- 1 - !" # $%# $%!%&! ## '&( ) ! " # $%"&%"' ""% &(&#&#'" ) *#! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * " "! * * &""#&## * + , ( #&#" * - - % - ! " ./0 122314 56738 39:/;6 ""! ;< ;:;8 3./9430 9: "=$$ .383/61<:38 83<38837 :; 10 >:.3 9:?! .10 @336 </437@A:.3941/B16:9.14436C/6C:.3D57CB36:1671E187 71:37 &""#&## 210037 @A :.3 774 36/;8 /F/4 57C3 167*/718167/718/6;( #&#" # *19:0 C/F/6C 8/03 :; :.3 </4/6C ;< :.3 122314 @8/3<4A 0:1:37183:.1:;6#G&(#&"=E.36:.3941/B16:167.38 .50@167 E383 28;9337/6C :;E1870 :.3/8 F/441C3 ;6 B;:;89A943 @318/6C 83C/0:81:/;6 ; %= %G'&( E.36 - 3 - :.3A8319.37631898;00;<18;;8;471HH18;171::.1: :/B3 ;63 819:;8 167 81/4;8 @318/6C 83C/0:81:/;6 ; % = %G& 167 81/4;8 83C/0:81:/;6 ; %= %$G @3/6C 78/F36 @A /:0 78/F38 1: 1 ./C. 02337 167 /6 1 810. 167 63C4/C36:B16638710.37:;:.3B;:;89A9430183054: ;< :.3 1<;8301/7 199/736: :.3 2/44/;6 8/738 941/B16: 167 8/738050:1/637C8/3F;50/6D58/30167E383.;02/:14/I37 .3941/B16:</437123:/:/;65673839:/;6"GG;<:.3 9:033H/6C9;B23601:/;6:E102431737:.1:0.30236: 0/C6/</916:1B;56::;E1870B37/9143J2360309;6F3A1693 9.18C30 167 ;:.38 8341:37 9;0:0 : E10 <58:.38 2431737 :.1: :.3 199/736: ;9958837 0;434A ;6 199;56: ;< 810. 167 63C4/C36:78/F/6C;<:.3;<<367/6CF3./943@A/:078/F38 ( 2;6038F/93;<6;:/93:.38302;6736:0;0"167# 12231837:.8;5C.:.3/89;56034167</437032181:3E8/::36 0:1:3B36: 736A/6C :.3 1F38B36:0 B173 /6 :.3 941/B 23:/:/;6 - 4 - ' 6 :.3 @10/0 ;< :.3 24317/6C0 ;< :.3 218:/30 :.3 41/B08/@5614<81B37:.3/00530167:.3831<:38839;8737 :.3 3F/73693 .3 8/@5614 @A /B25C637 D57CB36: 167 1E187.10218:4A144;E37:.3941/B23:/:/;6167.347:.1: :.3941/B16:/036:/:437:;19;B23601:/;6;<0$$'#" % 14;6CE/:./6:3830:1::.381:3;<GK211677/839:37:.3 60581693 ;B216A :; 732;0/: :.3 9;B23601:/;6 1B;56: 14;6C E/:. /6:3830: 3/6C 1CC8/3F37 :.3 283036: 122314 .10@336</437 G .3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 941/B16: .10 81/037 :.3 <;44;E/6C9;6:36:/;60 1! */80:4A :.3 941/B16: 10038:0 :.1: 0.3 E10 3186/6C 0#(&&& % 238 B;6:. @A E;8H/6C 10 1 1/4;8 10 E344 10 ;;4/3 ;E3F38 :.3 8/@5614 .10 38837 /6 :1H/6C :.3 /69;B310B3834A100""&&& %238B;6:. @! 