Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92509 (KAR)
VIJAYAKUMAR DESHMUKH v. THE COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE
WP/203474/2025 · 2025-11-10
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92509 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92509 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"#!$%&
' &("&"&
)*"+
!"
#
" $
! %& % '(
) *
" & +
)
, &
"
"
-"
! "
® Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
%
,$
+
"
%
*%
%" #$ + "
" ,
"
#& $ . #& $ #& $ +
#,$%/ ++0#$
+
%
"
%
"
+
1
! #" 1 $
"234345627 89:4;46< 35 =2 >56 5? 562 :994@:7AB6
2CCD 2>E;B@E 4> =2?572 3E4> 85B73 >22@46< ?5995F46< 72942?>
!" # $%&'! (
$ ) *
+%
, $* - . - 3 -
E2 8:>2 5? 3E2 G234345627 4> 3E:3 E4> ?:3E27 :994@:7AB6 2CCD2>E;B@EF:>E59C46<: 9482682:3 E433:GB7
3:3456 5:C 557 5, ?57 3E2 D2:7 ///E2>:4C9482682F:>46?5782?57562D2:7B2 35 499E2:93E :6C ?46:684:9 856>37:463> ?:3E27 5? 3E2 G234345627 85B9C 6243E27 7262F 3E2 9482682 657 856346B2 3E2=B>462>> E:3 56 / ?:3E27 5? 3E2 G234345627G:>>2C:F:DCB235E2:73:33:8@
, E272:?327 G234345627 ;:C2 72G72>263:3456> 56 :6C . 35 72>G56C263 5 >22@46< 7262F:9 5? 9482682 ?75; /// 35 . 6 327;> 5? B92 * 5? 3E2 :76:3:@: H84>2 #2627:9 56C434565?482682>$ B92>/*IE27246:?32772?2772C35 :>3E2J B92>/*K?57=72L43DM:9>5>5B<E3G27;4>>45635 >E4?3 3E2 958:3456 5? 3E2 9482682 CB2 35 656:L:49:=4943D 5? 3E2574<46:9G72;4>2>2<:L2D23:653E2772G72>263:3456 56 3572>G56C2635,F43E3E2>:;272NB2>3 4682 3E272 F:> 65 72>G56>2 G234345627 ;:C2 :6 :GG948:3456B6C27 4<E3356?57;:34568356
- 4 -
2>G56C2635,=D:85;;B648:3456C:32C 4>>B2C 46?57;:3456 4634;:346< 3E:3 56 L274?48:3456 65 72857C> 72<:7C46< 4>>B:682 5? 9482682 F272 ?5B6C 5F2L27 43 F:> 5=>27L2C 3E:3 3E272 F272 72?272682 35 37:6>:83456> ;:C2 ?57 3E2 D2:7 //// > >B8E 3E2 G234345627 4> =2?572 3E4> 5B73 >22@46< C47283456 :> 6532C :=5L2
. 2:762C 85B6>29 :GG2:746< ?57 3E2 G234345627 72?27746< 35 B92 * 5? 3E2 B92> /* L2E2;2639D >B=;43>3E:33E2G234345627=246<3E2>565?3E2C282:>2C 9482682E59C274>2634392C?5737:6>?275?3E2948268246E4> 6:;22:9>572?27>35 B925?3E2:76:3:@:#
:925? 6C4:6 :6C %5724<6 4NB57>$ B92> / IE27246:?327 72?2772C35:>J B92>/K?57=72L43DM:6C>B=;43>3E:3 3E2 G234345627 46 327;> 5? B= B92 #,$ 5? B92 5? B92>/4>2634392C?577262F:9=DG:D;2635?O5? 3E2?22G72>874=2CB6C27 B92:6C3E2G2343456274>72:CD :6C F49946< 35 G:D >B8E ?22> :6C >22@> ?57 C47283456 35 72>G56C263:B3E574342>35856>4C27E4>:GG948:3456
- 5 -
/ 92:762C CC43456:9 5L276;263 CL58:32 >B=;43> 3E:3 46 3E2 ?47>3 46>3:682 3E272 :72 65 72857C> FE23E27 57 653 3E2 ?:3E27 5? 3E2 G234345627 E:C =226 4>>B2C F43E : 9482682 :> 89:4;2C 2 >B=;43> ;272 46?57;:3456 46 72>G56>2 35 3E2 74<E3 35 46?57;:3456 :GG948:34565??:3E275?3E2G234345627E:L46<37:6>:832C?57 : =742? G2745C 8:6653 =2 3E2 <75B6C 35 G72>B;2 3E2 2H4>32682 5? 9482682 %B73E27 E2 >B=;4332C 3E272 4> 65 G75L4>456 ?57 : 92<:9 72G72>263:34L2 35 >22@ 7262F:9 5? : 9482682:6C3E2637:6>?272682>22@>?57C4>;4>>:95?3E2 G2343456
2:7C"27B>2C3E272857C>
*
"234345627E:> G75CB82C : GE53585GD 5?
