Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92616 (KAR)
MOAHMMED WAQAR AHMED v. THE STATE THROUGH M.B. NAGAR POLICE
CRL.RP/200075/2019 · 2025-07-21
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92616 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92616 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""# #"$%$
! &!'%#(##"
'(#
)*)+,
*-)!##,,
'(#
)*)+,
*-)!##,,
! "
! "#$#%&#
'
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! () &% ! '
%*%&*&%) '! + '
, *#% *&%)
'
! ! ,#$ *&%) &%&*&%( '
! -
*(
"#$#%&
"
! "#$#%&#
'
! () &% ! '
*%&*&%) '! +' *#% *&%)
'
! ! .& *&%) &%&*&%( '
! ! - 3 -
/'
" /'
0123 24 213005 6712 8012903 :,69;08 <,2 =>0 50=4=4,902; 193 24 '171312 >1>1?63349 8012903 4@> ,62= ,A029709=801302
* 0A4;4,9 0=4=4,902; 120 =>0 1::6;03
,;% 193 * B>,>1A0;6<<020319,2302,<:,9A4:=4,949
,*#% *&&) 31=03 %*%&*&%) ,9 =>0 <480 ,< =>0 338 4A48 '63@0 193 '!181?621@4193;09=09:031;69302
! "
#
$%!&&&' ( )*
)+
%+ ! ,
%
#
$%-&!&&&' ( )**
) +
% +
- 4 -
! % , #
$%-&!&&&' ( )*. ) +
% +
! % , #
$%-&!&&&' ( )/
) +
% +
! % , #
$%-&!&&&' ( )/)
) +
% +
! % , #
$%-&!&&&' ( )/* ) +
% + ! %0
- 5 -
4;= ,< =>0 52,;0:6=4,9 :1;0 4; =>1= 1::6;03
,;% 193*B4=>1:,77,949=09=4,9<1?24:1=03=>0712C;:123;,< 34<<0209= 94A02;4=40; 193 ?D :201=49@ <18;0 ;018 6;03 =, 1<<4E =>07 193 <,2@0 =>0 ;4@91=620; ,< =>0 0A1861=,2; 0=: 193 ;6558D =>07 =, =>0 502;,9; B>, 120 49 9003 ,< ;6:> <,2@03 712C;:123;
<=02 360 =2418 =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; ;6<<0203 19 ,2302,<:,9A4:=4,9193;09=09:01;20<02203=,;6521
# 18434=D,<=>02302,<:,9A4:=4,9193;09=09:0B1; :>18809@03 ?0<,20 =>0 4;=24:= ,62= 49 28
,;#$ *&%) 193 .& *&%)
.
012903 338 4;=24:= 193 0;;4,9; '63@0 181?621@4 1<=02 ;0:6249@ =>0 20:,23; >0123 =>0 512=40; 49 30=148 193 ,9 20"15520:41=4,9 ,< =>0 71=02418 0A4309:0 ,9 20:,23 ?D =>0 F63@709= 31=03 &%&*&%( 34;74;;03 =>0 155018;<4803?D=>01::6;03502;,9;
) >480 ;, 20:,2349@ 19 ,2302 ,< :,9A4:=4,9 =>0 8012903 2418 '63@0 1; B088 1; =>0 8012903 '63@0 49 =>0 !42;= 550881=0 ,62= B>, :,9<42703 =>0 ,2302 ,< :,9A4:=4,9 =,,C
- 6 -
49=, :,9;43021=4,9 =>1= 9, 0E58191=4,9 >1; ?009 ,<<0203 ?D 1::6;03502;,9;B>48020:,2349@1::6;03;=1=0709=
$ 049@1@@240A03?D=>0;1701::6;03502;,9;120 ?0<,20=>4;,62=
( 2421300567128012903:,69;08<,2=>020A4;4,9 50=4=4,902;A0>0709=8D:,9=09303=>1==>020A4;4,950=4=4,902;
120 499,:09= 502;,9; 193 ?,=> =>0 ,62=; >1A0 9,= 52,5028D 15520:41=03 =>0 71=02418 0A4309:0 ,9 20:,23 193 B2,9@8D :,9A4:=03=>0720;68=49@4974;:12241@0,<F6;=4:0
%& 0B,68318;,:,9=093=>1=20G6420330@200,<52,,< B1; 9,= <6294;>03 ?D =>0 52,;0:6=4,9 =, 65>,83 =>0 ,2302 ,< :,9A4:=4,949;,<121;50=4=4,902;120:,9:029034920;50:=,<=>0 1<,20;143 ,<<09:0; 193 =>0 2302 51;;03 ?D =>0 8012903 2418 '63@0 :,9<42703 ?D =>0 8012903 '63@0 49 =>0 !42;= 550881=0 ,62= 9,= ,98D ;6<<02; <2,7 ;0A0218 :,9=2134:=4,9; ?6= 18;, 4; ?1;03,9;6274;0;193:,9F0:=620;193;,6@>=<,2188,B49@=>0 20A4;4,950=4=4,9;
