- 1 - !!" # $ % %% &'( )* %% !! +&'( ) * !" # $ % !" & ' ( ) !" & ' ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - **+$'(* ', ( * * ### !*## !!) * ) * **) ** ) ! # & ' ( # $ - % !" & - 3 - ' *#( **+$'(* !##### * . $ /012/3/4546733485/794:0641;<087=6>55>0?@>3/ :0?54?3 0< A478?4= :01?54A <08 ;783>45 3/4B 784 37C4? 1; <08 /478>?2 #:0660?7@78==734=###@75;7554=DB ==>3>0?7A >538>:3 - 455>0?5 1=24 7?= 46D48 >E7B7;187>? 0+F0<##7?= 0!0<## $ >5 78>5>?2 013 0< 0!0<##@/484>?>3>553734=3/730?4>87;;7724= B4785 643 @>3/ 7? 7::>=4?3 0? "#F 7?= =>4= >5 ;784?35<>A4=3/47<08457>=:A7>6;43>3>0?:A7>6>?2:06;4?573>0? 0< 5$F @>3/ >?348453 /4 8>D1?7A :0?5>=484= 3/4 4?3>84 49>=4?:4 0? 84:08= 7?= 287?34= 5 @>3/ - 4 - >?348453733/487340<"G;487??16<8063/4=7340<;43>3>0? 3>AA847A>573>0? 228>494=DB3/457>=08=483/>57;;47A>5<>A4=DB3/4 :A7>67?35 544C>?2 4?/7?:464?3 0< :06;4?573>0? 7?= >3 >5 :0?34?=4=3/733/4=4:4754=@75724=B4785733/43>640< 7::>=4?35;483/4E1=264?30<3/40?.DA41;84640183>? >9>A;;47A0+$+#$D43@44?)>5/7?0;7A7?=?03/48 5 7A7 7?= 3/485 3/4 :A7>67?35 784 4?3>3A4= <08 />2/48 :06;4?573>0? 7?= 3/4 7601?3 287?34= 1?=48 03/48 /47=5 >5 6472483>5<183/48:0?34?=4=3/73>?348453>530D437C4?73 3/4 8734 0< !G ;48 7??16 7?= 3/15 84H14534= <08 4?/7?:464?30<3/4:06;4?573>0? )78?737C7373407=87?5;08308;0873>0?')( /75 7A50 ;84<4884= 7? 7;;47A >? !! + 727>?533/45764E1=264?37?=7@78=0<3/48>D1?7A>? 0! 0< ## :0?34?=>?2 3/73 8>=48 0< 3/4 60308 :B:A4 =75/4= 3/4 D15 /4 =4:4754= @75 8>=>?2 3/4 60308 :B:A4 D478>?2 0)#! #$ >? 7 875/ 7?= ?42A>24?3 67??48 @>3/013 0D5489>?2 7?B >?=>:73>0?5 7?= @>3/013 <0AA0@>?2 3/4 387<<>:81A45/4=8>9480<3/4)D15D478>?20)#!* - 5 - #!+@75=8>9>?23/4D155A0@AB7?=:713>015AB7?=3/484@75 ?0 ?42A>24?:4 0? />5 ;783 /4 7::>=4?3 0::1884= 0?AB =14 30 3/4 ?42A>24?:4 0< 3/4 8>=48 0< 3/4 60308:B:A4 3 >5 :0?34?=4= 3/73)4I76>?4= =8>948@/0/75:A478AB53734=3/73 3/47::>=4?30::1884=0?AB=14303/4?42A>24?:40<3/48>=480< 3/460308:B:A4D133/4;0A>:4<>A4=<7A54:/78245/443727>?53 3/4=8>9480<3/4D15/48>=480<3/460308:B:A4@7576>?08 7?=/4@75?03/0A=>?23/497A>=7?