39;674A :.3 941/B16: .10 3J1B/637 8/D1A1H5B18 8:.;237/9 58C3;6 10 %# 6 ./0 3F/73693.3732;037:.1::.3941/B16:.1005<<3837(K 238B1636:7/01@/4/:A;<:.343<:4;E384/B@167140;#(K:; - 5 - :.3;:.38218:0;<:.3E.;43@;7A ;E3F38:.38/@5614 .10 10030037 E.;43 @;7A 7/01@/4/:A /0 $K E./9. /0 ;6 4;E380/73 9! 10:4A 753 :; :.3 199/736: :.3 941/B16: .10 050:1/637 C8/3F;50 /6D58/30 .3 E10 :831:37 10 /621:/36: <;8 1 238/;7 ;< "" 71A0 F36 1<:38 7/09.18C3 <8;B :.3 .;02/:140.3E106;:/612;0/:/;6:;7/09.18C3.3883C5418 E;8H .3 .10 05<<3837 4;: ;< 21/6 758/6C :831:B36: ;60/738/6C :.3 01B3 :.3 ;F38144 9;B23601:/;6 1E18737 @A:.38/@5614/0;6:.34;E380/73 /:. :.3 1@;F3 9;6:36:/;60 :.3 4318637 9;56034 0;5C.::;144;E:.3122314 6 :.3 ;:.38 .167 :.3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 60581693 ;B216A .10 81/037 :.3 <;44;E/6C 9;56:38% 9;6:36:/;60 1! */80:4A :.3 10038:/;6 ;< 941/B16: :.1: 0.3 E10 3186/6C 0#(&&& % 238 B;6:. 83B1/60 5605@0:16:/1:37 753 :; 419H ;< 7;95B36:18A 3F/73693 6 :.3 1@03693 ;< - 6 - 28;;<;</69;B3:.38/@5614.1010030037:.3/69;B3;< :.3941/B16:6;:/;6144A @! 39;674A :.3 8/@5614 9;60/738/6C :.3 /6D58/30 050:1/637@A:.3941/B16:1673F/73693;<:.37;9:;8.10 10030037;6:.343<:4;E384/B@7/01@/4/:A/0(K167E.;43 @;7A7/01@/4/:A1:$K/0D50:1678310;61@43 9! ./874A 9;60/738/6C :.3 /6D58/30 050:1/637 @A :.3 941/B16: 167 9;60/738/6C :.3 1C3 167 1F;91:/;6 ;< :.3 941/B16: B37/914 832;8:0 :.3 ;F38144 9;B23601:/;6 1E18737@A:.38/@5614/0D50:1678310;61@43167/:7;30 6;:E18816:/6:38<383693 /:. :.3 1@;F3 9;6:36:/;60 :.3 4318637 9;56034 0;5C.::;7/0B/00:.3122314 $ 3187 :.3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 218:/30 167 2385037:.3D57CB36:1671E187;<:.38/@5614 = : /0 6;: /6 7/025:3 :.1: :.3 941/B16: .10 050:1/637 /6D58/30/6:.38;17:81<</9199/736:;9958837;6#G&(#&"= 753:;810.16763C4/C36:78/F/6C;<:.3;<<367/6CF3./943 - 7 - @A /:0 78/F38 53 :; :.3 199/736: :.3 941/B16: .10 05<<3837/6D58/30;6.388/C.:43C6318H633D;/6:167;F38 :.3 :/@/1 /6 4;E38 " 87 167 7/0:/4 :./87 ;< <3B58 167 ./2 <3B58 "& .3 941/B16: 941/B0 :.1: 0.3 E10 3186/6C 0#(&&& % 238 B;6:. 