Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92543 (KAR)
KULAPPA SAYABANNA BANGARI v. REHAMAN BANDAGISAB BAGAWAN AND ANR
MFA/203918/2023 · 2025-12-17
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92543 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92543 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $%#
$%!%&! ##
'&( )* ## +,
+'&( ##
+
'&( ## +
'&(
)
*
!"#"$ %
&
'
"$
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!""($
($ )
$*!*"( $ ! !##"#$ %
&
$
+",
+('
+ + "*&"' +
+
#-#.-(#(*
$! (#" + + +
$
$(*###-
+/ 0123 +4$
+, )
+
*
#
!"#"$ $$$
&
$'
- 3 -
"$
!""($
($ )
$*!*"( $ ! !##"#$ %
&
$
+",
+('
++ "*&"'+
+
#-#.-(#(*
$.((#" + + + $
$!(##-
+ / + 4 $
+)
*
4
- 4 -
!(#.$ $$$
&
$$'
"$ $
. & '
!"#*$
($
$ $*!*"( $ #"$ $$$
&
$ $+",
+('
+ + "*&"' +
#$#.$(#(*
$$$$! (#"
+ +
$
+4$
+ )
*
- 5 -
4
!(#.$ $$$
&
$'
"$
! & '
!"#*$
($
$
.+
###"*$ $$$
&
$ $+",
+('
+ + "*&"' +
#$#.$(#(*
$$$$.((#"
+ +
$
+4$
+
+
- 6 -
5 $$$
678 5 $
$
% & 5 $$$ '
9:2: 62: 3036; <012 6==:6;> <?;:8 6@6?7>3 39: A18@B:736786C628863:8#$#.$(#(*62?>?7@0130< 0>$!
(#" 678 .((#" =6>>:8 DE 88;$ :7?02 ?F?;18@:678:BD:2-?A6E6=126&<02>9023 G39: 2?D176;/'$ 13 0< <012 6==:6;> 3C0 6==:6;> ?7 + 0$(### ((#( 678 (#*." (#(* 62: =2:<:22:8 DE 39: H;6?B673>>::I?7@:7967H:B:730<H0B=:7>63?07C9:2:6> 039:2 3C0 6==:6;> ?7 + 0>$(#"(*(#( 678 (#*"(#(62:=2:<:22:8DE39:0C7:20<39:0<<:78?7@ F:9?H;: >::I?7@ <6>3:7?7@ 0< ;?6D?;?3E 07 39: ?7>1267H: H0B=67E?7>3:680<;?6D?;?3E0739:2:>=078:730$"$ 7+0$(### ((#( ($ 9:;:627:8H017>:;<0239:H;6?B67326?>:839: <0;;0C?7@H073:73?07> - 7 - 6' +?2>3;E 63 39: 3?B: 0< 6HH?8:73 39: H;6?B673 C6> 6@:8 6D013 * E:62> 678 81: 30 39: 6HH?8:73 39: H;6?B67396>>1<<:2:8@2?:F01>?7A12?:>76B:;E<26H312:0< 2?D>$9:H;6?B67396>:J6B?7:839:80H3026> $$*C90 8:=0>:8 3963 39: H;6?B673 96> >1<<:2:8 8?>6D?;?3E 30 39: :J3:730<"K3039:C90;:D08E?72:>=:H30<1==:2;?BD$ 13 39: 2?D176; 96> 6>>:>>:8 07;E K 8?>6D?;?3E 30 39: C90;:D08E67839:>6B:?>0739:;0C:2>?8:$ D' :H078;E 9: 96> H073:78:8 3963 H07>?8:2?7@ 39: ?7A12?:> >1<<:2:8 DE 39: H;6?B673 H07>?8:2?7@ 39: B:8?H6; 2:H028> 678 :F?8:7H: 0< 39: 80H302 39: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 DE 39: 2?D176; 30C628> =6?7 678 >1<<:2?7@;0>>0<6B:7?3?:>678039:26HH?8:736;:J=:7>:> 62:0739:;0C:2>?8:$ *$ ;:627:8 H017>:; 6==:62?7@ <02 39: 2:>=078:73 0$( ?7>1267H: H0B=67E 96> 26?