- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( !! " # $ %& ''& $ ! ! ( )! # $* ' $'$ # # " # # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $+',$'$& - ''''' % .&$ $'$ ! # # ,/ ./ # 0 # 0 12341 516 788679 :- 9:-56; <2= 7;>:--:2? @:51 516 A2?-6?52<967=?6;A23?-69<2=B25151687=5:6-:5:-57C6? 38<2=<:?79;:-82-79 $ 67=;5167=43>6?5-2<B251-:;6- 1:- 788679 :- <:96; 747:?-5 516 D3;4>6?5 7?; 7@7=; ;756; $+',$'$& 87--6; BE 516 =:?A:879 6?:2= :F:93;467?;!797B3=74::? 2.&$2<$'$ & 16 <7A5- 2< 516 A7-6 7=6 5175 2? ' $$'$' @1:96 516 ;6A67-6; 717;6F @7- 8=2A66;:?4 2? >252=AEA962? 6?6472?%7?;7=813==27;516=:;6=2<516 - 3 - 6=2 # 693G6 >252=AEA96 B67=:?4 2% #%' =2;6:5:?1:41-866;7?;=7-17?;?649:46?5>7??6=7?; ;7-16; 52 516 ;6A67-6; ;36 52 @1:A1 16 -3-57:?6; 4=:6F23- :?D3=:6- 7?; -3AA3>B6; 52 516 -7>6 :? 516 12-8:579 16=6<2=61:-@:<6<:96;7A97:>865:5:2?B6<2=6 516 =:B3?79 A97:>:?4 A2>86?-75:2? 2< -,'''' % 16 =:B3?79 A2?-:;6=:?4 516 6?5:=6 6F:;6?A6 2? =6A2=; 4=7?56; A2>86?-75:2? 2< - "+"'' % @:51 :?56=6-5 75 ,/ 87 <=2> 516 ;756 2< 865:5:2? 5:99 =679:-75:2? 7?; ;:=6A56; =6-82?;6?5 2$%?-3=7?A6 2>87?E 52 ;682-:5 516-7>6 , 44=:6F6;BE516-7:;D3;4>6?57?;7@7=;516 A97:>7?517-8=6<6==6;51:-788679:?@1:A1:5:-A2?56?;6; 5175 516 ;6A67-6; @7- 746; " E67=- 7?; 67=?:?4 - +''' % 86= >2?51 B35 516 =:B3?79 17- 57C6? 1:- :?A2>62?9E75- "' %86=>2?515:-<3=516=-5756; 5175 '/ 2< 516 :?A2>6 :- ;6;3A56; 52@7=;- 86=-2?79 6G86?-6-2<516;6A67-6;7?;:5:-52B6>2;:<:6;7- =; - 4 - " 67=?6;A23?-69<2==6-82?;6?52$A2?56?;6; 5175 516 =:B3?79 17- 4=7?56; A2>86?-75:2? 2? 8=286= 788=6A:75:2?2<516<7A5-7?;:517-;6;3A56;'/52@7=;- 86=-2?79 6G86?-6- 2< 516 ;6A67-6; 7- 516=6 :- 2?9E 2?6 A97:>7?5 + 16 ;6A67-6; @7- 746; " E67=- 7?; 516 >395:89:6= @7- =:4159E 57C6? 7- H I - 516 7886997?5 17- <7:96; 52 8=2;3A6 516 :?A2>6 8=22< 516 :?A2>6 2< 516 ;6A67-6;@7-57C6?75- "' %86=>2?517-86=516 43:;69:?6-2<516!7=?757C7575664796=F:A6-3512=:5E 7?;:5?66;-?2:?56=<6=6?A6 .162?IB9686G23=5:?516;:A53>2< 169; 5175 516 <353=6 8=2-86A5- 2< :?A2>6 2< 516 -69<%6>892E6; ;6A67-6; -1799 79-2 B6 :?A93;6; :? ;656=>:?75:2? 2< 516 A2>86?-75:2?13-A2?-:;6=:?45167462<516;6A67-6; &'/ 2< 516 :?A2>6 17- 52 B6 7;;6; 52@7=;- <353=6 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 5 - 8=2-86A5- 7?; 513- 516 7>23?5 @239; B6A2>6 - .$' %86=>2?51 "'J'' ' 16 =:B3?79 17- ;6;3A6; '/ 2< 516 :?A2>6 52@7=;- 86=-2?79 6G86?-6- 2< 516 ;6A67-6; ;>:556;9E 516;6A67-6;@7->7==:6;7?;1:-@:<617-<:96;516A97:> 865:5:2?6=69EB6A73-6-16792?6<:96;516A97:>865:5:2? 516 ;6;3A5:2? 2< '/ :- ?25 8=286= 7?; 7- 86= 516 43:;69:?6- 2< 516 2?IB96 86G 23=5 :? ;:A53> 2< =; 2< 516 :?A2>6 2< 516 ;6A67-6; :- 52 B6 ;6;3A56; 52@7=;- 1:- 86=-2?796G86?-6- 16=6<2=6 516 92-- 2< ;686?;6?AE A2>6- 52 -$ '''' % .$'G $G G$ $ #3=516= 7- 86= 516 43:;69:?6- 2< 516 2?IB96 86G23=5:?516;:A53>2< ! " #$ #% 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 6 - & 7?; ' " ( ) * ( +5167886997?5:-6?5:596;<2=-&'''' %52@7=;- 92--2<-823-79A2?-2=5:3> 16 :- 79-2 6?5:596; <2= 7? 7>23?5 2< -'''' % 3?;6= 516 A2?F6?5:2?79 167;- :6 92-- 2< 6-57567?;<3?6=796G86?-6-7-86=516A:575:2?:?516A7-6 2< & 6?A6 516 A2>86?-75:2? :- =67--6--6; 7- 3?;6= 2--2<;686?;6?AE -$ '''' % 2--2<A2?-2=5:3> -&'''' % 2?F6?5:2?79167;- -'''' % 2579 6--7@7=;6;BE516=:B3?79 -$+'''' % - "+"'' % ?17?A6;A2>86?-75:2? -.$'' % 13- 516 7886997?5 :- 6?5:596; <2= 6?17?A6; A2>86?-75:2? 2< -.$'' % @:51 :?56=6-5 75 ,/ 87 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 7 - <=2>516;7562<865:5:2?5:99=679:K75:2?7?;516=6<2=6516 788679;6-6=F6-52B67992@6;:?87=5 ?516=6-395516<2992@:?42=;6=:-87--6; : 16788679:-7992@6;:?87=5 :: 16 7886997?5 :- 6?5:596; <2= 6?17?A6; A2>86?-75:2? 2< -.$'' %792?4 @:51 :?56=6-5 75,/ 87<=2>516;7562<865:5:2?5:99=679:K75:2? ::: 6-82?;6?5 2$%?-3=7?A6 2>87?E :- ;:=6A56; 52 ;682-:5 516 7<2=6-7:; A2>86?-75:2? 7>23?5 @:51:?2?6>2?51<=2>516;7562<51:-D3;4>6?5 :F ? -3A1 ;682-:5 516 7886997?5 :- 86=>:556; 52 @:51;=7@ 516 6?5:=6 7>23?5 792?4 @:51 :?56=6-5 7AA=36; 2?:5 )*+ %$' # :-52 92+'