6?7>893?A;;F 26 567373896> ?89769<4 72A7 7234 HA4 A9 6>>8968=4 7>A94:6> A9< 726 A@8=97 HA4 3@@6<3A76;F >67=>96< 78 726 ?8@5;A39A97 H3723972>66@39=76472>8=C228966 ! =>39C 39G6473CA7389 ?A;; <67A3; >6?8><4 H6>6 ?8;;6?76< H23?2 >6G6A; 72A7 726 567373896> A9< 726 ?8@5;A39A97H6>63976;652893??8@@=93?A738989@=;735;6 8??A43894 A>8=9< 726 >6;6GA97 <A764 =@=;A73G6;F 726 ?89G6>4A73894 ;A476< ?;846 78 # @39=764 A?>844 46G6>A; 465A>A76 ?A;;4 26 5>846?=7389 A446>74 72A7 39 896 4=?2 - 6 - ?A;;726567373896>>6376>A76<726966<787>A94:6>)A7;6A47 4 """"" * $ 6A>96<?8=946;:8>726567373896>4=E@37472A7 726 G83?6 >6?8><39C <864 987 >6G6A; A9F <6@A9< 8> A??657A9?68:3;;6CA;C>A73:3?A73896:=>726>4=E@37472A7 726A@8=977>A94:6>>6<78726A??8=978: A3A>42AHA4A @347AB69 7>A94:6> A9< HA4 5>8@57;F >67=>96< 7 34 4=E@3776<72A7726?8@5;A39A972A<98>6A48978@667726 567373896>E6:8>6"("A426HA4A;>6A<F4=@@896< :8>72A7<A7689>6C347>A73898:E6:8>67268BAF=B7A 2A9<6< 8G6> 726 G83?6 >6?8><6> A9< 726 ?8@5;A39A97/4 :A3;=>6789A@6726567373896>A??8><39C78726567373896> ?A4746>38=4<8=E789726C69=39696448:726?8@5;A397 # 26567373896>>6;364=589726<6?343894390 !" # $% & '" ' - 7 - ( ) ** * * " ' + (% & , - . % $*/ - ''!0' * & #/1%/ 2 3 *#* $ 444 " ??8><39C 78 726 567373896> 72646 <6?343894 4=558>77265>85843738972A70 &A' A 5>6;3@39A>F 69D=3>F 34 @A9<A78>F E6:8>6 >6C347>A73898:+ &E' <6@A9<8:E>3E63496?644A>F:8>?89G3?7389+ &?' 3>>6C=;A>37364 39 7>A5 5>65A>A7389 G373A76 5>8?66<39C4+A9< &<' D=A4239C 34 A55>85>3A76 H26>6 A;;6CA73894 A>6 3926>697;F3@5>8EAE;6 - 8 - 9 4=5>A726 =5>6@68=>72A4 ?A76C8>3?A;;F 26;< 72A7 3: 726 39:8>@A7389 <34?;8464 ?8@@3443898:A?8C93KAE;68::69?6>6C347>A73898:34 @A9<A78>F 5>6;3@39A>F 69D=3>F 34 56>@3443E;6 89;F 78 A4?6>7A39H26726>?8C93KAE;68::69?634<34?;846<A9<987 787647G6>A?37F 26 ?8@5;A397 26>639 A;;6C64 &3' <6@A9< 8: E>3E6 8: 4(""""" &33' 42A>39C 8: EA9B A??8=97 78 >6?63G6 726 E>3E6 &333' 4=E46D=697 76;652893? ?8@@=93?A7389&3G'A?7=A;7>A94:6>8:@896F<=>39C5>6 7>A55>8?66<39C4A9<&G'>6?8><6<?89G6>4A738939<3?A739C @8967A>F<6@A9< ( 2646 A;;6CA73894 7AB69 A7 :A?6 GA;=6 ?;6A>;F <34?;846 7268::69?6 =9<6> 6?7389!&A' 8: 726>6G697389 8: 8>>=57389 ?7 H23?2 ?>3@39A;3464 6G69 A9 A776@57 78 8E7A39=9<=6A<GA97AC62=4726?A9987E64A3<78 E6H3728=7EA434 - 9 - 26 39G6473CA7389 2A4 >6G6A;6< 72A7 726 567373896> A9< ?8@5;A39A97 2A< ?8@@=93?A76< :8> A55>8J3@A76;F#@39=76445>6A<A?>84446G6>A;?A;;426 73@39C 8: 72646 ?A;;4 ?839?3<64 H372 726 <A764 8: A;;6C6< <6@A9< A9< 726 4=E46D=697 7>A94:6> 8: @896F 2646 @A76>3A;4?A9987E6<34?A><6<A7723447AC6 9 4=5>A726894737=7389A;69?2 8: 726 89/E;6 =5>6@6 8=>7 26;< 72A7 <6@A9< 34 726 C>AGA@698:7268::69?6E=75>88:8:<6@A9<34A@A776> 8:6G3<69?6A9<?A9987E6A<I=<3?A76<<=>39CAD=A4239C 56737389 7HA4:=>726>26;<72A76;6?7>893?6G3<69?64=?2 A4?A;;>6?8><39C434A<@3443E;64=EI6?7785>88: ! 