Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92626 (KAR)
SHIVAJI B v. SMT. RESHMA AND ANR
CCC/200075/2022 · 2025-07-22
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92626 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92626 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$!$$$%
#$!$
""
&' ( )$"" *(
! "#
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! $%&%"'
("$")'
*
*
('
+
('
*
*!,
*-+
*
) * *
*
''
*
. ''&"!'% *
''&"!'% * *
*(
! "#
- 3 -
! $%&%"'
("$")'
*
! ("$")'
("$")'
+ *
*
("#'''
*
*-, (*+
*
"*
*
- *
*
*
*
*
*
- 4 -
''&"!'
'' /%
*
*
*
*
)'0'" *
:. 1 2
1
)!$ . 34 566477589: ;3< ;4=4 934 649>9><84=: >8 <''&"!' 35?4 @>74A 93>: >89=5 <B=9 566457 C357748D>8D 934 <=A4= A594A '' 65::4A EF 934 745=84A >8D74 BAD4 ;34=4EF 934 ;=>9 649>9><8 C357748D>8D 934 <=A4= A594A '&')' 65::4A EF 934 =>8C>657 >:9=>C9 58A 4::><8: BAD4 58A ABC59><8 66477594
=>EB857 >A5= G
=>EB857. @<= :3<=9 >8 <!'&:499>8D5:>A4934A>:H>::57<@=4:6<8A489 < 58A A>=4C9>8D 3>: =4>8:9594H489 ;>93 E5CI%;5D4:
- 5 -
C<89>8B>9F <@ :4=?>C4 58A C<8:4JB489>57 E484@>9: ;5: A>:H>::4A
34=4:6<8A489 <>893>:>89=5<B=9566457 ;5:9345664775895667>C589E4@<=4934
=>EB85758A934 C<894:9>8D=4:6<8A489 <>8 <''&"!'
34 =4:6<8A489 <: 58A E4@<=4 934
=>EB857 5=4 934 649>9><84=:>8 <''&"!'58A566477589:>8;=>9 566457
+ 45=A 934 745=84A C<B8:47 56645=>8D @<= 934 566477589: 745=84A 48><= <B8:47 56645=>8D @<= =4:6<8A489 < 745=84A <?4=8H489 A?<C594 @<= =4:6<8A489 <: 58A + 58A 57:< 745=84A AA>9><857 <?4=8H489 A?<C594 56645=>8D @<= =4:6<8A489 <+ >8 934C<894H69649>9><8
) 34 65=9>4: 34=4>8 5=4 =4@4==4A 9< 5: 64= 934>= =58IE4@<=4934
=>EB857@<=934:5I4<@C<8?48>48C4
" 34 5667>C589 35: @>74A C<894H69 649>9><8 5774D>8D ;>77@B7 A>:<E4A>48C4 <@ 934 <=A4= 65::4A EF 934
- 6 -
=>EB857 5: C<8@>=H4A EF 934 745=84A >8D74 BAD4 58A :44I>8D >H674H48959><8 <@ 934 =4>8:9594H489 58A E5CI% ;5D4:
# 34 5667>C589 ;5: 566<>894A 5: 5 4C9B=4= EF =4:6<8A489 < ( ABC59><8 <C>49F 58A ;5: :4=?>8D >8 =4:6<8A489 < % 5;535=757 43=B <7F94C38>C 5H5785D5=
>:9 >A5= @<= :3<=9 G<774D4.