%% 8=0291=4A08D 24 213005 6712 B,683 :,9=093 =>1= =>0 49:4309= >1; ,::62203 B>09 =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902;
B020 D,69@ 49 =>042 1@0 193 =>0D 120 9,B >1A49@ <1748D =,
- 7 -
7149=14919312049=>07433801@0==>4;34;=19:0,<=4704< =>020A4;4,950=4=4,902;1201@149;09==,F1489,=,98D4=B,683 1:= >12;> ,9 =>07 ?6= 18;, =>042 <1748D B488 ?0 80<= 1= 862:> >020<,20 =1C49@ 9,=0 ,< =>0 <1:= =>1= 50=4=4,902; B020 49 :6;=,3D <,2 1 5024,3 ,< <,62 7,9=>; ?D 09>19:49@ =>0 <490 17,69=201;,91?8D20714949@5024,3,<47524;,9709=71D?0 ;0="1;430
%*
80129034@>,62=,A029709=801302 B,683 :,9=093 =>1= :1;0 ,< =>0 52,;0:6=4,9 20;=03 7,20 5203,74919=8D ,9 =>0 3,:6709=12D 0A4309:0 491;76:> 1;
;04H03 712C; :123; ;018; 193 ;4@91=620; B>4:> B020 ;09= =, 0E502=;193B020<,693=,?0<1C0
% 374==038D =>0 0G645709=; 6;03 120 ;04H03 <2,7 =>0:6;=,3D,<=>020A4;4,950=4=4,902;69302=>071>1H12193 49=>01?;09:0,<520A4,6;0974=D,21947,;4=D962=6203?D=>0 5,84:0 1@149;= =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; =>0 =>0,2D ,< <18;0 47584:1=4,9 @0=; 49=, 49;4@94<4:19:0 193 =>6; ;,6@>= <,2 34;74;;18,<=>020A4;4,950=4=4,9;
% 9;,<12 1; 18=0291=4A0 ;6?74;;4,9 4; :,9:02903 80129034@>,62=,A029709=801302B,683:,9=093=>1=4<
- 8 -
702:D ,2 809409:D 4; ;>,B9 =, =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; ;170 B,683 ;093 1 B2,9@ ;4@918 =, =>0 ,:40=D 1= 812@0 193 B,683 09:,621@0;4748128D581:0350250=21=,2;,<:247049:,774==49@ ;6:>:2470;49<6=620193=>020<,2020A4;4,950=4=4,9;9003;=, ?034;74;;0349
%# 1A49@>0123=>012@6709=;,<=>08012903:,69;08 <,2 =>0 512=40; =>4; ,62= 5026;03 =>0 71=02418 ,9 20:,23 70=4:68,6;8D
%.
9 ;6:> 5026;18 ,< =>0 71=02418 ,9 20:,23 1; 4;
24@>=8D :,9=09303 ,9 ?0>18< ,< =>0 52,;0:6=4,9 :1;0 ,< 52,;0:6=4,9 5203,74919=8D >49@03 ,9 =>0 3,:6709=12D 0A4309:021=>02=>19=>0,2180A4309:0
%) >0 52,;0:6=4,9 49 188 712C03 *& 3,:6709=; 1;
E% =, E*& >0 3,:6709=12D 0A4309:0 581:03 ,9 20:,23 ;>,B; ?819C 712C; :123; 52,A4;4,918 :02=4<4:1=0; <,2 34<<0209= ;6?F0:=; 193 18;, <,2 34<<0209= 30@200; >0 :,9A,:1=4,9 :02=4<4:1=0; ;4@91=620; ;018; B020 ;04H03 36249@ =>0 2143 ?1;03 ,9 =>0 A,869=12D ;=1=0709=; @4A09 ?D =>0 1::6;03 >0 71=02418 ,?F0:=; B>4:> B020 712C03 ?0<,20 =>0 ,62=B020$49967?02;B>4:>:,7524;0;,<%:,751:=34;:
- 9 -
193%&<8,55D324A0;512=<2,7=>0;170:,756=027,94=,2 7,6;0 5249=02; ;:19902 =D50 B24=02 7,?480 =0805>,90; ;=175513;018;,<34<<0209=694A02;4=40;B020;04H03
%$ ,B :19 1 9,2718 526309= 502;,9 B,683 5,;;0;;
=>0;0 3,:6709=; 193 =>0 71=02418 ,?F0:=; 49 >4; >,6;0 4; 1 G60;=4,9 =>1= 207149; 6919;B0203 ,9 ?0>18< ,< =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902;
%( !62=>02=>0204;9,0E58191=4,9B>1=;,0A02,<<0203 ?D=>020A4;4,950=4=4,902;1==>0=470,<20:,2349@=>01::6;03 ;=1=0709=49;,<121;=>049:247491=,2D71=02418:42:67;=19:0;
