- 1 - ! "#$$ ## %& !" #$%&&& " # ' ( ) #$*$& + Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) $ " #$*$& " !, '!+, " $ - % . - /0 12314 567489: ;<59=36 ><8 2?3 @32:2:<938 8:?3=?4A8:"4:=?49748><883=@<9A392=49A8: 85@4 4B48 42:6 ;<59=36 ><8 83=@<9A392= ' 49A + 49A 8: C4D 5148 ;<59=36 ><8 83=@<9A392 <$ 4@@3483A :9 @38=<9 ?3 ;4@2:<93A -8:2 32:2:<9 := >:63A =337:9B 2?3 ><66<E:9B836:3>= 4 ==53 4 -8:2 <> 382:<848: 2< F54=? 2?3 :946 363;2:<9 :=2 A423A .&&$ @4==3A GD 83=@<9A392<'H:A3993I583#" - 3 - G ==53 4 -8:2 <> 49A415= A:83;2:9B 2?3 83=@<9A392= 2< ;<9=:A38 2?3 83@83=39242:<9 =5G1:223A GD 2?3 @32:2:<938 <9 '&+ H:A3 993I583# 49A 2< =363;2 2?3 @32:2:<938 ><82?3@<=2<>:G848D5@38H:=<8><83A4=58 841 49;?4D42 GD ;<9=:A38:9B 2?3 <GC3;2:<9==5G1:223AGD2?3@32:2:<938 ' <59=36 ><8 2?3 83=@3;2:H3 @482:3= 58B3A =3H3846 ;<92392:<9= <59=36 12314 :9 @83=392:9B ?38 48B51392= =28395<5=6D 58B3A 2?42 2?3 @32:2:<938 := 4 83=:A392 <> 3A4=58 84149;?4D4249A2?3>:>2?83=@<9A392:=483=:A392<><9=?: :664B3 39;3 4 83=:A392:46 @83>3839;3 =?<56A ?4H3 G339 ;<9=:A383A D E4D <> 83@6D ;<59=36 8: 85@4 4B48 42:6 =5G1:2= 2?42 2?3 @32:2:<938 A<3= 9<2 @<==3== 2?3 83F5:=:23 F546:>:;42:<9,?39;32?3>:>2?83=@<9A392E4==363;23A 348A 2?3 48B51392= 49A @385=3A 2?3 -8:2 @4@38= E:2? ;483 - 4 - + ?3:==53>466=E:2?:949488<E;<1@4==49A836423= 2<2?3=363;2:<92<2?3@<=2<>:G848D5@38H:=<8 <2:>:;42:<9 E4= :==53A <9 J&&J&' ;466:9B ><8 4@@<:921392 2< 2?3 @<=2 <> :G848D 5@38H:=<8 :9 2?3 841 49;?4D42? E:2?:9 2?3 56G48B4 :=28:;2 1<9B <2?38= 2?3 @32:2:<93849A83=@<9A392<$4@@6:3A><82?3=4:A@<=2>238 83;3:@2 <> 2?3 4@@6:;42:<9= 2?3 3@52D 3;83248D ><582? 83=@<9A392 @83@483A 2?3 36:B:G63 49A :936:B:G63 6:=2 ?3 >:>2? 83=@<9A3920=9413E4=9<2:9;65A3A:92?336:B:G636:=2,?39;3 =?3>:63A<GC3;2:<9=3H3846<GC3;2:<9=E38383;3:H3A,?39;34 <11:2233 E4= ><813A 49A 2?3 <11:2233 @83@483A >:H3 83H:=3A 6:=2= 4= @38 2?3 841 49;?4D42 4>238 =337:9B 2?3 <@:9:<9<>2?3<H3891392 ?3 6:=2 <> ;49A:A423= E?< ?4H3 59A38B<93 2?3 :G848D ;:39;3 84:9:9B <58=3 :9 2?3 84149;?4D42:1:2= :=2 <> ;49A:A423= E?< ?4H3 59A38B<93 2?3 :G848D;:39;384:9:9B<58=3:92?346574 49;?4D42:1:2= - 5 - ' :=2 <> ;49A:A423= E?< ?4H3 =3;583A 2?3 ?:B?3=2 1487= :9 :9 841 49;?4D42 :1:2= + :=2 <> ;49A:A423= E?< ?4H3 =3;583A 2?3 ?:B?3=2 1487= :9 :9 46574 49;?4D42 :1:2= $ :=2<>83C3;23A4@@6:;42:<9= >238H38:>:;42:<9<>2?36:=2=49A2?3<8:B:9464@@6:;42:<9= <>2?3;49A:A423=4>:946=363;2:<96:=2E4=:==53A49A2?3>:>2? 