- 1 - ! " # $ % # $ $"" & !"# $ % &'&(&#' &#&#' ) !!*&+ !"+ '& $ !,,- $ #((. !!*&+!"+ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '& $ !,,- $ #(( / 0 0 $ 0 12 3432 145 672827729 31,5 46624: 4;4,<53 312 =>9;?2<3 ,< 62@,4: 452 A#&#' 94329 &'&(&#' 645529 %B 312 62@,4: >9;2 4<9 99,3,A<4: ,537,@3 4<9 255,A<5 >9;2 ,947 1272,<48327 72827729 3A 45 C62@,4: >9;2D8A751A73E1272%B31262@,4:>9;21454@F>,3329 3124@@>5297256A<92<38A7312A882<@256><,514%:2><927 2@3,A<5!!*&+!"+4<9'&A84<92@3,A<!,,- A8 @129>:29 45325 4<9 @129>:29 7,%25 72-2<3,A< A8 37A@,3B@3#((8A751A73C312@3D 12 84@3>4: ?437,G A8 312 @452 ,< %7,28 ,5 3143 /' 312 -,@3,? ,< 31,5 @452 ,5 312 ?2?%27 A8 4 @129>:29 4532 4<9 512 %2:A<;5 3A ,<9> A:2B4 - 3 - @A??><,3B 12 E45 EA7H,<; 45 4 5>627-,5A7 ,< 49147 <,F>2 92<3,8,@43,A< >31A7,3B ,< 312 B247 &# E1272 3124@@>529E45127@AIEA7H27.31272%B312B%A3182::,< :A-2E,3124@1A3127124@@>529%B34H,<;49-4<34;2A8 87,2<951,6 92-2:A629 ,<3,?4@B E,31 127 4<9 4:5A 149 61B5,@4: @A<34@3 E,31 127 %B 455>7,<; 127 3A ?477B 127248327 12 84,:29 3A 8>:8,:: 1,5 67A?,52 4<9 A< 31,5 %4@H;7A><9 A< &&#! 43 4%A>3 && 6? E12< 4@@>5297256A<92<3E45431,51A>5243>?<4%49-,@3,? E2<3 31272 4<9 4:: A8 4 5>992< 4@@>529 4%>529 127 ,< 8,:31B:4<;>4;2%B?2<3,A<,<;127@4532>73127124:5A 534329 3143 5,<@2 512 %2:A<;5 3A @129>:29 4532 @A??><,3B12E,::<A3?477B1274<9,85128A7@21,?3A ?477B 127 12 E,:: 3A55 4@,9 A< 127 84@2 >%52F>2<3:B 312 54,9 4562@3 E45 %7A>;13 3A 312 H<AE:29;2 A8 127 6472<35 312B 4:5A ?492 288A735 3A 6>75>2 312 4@@>529 E1,@1 E2<3 ,< -4,< 4327 A< &&(&#! 43 4%A>3+!& 6? E12< 312 4@@>529 E45 534<9,<; <247 ?%29H47 ,7@:2 >?<4%49 312 -,@3,? 2<F>,729 1,? 4%A>3 312 67A?,52 455>729 %B 1,? 4%A>3 ?477B,<; 127 AE2-27 - 4 - 4@@>529 A<@2 4;4,< 4%>529 4<9 3172432<29 127 E,31 9,72 @A<52F>2<@254554>:3294<9@4>5291>733A12755>@1 312 -,@3,? :A9;29 312 @A?6:4,<3 %28A72 312 @A?6:4,<4<3I A:,@2 A< &&(&#! 45 627 G! < 312 5372<;31 A8 G! @A?6:4,<4<3 A:,@2 72;,532729 312 @452 ,< 7,?2 A#("&#! 94329 &&(&#! 