- 1 - !!""!# $ % "&"'""! ( ! " # $% "$ " ! ! " # $&% "$ " ! " # $% "$ ! " # % "$ ' ! ! # $% "$ " $ # # " ($) $! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' # " * % + " ! ! " # $'% "$# " $''" % ! #" #" ($ " $! #',' # $% "$# " $ " ($+ #',' # " # % # " " ! #"( " # " ',& * % " " - ! # " " - " %# % + # % + # - 3 - " ! #" '', % # % # " %"+ # $ $ . + &! /01233425013647466489:;/4<520=2>;12?20>1;;/4 @A8?=4>; 2>8 2B268 82;48 321148 9: ;/4 60><0325 4>0C6 0D05 +A8?4 2>8 C;C6 <<084>; 520=1 609A>25" !2529A62?0 E7C6 1/C6; F 609A>25GH" 0> C'',"144I0>?4>/2><4=4>;C7<C=34>12;0C> >4 /A52332 =4; B0;/ 2> 2<<084>; C> ' 2>8 8048 01 B074 2>8 </05864> 70548 <520= 34;0;0C> <520=0>? <C=34>12;0C> 1'"" /4 609A>25 <C>1084648 ;/4 4>;064 =2;460251 C> 64<C68 2>8 ?62>;48 1""B0;/0>;4641;2;;/462;4C7&J346 2>>A=76C=;/482;4C734;0;0C>;0556425012;0C>??604D48 9:;/41208C6846"<520=2>;170548;/01233425 - 4 - 4268 26?A=4>;1 C7 9C;/ ;/4 326;041 2>8 346A148;/4=2;4602512D2052954C>64<C68 /4=20><C>;4>;0C>1C7;/4<520=2>;1264;/2; ;/4 84<42148 B21 BC6I0>? 21 2?60<A5;A625 <CC504 2>8 426>0>? 1" 346 =C>;/" 9A; ;/4 609A>25 B0;/CA; 2>: 92101 ;2I4> ;/4 12=4 2; 1," 346 =C>;/ 2>8 2B26848 =42?64 <C=34>12;0C> 2>8 466C>4CA15: 2B26848 1" 7C6 5C11 C7 <C>1C6;0A= ; 01 7A6;/46 1;2;48 ;/2;;/4 609A>25466480>>C;2880>?J;CB26817A;A64 36C134<;1" ;/4647C64" ;/4: 362: 7C6 4>/2><4=4>; C7 ;/4 <C=34>12;0C>B0;/0>;4641;2;;/462;4C7J3462>>A= ' 426>48 <CA>145 7C6 6413C>84>; C K >1A62><4 C=32>: <C>;4>848 ;/2; /4 011A48 >C;0<4 ;C 6413C>84>; C CB>46 C7 ;/4 D4/0<54" 9A; 6413C>84>; C808>C;;A6>A32>8;/A1"/4801</26?48;/49A684>" ;/4647C64" >1A62><4 C=32>: =2: 94 4LC>462;48 76C= 32:0>?;/4<C=34>12;0C> - 5 - & /4 609A>25C9146D48;/2;;/464B21>C60D0>? 0<4>14;C;/4860D46C7;/4C774>80>?D4/0<542>8/4B21 </26?41/44;48 21 346 L 7C6 ;/4 C774><4 3A>01/2954 A>846 4<;0C> 6428 B0;/ , C7 <; ; B21 251C C9146D48 9: ;/4 609A>25 ;/2; ;/4 >1A62><4 C=32>: CA?/; ;C /2D4 C9;20>48 46;070<2;4 76C= ;/4 @A60180<;0C>25 62>13C6;770<46"9A;;/4:/2D4>C;36C8A<482>:64<C681 ; B21 1;2;48 ;/2; 0; 01 7C6 ;/4 >1A646 ;C 36CD4 ;/2; ;/4 860D46C7;/4C774>80>?D4/0<54/28>CD250860D0>?0<4>14 2>8;/49A684>641;1A3C>;/4= /4 <CA>145 7C6 ;/4 2334552>;1 645048 A3C> 84<010C> C7 C>G954 A364=4 CA6; 0> ;/4 <214 C7 " 321148 0> " 0> B/0</ 0; B21 /458 ;/2; 07 ;/4 860D46 C7 ;/4 C774>80>? D4/0<54 B21 >C; /2D0>? 60D0>? D4/0<54 B21 >C; /2D0>? 60D0>? 0<4>14" ;/4 >1A62><4 C=32>: 01 ;C 94 8064<;48 ;C 32: ;/4 <C=34>12;0C> 2>8 B0;/ 50946;: ;C ;/4 C=32>: ;C 64<CD46 ;/4 12=4 76C= ;/4 CB>46860D46 C7 ;/4 D4/0<54 > D04B C7 29CD4 801<A110C>" 7C55CB0>? ;/4 - 6 - 84<010C> C7;/434L CA6;";/01CA6; 70>810; 6421C>2954 ;CC68467C632:2>864<CD46;C;/4>1A62><4C=32>: , /CA?/ 0; B21 1;2;48 ;/2; ;/4 84<42148 B21 426>0>? 