>:8 39: <0;;0C?7@H073:73?07> - 8 - 6' 96339:H;6?B67396>:J6B?7:839:80H3026> $$*$79?>:F?8:7H: $$*8:=0>:8396339:H;6?B673 96>>1<<:2:8"K8?>6D?;?3E?72:>=:H30<1==:2;?BD$13 39:2?D176;96>H07>?8:2:8"*280<39:8?>6D?;?3E<02C90;: D08E6782?@93;E6>>:>>:8C90;:8?>6D?;?3E63K$ D' 6>3;E 9: 96> H073:78:8 3963 H07>?8:2?7@ 39: :F?8:7H: 0< 80H302 678 ?7A12?:> >1<<:2:8 DE 39: H;6?B673 39: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 DE 39: 2?D176; 30C628> =6?7 678 >1<<:2?7@ ;0>> 0< 6B:7?3?:> 039:2 ?7H?8:736; ?7A12?:> 62:A1>36782:6>076D;:$:7H:9:>01@93<028?>B?>>6;0< 39:6==:6;$ $ :628 39: ;:627:8 H017>:; <02 39: =623?:> =:21>:839:A18@B:736786C6280<39:2?D176;6786;>0 39:6==:6;=6=:2>$ $ 3 ?> 703 ?7 8?>=13: 3963 39: H;6?B673> 96F: >1<<:2:8 ?7A12E ?7 6 2068 326<<?H 6HH?8:73 0HH122:8 07 ($# $(#"81:3026>96787:@;?@:7382?F?7@0<82?F:20< :B=026JD:62?7@:@$0$-( -***$3?>6;>0703 - 9 - ?7 8?>=13: 3963 81: 30 39: 6D0F: 6HH?8:73 39: H;6?B673> 96F:>1<<:2:8?7A12?:>$ !$ 1: 30 39: 6HH?8:7339:H;6?B673 96> >1<<:2:8 <26H312: 0< 2?D> 678 >9: 96> :J6B?7:8 2$ >90I 6E6I 2390=:8?H 12@:07 6> $$* C90 32:63:8 39: H;6?B673$ 7 9?> :F?8:7H: $$* 8:=0>:8 3963 39: H;6?B673 96> >1<<:2:8 "K 8?>6D?;?3E 30 39: C90;: D08E$ 07>?8:2?7@ 39::F?8:7H:0<80H302678B:8?H6;2:H028>C:62:0<39: 0=?7?073963C90;:D08E8?>6D?;?3EH67D:6>>:>>:863"#K$ 739:6D>:7H:0<=200<0<?7H0B:39:2?D176;96>2?@93;E 6>>:>>:8 39: 703?076; ?7H0B: 0< 39: H;6?B673 63 >$"#(#-=$B$339:3?B:0<6HH?8:7339:H;6?B673C6> 6@:86D013*E:62>$9:B1;3?=;?:26==;?H6D;:3039:6@: @201= 0< 39: H;6?B673 ?> G"/$ HH028?7@;E ;0>> 0< <1312: :627?7@96>D::72:-6>>:>>:86>178:2 >$"#(#-J"(J"J"#KL>$"((##-$ $ 1: 30 39: 6HH?8:7339:H;6?B673 96> >1<<:2:8 @2?:F01>?7A12E$9:C6>68B?33:86>67?7-=63?:73$9: - 10 - 96> >1<<:2:8 ;03 0< =6?7 812?7@ 39: 32:63B:73 D:H61>: 0< 8?>6D?;?3E 678 96> 30 >1<<:2 1796==?7:>> 812?7@ 9:2 ;?<:$ 07>?8:2?7@39::F?8:7H:0<80H302678?7A12E>1<<:2:8DE 39:H;6?B673C:62:?7H;?7:830:7967H:39:H0B=:7>63?07 30C628> G=6?7 678 >1<<:2?7@/ <20B >$"####- 30 >$*####-$ ?I:C?>: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 178:2 39: 9:68G<0086787012?>9B:73/?>:7967H:8<20B>$###- 30 >$"####-$ 9: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 178:2 39: 9:68 G;0>> 0< 6B:7?3?:>/ ?> :7967H:8 <20B >$"####- 30 >$(####-$ 9: H;6?B673 ?