5: 0.3 .10 6;: 28;75937 16A 7;95B36:0 :; 05@0:16:/1:3 .38 941/B .383<;83 /6 :.3 1@03693 ;< 28;;< ;< /69;B3 6;:/;614 /69;B3 .10 :; @3 10030037 199;87/6C :; :.3 C5/734/630 /00537 @A :.3 1861:1H1 :1:3 3C14 38F/930 5:.;8/:A <;8 199/736: ;9958837/6:.3A318#&"=6;:/;614/69;B30.144@3:1H36 1:0"#'& %2B "" 0238:.33F/73693;<:.3;9:;8:.3941/B16:.10 05<<3837 (K 238B1636: 7/01@/4/:A :; :.3 43<: 4;E38 4/B@ 167#(K7/01@/4/:A:;;:.38218:0;<:.3@;7A;60/738/6C :.361:583;<:.3/6D58/3005<<3837@A:.3941/B16:E3183 ;< :.3 ;2/6/;6 :.1: :.3 E.;43 @;7A 7/01@/4/:A /0 :; @3 100300371:#&K.3941/B16:E101C371@;5:'A3180 - 8 - 1::.3:/B3;<:.3199/736:167B54:/24/381224/91@43:;.38 1C3 C8;52 /0 >"G? .50 :.3 941/B16: /0 36:/:437 <;8 9;B23601:/;6;<*" " +0"#'&L"#L"GL#&K! ;6199;56:;<-4;00;<<5:583/69;B3- "# .3 61:583 ;< /6D58/30 /67/91:30 :.1: :.3 941/B16: B50:.1F3@33656738830:167:831:B36:<;81238/;7;< B;6:.0 ;603M536:4A :.3 941/B16: /0 36:/:437 <;8 9;B23601:/;6 ;< *," + 0"#'& L B;6:.0! 56738:.3.317>4;00;</69;B3758/6C41/752238/;7? " .3941/B16:E10.;02/:14/I371016/621:/36:<;8"" 71A0 /6 :.3 .;02/:14 167 05@03M536:4A 8393/F37 <58:.38 :831:B36:53:;:.3199/736::.3941/B16:.1005<<3837 C8/3F;50/6D58/30167140;56738C;63058C38A;60/738/6C :.3 28;4;6C37 21/6 758/6C :831:B36: 10 E344 10 :.3 238B1636: 7/01@/4/:A 938:/</37 @A :.3 7;9:;8 E3 183 /694/637 :; 36.1693 :.3 9;B23601:/;6 1E18737 @A :.3 8/@5614 56738 :.3 .317 ;< -4;00 ;< 1B36/:/30- <8;B 0#&&&& %:;*"+ - 9 - "( ;60/738/6C:.361:583;</6D58/30:.39;B23601:/;6 1E18737 @A :.3 8/@5614 56738 ;:.38 .3170 /0 D50: 167 8310;61@43 "' .50 :.3 941/B16: /0 36:/:437 :; :.3 <;44;E/6C 9;B23601:/;6 -./0*1230405/6 53/6/02/15* *17165/5 892:/ 638401; '*( *17165/5 892:3* 462 '*( 1/616705<<38/6C0 '&&&& '&&&& 37/9143J236030 ""'G" ""'G" *;;76;58/0.B36: 9;6F3A1693167 1::36716:9.18C30 "&&&& "&&&& ;00;</69;B3758/6C 41/752238/;7 ##&&& ='& ;00;<1B36/:/30 #&&&& (&&&& ;00;<<5:583/69;B3 "G$=G& '&$$&& 21; " " "<<" "G 6:.383054::.3<;44;E/6C;8738/0210037 - 10 - 1! .3122314/01;;7/530.162 @! .3D57CB36:;<:.341/B08/@5614/0B;7/</37 9! .3122314/01;;7/530.162 @! .3D57CB36:;<:.341/B08/@5614/0B;7/</37 9! .3 941/B16: /0 36:/:437 :; 1 :;:14 9;B23601:/;6 ;< * "<<"+ 10 1C1/60: *" " + 1E18737 @A:.38/@5614 7! .3 60581693 ;B216A /0 7/839:37 :; 732;0/: :.3 9;B23601:/;6 1B;56: 14;6C E/:. /6:3830: N GK 21 <8;B :.3 71:3 ;< </4/6C ;< :.3 941/B 23:/:/;6:/44:.371:3;<8314/I1:/;6E/:./61238/;7;< 0/J E33H0 <8;B :.3 71:3 ;< 8393/2: ;< 9;2A ;< :./0 D57CB36: 3! .3732;0/:1678343103;<1B;56:0.144@3B173/6 :38B0;<:.31E187;<:.38/@5614 5+ '#( % 5+ '!%&!( % /0:;"4;#G