9482682 46 %57; GB7G5732C 35 E:L2 =226 4>>B2C =D 3E2 72>G56C263
:B3E574342> E2 :B3E2634843D 5? >:4C C58B;263 4> D23 35 =2 2>3:=94>E2C G:7348B9:79D 46 L42F 5? 3E2 72>G56>2 4>>B2C 35 3E2 :GG948:3456 ?492C =D 3E2 G234345627 B6C27 4<E3 35 6?57;:3456 83 :> G75CB82C :3
- 6 -
662HB72% E2 72>G56>2 35 3E2 72NB2>3 ;:C2 B6C27
4<E3356?57;:3456834>:>B6C27
! " ! #$%&
'!(%&)! * ++,-++ ./01- 2 345 6%5 ' !7 8 9
./01-2 345 : ) ;1'<=3 6%5'8>!?/
!? @! !A' ! B
! 01 ;1'<=3" .@>1 C" ! #$%&
'!(%&)! * D./01-23453' !7 8 9 E:FG!?4/ B ><=3" !!=
H" !F !7 * <= G! I4 ,+J,J++,
,KJ,KJ++, I+L+-+,MM )! 4
N2J,2J++, * !@ !FJ 7O!FP
<%<# Q ! !@ Q D >
47/ I' <'7.M *<@ B ><= @ " ! #$%&
'!(%&C)! !< " G#
! 9!; ! #$ %& 9!; N )! 4
R 2J,SJ2,22
!F P Q
7C <=@ !< 8% !G P $C 34 ' !7 ! T!!!<= '<=3 @7 !<$! P
!F P U Q
7C
C ! !7 !F P U P45VC U GE:< 7! !@ O BT
!A' @. <=E:FG7!/'<=3<'7./ )!?<= *@ %. )
!? ;1'<= O B< E:F )!?40
!A'!<8%/ 2 @!!A'P!45/ ++,-++ <W
- 7 -
EB> :> 74<E39D G54632C 5B3 =D 92:762C :GG2:746< ?57 3E2 72>G56C263 :B3E574342> :3 3E2 ?47>3 46>3:682G2343456274>653:=9235G75L23E2L27D4>>B:682 5?9482682463E26:;25?E4>?:3E27>>B8E856>4C27:3456 5? E4> :GG948:3456 ?57 7262F:9 5? : 656 2H4>346< 9482682 F5B9C653:74>2
/ 2 3E:3 :> 43 4> 92:762C 85B6>29 ?57 3E2 G234345627 72942C BG56 B92 * 5? B92> /* FE48E 72:C>:>B6C27
0) 1
% %
2
* -++ +* $* , %
1 %
"-++2 %
+*$2 %1. G27B>:9 5? 3E2 :?572>:4C G75L4>456 46C48:32> 3E:3 3E5B<E 37:6>?27 5? 3E2 9482682 4> G27;4>>4=92 46 3E2 2L2635?C2:3E5?3E2E59C2746?:L5B75?E4>92<:9E247>43 G72>BGG5>2>2H4>326825?:9482682:33E234;25?C2:3E5? 3E29482682E59C2763E246>3:638:>22L26:8857C46<35 3E2 G234345627 3E2 :992<2C 9482682 F:> 4>>B2C 46 3E2 D2:7
- 8 -
//569D?57:G2745C5?562D2:7:6C3E2>:;2E:>653 =2262H326C2C3E272:?327
262F:9 5? 9482682 4> 85632;G9:32C B6C27 B92 5?3E2 B92>/FE48E72:C>:>B6C27
'
" -++
* -++2
+* $2 +* + + ,
%
$#!