26726>726?89G6>4A7389?894737=764A<6@A9< :8>=9<=6A<GA97AC6H26726>726@896FHA47>A94:6>>6< EF @347AB6 8> H26726> 726 ?8@5;A39A97 A?76< 8=7 8: @A;3?6A>6A;;@A776>4:8>7>3A;26F?A9987E6<6?3<6<39 5>8?66<39C4=9<6> 6?7389$> - 10 - $ 26 567373896> ?89769<4 72A7 726 @896F HA4 39769<6< :8> 726 489 8: 234 :>369< A9< HA4 H>89C;F 7>A94:6>>6< 78 726 ?8@5;A39A97 234 34 A @A776> :8> 726 <6:69?6 >6D=3>39C 6JA@39A7389 8: 726 567373896>/4 =4AC6 23478>F234?897A?7;347A9<?3>?=@47A9?644=>>8=9<39C726 7>A94:6> # 4 26;< 39 4=5>A <6:69?64 >6D=3>39C 6GA;=A7389 8: <345=76< D=6473894 8: :A?7 ?A9987 E6 6976>7A396< A7 726 47AC6 8: D=A4239C 26 )@347AB69 7>A94:6>*7268>F726>6:8>6?A9987;6A<78D=A4239C8: " 26567373896>A>C=6472A77268BAF=B7A8;3?6 CAG6AG83?6>6?8><6>H3728=7>6C3476>39C8>3<6973:F39C 726A??=46<26 =5>6@68=>739 4=5>A 26;< 72A7 6>>8>4 8> 3>>6C=;A>37364 39 726 @8<6 8: 39G6473CA7389 <8 987 G373A76 726 =9;644 726F ?A=46 46>38=45>6I=<3?6A::6?739C726>8878:726?A46 97265>64697?A46726HA44=E46D=697;F >6C3476>6<A9<726>63498A;;6CA73898::AE>3?A7389G69 - 11 - A44=@39C ?6>7A39 3>>6C=;A>37364 726F <8 987 47>3B6 A7 726 I=>34<3?7389 8: 726 58;3?6 78 39G6473CA76 A <34?;846< ?8C93KAE;68::69?6 9 4=5>A 7234 8=>7 26;< 72A7 A;;6CA73894 8: ?8>>=57389 @=47 E6 47>3?7;F 4?>=739346< A9< D=A4239C34I=473:36<89;FH269726A;;6CA73894A>6AE4=>< 3926>697;F3@5>8EAE;68>@A93:647;F@A;A:3<6 ( 6>6 726 ?8@5;A39A97/4 A;;6CA73894 A>6 4=558>76<EF0 &A' ??8=97<67A3;4A;;6C6<;F4=55;36<EF567373896> &E' =;735;676;652893??8@@=93?A73894 &?' G83?6 >6?8><39C 428H39C <34?=44389 8: @8967A>F7>A94:6>A9< &<' ?7=A; 7>A94:6> 8: 4 """"" =9<6> /4 3947>=?73894 2646@A76>3A;45>8G3<6 4A734:A?7389 72A739G6473CA7389@=47?89739=6 - 12 - 9 4=5>A 7234 8=>7 >6376>A76< 72A7 <6@A9< 8: 3;;6CA; C>A73:3?A7389 A9< 374 4=>>8=9<39C ?3>?=@47A9?64 A>6 @A776>4 :8> 7>3A; A9< 3926>697 58H6>4 ?A9987 E6 39G8B6< 78 5>66@57 A ?8>>=57389 7>3A; A7 726 72>6428;< 589 ?A>6:=; 6JA@39A7389 8: 726 @A76>3A; 89 >6?8>< A9< 726 ;6CA; 58437389 7234 8=>7 34 8: 726 ?8943<6>6< G36H 72A7 726 <34?;8464 A ?8C93KAE;6 8::69?6 26 567373896>/4 <6:69?64 >6D=3>6 A55>6?3A7389 8: 6G3<69?6 A9< ?A9987 E6 ;88B6< 3978 39 A 56737389 =9<6> 6?7389$>26?A;;>6?8><4G83?6>6?8><39CA9< 7>A94:6>8:@896F7AB69?=@=;A73G6;F I=473:F ?89739=A73898:39G6473CA7389 ! 234 34 726>6:8>6 987 A :37 ?A46 :8> 6J6>?346 8: 3926>697 I=>34<3?7389 78 D=A42 726 9F 8E46>GA7389 26>639 34 ?89:396<:8> 7265=>58468:726 5>6469756737389 A9<42A;;98739:;=69?67267>3A; - 13 - &3' 26>3@39A;673738947A9<4<34@3446< &33' 9G6473CA738939>3@68 ">6C3476>6<EF 726 8BAF=B7A 8;3?6 A;AE=>AC3 :8> 726 8::69?6 5=9342AE;6 =9<6> 6?7389 !&A' 8: 726 >6G697389 8: 8>>=57389 ?7 #$$ 98H 569<39C E6:8>6 726 >39?35A; 347>3?7 A9< 64438948=>7& 56?3A;8=>7'A;AE=>AC342A;; ?89739=639A??8><A9?6H372;AH &333' ;; 569<39C 3976>;8?=78>F A55;3?A73894 3: A9F 47A9<<345846<8: ,) %!!( $ 34780 ;80 0