4;4,<53 312 4@@>529 8A7 312 A882<@25 6><,514%:2 ><927 2@3,A<5 '(! *&+ '#" A8 4<9 ><927 2@3,A<5 !,G,, 4<9 !,,- A8 312 @3 %28A72 312 62@,4: A>73 127248327 312 :247<29 62@,4: >9;2874?29312@147;254;4,<533124@@>5298A731254,9 A882<@25 4<9 312 54?2 E45 7249 3A 1,? -27%43,? AE2-273124@@>52992<,29312@147;254<9@:4,?293A %237,29 ! < A7927 3A 67A-2 312 @147;25 :2-2:29 4;4,<53 312 4@@>529 312 67A52@>3,A< ,< 3A34: 2G4?,<29 # E,3<25525 45 /5# 3A # 5A 4:5A ;A3 ?47H29 & 9A@>?2<3543G5#3A ' < 455255,<; %A31 A74: 4<9 9A@>?2<347B 2-,92<@2312:247<2962@,4:>9;24@F>,33293124@@>529 - 5 - 8A7312@147;25:2-2:294;4,<531,?1254,9=>9;?2<3,5 @14::2<;29,<31,546624:%B3123432 * /2 14-2 12479 312 :247<29 99: 8A7 312 4662::4<33432 5A 4:5A :247<29 @A><52: 7, 4<3A51 43,: 8A73127256A<92<34@@>529 + 12 67,?47B @A<32<3,A< A8 312 :247<29 99: 3432>%:,@7A52@>3A78A73124662::4<3I3432,53143312 :247<2962@,4:>9;214584,:293A46672@,4323122-,92<@2 A8/'I7A52@>37,G,<47,;13627562@3,-212145534329 ,< 127 @A?6:4,<3IG! 5A 4:5A ,< 127 2-,92<@2 3143 312 4@@>529@A??,332952G>4:,<327@A>752A<1278A74627,A9 A8 4<9 J 14:8 B2475 A< 312 672?,52 A8 ?477B,<; 127 127248327123172432<29127E,319,72@A<52F>2<@254<9 1494:5A4554>:329A<1271,52-,92<@2A8/'@:247:B @A77A%A74325 3A 312 3253,?A<B A8 127 843127 /" >73127 /5 4<9 ( 4:5A 534329 3143 4 4<@14B43 E45 12:9 %23E22< 312 4@@>529 4<9 312 -,@3,? 3A 64@,8B 312 ,55>2E,3172;4793A:A-24884,7%23E22<312?5A4:5A312 455>74<@2 ;,-2< %B 312 4@@>529 3A ?477B 312 -,@3,? < - 6 - 5>@1 @,7@>?534<@2 312 62@,4: >9;2 A>;13 3A 14-2 46672@,4329 312 2-,92<@2 A8 /' 4<9 @A<-,@329 312 4@@>5298A7312A882<@212,5@147;2912:247<2999: 3432>%:,@7A52@>3A74:5A@A<32<9293143H<AE,<;8>::B E2:: 3143 312 -,@3,? %2:A<;5 3A @129>:29 4532 @A??><,3B 312 4@@>529 ,<32<3,A<4::B @A??,3329 7462 A< 127%B67A?,5,<;3A?477B127<5>@1@,7@>?534<@2312 ,?6>;<29 =>9;?2<3 ,5 :,4%:2 3A 523 5,92 4<9 312 4@@>529 %2@A<-,@3298A7312@147;25:2-2:294;4,<531,? " 312 :247<29 @A><52: 8A7 312 7256A<92<33432 5>%?,35 3143 312 :247<29 62@,4: >9;2 145 2:4%A7432:B 9,5@>5529 312 2-,92<@2 A8 67A52@>3,A< E,3<255122-,92<@2A8/'72-24:53143,3,5312@:247 @452 A8 84:52 ,?6:,@43,A< A8 312 4@@>529 %B 127 8A7 312 7245A<314331284?,:B?2?%275A83124@@>529E272<A3 E,::,<;3A6278A7?127?477,4;2E,314@@>529>73127312 2-,92<@2A8/'@:247:B72-24:5314343<A6A,<3A83,?2 3124@@>529@A??,332952G>4:4@3E,31127%B67A?,5,<;3A ?477B 127 12 67A52@>3,A< 145 4:5A 84,:29 3A 67A-2 312 - 7 - 4562@331433124@@>529149312H<AE:29;23143312-,@3,? %2:A<;5 3A 5@129>:29 @4532 @A??><,3B 5 5>@1 312 67A52@>3,A<14584,:293A67A-2312@147;25:2-2:29><927 312 67A-,5,A<5 A8 @129>:29 45325 4<9 @129>:29 7,%25 72-2<3,A<A837A@,3B@3#((@@A79,<;:B31262@,4: >9;21457,;13:B4@F>,33293124@@>52987A?312@147;25 :2-2:29 4;4,<53 1,? 