- 1 - !"# $% &!'!(!! !!(( )%* + !!" "#" $% &$% '( )$ #' !**+ ! "#&!"" "" " " " $$!! " "! ! " !" "!"!"#$, "" ! "# "- Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ $ -+$#"!" $ " # (+ " $ $ " # " " " !! $ " " " *' ! # (+ " # """! " $ *' "(." "" '** "." " " !! $ " " #" / / 0 "! ' "123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?< 4@42?3< <16 A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 94<69 *' 543369 2? # D(+ :; <16 992<2D?47 6?2DC 2E27 A9@6 4?9 " 474:AC4@2 8DC 31DC< F<16 <C2:A?47G 366H2?@ =D>56?34<2D?D83 < 23 3<4<69 <14< <16 =742>4?< >6< B2<1 4==296?< D?''6B434@69'*;64C343D?<1694<6D8<16 4==296?< 4?9 64C?2?@ 4 3A> D8 3+ 56C >D?<1 :; 9D2?@=DD726BDCHA6<D<162?IAC2633A886C69:;12>2?<16 4==296?< 16 82769 =742> 56<2<2D? :68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 "16 <C2:A?47 48<6C =D?3296C2?@ <16 6?<2C6 6E296?=6 D? C6=DC9 - 3 - 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3*' 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6D8(.2?<6C63<8CD><1694<6D856<2<2D?<277C6472J4<2D? 62?@ 4@@C26E69 :; <16 3429 A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 <16 =742>4?< 143 5C686CC69 <16 5C636?< 455647 366H2?@ 6?14?=6>6?<D8<16=D>56?34<2D? + ?<165C636?<4556472<23>42?7;=D?<6?969<14< ! D=<DC <1DA@1 3<4<69 <14< =742>4?< C6KA2C634?D<16C 3AC@6C; 2? 8A<AC6 4?9 63<2>4<69 =D3< D8 3AC@6C; 43 3 <D 3 ?D 4>DA?<3 B6C6 @C4?<69 8DC8A<AC6>692=476L56?363:;<16<C2:A?47"16D=<DC26 !43363369<169234:272<;D8<16=742>4?<4<++.<D <16 B1D76 :D9; :A< <16 <C2:A?47 143 D?7; =D?3296C69 . $AC<16C2<233<4<69<14<.23<D:649969<DB4C938A<AC6 5CD356=<3 4?9 C6KA63<3 8DC 6?14?=6>6?< D8 <16 =D>56?34<2D? ' 64C9<164C@A>6?<38CD>:D<132963 64C?69 =DA?367 8DC <16 C635D?96?< D 3<4<69 <14< ! 23 ?D< 4 <C64<69 D=<DC "16C68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 143C2@1<7;<4H6?<169234:272<;4<.4?9?D<@C4?<694?; - 4 - 4>DA?< <DB4C93 8A<AC6 >692=47 6L56?363, <16 4>DA?<3 @C4?<69 :; <16 <C2:A?47 4C6 IA3< 4?9 5CD56C 4?9 5C4;3 8DC 923>23347D8<16455647 ( "16 =742>4?< 3A3<42?69 8C2=<2D? 4:C432D? 96@7DE2?@ 2?IAC; C2@1< J;@D>4<2= A556C 725 768< 3296 7DB6C =163<4?94:9D>6?4356CL!(MBDA?9=6C<282=4<6L! 23 <16 923=14C@6 3A>>4C; 3 56C 923=14C@6 3A>>4C; <16 =742>4?< 49>2<<69 <D <16 1D352<47 D? ' 4?9 923=14C@69D?6B4349>2<<698DC'94;3"16 =742>4?< 143 3<4<69 <14< 16 B43 64C?2?@ 4 3A> D8 3+ 56C>D?<1:A<16143?D<5CD9A=694?;5CDD8 <D5CDE61232?=D>66>6<B2<14==296?<2?<16;64C' 3 56C <16 @A29672?63 233A69 :; <16 4C?4<4H4 <4<6 6@47 6CE2=63A<1DC2<;<162?=D>6D8<16=742>4?<23<D:6<4H6? 4< 3- 8DC <16 ;64C ' 6?=6 <16 <C2:A?47 143 C2@1<7; <4H6? <16 2?=D>6 D8 <16 =742>4?