Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92622 (KAR)
SURAJ v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201544/2025 · 2025-12-12
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92622 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92622 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! ! %& %'() &%(( *
! "
#
$
! "
$#
! "
" %
$
! "
&%
'
(
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
) % %%%
) ! #
##
)
! "
&%
'%) * % % ) #(
% ) #! ) '( ' "!# ) %( %
%
% )
+, ##
%
)
))% ! "+ '#( # + )% ) ))
%
)
)
-
./0123/3/45/06/7289:123/3/452;4 <==>0284 ?.4 /0 .>09<58 46 ;201458253 4# =4@17</5<53 <58 123/3/452;0 # 34 " ?.4 <;2 6<3.2;/57<? <58 ;27<3/A20 46
- 3 -
<==>028 4 .>09<58 022B/5C D><0./5C 46 3.2 1;4=228/5C0 1258/5C /5 ;4+, ## 64; 3.2 46625=20 1>5/0.<972 >582; 2=3/450 ! "+ '#( # + 46 ##
# ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 022B/5C D><0.@253 46 3.2 1;4=228/5C0 45 3.2 C;4>58 3.<3 3.2 =4@17</53 .<0 9225 748C28 ?/3. @<7/=2 <58 >732;/4; @43/A2 04727: ?/3. <5 /53253/45 34.<;<00 123/3/452; 4 .>09<58 <58./0 <C28 6<3.2;<745C?/3../06<3.2;E09;43.2;<580/032;?.4<;2 <;;</C528 <0 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " ;2012=3/A27: 3 /0 =45325828 3.<3 3.2 =4@17</53 /0 < =72<; <9>02 46 3.2 1;4=200467<? 2<;528 =4>5027 <112<;/5C 64; ;201458253 4# =4@17</5<53 .4?2A2; 0>9@/30 3.<3 3.2 =4@17</53 8/0=740200>66/=/253@<32;/<7341;4=228<C</503123/3/452;0 40# 34 " <58 =4532580 3.<3 <3 3.2 03<C2 46 1258/5C /5A203/C<3/453./04>;34>C.3543342F2;=/02/30/5.2;253 G>;/08/=3/4534D><0.3.21;4=228/5C0
- 4 -
" 2<;528 /C. 4>;3 4A2;5@253 %72<82; 17<=/5C ;27/<5=2453.2<772C<3/450@<82/53.2=4@17</53.<0<704 <8A<5=28<;C>@2530/53.20<@2A2/5<580>9@/303.<354 /58>7C25=2/0?<;;<5328<33./0G>5=3>;2 <A/5C .2<;8 3.2 72<;528 =4>5027 <112<;/5C 64; 3.2 1<;3/20 <58 >145 12;>0<7 46 3.2 @<32;/<7 45 ;2=4;8 3./0 4>;3 .<0 <8A2;328 34 3.2 <772C<3/450 023 4>3 /5 3.2 =4@17</53748C2845+## 9:;2014582534#?.4 /03.28<>C.32;/57<?46123/3/452;40#34" $ .2 0.4;3 D>203/45 3.<3 6<770 64; =450/82;<3/45 9264;2 3./0 4>;3 /0 <0 34 ?.23.2; 3.2 =453/5><3/45 46 =;/@/5<7 1;4=228/5C0 <C</503 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " /0 ?<;;<53281<;3/=>7<;7:?.253.2:<;212;@<5253;20/82530 463.23<3246<.<;<0.3;<<58?.253.2=4@17</53/30276 8/0=74020 3.<3 4?/5C 34 8/662;25=20 923?225 123/3/452;
4 <58 ;201458253 4# <58 <3 3.2 /532;A253/45 46 A/77<C2 2782;0 3.2 =4>172 ?<0 1;4A/828 < 021<;<32 ;20/825=2<327B>5//77<C2
- 5 -
264;2 <8A2;3/5C 34 3.2 @2;/30 46 3.2 =<02 45 .<58 3./0 4>;3 822@0 /3 <11;41;/<32 34 2F3;<=3 3.2 ;272A<53 14;3/45463.2?;/3325=4@17</53?./=.;2<80<0>582;
!" #$ % & '
()*+(*(+(,
'
$ -.