=4<<4:3>94=8>9>?2A>:4?:4 D13 3/4 8>D1?7A 4880?4015AB <7534?4=3/4 4?3>84 845;0?5>D>A>3B 0?3/4=8>9480<3/4D15 "478=3/4782164?350<D03/5>=45 + 48157A 0< 3/4 E1=264?3 0< 3/4 8>D1?7A 5/0@5 3/73 @/>A4>87;;77A0?2@>3/;43>3>0?48>? 0+F0<##@75 ;80:44=>?20?760308:B:A4D478>?20)#! #$>?75A0@ 7?=:713>01567??483/4)D15D478>?20)#!*#!+ :764<806D7:C5>=4@>3//>2/5;44=A053:0?380A0<3/494/>:A4 7?= =75/4=3/4 60308:B:A4 5 7 8451A3 3/4 8>=48 7?=;>AA>0? 8>=480<3/460308:B:A451537>?4=28>49015>?E18>450@4948 3/4 8>=48 0< 3/4 60308 :B:A4>87;;7 =>4= 0? 3/4 5;03 /4 :/7824 5/443 >5 <>A4= 727>?53 =8>948 0< 3/4 ) D15 3 >5 - 6 - <183/4851D6>334=3/733/4<73/480<>87;;7@753/40@?480< 3/460308:B:A47?=/4/7?=4=09483/4576430/>56>?0850? @/0@75?03/79>?23/497A>==8>9>?2A>:4?:4551:/7:754 @757A50842>53484=727>?533/4<73/480<3/4=4:4754=5/0@>?2 />6 75 7::154= 0# /4 8>D1?7A :0?5>=48>?2 3/4 57>= <7:3 0D54894= 3/73 <73/48 0< 3/4 =4:4754= >5 ?03 4?3>3A4= <08 :06;4?573>0?7?=0?AB3/4603/480<3/4=4:4754=>54?3>3A4= <08:06;4?573>0? !=6>334=AB3/4:/78245/443>5<>A4=727>?533/4=8>948 0< 3/4 ) D15 @/0 =75/4= 3/4 60308 :B:A4 <806 D4/>?= /484<084>3:7??03D457>=3/733/47::>=4?30::1884=0?AB=14 30 3/4 875/ 7?= ?42A>24?3 0< 3/4 8>=48 0< 3/4 60308 :B:A4 /484<0843/>50183<>?=5>384750?7DA430=>84:33/4)30 =4;05>33/4:06;4?573>0? F478?4=:01?54A<083/47;;4AA7?35>?*0###FF 0< ### /75 84A>4= 1;0? 3/4 E1=264?3 >? 3/4 :754 0< ! " # $ % & & '# >? >9>A ;;47A 0$ F 0<##=4:>=4=0?!!## 7?=:0?34?=4=3/73 >? 3/4 57>= :754 3/4 724 0< 3/4 D0B @75 B4785 7?= 3/4 - 7 - 8>D1?7A /75 37C4? 3/4 ?03>0?7A >?:064 75 5 ;48 60?3/ D13 3/4 B478 0< 7::>=4?3 @75 ?03 64?3>0?4= 3/484>? 478?4=:01?54A<083/47;;4AA7?35/75<183/4884A>4=1;0?3/4 E1=264?3 >? 3/4 :754 0< ( )* + ,** )* -* . 84;0834= >? ''/ 0%1 23 >? @/>:/ 3/4 0?.DA41;8464 0183 /75 /4A=751?=48 J *083/4;18;0540<46;/75>5>3>5727>? :A78><>4= /484 3/73 @/4? 7 8>D1?7A 08 3/4 >2/ 0183 >? 7;;47A >5 :0?:48?4= @>3/ 3/4 :754 >?90A9>?2 7 :/>A= /79>?2 51<<484= >?E18B 08 /79>?2 ;7554= 7@7B 3/4 :7A:1A73>0? 0< A055 0< >?:064 ?4:45578>AB /75 30 D4 67=4 0? 3/4 6738>: 0< 6>?>616@7245;7B7DA43075C>AA4=@08C48>?3/4 845;4:3>943734733/484A497?3;0>?30<3>643>5 018/0;43/733/>5845373464?3/4A;5790>=>?251:/ 488085 7?