*& 9 1334=4,9 =, =>0 ;170 49 =>0 1?;09:0 ,< 19D 520A4,6; 0974=D ,2 1947,;4=D B>D B,683 =>0 5,84:0 475819= =>0;0719D3,:6709=;193=>071=02418,?F0:=;,98D=,,?=149 19,2302,<:,9A4:=4,94;1G60;=4,9=>1=B>4:>1@149207149; 6919;B0203
*% 1:= 207149; =>1= 1; 502 =>0 :2034?80 49<,271=4,9 =>0 49A0;=4@1=4,9 1@09:D ,?=14903 1::6;03 502;,9; B020 1220;=03 193 ?1;03 ,9 =>042 A,869=12D ;=1=0709=; 71=02418 ,?F0:=; B020 ;04H03 69302 =>0 519:>19171 1; :,683 ?0 ;009 <2,7 =>0 ?819C 712C; :123; =>0D 9,= ,98D 502=149 =, ,90
- 10 -
512=4:6812694A02;4=D?6=18;,<,234<<0209=0E17491=4,9;B>4:> 49:8630 0A09 =>0 458,71 :02=4<4:1=0; ,9A,:1=4,9 :02=4<4:1=0; B02018;,<,693B>4:>B0201374==038D<1C0,90
** 9 ,=>02 B,23; =>0 1::6;03 6;03 =>0 13A19:03 =0:>9,8,@D193=>0,24@4918;=>1=B020,?=14903<2,734<<0209= 694A02;4=40; B020 ;:19903 =>2,6@> =>0 >085 ,< =>0 :,756=02 193 =>0201<=02 =>0D >1A0 :,9:,:=03 =>0;0 8,,C 184C0 712C; :123;:,9A,:1=4,9:02=4<4:1=0;193;4@91=620;B020<,2@03
* >0;0 1;50:=; ,< =>0 71==02 ;=,,3 0;=1?84;>03 ?D 581:49@ :,@09= 193 :,9A49:49@ 0A4309:0 ,9 20:,23 193 =>020<,20=>015584:1=4,9,<F634:4,6;7493B>480:,9A4:=49@=>0 1::6;03 502;,9; <,2 =>0 1<,20;143 ,<<09:0; ?D =>0 =2418 1@4;=21=0B>4:>>1;?00924@>=8D20"15520:41=03193:,9<42703 ?D =>0 <42;= 1550881=0 ,62= 9003; 9, 49=02<0209:0 ?D =>4; ,62==>1==,,49=>020A4;4,918F624;34:=4,9
* 1A49@ ;143 =>6; =>0 18=0291=0 ;6?74;;4,9 :19A1;;03 ,9 ?0>18< ,< =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; 9003; =, ?0 :,9;430203 ?D =>4; ,62= >1A49@ 20@123 =, =>0 1@0 ,< =>0 20A4;4,950=4=4,902;1;B0881;=>042<1748D:,774=709=
- 11 -
*# 374==038D =>0 1:= >1; ,::62203 B1D ?1:C 49 =>0 D012 *&&) 193 76:> B1=02 >1; ?009 <8,B9 69302 =>0 ?243@0 148:,934=4,9;B0209,=74;"6=484H03?D=>020A4;4,950=4=4,902; 9,2=>0204;19D<62=>02:,758149=1@149;==>050=4=4,902;1<=02 =>0D012*&&)
*.
9,=>02B,23;=>049:4309==>1= 4;;6?F0:=71==02 ,<=>0520;09=50=4=4,94;194;,81=0349:4309=193=1C49@9,=0 ,< =>0 <1:= =>1= =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; B020 49 :6;=,3D <,2 1 5024,3 ,< <,62 7,9=>; 36249@ =>0 :,62;0 ,< 49A0;=4@1=4,9 193 =2418 4<=>0;1704;=201=031;5024,3,<47524;,9709=<,2=>0 52,A03 ,<<09:0; ?D 09>19:49@ =>0 <490 17,69= 49 1 ;67 ,< ;&&&&&
"01:>=>0093;,<F6;=4:0B,683?070=
*) ::,2349@8D<,88,B49@,2302
"
4 0A4;4,90=4=4,9;120188,B0349512=I
44 >480 7149=14949@ =>0 :,9A4:=4,9 ,< =>0 20A4;4,950=4=4,902;<,2=>0,<<09:0;5694;>1?8069302 0:=4,9;*#% ,<2=>0:6;=,3D5024,3,<<,62 7,9=>;182013D69302@,90?D=>020A4;4,950=4=4,902;
4; =201=03 1; 5024,3 ,< 47524;,9709= ?D 09>19:49@ =>0 <490 17,69= 49 1 ;67 ,< ;&&&&&
" 51D1?80
- 12 -
?D 01:> ,< =>0 20A4;4,9 50=4=4,902; ,9 ,2 ?0<,20 *&&$*&*#I
444 !148620=,51D=>009>19:03<49017,69= B,68316=,71=4:188D20;68=4920;=,21=4,9,<=>0,2302 ,<;09=09:0,<47524;,9709=16=,71=4:188DI
4A <<4:0 3420:=03 =, 20=629 =>0 =2418 ,62= 20:,23;B4=>:,5D,<=>4;,2302<,2=>B4=><,24;;60,< 7,34<403:,9A4:=4,9B12219=
#. )(##", %"
C:75121@215>;%=,%. 5121@215>;%)=488093 4;=
,% 8
,%&#