/
0 '
1 2 3456 / !" 3 78 '
9
:
; 3 !" ' < !" #7=
> 0 #7=8 ?3
$
'
' -.@ A >
#/ ;=B C D E 3 /
' FG 3 #7 = 7 &
9 # HI 3 !" #/
!"
- 2F2 C
"#7 = 8 J
#K
> L K > M N 9
O
P ? Q N N N 9 &
P ? NRM8 J '
'
9K > '
9K 9
' 0
- 6 -
S$
H GC &" A HI L ' 0 27 3 T 9 92 7
' !"
A # $ $
;K= >!" >
C:D
& -
C #" A : T # = 8 $
' CD
?L
L ; 3
> L U ' 9K
>!" HL = 8 > N
> LI ' ' !" 92 ' SVN '
9 3
5 92 9 # = 7 #/
' ' >P W B = $ ' $ SV
# =X J '
' CD ' #K > ; 3
C P
P YE > ' ' 7 ' ' S$ -. / !" !" C /W 3 HL '
9 >
S:
L #K > > Z # K
7 '
[L !" N= &8 N '
9 >
S:
[L
'
[ 9
93
N '
' 0 & 9 & 9
- 7 -
: ' HFG$ % & S > '
9 ' Y C \
#K= A 9K= 8 W
> 9 #7 9 C /
'
' ' 9 & 7 & # = 8
C /# '
J E ? N
]-
!" ' !" > ]-
H ' ' L
3 $ %7 9 & L# ' &" A ^G = 8 HG
'
9 '
9 '
S: 9 '
>7 C/ NST 9 '
9 L B /U S: 5 A" L 3 9 C _3 -. ` 3 '
' ' B L 3 9 3 2 $
C /P #7= 8
?3 '
aa*+b*(+(, #/ aa c Z VT ' ' ? H' VT #7
' 53 M
0 SCP O S: V 0 ?
N
d
c M A A$
9 9
Y
e
!" '
- 8 -
9
9
C /B
H LI
' ' 5 7 8
0
' 9V/S !" ' L -. ` J
#K = > >!"
3 & L >
N ' P YE ]-
!" 3 78
L ' '
9 B L 2 $ FG RF5 RE W A #7 '
: X '
:
Sf
'
9 L B /U
S:
5 X '
Y C \ S:
Sf
9 '
>7 C/ NST
0:
H " N
/ V H U C / - d! ' ' W Z 3 S !" $ KT 8
, 5<=<;26>7<58=7402;2F<@/5<3/45463.2?;/3325 =4@17</53 748C28 9: ;201458253 4# 8<>C.32;/57<? /3
- 9 -
/0 2A/8253 3.<3 0.2 .<0 >52D>/A4=<77: <8@/3328 3.<3 < 1<5=.<:<3?<0=45A2528<581>;0><533.2;234123/3/452; 4# ?.4 /0 3.2 6<3.2;/57<? 46 ;201458253 4# <58 6<3.2; 46 123/3/452; 4 ?<0 <8A/028 34 1;4A/82 < 021<;<32 ;20/825=2 34 123/3/452; 4 <58 ;201458253 4# 5 <==4;8<5=2 ?/3. 3.2 0</8 1<5=.<:<3 123/3/452; 4 <58 ;201458253 4# =4@@25=28 3.2/; @<;/3<7 7/62 021<;<327:<327B>5//77<C2 ! 3 3.2 0<@2 3/@2 ;201458253 4# <772C20 3.<3 543?/3.03<58/5C 3.2 1;4A/0/45 46 < 021<;<32 ;20/825=2 123/3/452;
4# 6<3.2;/57<? <745C ?/3. ./0 9;43.2; /503/C<328123/3/452;4<583.<3123/3/452;492/5C >582;3.2/567>25=246./06<3.2;<58>5=720>9G2=328.2;