3>:
566<>89H489 ;5: AB7F 566=<?4A EF 934 <?4=8H489
465=9H489: =4:6<8A489 <:+ 58A )
34 5667>C589 ;5: 6=<H<94A 5: 48><= =5A4 4C9B=4= <8 0'"''" 58A 5: 474C9><8 =5A4 4C9B=4= <8 +'''# 774D59><8: <@ 5E:48944>:H ;4=4 H5A4 5D5>8:9 934 5667>C589 @<= 934 64=><A @=<H '''$ 9< '''& C35=D4 H4H< ;5: >::B4A 58A A>:C>67>85=F 6=<C44A>8D:
;4=4 >8>9>594A
34 48JB>=F <@@>C4= C<8C7BA4A 9359 934 C35=D4 5D5>8:9 934 5667>C589 ;5: 6=<?4A <8:4JB4897F 58 <=A4= <@ A>:H>::57 @=<H :4=?>C4 ;5: 65::4A <8 &'+'&EF=4:6<8A489 <
- 7 -
0 DD=>4?4AEF934A>:H>::57<=A4=9345667>C589 @>74A 58 566457 B8A4= 4C9><8 &) <@ 934 5=8595I5 ABC59><8 C9 &$+ 34=4>85@94= =4@4==4A 9< 5: G934 C9 &$+. C357748D>8D 934 <=A4= <@ A>:H>::57 A594A &'+'& 65::4A EF 934 =4:6<8A489 < (<774D4 5C9>8D <8 934 >8:9=BC9><8: 58A A>=4C9><8: <@ =4:6<8A489 < % >?4I5858A5 ABC59><8 <C>49F @<= :3<=9 GABC59><8<C>49F. $ 4@<=4 934
=>EB857 934 =4:6<8A489: 56645=4A 58A @>74A <EK4C9><8: C<8948A>8D 9359 934 A>:H>::57 ;5:
74D57 58A ?57>A 35?>8D >::B4A @<= 6=<?4A H>:C<8ABC9 9 ;5: @B=934= C<8948A4A 9359 B8A4= 4C9><8 )#E <@ 934 C9 &$+ 934 585D>8D <HH>9944 35: @B77 5B93<=>9F 9< 95I4A>:C>67>85=F5C9><85D5>8:9934945C34=:58A:95@@58A 9<65:::B>95E74<=A4=:5:64=4C9><8&<@934C9&$+ 6<8 C<8:>A4=59><8 <@ 934 489>=4 H594=>57 <8 =4C<=A 934 =>EB857577<;4A934566457A>=4C9>8D=4>8:9594H489<@934 5667>C589 ;>93 E5CI%;5D4: C<89>8B>9F <@ :4=?>C4 58A 577 C<8:4JB489>57E484@>9:;>93@B=934=A>=4C9><89<=4:6<8A489
- 8 -
<: 58A 9< C<H67F ;>93 934 <=A4= <@ =4>8:9594H489 ;>93>8@<B=;44I:@=<H934A594<@934<=A4=3>74A<>8D :< 934
=>EB857 <E:4=?4A 9359 :>8C4 934 5667>C589.:
566<>89H489 35: E448 566=<?4A EF 934 <H649489 B93<=>9F>9;5:H58A59<=F@<==4:6<8A489 <:58A9< <E95>86=><=566=<?57E4@<=465::>8D934<=A4=<@A>:H>::57 5: 64= B74 + <@ 934 5=8595I5 ABC59><857 8:9>9B9><8: <774D>594ABC59><8B74:''+34=4>85@94==4@4==4A9< 5:GB74:''+. & 34
=>EB857 57:< 8<94A 9359 934 5667>C589.:
:4=?>C4 @=<H 934 A594 <@ 566<>89H489 >4 @=<H && 9>77
4C4HE4='0;5:B8E74H>:34A58A934=4@<=4>9C<B7A 8<9E46=4:BH4A9359934H>:C<8ABC935:<CCB==4A;>93<B9 5:9=<8DKB:9>@>C59><8
34
=>EB857@B=934=<E:4=?4A9359 >8 934 8<9>C4 >::B4A 9< 934 5667>C589 934=4 ;5: 8< 5774D59><8935934;5:8<959577C<H>8D9<934C<774D4EB9 ;359 ;5: :5>A >: 9359 34 35: 8<9 95I48 934 C75::4: @=<H '''$ 9< '''&
3B: 934 859B=4 <@ C35=D4 H4H<58A934A465=9H4895748JB>=F@>8A>8D:A>A8<957>D8
- 9 -
C5:9>8D A<BE9 <8 934 A>:C>67>85=F 5C9><8 CC<=A>8D7F 934 =>EB857@<B8A9359934<=A4=<@A>:H>::57844A:9<E4:49 5:>A4
'
34 566477589: 6=4@4==4A ;=>9 649>9><8 5::5>7>8D 934<=A4=<@
=>EB857<8?5=><B:D=<B8A:H<=465=9>CB75=7F C<8948A>8D9359C9<@&$+>:8<95667>C5E745:934F5=4 D<?4=84AEF934778A>5<B8C>7@<=
4C38>C57ABC59><8 C9 &$0 G
C9 &$0.