83=@<9A392E4==363;23A><82?3@<=2<>:G848D5@38H:=<84= =?3?4=?36A2?383F5:=:23F546:>:;42:<94=@382?3<2:>:;42:<9= A423AJ&&J&'49A+& $ ?3 <2:>:;42:<9 A423A J&&J&' := >589:=?3A 46<9B E:2? 2?3 -8:2 32:2:<9 49A 2?3 =413 := 14873A 4= 993I583# 9 2?3 9<2:>:;42:<9 :2 ?4= G339 =2423A 2?42 4 ;49A:A423E?<4@@6:3=2<2?3@<=2<>:G848D5@38H:=<815=2G3 4 83=:A392 <> 2?3 8414 49;?4D42 ;<9;3893A > 4 =5:24G63 ;49A:A423 := 9<2 4H4:64G63 2?39 4 ;49A:A423 83=:A:9B :9 2?3 =413 4657 49;?4D42 14D G3 ;<9=:A383A GD <G24:9:9B 4 83=:A39;3 ;382:>:;423 >8<1 2?3 ;<9;3893A 4?=:6A48 - 6 - <2:>:;42:<9 A423A +& := >589:=?3A 46<9B E:2? 2?3 =24231392<><GC3;2:<9=49A2?3=413:=14873A4=993I583# & 49A 2?3 =413 := @385=3A E:2? ;483 = @38 2?3 9<2:>:;42:<9= 4 ;49A:A423 E?< 4@@6:3= 2< 2?3 @<=2 <> :G848D 5@38H:=<815=2?4H3@4==3A ?<6A4;382:>:;423;<58=3:9 :G848D ;:39;3 49A ?4H3 ;<1@6323A 4 2?833#1<92? <1@5238 ;<58=3 9 2?3 @83=392 ;4=3 2?3 @32:2:<938 ?4= 9<2;<1@6323A 2?3:G848D;:39;3;<58=3?<5B?=?3:=483=:A392<>3A4=58 841 49;?4D42 =?3 A<3= 9<2 @<==3== 2?3 83F5:=:23 F546:>:;42:<9, ?38 9413 ;499<2 G3 ;<9=:A383A ><8 2?3 @<=2 <> :G848D5@38H:=<8 B<<A A346 <> 48B51392 := 4AA83==3A 4G<52 2?3 83=:A392:46 @83>3839;3 49A 2?3 3A5;42:<946 F546:>:;42:<9 ?383 := 9< A:=@523 2?42 2?3 @32:2:<938 A<3= 9<2 ?<6A 2?3 ;<58=3 ;382:>:;423:9:G848D;:39;3=5G1:==:<9:=14A3<9G3?46><> 2?3 @32:2:<938 2?42 2?3 >:>2? 83=@<9A392 G36<9B= 2< <9=?: :664B3 ?39;3 =?3 ;<56A 9<2 ?4H3 G339 =363;23A <59=36 ><8 2?3@32:2:<938A83E2?3422392:<9<>2?3<5822<993I583# 2< ;<9239A2?42<9=?:;<13=59A382?33GG46465749;?4D42 ?3 ;<92392:<9 <> 2?3 @32:2:<938 ;499<2 G3 4;;3@23A ?3 - 7 - 834=<9:=4@@48392<9=?::664B3;<13=59A382?3464B:4657 49;?4D42 = 46834AD 9<23A 4G<H3 4 =5:24G63 ;49A:A423 @<==3==:9B2?383F5:=:23F546:>:;42:<9E4=9<24H4:64G63,?39;3 ;49A:A423 >8<1 464B: 4657 49;?4D42 E4= =363;23A ?3 452?<8:2D ;<9;3893A ;?<=3 4 ;49A:A423 :3 2?3 >:>2? 83=@<9A392E?<=3F546:>:;42:<9=E38346:B93AE:2?2?3=@3;:>:; 933A= <> 2?3 @<=2@<=:2:<9?:= <5828563= 2?42 2?3 =363;2:<9 @8<;3== E4= 63B:2:1423 49A 9<2 H:2:423A GD 49D :663B46:2D <8 @8<;3A5846 :1@8<@8:32D ?3 @32:2:<938 ?4= 9<2 14A3 <52 B8<59A= 2< >:9A >4562 E:2? 2?3 =363;2:<9 @8<;3== ?3 -8:2 32:2:<9:=A3H<:A<>138:2=49A:=6:4G632<G3A:=1:==3A % 3=5624926D2?3-8:232:2:<9:= '( %$ ##& $ :=2<6<%