Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92619 (KAR)

SANGANNA DESAI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/200965/2025 · 2025-11-17

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %$& $ $ ' ( !" # $" % " &'' ( )))" " * ( " " & && ( ' ! # $'("& + '("(" & % Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * & , & & $% * & - ( ( " !")")! " "" ( ' & * .+$%* &(( " "" ( ' " " / ( ' ' ' ( & & && &( ' .+$% * (&& ( & * & " ( & *( ( 0("("""'( $ 0("("""'(% 123234516 37 819461 2:37 4;62 711<35= 94>>4?35= 61>3197 !" #$%&' ()'* ( + , -. + !" &' ()'* ' ' / !"010 & ')'*()'* 2'()'* - 3 - 3'' ( &' )'* + , #. ( ' ' 4 " @71 49 2:1 A123234516 37 2:@2 :1 8135= 2:1 4?516 49 >@5B 35 C"4" / 732;@21B @2 (;BB183:@> 2@>;< @>3<423 48@>3 @>3<423 D3>>@=1 E1@7;635= @F617 :@B @AA>31B 946 F:@5=1 49 >@5B ;7@=1 964E @=63F;>2;6@> A;6A4717 24 545@=63F;>2;6@> A;6A4717 ?:3F: ?@7 B;>C @FF46B1B8C2:1617A45B152@;2:463231735216E749 993F3@> (1E46@5B;E B@21B )")!") @5B 2:161@9216 :1 :@B @AA>31B 946 @AA64D@> 49 2:1 B1D1>4AE152 A>@5" :@2 2:1 617A45B1524":@B@FF46B1B@AA64D@>242:1>@C4;2A>@5 45)") "),@77115@2551G;61242:1?632A1232345" :161@9216 2:1 A123234516 :@B E@B1 @ 61A617152@2345 24 617A45B1524":319 993F162461=372162:1A>427352:1 61D15;1 61F46B7 49 2:1 4993F1 49 617A45B152 4"" 5 617A4571 2:16149 617A45B152 4" :@7 377;1B @5 15B4671E152 B@21B ")") 3523E@235= 2:@2 2:1 A64A162C 81@635= 4" / E1@7;635= @F617 35 ?:3F: - 4 - 2:1 A123234516 :@7 @>61@BC 482@351B F45D167345 @5B B1D1>4AE152 A>@5 B4 542 9@>> ?32:35 2:1 H;637B3F2345 49 @>3<423 (;53F3A@>32C" 135= @==631D1B 8C 2:1 7@E1 2:1 A123234516378194612:374;62" " 1@651B F4;571> 946 2:1 A123234516 @AA1@635= 2:64;=:D3B14F4591615F17;8E3272:@22:1D16CB4F;E152 @2 551G;61 ?:3F: 37 2:1 B1D1>4AE152 A>@5 35B3F@217 2:@22:17@3B>@5B35C"4" / E1@7;635=@F6179@>>7 ?32:35 2:1 H;637B3F2345 49 @>3<423 (;53F3A@>32C" 7 7;F: 2:161 37 54 61@745 946 2:1E 24 B1F>351 24 F4573B16 2:1 61I;172E@B18C2:1A1232345162461=372162:1A>427352:1 61D15;1 61F46B7 49 2:1 (;53F3A@>32C" 15F1 711<7 946 I;@7:35= 49 2:1 7@3B 15B4671E152 @5B 946 @ B361F2345 24 2:1617A45B152724B42:1511B9;>" !" 5617A457163:@32@5C@';E@6"(">1@651B F4;571> @AA1@635= 946 617A45B152 4" 7;8E327 2:@2 35 216E7492:1542393F@23452:1H;637B3F234549E;53F3A@>32C37 45>C ?32:35 <3>4E12617 6@B3;7 @5B @5C A64A162C 9@>>35= - 5 - 81C45B 2:1 7@3B >3E32 ?4;>B 542 F4E1 ?32:35 2:1 H;637B3F2345 49 E;53F3A@>32C" :@2 @5C @61@ 4;273B1 >3E32 2:4;=: ?32:35 2:1 7@E1 D3>>@=1 ?3>> 81 @773=51B 24 81 E@5@=1B@5B@BE35372161B8C2:1 @5F:@C@2" " 4?1D16:17;8E3272:@2=3D1574E123E12:1 61I;172 49 2:1 A123234516 ?4;>B 81 F4573B161B @5B @ B12@3>1B46B16352:3761=@6B?4;>B81A@771B" " ;8E377345372@<154561F46B" ," FF46B35=>C2:194>>4?35= $3% :1 15B4671E152 @2 551G;61 B@21B ")") A@771B 8C 617A45B152 4" (;53F3A@>32C37I;@7:1B" $33% 17A45B152 4" (;53F3A@>32C 37 B361F21B 24 61F4573B16 2:1 @AA>3F@2345 49 2:1 A123234516":1617A45B1524"7:@>>=3D1@ B12@3>1B617A4571242:1@AA>3F@234593>1B8C 2:1 A123234516 711<35= 61=3726@2345 49 :37 - 6 - A64A162317 E1523451B 35 551G;61 35 2:1 61D15;161F46B7" $333% 9 32 37 94;5B 2:@2 2:1 7@3B A64A162C 9@>>7 ?32:352:1H;637B3F234549617A45B1524" (;53F3A@>32C 511B9;> 24 81 B451" 9 32 9@>>7 4;273B1 327 H;637B3F2345 51F177@6C 15B4671E152 35B3F@235= 2:1 5@E1 49 @;2:4632C ?32:35 ?:471 H;637B3F2345 7@3B A64A162C 9@>>7 7:@>> 81 3523E@21B 24 2:1 A123234516" $3D% ;F: @F2345 7:@>> 81 2@<15 ?32:35 @5 4;216 >3E3249)B@C7964E2:1B@214961F13A249 F1623931BF4AC492:3746B16" FF46B35=>C2:1*632 123234537" )* '$ $( & *' 3724">4", 2A<