Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92620 (KAR)
HANUMAYYA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/201670/2024 · 2025-12-08
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92620 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92620 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$
%#&!#!#
'!(#)
! "#
! $%#
&
! #
!! ! #
'
' !! ! #
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
! %#
$ (
&
! $#
! $#
" )
!!! ! "#
!! ! #
&
! #
!! !! ! "#
- 3 -
& !! !! ! #
!! !! ! #
!! !! ! $#
% ' !! ! %#
$ (
! $#
!! ! "#
"
! "#
- 4 -
(
' !! &
! $#
!! ! &#
!! '!! ! $$#
& !! !! ! $#
!! !! ! $#
!! !! ! #
% '!! !! ! &#
- 5 -
$ !! !! ! #
!! !! &
! "#
" !! !! ! $#
& !! ! &#
&
!! ! %%#
& !! ! "#
&&
!! ! ""#
- 6 -
& (
&
! "#
& !! !! ! #
&% ' !! '
! $#
&$ '
! #
& !! &
! %#
&" ) !! ! $#
! %#
- 7 -
!! !! ! #
)
!! ! %"#
&
! %#
! ')
! %#
! "#
% (
&
! $&#
$ )
!! ! &#
- 8 -
' (
&
! %#
" '( !! ! "#
!! ! #
!! '!! ! #
! &&#
& '
! #
!! ! #
- 9 -
!! !! ! %$#
% (
!! ! #
$ '!! ! $#
*! '
!!#
+' ' ! ! ! ! +! %
! '
%
& ) +! ! &+ '
%$
! ++! - 10 -
% ++
! +! $ +! ++ !'' ! '
!#
" +, ++ !'' ! '
!#
)
!! (
(
% ! !! !! "
& !!'
'!'
- 11 -
!! ! *! ')
'+ $- ++ %- +"- +#
( ! + % $ + + ! #
( +
, ./0 + ( ! ! " + ! # (
+ !!! (
! ! " (
+ ! + # 1/.# ' '!# (
+ ! 2 " +! +( , #! !!! + +
! +! !
(
- 12 -
3) '
45 657/7/895:2 1:5 ;5<8:5 74/2 8=:7 255>/9? <8@@8A/9?:5@/5<2
! ""
! #
"
#
$%&$&
' ( )
#
""
! "
*
+
"
"
4/2 8=:7 ;B /975:/C 8:D5: D175D $ 41D61225D745<8@@8A/9?8:D5: ,- . - 13 -
/ 0 )
1
"+
2
34 # #
"
5
" 6 ! 7
(
""
6 ! 7
! 7
""
! " # $%&$&
' ( ) #
2!3! 7
""
"
#
8 29: ' ( ) #
8 2!6%
"
! 2 %4$%$5 7 8 - ;
(
"
"
) 7 . "
"
/
2!%4$%$5<
- 14 -
& 7 /2 2=;C/775D ;B @51:95D E8=925@ <8: 745 :52689D5972 7417 2/9E5 745 /22=5 :1/25D /9 74/2 657/7/89 /2 A/74:5?1:D78/9E@=2/898<74591C528<745657/7/895:2/9 745@/278<5@/?/;@5.875:2A4/E4<8:C2745/975?:1@61:78< 7455@5E7/896:8E52219BD/26=75A/74:5?1:D7874521C5 412 78;5 1DF=D/E175D =9D5: 5E7/89 $ 8<745'1:9171>1 8865:17/.58E/57/52E7"" GE7H;:5./7B# 51:95D E8=925@ <8: 745 :52689D5972 :5@/52 =689 745 8:D5: D175D 61225D ;B 745 88:D/9175 59E48< 74/2 8=:7 /9
A4/E4/97=:9412;55961225D:5@B/9?=689745F=D?C597 8< 745 65I 8=:7 /9 745 E125 8<
!"
# $ %#
$ & # $# :568:75D /9 '
(( ) 12A5@@127458:D5:8<88:D/917559E48<74/28=:7 /9 745 E125 8< *$+ $# %# ,$ $ & -
$# /9
.19D/
0 $#%# $ & - $# :568:75D /9
- 15 -
1-0..)19D2=;C/775D74172/9E5745D/26=7/9?J=527/892 8<<1E72A/74:5?1:D7891C52/9745.875:2@/27/2/9.8@.5D 745 657/7/895:2 241@@ ;5 :5@5?175D 78 1.1/@ :5C5DB =9D5: 5E7/89$8<745E7 51:95D E8=925@ <8: 745 657/7/895:2 D852 987 D/26=757458:D5:261225D;B74588:D/917559E48<74/2 8=:7:5@5?17/9?74561:7/52781.1/@:5C5DB=9D5:5E7/89 $8<745E7=9D5:2/C/@1:E/:E=C2719E52 % 9 7417 ./5A 745 C1775: 745 657/7/89 /2 #" #$ &A/74745<8@@8A/9?D/:5E7/89 / 45657/7/895:/217@/;5:7B786:8E55D;5<8:5745 5?/27:1:/9.8>/9?7456:8./2/8928<5E7/89$ 8<745E7/<281D./25A/74/9&D1B2<:8C745 D1758<:5E5/678<E5:7/</5DE86B8<74/28:D5: // 455?/27:1:'1:9171>18865:17/.58E/57/52 241@@ 745:51<75: 1<<8:D/9? 8668:7=9/7/52 78 745 61:7/5261221166:86:/1758:D5::5D:522/9?745 ?:/5.19E58<745657/7/895:2/91EE8:D19E5A/74 @1AA/74/9%D1B2745:51<75:
- 16 -
/// 45.8752E1275D;B745657/7/895:2>567=9D5:
2561:175 ;8I /9 75:C2 8< 745 /975:/C 8:D5:
?:1975D ;B 74/2 8=:7 241@@ ;5 71>59 /978 E892/D5:17/89 1<75: D/26821@ 8< 745 6:8E55D/9? ;5<8:57455?/27:1:
!*( '#!#) &
')) /27 8@ 8& !'