@<= :3<=9
34 745=84A >8D74 BAD4 B6<8 566=4C>59><8 <@ 934 C<89489><8: 58A H594=>57 <8 =4C<=A 347A 9359 4C9><8 + <@ C9 &$+ 4LC7BA4:9345667>C59><8<@934C99<>8:9>9B94:D<?4=84A EF
C9 &$0 <;4?4=
4C38>C57 ABC59><8 >: A4@>84AB8A4=4C9><8+0<@934C9&$+58A934C9 5667>4:9<577>8:9>9B9><84LC46993<:4:64C>@>C577F4LC7BA4A 58A 347A 9359 >8 934 >8:9589 C5:4 649>9><84= < >: 5 6=>?594 6<7F94C38>C C<774D4 58A 934=4@<=4 >: D<?4=84A EF 934B74:@=5H4AB8A4=9345=8595I5=>?594ABC59><857 8:9>9B9><8: >:C>67>8458A<89=<7B74:&0$;3>C35=4 :5?4AEF4C9><8)#<@934C9&$+
34745=84A>8D74
- 10 -
BAD4@B=934=<E:4=?4A9359934B74:''+6=4:C=>E4:5 6=<C4AB=4 @<= >H6<:>8D H5K<= 648579>4: 65=9>CB75=7F >8 B74 +$ >8C7BA>8D 934 A>:H>::57 @=<H :4=?>C4 58A <8 934 <934= 358A 934
C9 &$0 6=>H5=>7F A457: ;>93 =4DB759><8: <@ C<B=:4: <@ :9BAF >8 934 @>47A: :BC3 5: 8D>844=>8D 4C38<7<DF =C3>94C9B=4 4=5H>C:
8AB:9=>57
=5>8>8D >8>8D <= 58F <934= :BEK4C9 5: 934 9594 <?4=8H489 H5F 8<9>@F 48C4 >9 ;5: <E:4=?4A 9359 934
C9 &$0 A<4: 8<9 C<?4= 6<7F94C38>C >8:9>9B9><8: B8A4= >9: A>:C>67>85=F 6=<?>:><8: 58A 5CC<=A>8D7F 347A 9359 934 C9 &$+ >: 5667>C5E74 9< 934 @5C9:<@9346=4:489C5:4
34745=84A>8D74BAD4@B=934=8<94A9359934 =>EB857 ;5: KB:9>@>4A >8 5==>?>8D 59 >9: C<8C7B:><8 35?>8D @B77F566=4C>594A934489>=4A<CBH4895=F4?>A48C4*B=934= <E:4=?>8D 9359 934 C35=D4 <@ B85B93<=>M4A 5E:48944>:H 4?48 >@ 6=<?4A A>A 8<9 KB:9>@F 934 4L9=4H4 648579F <@ A>:H>::57 58A 6B8>:3H489 ;5: D=<::7F A>:6=<6<=9><8594 58AC<8@>=H4A934<=A4=65::4AEF934
=>EB857
- 11 -
34566477589:C<8948A9359934C9&$+A<4: 8<95667F9<934>=>8:9>9B9><858A5::4=99359934>8:9>9B9><8 >:D<?4=84AEF
C9&$0;3>C36=4:C=>E4A>9:<;8 @=5H4;<=I @<= 94C38>C57 >8:9>9B9><8 9 >: 57:< C<8948A4A 9359 934 A>:H>::57 ;5: E5:4A <8 B85B93<=>M4A 5E:48C4 @=<H '''$ 9< '''& ;3>C3 ;5: 6=<?4A >8 A465=9H48957 48JB>=F 9 >: C<8948A4A 9359 934
=>EB857.: A>:C=49><8 =4>8:9594H489 ;>93 E5CI%;5D4: >: 3>D37F A>:6=<6<=9><8594 58A :B@@4=: @=<H 64=?4=:>9F ;5==589>8D >894=@4=48C4EF93>:<B=9
+ 6<864=B:57<@4C9><8+4C9><8+058A 4C9><8 )# <@ C9 &$+ 58A B74: + 58A +$ <@ B74: ''+;43<7A9359934A>:C>67>85=FH5994=:C<8C4=8>8D934 4H67<F44: <@ 934 566477589:.