2<@2 12 674B5 3A 9,5?,55 312 46624: 4-,<; 12479 312 :247<29 @A><52: 8A7 312 72562@3,-26473,255A4:5A627>5,<;3122<3,722-,92<@2A< 72@A79 ,<@:>9,<; 312 ,?6>;<29 =>9;?2<3 312 8A::AE,<; 6A,<347,5258A7A>7@A<5,92743,A< ( /2 14-2 @4728>::B 627>529 312 2<3,72 2-,92<@2 4-4,:4%:2 A< 72@A79 5A 4:5A 312 9A@>?2<35 6:4@29 %28A72 >5 - 8 - #& 5@A>:9%2522<87A?31272@A795,<A79273A 67A-2 312 @147;25 :2-2:29 4;4,<53 312 4@@>529 312 67A52@>3,A< 145 6729A?,<4<3:B 72:,29 312 2-,92<@2 A8 /'K7A52@>37,G < 627>54: A8 127 2-,92<@2 512 145 @432;A7,@4::B534329314312752:84<94@@>529E272,<:A-2 4884,78A74627,A9A84<9JB247567,A73A:A9;,<;G! 124:5A49?,3329,<1272-,92<@2314312752:84<94@@>529 E2<3 3A -47,A>5 6:4@25 :,H2 >:%47;4 B9274%49 4<9 14H>74<9>5293A374-2:,<9,88272<36:4@2A<@2A7317,@2 ,<4E22H>73127512>5293A-,5,33121A>52A84@@>529 A832< < 627>54: A8 127 2-,92<@2 ,3 ,5 <AE1272 534329 4%A>33124::2;2952G>4:4@354,93A14-2%22<@A??,3329 %B3124@@>529A<1274<94:5A31294324<93,?2A85>@1 4@3@A??,3329%B3124@@>529A72A-2731272,5492:4B A8 94B5 ,< :A9;,<; G! 1272 ,5 <A 2-,92<@2 4-4,:4%:2 A< 72@A79 3A 67A-2 3143 312 4@@>529 @A??,3329 52G>4: 4@3 A< 127 %B 92@2,-,<; 127 874>9>:2<3:B A7 9,51A<253:B,<9>@,<;127 ## <A79273A43374@331267A-,5,A<5A82@3,A<'& A83128A::AE,<;,<;729,2<35?>53%267A-29 - 9 - L, 1272 51A>:9 %2 874>9>:2<3 A7 9,51A<253 ,<9>@2?2<3A846275A<%B92@2,-,<;1,? ,, 4 312 6275A< 5A 92@2,-29 51A>:9 %2 ,<9>@29 3A 92:,-27 4<B 67A6273B 3A 4<B 6275A< A7 3A @A<52<3 3143 4<B 6275A< 514::7234,<4<B67A6273BA7. % 312 6275A< 5A 92@2,-29 51A>:9 %2 ,<32<3,A<4::B ,<9>@29 3A 9A A7 A?,3 3A 9A 4<B31,<;E1,@112EA>:9<A39AA7A?,3,8 12E272<A35A92@2,-294<9 ,,, ,< @4525 @A-2729 %B. ,, 312 4@3 A8 A?,55,A<51A>:9%2A<2E1,@1@4>525A7,5 :,H2:B 3A @4>52 94?4;2 A7 147? 3A 312 6275A<,<9>@29,<%A9B?,<9726>343,A< A767A6273BM # <312@452A<14<931272,5<A5>@1874>9A7 9,51A<253 ,<32<3,A< ,5 8A731@A?,<; E1,:2 627>54: A8 2-,92<@2A8/'1A>;131267A52@>3,A<14572:,29312 2-,92<@2 A8 /5" 4<9 ( 4:: 31252 E,3<25525 14-2 926A529314348327312,<@,92<34 4<@14B43 E4512:93A 49-,52 312 4@@>529 -,@3,? 