1" 346 =C>;/" >C 8C<A=4>; 01 36C8A<48 ;C36CD4;/412=4>;/42914><4C736CC7C70><C=4"21 346 ;/4 ?A08450>41 011A48 9: ;/4 !26>2;2I2 ;2;4 4?25 46D0<41A;/C60;:";/01CA6;70>810;@A1;2>86421C>2954 ;C ;2I4 ;/4 >C;0C>25 0><C=4 C7 ;/4 84<42148 2; 1"'346=C>;/7C6;/42<<084>;C7;/4:426" 0>1;428C7 1,"1;/484<42148B212?48':4261 2;;/4;0=4C72<<084>;2>8;/A1";/4=A5;03504623350489: ;/4 609A>252;F&G01@A1;2>836C346 1 <C>;4>848 9: ;/4 5426>48 <CA>145 7C6 ;/4 <520=2>;1"0>D04BC7;/4360><0325C752B52088CB>9:;/4 34L CA6; 0> ;/4 <214 C7 ! !"#$!% & " $!' ( !& ($"" 10><4 ;/484<42148 B21 2?48 ' :4261 2; ;/4 ;0=4 C7 2<<084>;" J 7A;A64 1 2017 ACJ 2700 SC - 7 - 36C134<;1 01 ;C 94 28848 <<C680>?5:" J C7 1"'<C=41;C 1"2>8;/A1";C;250><C=4C7 ;/484<42148<C=41;C 1"'A;C7;/012=CA>;"07 ;/ 01 848A<;48 ;CB2681 ;/4 3461C>25 4L34>141 C7 ;/4 84<42148" ;/4 <520=2>;1 264 4>;0;548 7C6 ;/ C7 ;/4 0><C=4 /A1" ;/4 5C11 C7 8434>84><: <C=41 ;C$ 1"'LL&LM 1"&&" /4 609A>252B26848C>5: 1"7C65C11 C7 <C>1C6;0A= ;C ;/4 <520=2>;1" B/0</ 01 >C; @A1; 2>8 36C3462>8;/01CA6;2B2681 1";C<520=2>;C 7C6 5C11 C7 13CA125 <C>1C6;0A= 2>8 1" 42</ ;C <520=2>;C1;C'7C65C11C73264>;25<C>1C6;0A="0>;C;25 1"" /4 609A>25/2160?/;5:2B268482>2=CA>;C7 1" A>846 ;/4 <C>D4>;0C>25 /4281 21 346 ;/4 <0;2;0C>0>;/4<214C7$!' ( 1 /458 9: ;/4 34L CA6; 0> ;/4 <214 C7 $!' (64746648"J01;C9428848;C;/4 - 8 - 2=CA>;2B268487C65C11C7<C>1C6;0A=2>8<C>D4>;0C>25 4><4" ;/4 <520=2>;1 264 4>;0;548 7C6 J C> 1""7C6 4D46:;/644:4261" B/0</ B055942 1A= C7 1&" <<C680>?5:";/4<520=2>;12644>;0;5487C6;C;25 <C=34>12;0C>C7 1""212?20>1; 1"" 2B268489:;/4 609A>25"21A>846$ 4281 B2689:;/4 609A>25 B2689:;/01 CA6; C11 C7 8434>84><: 1"'" 1"&&" C11 C7 <C>1C6;0A= 1" 1"" 62>13C6;2;0C>" 7A>46252>85C11 C741;2;4 1" 1" J 41<252;0C> C> ;C;25 5C11 C7 <C>1C6;0A= 2>8 <C>D4>;0C>25 /4281 1&" C;25 1"" 1"" /464B055944>/2><4=4>;C7 1"" - 9 - 413C>84>;C/21>C;843C10;482>:2=CA>; 947C64;/4 609A>254><4"6413C>84>;CK>1A62><4 C=32>: 01 8064<;48 ;C 843C10; 1"" B0;/ 0>;4641; 2; &J 346 2>>A= 76C= ;/4 82;4 C7 843C10; ;055 64250N2;0C>" 2; ;/4 7061; 0>1;2><4 2>8 ;C 64<CD46 ;/4 12=4 76C=6413C>84>;C ' C6;/427C6412086421C>1";/47C55CB0>?$ ! 0 /423342501)& 00 /4 2334552>;1 264 4>;0;548 7C6 <C=34>12;0C>C7 1""B0;/0>;4641;2; &J 346 2>>A= 76C= ;/4 82;4 C7 34;0;0C> ;055 64250N2;0C> 0> 2880;0C> ;C B/2; /21 944> 2B268489:;/4 609A>25 000 413C>84>; C K >1A62><4 C=32>: 01 8064<;48 ;C 843C10; ;/4 <C=34>12;0C> 2=CA>; B0;/0> 7CA6 B44I1 76C= ;/482;4C7;/01@A8?=4>; - 10 - 0D 0946;: 01 64146D48 ;C ;/4 >1A62><4 C=32>:;C64<CD46;/412=476C=6413C>84>; C D > 1A</ 843C10;" 34;0;0C>46<520=2>; C1 ;C ' 264 4>;0;548 7C6 2> 233C6;0C>=4>; 1"" 42</ 2>8 ;/4 1208 2=CA>; 01 ;C 94I43;0> ;055;/4:2;;20>2?4C7=2@C60;: 1; 34;0;0C>46B074 01 346=0;;48 ;C B0;/862B 9252><42=CA>;25C>?B0;/0>;4641;2<<6A48C> 0; )*+ ,'""!- &! 01;C$5C$ $ +