Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92518 (KAR)
SMT NANDINI v. SMT SHANTHA BAI
CRL.P/200759/2025 · 2025-11-10
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92518 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92518 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
"
&'( &)*+ (&** ,
! ! "
" #$ %
&
'
#
()
"
* "
(
)
"
" #$ % & ! '
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
" # + &
' " + &'
*"
$&
$$$' +
!" !+ " +
++
" #,#
#,
+
+
"
-!"
"
&
-!"
"' ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 8/03/5;3 <27=3/>20 46 =;;?0284022@/5AB?=0./5A463.21<4;228/5A01258/5A /5 4$ <2A/032<28 64< 3.2 46625;20 1?5/0.=972 ?582< 2;3/450 #,# <2=8 C/3. 2;3/45 #, 46
58/=525=7482 D$
.2 <201458253 482 6=;34 ;4E17=/5=53 ;7=/E/5A 34 92 3.2 72A=77: C28828 C/62 46 =;;?028 4 .=0 6/728 3.2 1<20253 1</>=32 ;4E17=/53 =772A/5A 3.=3 =;;?028 4 8?</5A 3.2 0?90/0325;2 46 .2< >=7/8
- 3 -
E=<</=A2 .=0 ;453<=;328 = 02;458 E=<</=A2 45 $$$ .2 0=/8 =;3 =;;4<8/5A 34 3.2 ;4E17=/5=53 ;=E234.2<@54C728A2?145543/;/5A3.21.434A<=1.0=58 ?18=3201403289:=;;?028445./0.=301103=3?0 C./;. 0?AA20328 3.=3 .2 .=8 0472E5/F28 =543.2< E=<</=A2
.2 72=<528 ;4?5027 =112=</5A 64< 3.2 123/3/452<0 C.4 =<2 3.2 <27=3/>20 46 =;;?028 4 >2.2E2537: ;45325828 3.=3 2>25 /6 3.2 =772A=3/450 /5 3.2 1</>=32;4E17=/53=583.20C4<503=32E253=<2=;;21328/5 3.2/< 253/<23: 3.2 0=E2 84 543 8/0;7402 =5: 012;/6/; 4< 3=5A/9724>2<3=;3453.21=<3463.21<20253123/3/452<034 =33<=;33.2/5A<28/2530462;3/45#,#463.2 58/=525=7 482 D$ 3 /0 =<A?28 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452<0 .=>2 9225 =<<=:28 =0 =;;?028 E2<27: 45 3.2 9=0/0 46 3.2/< <27=3/450./1 C/3. =;;?028 4 C/3.4?3 =5: E=32</=7 1=<3/;?7=<0 /58/;=3/5A 3.=3 3.2: .=8 2/3.2< 6=;/7/3=328 1=<3/;/1=328/54<=9233283.2=772A2802;458E=<</=A2
- 4 -
# 5 3.2 43.2< .=58 72=<528 ;4?5027 =112=</5A 64< <201458253 4 04?A.3 34 G?03/6: 3.2 ;453/5?=3/45 46 1<4;228/5A0 9: 0?9E/33/5A 3.=3 3.2<2 /0 04E2 E=32</=7 /5 3.2;4E17=/53341<4;228=A=/5033.202123/3/452<0
4C2>2<?145;74020;<?3/5:463.2;4E17=/53 0C4<5 03=32E253 =58 =;;4E1=5:/5A 84;?E2530 3./0 4?<3 6/580 3.=3 3.2<2 /0 = ;4E17232 =9025;2 46 =5:
012;/6/; =772A=3/45 4< E=32</=7 3.=3 C4?78 /58/;=32 =5: <472 17=:28 9: 3.2 123/3/452<0 /5 3.2 =772A28 02;458E=<</=A2.2E=32</=7045<2;4<82>25/63=@25=3 6=;2>=7?2845438/0;7402=5:=;3;4503/3?3/5A=923E253 /503/A=3/45 4< 1=<3/;/1=3/45 04 =0 34 =33<=;3 ;?71=9/7/3: ?582<2;3/45#,#<2=8C/3.2;3/45#,46
D 264<2 827>/5A 6?<3.2< 3./0 4?<3 822E0 /3 52;200=<: 34 2H3<=;3 1=<=A<=1.0 34 $ 46 3.2 1</>=32 ;4E17=/53 C./;. =<2 <27/28 ?145 9: 3.2 ;4E17=/5=53 34 /E17/;=323.2123/3/452<0
! "
- 5 -
!" !" # " " $ " !" $!" ! ! $!" %"
" $ " &""" '()" *) &)) + *
"" """ !" ! %! " " ! ") " %! % , ! "
" " & " $ " - #. , ! * +." //01.%/23- " $ 45$ 67- -! , ! "! " 2 )% &%!