>8:9>9B9><8 @577: ;>93>8 934 :C<64<@934C9&$+
34745=84A>8D74BAD458A934 =>EB857 ;5: KB:9>@>4A >8 3<7A>8D 9359 C9 &$+ ;5:
5667>C5E74 B74 + <@ B74: ''+ H58A594: 6=><= 566=<?57@=<H934C<H6494895B93<=>9FE4@<=4A>:H>::>8D :B:648A>8D <= =4H<?>8D 58 4H67<F44 @=<H :4=?>C4 58A
- 12 -
@5>7B=4 9< C<H67F ;>93 93>: =B74 =48A4= 934 A>:H>::57 6=<C4AB=577F >8?57>A
34
=>EB857 C5=4@B77F 566=4C>594A 9344?>A48C458A934=4>:8<64=?4=:>9F>8>9:@>8A>8D
34 745=84A >8D74 BAD4 <8 566=4C>59>8D 934 489>=4 H594=>57 35:=>D397FA>:H>::4A934;=>9649>9><8=4@B:>8D9<>894=@4=4 ;>93 934 <=A4= 65::4A EF 934
=>EB857 *<= 577 934 :5>A =45:<8: 934 <=A4= 65::4A EF 934
=>EB857 C<8@>=H4A EF 934 745=84A >8D74 BAD4 5=4 74D577F :B:95>85E74 58A C577 @<=8<>894=@4=48C4EF93>:<B=9
) B66<=9>8D 934 <=A4= 65::4A EF 934
=>EB857 C<8@>=H4AEF934745=84A>8D74BAD4>9>:C<8948A4AEF 934745=84A48><=<B8:479359A4:6>94934C745=A>=4C9><8 <@934
=>EB857;3>C35995>84A@>857>9FB6<8C<8@>=H59><8EF 93>:<B=9>8934;=>9649>9><8934566477589:35?4;>77@B77F @5>74A9<=4>8:95949345667>C589934=4EFC<HH>99>8DD=<::
C<894H69
34 8<8%C<H67>58C4 >9 >: 5::4=94A >: 8<9 >85A?4=9489EB9A47>E4=594C<89BH5C><B:;5==589>8D64857 C<8:4JB48C4: CC<=A>8D7F 934 C<H675>8589 :<BD39
- 13 -
>8>9>59><8 <@ C<894H69 6=<C44A>8D: 5D5>8:9 934 =4:6<8A489:
" 8 93>: C<894L9 => HE4AI5= 745=84A C<B8:47 56645=>8D @<= 934 566477589: :BEH>9: 9359 934 6=4:489 C<894H69 649>9><8 >: 8<9 H5>895>85E74 >8 ?>4; <@ 934 :959B9<=F =4H4AF 5?5>75E74 B8A4= 934 6=<?>:><8: <@ C9 &$+ 58A 34 =47>4A B6<8 4C9><8 &# A <@ 934 C9 &$+9;5:C<8948A4A9359>87>D39<@934:5>A6=<?>:><8 934 C<H675>8589 HB:9 566=<5C3 =>EB857 >9:47@ @<= 4L4CB9><8 <@ 934 5;5=A ;3>C3 35: :959B9<=F 6<;4= B8A4= 934<A4<@>?>7=<C4AB=4&'$48C4934=44L>:9:58 5794=859>?4 58A 4@@>C5C><B: =4H4AF 58A 934 C<894H69 KB=>:A>C9><8<@93>:<B=9>:8<9599=5C94A>8:BC3C5:4:
# 4C9><8&#A<@934C9&$+=45A:5:B8A4=
- 14 -
! "#$% & "#$% '(
0 8?>4;<@934:64C>@>C758DB5D4<@4C9><8&#A <@ 934 C9 &$+ 934 ABC59><8 66477594
=>EB857 >:
?4:94A ;>93 @B77 6<;4=: 9< 48@<=C4 >9: <=A4=: 5: 93<BD3 934F 5=4 A4C=44: <@ 5 >?>7 <B=9
34=4@<=4 934 C<H675>8589 35: 5 A>=4C9 :959B9<=F =4H4AF E4@<=4 934 =>EB857 58A 93>: =4H4AF >: 5A4JB594 4@@>C5C><B: 58A :64C>@>C577FA4:>D84A@<=48@<=C4H489<@934<=A4=:65::4A B8A4=934C9<@&$+
34=4@<=4934C<894H69649>9><8>:
8<9 H5>895>85E74 58A 934 C<H675>8589 >: 59 7>E4=9F 9< 566=<5C3 934
=>EB857 B8A4= 4C9><8 &#A <@ 934 C9 &$+ @<= 4L4CB9><8 <@ 934 5;5=A!<=A4= < C5:4 >: H5A4 <B9@<=>8>9>59><8<@C<894H696=<C44A>8D:348C4:5H4>: A=<664A58A;465::934@<77<;>8D
>
34 ;=>9 566457 >: 34=4EF
- 15 -
>> 34 <=A4= A594A '' >8 =>949>9><8 <''&"!':958A:
>>> 34 C<894H69 6=<C44A>8D: 5=4 34=4EF ;>93 7>E4=9F 9< 934 C<H675>8589 9< 566=<5C3 934 =>EB857>85CC<=A58C4;>9375;
+( &$$$%' ! +( &$' ! >:9 <7 <