- 1 - !"# $"% " " &"! '( &"! ' ( ! "# ! $$! ! !% &'( ) * ! + Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' '! ! ! ! ((* + ' ! (&,! ((* + ) * ! + --,*'+ -- ! - ! - &( (, !- ! - % ' ( ' ! ! $' ! ! ! ! ((( * ! + - 3 - ! ! ! ( ! ! $$ ! % * ! + --,*'+ -- ! - ! &(! (,! !- ! - $- ! - !((($ ! - ! - - ! ! . - 4 - . / #"01 2113"#4#5 67 89# :35#3 528#5 &( ;2 #5 "0 3"" < :(, 67 89# -2=">7 :?38! 2"<9?3! 2@235"01 =2"08#020<# :A !((($ #2<9 8: <9">53#0$;#8"8":0#3 : 205 ! 89# ;#8"8":0#3 $@"A# 205 <9">53#0 :A 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 23# 6#A:3# 89" :?38 "0 - :((((( ##B"01 #0920<#=#08 :A =2"08#020<# 2=:?08! @9"># 89# ;#8"8":0#3$9? 6205 "0 - :(((( " 6#A:3# 89" :?38 ##B"01 3#5?<8":0 9#=233"21#6#8@##0;#8"8":0#3 :$@"A#205 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 924"01 6##0 :>#=0"C#5 :0 ((205;#8"8":0#3 : 205924"016:3089#= " 0:8"05" ;?8# 9# ;#8"8":0#3$@"A# 2>>#1"01 9232 =#08 28 89# 9205 :A3# ;:05#08$9? 6205:A5:@375#=205!3# ?>8"01 "0 A2=">7 5" <235 205 2<3"=:07! 2;;3:2<9#5 89# -2=">7 - 5 - :?38 67 A">"01 ;#8"8":0 ?05#3 #<8":0 :A 3 ##B"01=2"08#020<#:A (!((($;#3=:089 ' 9# 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 @9: 2;;#23#5 5#0"#5 89#24#3=#08 2052>>#128":0 =25#"089#;#8"8":0 9# ;#8"8":0#3$@"A# " @:3B"01 2 " 8208 D#<?8"4#01"0##3"0282<"9?3!@9">#3# ;:05#08$ 9? 6205" :A8@23#01"0##3@:3B"01"0 :0 "5#3"0189#<2 #:0=#3"8 !<>2"= 2053"42> <>2"= 205 89# A"020<"2> 828? :A 89# ;238"# ! 89# -2=">7 :?386789#"=;?10#5:35#39#>5;#8"8":0#3 :$@"A#0:8 6#"01 #08"8>#5 A:3 207 =2"08#020<#! @9"># 5"3#<8#5 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205A289#3 8: ;27 !((($ #2<9 8: ;#8"8":0#3 : 205!@9:23#="0:3<9">53#0 #"01 2113"#4#5 67 89# 2"5 :35#3! @"A# 205 <9">53#0 23# 6#A:3# 89" :?38 2 0:8#5 26:4# ##B"01 #0920<#=#08! @9"># 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 " 6#A:3# 89" :?38 ##B"013#4#3 #:A89# 2"5:35#3 - 6 - & 9#=288#3@2 3#A#33#58:=#5"28":0<#083#A:3 #D;>:3"01;: "6">"87:A #88>#=#08 , 9# ;#8"8":0#3$@"A# ##B"01 !((($ ;#3 =:089 8: #2<9 ="0:3 <9">5! @9"># 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 " 3#257205@">>"018:;27 (!((($#2<98:="0:3<9">5 ( 9#3# " 0: 5" ;?8# :A 89# A2<8 8928 ;#8"8":0#3$ @"A#" #=;>:7#5205#230"01205="0:3<9">53#023#"09#3 <23#205<? 8:572?198#3" 828#58:6#;3# #08>721#5 26:?87#23 !205 :0" ;3# #08>721#526:?8,7#23 0 2 E?#37 67 89" :?38! >#230#5 <:?0 #> A:3 89# 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 :0 "0 83?<8":0 A3:= 89# 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205A289#3 @9: " ;#3 :02>>7 ;3# #08 6#A:3# 89" :?38 ?6="8 8928 (!((($ 6#"01 :AA#3#5 67 9"= A:3 #2<9 <9">5 "0<>? "4# :A 89#"3 #5?<28":02> #D;#0 # - 7 - #230#5<:?0 #>A:389#;#8"8":0#3 "03# ;:0 # ?6="8 8928 89# 2"5 2=:?08 " =#21#3 205 89# ;#8"8":0#3 @:?>5 0:8 6# 26># 8: =##8 89# 3#E?"3#=#08 #0<#! ##B A:33#2 :026>##0920<#=#08 =#=: 528#5 ,(( 92 6##0 A">#5 67 89# ;#8"8":0#3 "05"<28"01 89# 3#<?33"01 #5?<28":02> #D;#0 # ! @9"<9 " 6#"01 =#8 67 89# ;#8"8":0#3$=:89#3 @9#3#"0 2;;3:D"=28#>7 2 ?= :A &(!((($ " 6#"01 ;#08:4#3#5?<28":02>#D;#0 # :A89#6:8989#<9">53#0 ' 8 " ?6="88#5 67 89# >#230#5 <:?0 #> A:3 89# 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 8928 9" 82B# 9:=# 2>237 " ,!((($;#3=:089 9#3#" 0:5" ;?8#:089" 2 ;#<8:A89#=288#3 0 89# <"3<?= 820<# "0<# 89# ;#8"8":0#3 23# ##B"01 !((($ ;#3 =:089 #2<9 8: ;#8"8":0#3 : 2052053# ;:05#08$9? 6205" 3#257205@">>"018:;27 (!((($ #2<9! <:0 "5#3"01 89# =28#3"2> :0 3#<:35! - 8 - =:3# ;238"<?>23>7! 89# #5?<28":02> #D;#0 # ! 89" :?38 5##= "8 2;;3:;3"28# 8928 89# 2=:?08 :A =2"08#020<# 6# #0920<#58: !((($8: !((($;#3=:0898:#2<9 :A 89# <9">5 8928 9:?>5 =##8 89# 3#E?"3#=#08 :A =2"08#020<#2 @#>>2 89#;238:A#5?<28":02>#D;#0 # <<:35"01>7!89#A:>>:@"01. *"+ #8"8":0"0- :(((((A">#56789# @"A#205<9">53#0" F *""+ 9# =2"08#020<# 2=:?08 2@235#5 28 !((($#2<98:;#8"8":0#3 : 205" #0920<#58: !((($;#3=:089#2<9F *"""+ 9# 3#G#<8":0 :A 89# 3#E?# 8 :A ;#8"8":0#3 :$@"A# A:3 =2"08#020<# 67 89# -2=">7 :?38!2"<9?3!" <:0A"3=#5F *"4+ :0 #E?#08>7! ;#8"8":0 A">#5 67 89# 3# ;:05#08$9? 6205 "0 - :((((" - 9 - *4+ 0920<#=#08 =25# 92>> 6# #AA#<8"4# A3:= 89#528#:A89" :35#3 9#2=:?085#;: "8#56#A:3#89" :?38!"A207! 92>> 6# 3#>#2 #5 "0 A24:?3 :A ;#8"8":0#3 : 205 3#;3# #08#56789#"3=:89#3 ?6G#<88: 28" A2<8":0:A89#"3 "5#08"87 #05"01 !"A207!5:0:8 ?34"4#A:3<:0 "5#328":0 205 2=# 92>>6#5" ;: #5:A )' *" "+ % . .F F