)% " ! "!$" $ % & & %! " !% " " $ "" " &&8 !" # %& 9
!" ""
" $
%! - 6 -
!" "" % ! % " " " % !" # & !" "" % ! )% " " :" $ % & %! " $ "& &&8 &% &;
/@2C/02 /3 /0 =704 =11<41</=32 34 2H3<=;3 1=<=A<=1. 4 46 3.2 82140/3/45 46 <201458253 482 6=;34 ;4E17=/5=53 <2;4<828 45 $$$ C.2<2/5 0.2 <2/32<=3203.2=772A=3/450/53.2;4E17=/53
08
!" #! $% &
'()
*
+ 8 , -./
01
2. *3
4*5 &6 <7
8
9:
&#!9() 8;:2
<
= 7
.# 8
> . "
? @(&A
0 ()<!BCB8
D(
8() ()
6
E 8 * :2 *E)
FG
4 # H(()
- 7 -
$
7B
8 5&.!I2
7 G J
K
5 = E23/;?74?0 <2=8/5A 46 943. 3.2 1</>=32 ;4E17=/53 =58 3.2 0C4<503=32E253 3./04?<3 6/580 3.=3 3.2<2 =<2 54 012;/6/; =772A=3/450 34 /58/;=32 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452<0C2<21<20253=33.23/E2463.2=772A2802;458 E=<</=A24<3.=33.2:.=8/5=5:E=552<=/828/503/A=328 4<;4501/<28C/3.=;;?028434;453<=;30?;.E=<</=A2 .2457:9=0/064</5/3/=3/45461<4;228/5A0=112=<03492 3.2 .=3011 03=3?0 46 =;;?028 4 C./;. =772A287:
<2>2=728 ./0 <2E=<</=A2 2<2 <27=3/450./1 C/3. 3.2 1</5;/1=7 =;;?028 4< 1=00/>2 @54C728A2 46 0?;.
E=<</=A2 ;=55439:/302766=0325;</E/5=77/=9/7/3:?582<2;3/45#,#
,
3 /0 = C2770233728 1<4140/3/45 46 7=C 3.=3 /5 ;=020=772A/5A9/A=E:3.246625;2?582<2;3/45#,#
/012<045=7/55=3?<2=583.27/=9/7/3:1</E=</7:=33=;.2034 3.2 12<045 C.4 ;453<=;30 = 02;458 E=<</=A2 8?</5A 3.2 0?90/0325;246=>=7/86/<03E=<</=A2.2?1<2E24?<3/5
- 8 -
.=0 ;=32A4</;=77: .278 3.=3 >=A?2 =584E5/9?0=772A=3/450=A=/5036=E/7:E2E92<0C/3.4?3 012;/6/; E=32</=7 1=<3/;?7=<0 4< 4>2<3 =;30 ;=5543 0?03=/5 1<402;?3/45 ?582< 2;3/45 #,#
"57200 3.2<2 /0 3=5A/972 2>/825;2 0.4C/5A 3.=3 3.2 <27=3/>20 =;3/>27:
1=<3/;/1=328 /5 6=;/7/3=328 4< =923328 3.2 12<64<E=5;2 46 3.202;458E=<</=A23.2:;=5543921<402;?3289:>/<3?2 46E2<26=E/7/=7=004;/=3/45
$
5 3.2 1<20253 ;=02 52/3.2< 3.2 ;4E17=/53 54< 3.20C4<503=32E2538/0;74020=5:E=32</=7/58/;=3/5A3.2 123/3/452<0I 1<2025;2 =3 3.2 =772A28 ;2<2E45: 3.2/< /5>47>2E253 /5 =<<=5A/5A 3.2 E=<</=A2 4< =5: =;3 46 /503/A=3/45 .2 =772A=3/450 =<2 C.477: A252<=7 =58 92<263 46 1=<3/;?7=<0 .2<264<2 3.2 ;453/5?=3/45 46 ;</E/5=7 1<4;228/5A0=A=/5033.202123/3/452<0C4?78=E4?5334=5 =9?02461<4;200467=C=03.2<2/054<2=045=9721<4012;3 46;45>/;3/452>25/63.21<402;?3/45/0=774C28341<4;228
- 9 -
+4< 3.2 64<2A4/5A <2=0450 3./0 4?<3 1<4;2280 341=003.264774C/5A
&/' .2</E/5=723/3/45/0=774C28 &//' .2 253/<2 1<4;228/5A0 /5 4$ &=</0/5A4?3464$$$'1258/5A9264<2 3.2 />/7 !?8A2 =58 !+ 2>=8?<A= 64< 3.2 46625;21?5/0.=972?582<2;3/45#,#<2=8C/3. 2;3/45#,463.2 58/=525=7482 D$=<2 .2<29: B?=0.28 /5046=< =0 3.2: <27=32 34 3.2 1<20253123/3/452<0 &///' 77 1258/5A /532<74;?34<: =117/;=3/450 /6 =5: 03=588/01402846
-+ &""* %
/03474D