= 3/484DB 0D9>7345 3/4 ?4:455>3B 0< 3/>5 0183K5 >?348<484?:4 7;;AB>?2 @4AA4537DA>5/4= ;8>?:>;A450<A7@L =6>334=AB753/4=4:4754=>?3/4;8454?3:754@75 76>?08/>5?03>0?7A>?:064>530D437C4?75;483/46>?>616 @72454I>53>?2>?3/484A497?33734733/73;0>?30<3>64/4 =4:4754=643@>3/7::>=4?3>?3/4B478#F0?5>=48>?2/>5 - 8 - 7247?=3/4B4780<7::>=4?33/>50183<>?=5>384750?7DA430 37C4 />5 ?03>0?7A >?:064 75 5! ;48 60?3/ 7?= 61A3>;A>48>530D437C4?75 G0<>?:064>530D47==4= 30@78=5 <13184 ;805;4:35 75 ;48 3/4 E1=264?3 0< 3/4 0?.DA4 1;84640183>?3/4:7540< 4$! #&5 '# +5 % 7?= G >5 30 D4 =4=1:34= 30@78=5;4850?7A4I;4?54575;483/421>=4A>?450<3/40?.DA4 1;8464 0183 >? 3/4 :754 0< % # & & /153/4A0550<=4;4?=4?:B:0645 305!'!MG GI#I ( /4 :A7>67?35 D4>?2 3/4 ;784?35 0< 3/4 =4:4754= 47:/0<3/467844?3>3A4=<087?7601?30<530@78=5 A0550<:0?5083>1675;483/421>=4A>?450<3/40?KDA41;8464 0183 >? 3/4 :754 0< # 6 4$! #&5 '# $-#$$-#. 7?=>? 3/4 :754 0< 7 4 4$! #&5 '# % 8$ 9 %/ 8$ : /4B 784 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 9 - 7A50 4?3>3A4= <08 5$$ 1?=48 3/4 :0?94?3>0?7A /47=5 75 ;48 3/4 21>=4A>?45 0< 0?.DA4 1;8464 0183 >? 3/4 :754 0< 4$! #&5 '# +5 % /15?7AA3/4:A7>67?357844?3>3A4=<083/4:06;4?573>0?0< 5 5#F @>3/ >?348453 73 "G ;48 7??16 75 727>?53 5 7@78=4=DB3/48>D1?7A #/47@78=0<:06;4?573>0?;7554=DB3/48>D1?7A >560=><>4=751?=48 47=5 601?3>?5 0550<4;4?=4?:B ! #0550<0?5083>16 !! $0@78=5:0?94?3>0?7A/47=5 $$ 037A 5#F) $?3/48451A33/4<0AA0@>?208=48>5;7554= '>( * 0###FF 0< ### <>A4= DB 3/4 :A7>67?35 537?=5 7AA0@4= >? ;783 7?= * 0#F ##$ <>A4= DB )537?=5=>56>554= 5 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 10 - '>>( /4 :A7>67?35 784 4?3>3A4= <08 3/4 3037A :06;4?573>0? 0< 5#F @>3/ >?348453 73 "G ;48 7??16<8063/4=7340<;43>3>0?3>AA3/4=7340<847A>N73>0? '>>>( )/757A847=B=4;05>34= G0<:06;4?573>0? 7?=3/484<0843/4B784=>84:34=30=4;05>33/4D7A7?:47601?3 @>3/>?34845373"G;487??16@>3/>?0?460?3/<8063/4=734 0<3/>508=48 '>9( ? 51:/ =4;05>3 3/4 53 7;;4AA7?3 >? * 0###FF 0< ### '/>??7997603/48 0< 3/4 =4:4754=( >5 ;486>334=30@>3/=87@3/44?3>847601?37A0?2@>3/3/4>?348453 7::814=0?>3 '9( 4?=>?25><7?B537?==>5;054=7::08=>?2AB ,-) &% ( $ >530A0+