- 1 - !" #!$!! %! & ! " ! #$% & '! ( ) * #! " ! #$$ & '! ) *'%) ##% ! ( $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +! ( ,-.-./0,1/#2.3,4056,-.-./0,1/#54789-,141, :,3/1, -9.; /71- ;,,<.08 ,0940=,>,0- /3 >4.0-,040=, 4>/70-42415,5:?-9,4>.@?/71-/0-9,.1466@.=4-./0 3.@,5 705,1 ,=-./0 A /3 1 .0 1..;=/$ /0 -9, 3.@, /3 1@ (758, 4>.@? /71- 4.=971 ;,,<.08 371-9,1,0940=,>,0- 411.48, :,-2,,0 6,-.-./0,1 /#2.3, 405 -9, 1,;6/05,0-#97;:405 405 -9, 6,-.-./0,1 / 94B.08 :/10 -/-9,6,-.-./0,1/#2.3,4051,;6/05,0-#97;:405.;0/- .05.;67-,7,-/=,1-4.0>41.-4@5.;=/15-9,641-.,;41, ;-4?.08 ;,6414-,@? ,-.-./0,1; 945 ,41@.,1 3.@,5 6,-.-./0 ;,,<.08 >4.0-,040=, 705,1 ,=-./0 $ /3 1 29.=9 24; 4@@/2,5 :? 42415.08 -9, >4.0-,040=, /3 ;* # 405 ;C # 1,;6,=-.B,@? -/ -9, 6,-.-./0,1; 7:;,D7,0-@?76/0-9,466@.=4-./0>45,:?-9,6,-.-./0,1; - 3 - 705,1 ,=-./0 $ /3 1 ;,,<.08 ,0940=,>,0- /3 -9, ;4>,/0-9,61,>.;,-94--9,1,;6/05,0-#97;:405 34-9,1 1,;6,=-.B,@? 24; 2/1<.08 4; 40 ;;.;-40- 4;-,1 /3 9?;.=4@57=4-./0145,#.0-9,/B,10>,0-=9//@405 24;5142.08-9,;4@41?/3 ; #6,1>/0-90-9, =1/;;#,E4>.04-./0-9,1,;6/05,0-#97;:40545>.--,5-/:, 1,=,.B.08 81/;; ;4@41? /3 ;A # 3/1 -9, >/0-9 /3 ,6-,>:,14050,-;4@41?/3 ;$ #6,1>/0-9 4<.08.0-/=/0;.5,14-./0-9,;4>,-9,4>.@?/71-945 ,0940=,5 -9, >/0-9@? >4.0-,040=, 31/> ;C 405 ;%6,1>/0-9-/ ;*405 ;C #6,1>/0-9 1,;6,=-.B,@? ,410,5 =/70;,@ 3/1 -9, 6,-.-./0,1; -4<.08 -9.; /71--91/789-9,1,=/15;;7:>.-;-94--9,,0940=,>,0- 24; =/0;.5,1,5 :4;,5 /0 -9, ;4@41? 29.=9 1,;6/05,0-# 97;:40524;5142.08.0-9,>/0-9/3(7@?.,EC .05.=4-,;9.;81/;;;4@41?.;;9/204; ;A%$$ #405-9, 0,-;4@41?.;;9/204; ;$*$ #9,1,3/1,9,;7:>.-; -94- -9, 6,-.-./0,1; 41, ,0-.-@,5 3/1 =/11,;6/05.08 - 4 - ,0940=,>,0- 4; -9, 6,-.-./0,1 / .; ;=9//@ 8/.08 405 57,-/1,=711.08,E6,0;,;6,-.-./0,1;41,0/-4:@,-/>,,- -9,.1 1,D7.1,>,0- 2.-9 -9, 42415 /3 >4.0-,040=, :? -9, 4>.@?/71- % 01,;6/0;,@,410,5=/70;,@3/1-9,1,;6/05,0-# 97;:405 ;7:>.-; -94- 1,;6/05,0- 94; 1,;6/0;.:.@.-? /3 >4.0-4.0.089.;48,/@5641,0-;9,1,3/1,40?455.-./04@ :715,02/7@5:,;,B,1,/09.> $ ,415,17;,5-9,1,=/15; C EC.;464?#;@.63/1-9,>/0-9/3(7@? 29.=9 .05.=4-, 81/;; ;4@41? /3 -9, 1,;6/05,0-#97;:405 :,.08 ;A%$$ # 405 -9, 0,- ;4@41? :,.08 ;$*$ # 9, ,0940=,5 4>/70- 42415,5 :? -9, 4>.@? /71- .; ;* # -/ -9, 6,-.-./0,1 / 405 ;A # -/ -9, 6,-.-./0,1/ A 0-9,=.1=7>;-40=,;=/0;.5,1.08-9,;-4-7;-/ 29.=9-9,641-.,;41,4==7;-/>,5-/4054@;/-4<.08.0-/ =/0;.5,14-./0 /3 -9, ,57=4-./04@ 405 /-9,1 ,E6,0;,; - 5 - .0B/@B,5 -9.; /71- 5,,>; .- 4661/61.4-, -/ ,0940=, -9, >4.0-,040=, 42415,5 :? -9, 4>.@? /71- ==/15.08@? >4.0-,040=, 4>/70- /3 ;* # -/ :, 64?4:@, -/ -9, 6,-.-./0,1 / .; 371-9,1 ,0940=,5 -/ ; # 405 >4.0-,040=, 4>/70- /3 ;A # -/ :, 64?4:@, -/ 6,-.-./0,1 / .; 371-9,1 ,0940=,5 -/ ; # 7=9 ,0940=,>,0-;94@@:,64?4:@,31/>-9,54-,/3-9.;/15,1 .-9 -9, 4:/B, >/5.3.=4-./0 /15,1 64;;,5 :? -9,4>.@?/71-.;=/03.1>,5 * 9, 1,;6/05,0-#97;:405 ;94@@ 64? 4@@ -9, 4>/70- .0=@75.08 -9, 411,41; .3 40? 2.-9.0 3/71 >/0-9; 31/>-9,54-,/31,=,.6-/34=/6?/3-9.;/15,1405;94@@ =/0-.07, -/ 64? 1,87@41@? -9, 4>/70- 4; 42415,5 9,1,.0 4:/B, '( )!!* $ A