< 4?9 ?6693 ?D 2?<6C86C6?=6 ! <16 D=<DC 3<4<69 <14< 16 E6C28269 <16 BDA?9=6C<282=4<64?9923=14C@63A>>4C;4?9473D6L4>2?69 <16 =742>4?< =72?2=477; 4?9 8DA?9 <16 =742>4?< 143 3A886C69 82=<2D?4:C432D?96@7DE2?@2?IAC;C2@1<J;@D>4<2=A556C725 - 5 - 768< 3296 7DB6C =163< 4?9 4:9D>6? "16 D=<DC 143 D52?69 <14<<16=742>4?<=4??D<32<4?93KA4<4?916=4??D<B47H 8DC 7D?@ 923<4?=6 "16C6 23 >47A?2<69 8C4=<AC6 D8 :D<1 26 :274<6C473A56C2DC4?92?86C2DCC4>D85A:72=C6@2D?923<DC<69 567E2= C2?@ B2<1 5CDL2>47 >2@C4<2D? D8 C2@1< 16>2 567E23 16?=6 16 143 72>52?@ @42< D? C2@1< 3296 4< +. 4?9 <1A3 43363369<169234:272<;43++.4?98AC<16C3<4<69<14<16 C6KA2C63 D?6 >DC6 5743<2= 3AC@6C; D8 768< 2?@A2?47 C6@2D? B12=1=D3<33 <D3 - D?3296C2?@ <16 6E296?=6 D8 ! <123 DAC< 82?932<C643D?4:76<D<4H6 +C9D8++.26-.2?3<649 D8 . "16 7D33 D8 8A<AC6 64C?2?@ =454=2<; =D>63 <D 3- NNN-.O3(+ 2?=6 <16 =742>4?< 143 <4H6? <C64<>6?< 2? <16 DE6C?>6?< D352<47 <C2:A?47 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3 <DB4C93>692=476L56?3634?9<16C623?D9235A<6C6@4C92?@ <16 34>6 D?3296C2?@ <16 ?4<AC6 D8 2?IAC263 D==A54<2D? D8 <16 =742>4?< 56C2D9 D8 1D352<472J4<2D? 4?9 D<16C C676E4?< 84=<DC3<123DAC<82?932<C643D?4:76<D@C4?<4?4>DA?<D8 - 6 - 3 <DB4C93542?4?93A886C2?@33 7D33D8 4>6?2<263 4?9 3+ <DB4C93 <C4?35DC<4<2D? 6L<C4 ?DAC231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?< =14C@63 "16 =742>4?< >2@1< 14E6?D<4<<6?9694?;BDCH8DC4<7643<8DAC>D?<136?=6 4 3A> D8 3+ 23 4B4C969 <DB4C93 7D33 D8 2?=D>6 9AC2?@ 7429 A5 56C2D9 6?=6 <16 <D<47 =D>56?34<2D? 23 43 A?96C/ !, -./0123-40.564 2745 D33D88A<AC62?=D>6 3(+ 692=476L56?363 3 + D33D84>6?2<263 3 ' !42?4?93A886C2?@3 3 "C4?35DC<4<2D? 6L<C4 ?DAC231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?< =14C@63 3+ ( $A<AC6>692=476L56?363 3 - D33 D8 2?=D>6 9AC2?@ 7429 A5 56C2D9 3- N ' >D?<13 3+ 5., 08 * 64C?69 =DA?367 8DC <16 ?3AC4?=6 =D>54?; 3A:>2<3<14<<16=D>56?34<2D?4B4C969:;<16<C2:A?47143 :66?965D32<69:68DC6<16<C2:A?4747D?@B2<12?<6C63< ==DC92?@7;<168D77DB2?@/ - 7 - 2 "1645564723477DB692?54C<, 22 "16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<76 <D <D<47 =D>56?34<2D?D83'+ 47D?@B2<12?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6 D8 (. 56C 4??A> 8CD> <16 94<6 D8 56<2<2D? <277 <16 94<6 D8 C6472J4<2D? 43 4@42?3< 3*' , 222 "16 ?3AC4?=6 =D>54?; 23 92C6=<69 <D 965D32< <16 6?14?=69 =D>56?34<2D? D8 3*+ 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< B2<12? 4 56C2D9 D8D?6>D?<18CD><1694<6D8<123DC96C, 2E ? 3A=1 965D32< <16 =742>4?< 23 56C>2<<69 <D B2<19C4B <16 6?<2C6 4>DA?< 47D?@ B2<12?<6C63<4==CA69D?2< 0/8 )(!! * ' # 23<D/ 7D/-