> 6;>0 :73?3;:8 <02 H0B=:7>63?0730C628>;0>>0<?7H0B:812?7@;6?81==:2?08 <02392::B0739>?$:$>$*##-&>$"#(#-J*'$9: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 178:2 039:2 9:68> 62: A1>3 678 2:6>076D;:$ $ 7 2:-6>>:>>B:73 678 2:-8:3:2B?763?07 39: H0B=1363?070<H0B=:7>63?07?>6>178:2 -./012314 5361.703 6?7678>1<<:2?7@ >$*####- - 11 - :8?H6;:J=:7>:> >$"( ###-
+0086787012?>9B:73 >$"####- 0>>0<<1312::627?7@ H6=6H?3E >$"((##- 0>>0<?7H0B:812?7@ ;6?81==:2?08 >$*##- 0>>0<6B:7?3?:> >$(####- 389 .+",",) .$ 9: H0B=:7>63?07 6C628:8 30 39: H;6?B673 DE 39: 2?D176; ?7 + 0$(#*." (#(* ?> A1>3 678 =20=:2 6789:7H:70?73:2<:2:7H:?>H6;;:8<02$ ! "#$ :627:8 H017>:; 6==:62?7@ <02 0C7:2 0< 39: 0<<:78?7@F:9?H;:?$:$2:>=078:730$"H073:78:8396339: 0<<:78?7@F:9?H;:?>H0F:2:8C?39F6;?8?7>1267H:=0;?HE678 39: 82?F:2 0< 39: 0<<:78?7@ F:9?H;: C6> 96F?7@ F6;?8 678 :<<:H3?F:82?F?7@;?H:7H:6>0739:863:0<39:6HH?8:73$
""$ 9: ;:627:8 H017>:; <02 2:>=078:73 0$" 96> 2:;?:8 07 39: A18@B:73 863:8 (.$""$(#(* ?7 +
- 12 -
0>$(##!#(#(( C (#"" "(#(( 62?>?7@ 013 0< 39: >6B:6HH?8:73C9:2:?739:A18@B:736786C628=6>>:8DE 39:2?D176;96>D::7B08?<?:890;8?7@396339:82?F:20< 39:0<<:78?7@F:9?H;:C6>96F?7@F6;?8678:<<:H3?F:82?F?7@ ;?H:7H: 6> 07 39: 863: 0< 39: 6HH?8:73 678 9:;8 3963 39: ?7>1267H:H0B=67E?>;?6D;:30=6E:73?2:H0B=:7>63?0730 39:H;6?B673>$78:2>1H9H?2H1B>367H:>39:?B=1@7:8 A18@B:73 678 6C628 ?> 6;>0 62?>?7@ 013 0< 39: >6B: 6HH?8:736789:7H:;?6D?;?3E2:M1?2:>30D:>688;:80739: 2:>=078:730$(?7>1267H:H0B=67E$
"($ 739:2:>1;3C:=6>>39:<0;;0C?7@
6' 9: 6==:6; =2:<:22:8 DE 39: H;6?B673 ?7 +0$(### ((#(?> !"#$
D' 9: H;6?B673 ?> :73?3;:8 30 6 3036;
H0B=:7>63?07 0< >$*.#.#- 6> 6@6?7>3 >$(.(!!- 6C628:8 DE 39: 2?D176;
6;07@ C?39 ?73:2:>3 63 39: 263: 0< !K =:2 6771B$
- 13 -
H' 9:6==:6;>=2:<:22:8DE39:0C7:20<39: 0<<:78?7@F:9?H;:?7+0>$(#"(*(#( 678 (#*"(#( 62: !"# 07;E 30 39: :J3:73 0< >688;?7@ ;?6D?;?3E 07 39:2:>=078:730$(7>1267H:H0B=67E ?7>3:680<2:>=078:730$"$
8' 9::>=078:730$(-7>1267H:0B=67E ?> 8?2:H3:8 30 8:=0>?3 :73?2: H0B=:7>63?07 6B0173 6;07@ C?39 ?73:2:>3 63 39: 263: 0< !K =:2 6771B <20B 39: 863: 0< <?;?7@ 0< 39: H;6?B =:3?3?07> 3?;; 39: 863: 0< 2:6;?N63?07 C?39?7 6 =:2?08 0< >?J C::I> <20B 39: 863: 0< 2:H:?=3 0< 6 H0=E 0< 39?> A18@B:73$
:' 9:8:=0>?36782:;:6>:>96;;D:6>=:239: 028:20<39:2?D176;$
:) '#( %
:) '!%&!( %
?>30$";0$"