4<9 127 84?,:B 1,5 6,2@2 A8 2-,92<@2<AE4B12:68>:3A312@452A831267A52@>3,A<3A 67A-2312;>,:3A83124@@>529 - 10 - #! <5A84745@147;2><9272@3,A<!'A8312 67A52@>3,A< 145 <A3 6:4@29 4<B 5>@1 ?29,@4: 72@A79 A7 2-,92<@2A83129A@3A7>731273A%7,<;1A?2312;>,:3A8 312 A882<@25 :2-2:29 4;4,<53 312 4@@>529 ><927 312 67A-,5,A<5 A8 @129>:29 4532 4<9 @129>:29 7,%2 312 67A52@>3,A< ,5 72F>,729 3A 67A-2 3143 312 4@@>529 51A>:9 14-2 @A??,3329 312 A882<@2 4;4,<53 312 ?2?%27 A8 312 5@129>:2 @4532 H<AE,<; 3143 512 4 ?2?%27 A8 3143 @A??><,3B /' 145 <A3 534329 3143 312 4@@>529 E45 4E4724%A>3127@4532E1,:2312B:A-,<;24@1A312754 ?43327 A8 84@3 /' 49?,3329 3143 512 >529 3A -,5,3 312 1A>52 872F>2<3:B 4<9 312B %A31 >529 3A 374-2: 3A;23127 A<@2A7317,@2,<4E22H<5>@1@,7@>?534<@2312A882<@2 @A??,3329 ><927 312 67A-,5,A<5 A8 4:5A 9A25 <A3 43374@3,<31,5@4521272,5,<A79,<43292:4BA8#94B5,< :A9;,<; 312 @A?6:4,<3 12 2-,92<@2 A8 312 9A@3A7 E1A 3724329312,<=>729-,@3,?4:5A145<A3A%527-294<B5>@1 ,<=>7,25 >6A< 6A55,%,:,3B A8 52G>4: 4@3 @A??,3329 %B 312 4@@>529<5>@1@,7@>?534<@231267A52@>3,A<14584,:29 - 11 - 3A 67A-2 312 @147;25 :2-2::29 312 4;4,<53 %2BA<9 7245A<4%:29A>%3 #' 1,5 46624: ,5 4;4,<53 312 4@F>,334: A7927 312 A<D%:2 62G A>73 ,< 312 @452 A8 726A7329 ,< 5>??47,N2931267,<@,6:253A2G27@,523126AE27 %B 312 662::432 A>73 3A ,<3278272 ,< 312 A7927 A8 312 255,A<5A>73,<6474;7461A(45><927 ! " # $ % ! " # $ % ! # $" " " & # $ ! " '" " # $ % ! " " (" # ) ! # $ " & $* " " + " & # $ ! ) " " + +! + + ,! +! + # $ " !+ & # $ " " (+! & $" - 12 - + +! ( + - " (+! & $ +" # $ " " + ( #* >73127312A<D%:262GA>73,<312 @452A8 !! " 726A7329 ,< # ## E1,:25>??47,N,<;31267,<@,6:25,< 924:,<; E,31 312 46624: 4;4,<53 4@F>,334: ,< 6474;7461 A'12:945><927 #, ! + + ! # " ! & " ! . #-/ 0.10 $ 203 " + 4 5 67# + 8 !9 67 ! 9 67 - $ "" + !+"9 - 13 - 67 - " & $ ! +" +! !" ! 9 67- $ ) ! +! & $ 9 67 - $ ! ! " & $ #+ 2<@2A<@4728>:627>54:A83124%A-2:4E:4,9 9AE<%B312A<D%:262GA>734<93122-,92<@26:4@29 %B 312 67A52@>3,A< ,< 312 ,<534<3 @452 E2 472 A8 312 @A<5,92729 -,2E 3143 312 67A52@>3,A< 145 84,:29 3A 6:4@2 5>88,@,2<3 2-,92<@2 3A 67A-2 312 @147;25 :2-2:29 4;4,<53 3124@@>529%2BA<97245A<4%:29A>%3>7312731272,5<A 5>@1 @A?62::,<; 7245A<5 8A731@A?,<; 3A ,<3278272 ,< 312 4@F>,334:=>9;?2<3645529%B31262@,4:>9;2 #" < 3143 -,2E A8 312 ?43327 E2 92@:,<2 3A ,<3278272 ,< 312 =>9;?2<3 645529 %B 312 62@,4: A>73 @@A79,<;:B E2 4<5E27 312 6A,<3 74,529 4%A-2 ,< 312 488,7?43,-24<967A@2293A64553128A::AE,<; - 14 - 12 7,?,<4: 6624: ,5 $%$ %2,<; 92-A,9 A8 ?27,35 '( )%* '( ) * ,53A#:A'