34 .<;<00@253 9: >0/5C <9>0/A2 7<5C><C2 .25 3.202 <772C<3/450 <;2 2F<@/528 /5 3.2/; 1;412; 12;012=3/A2 1<;3/=>7<;7:/53.27/C.3463.2<8.<<;=<;80<58272=3;/=/3: 9/7701;48>=289:123/3/452;040#34"?./=.1;/@<6<=/2 203<97/0. 3.<3 3.2: <;2 12;@<5253 ;20/82530 46 8C/; /03;/=3/53.23<3246<.<;<0.3;</392=4@20<11<;253
- 10 -
3.<3 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " ?2;2 543 0.<;/5C < =4@@45 .4>02.478?/3.;2014582534# + 3 /0 >564;3>5<32 3.<3 8201/32 3.2 <8@/3328 6<=346 021<;<32 ;20/825=2 .<A/5C 9225 1;4A/828 3.;4>C. 3.2 /532;A253/45 46 3.2 1<5=.<:<3 ;201458253 4# .<0 =.4025 34 /@17/=<32 3.2 ;27<3/A20 46 .2; .>09<58 9: @<B/5CA<C>2<584@5/9>0<772C<3/450.2;2=4;86>;3.2; /58/=<3203.<33.26<3.2;/57<?<58./09;43.2;<580/032;
<C28 <94>3 $# <58 $ :2<;0 ;2012=3/A27: .<A2 9225 <;;</C528/53.2=;/@/5<71;4=228/5C0/53.29<=B8;4146< @<;/3<7 8/0=4;8 923?225 123/3/452; 4 <58 ;201458253 4# ./72123/3/452;4 .>09<58/0;2D>/;28346<=2 3.2 3;/<7 /5 <==4;8<5=2 ?/3. 7<? 3./0 4>;3 /0 46 3.2 =450/82;28 A/2? 3.<3 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " ?.4 <;2 ;20/82530 46 3.2 3<32 46 <.<;<0.3;< <58 <C</503 ?.4@ 54012=/6/=4A2;3<=30<;2<33;/9>328.<A2548/;2=3;472/5 3.2@<;/3<78/0=4;854?1;2A</7/5C923?225123/3/452;4
- 11 -
<58 ;201458253 4# >9G2=3/5C 3.2@ 34 =;/@/5<7 1;402=>3/45<3>;<8/03;/=3/8<;/53.2<9025=246<5: 1;/@< 6<=/2 @<32;/<7 ?4>78 <@4>53 34 <5 <9>02 46 3.2 1;4=200467<?
.2;264;2/54;82;3402=>;23.2258046G>03/=2 3./04>;3822@0/3<11;41;/<3234D><0.3.21;4=228/5C0 /5046<; <0 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " <;2 =45=2;528 3 /0 .4?2A2; @<82 =72<; 3.<3 3.2 1;402=>3/45 0.<77 =453/5>2 <C</503123/3/452;4
)4; 3.2 64;2C4/5C ;2<0450 3./0 4>;3 1;4=2280 34 1<003.264774?/5C
'/(.2123/3/45/0<774?28/51<;3 '//( .2 1;4=228/5C0 /5 ;/@2 4+, ## 64; 3.2 46625=20 1>5/0.<972 >582; 2=3/450 ! "+ '#( # <58+463.2.<;<3/:<:<:<<5./3<##<;2.2;29:
D><0.28 /5046<; <0 123/3/452;0 40# 34 " <;2 =45=2;528
- 12 -
4?2A2; 3.2 1;4=228/5C0 0.<77 =453/5>2 <C</503 123/3/452;4/5<==4;8<5=2?/3.7<? +) %!!( $
/034#74 30/