,
, 3+-43+-4 2 % ++, %+ 5*2 '
"1* $+
+ $% * % * , 6
/1
" -++
* -++2 +* $2 +*
* +%
%
%+ 2% %
%% % +7,
,
% % 5*2 &&&+*$
%
" -++
* -++2
+*$
*+ %8%% * %
%
$ # ! %
% , 2 %
%+ ,
*% 6
/1
,
$
*-++
"
- 9 -
-++2 +*$
+$%,
9 % # 2 % , % 7%%. B=7B92 # $ 5? B92 5? B92> / 85632;G9:32> ?4946< 5? :6 :GG948:3456 ?57 7262F:9 562 ;563E =2?572 3E2 2HG47D 5? 3E2 9482682 :972:CD <7:632C 5F2L27 F43E : C4>8723456:7D G5F27 L2>32C F43E 3E2 H84>25;;4>>45627573E22GB3D5;;4>>45627:>3E2 8:>2 ;:D =2 35 856C562 3E2 C29:D
B=7B92 #,$ 5? B925? B92>/:>6532C:=5L2:9>5G75L4C2>?57 7262F:9 5? 3E2 9482682 4>>B2C G7457 35 */// 56 G:D;2635?O5?3E2G72>874=2C?22?573E2GB7G5>25? ;:463:4646<856346B43D5?3E29482682>
, 2:762C85B6>29?573E2G234345627E2:L49D72942> BG56>B= B92#,$5? B925? B92>/35856326C 3E:3>46823E29482682463E246>3:638:>2F:>4>>B2CG7457 35 /// 8:>2 5? 3E2 G234345627 8:6 =2 856>4C272C 56 G:D;2635?O5?3E2G72>874=2C?22
- 10 -
. :4C >B=;4>>456 8:6653 =2 85B6326:682C 46:>;B8E:>G75L4>535>B=7B92#,$5? B925? B92> / 46C48:32> >B8E 7262F:9 >E:99 26>B72 3E:3 3E2 353:9 6B;=27 5? 9482682> <7:632C 57 7262F2C C5 653 2H822C NB53:?4H2C46 B92 ?573E2<7:635?2:8E94826825?:6 :72:
B92 * 5? B92> /* :6C B92 5? B92> / :> 6532C :=5L2 5G27:32 46 : 85;G92329D C4??27263 C5;:465G75L4>4565?9:F4>=75B<E3353E26534825?3E4> 5B73 =D 3E2 G234345627 26343946< E4; 35 >22@ 7262F:9 5? 9482682 FE48E 4> 2HG472CCB746<3E2 94?234;2 5? 3E29482682 E59C27 :6C ?57 37:6>?27 3E272:?327 BG56 E4> C2;4>2 B6C27
B92*5? B92>/*
2:762C85B6>29?573E2G234345627?:479D>B=;43> 3E:3 3E272 4> 65 >B8E G75L4>456 G75L4C2C 5F2L27 E2 46>4>3> B92 * 5? B92> /* :6C B92 5? B92> / >E5B9C =2 72:C 35<23E27 E4> 5B73 4> B6:=92 35 :882G3 3E2 >:4C >B=;4>>456 262F:9 5? 9482682 B6C27
B92 E:> 35 =2 >374839D B6C27 3E2 G75L4>456> 85632;G9:32C 3E27246 FE48E 4> :972:CD 2H37:832C
- 11 -
E27246:=5L2C;4332C9D65>B8E7262F:9E:>3:@26G9:82 CB746< 3E2 94?234;2 5? :994@:7AB6 2CCD L26 4? 43 4> :>>B;2C3E:3>B8E:9482682E:C=2264>>B2C46?:L5B75? :994@:7AB6 2CCD3E246?57;:3456G75L4C2CB6C27 4<E335 6?57;:345683:>2H37:832CE27246:=5L2C52>653>BGG573 3E289:4;5?3E2G2343456275?E4>?:3E27E:L46<=2264>>B2C F43E 9482682 7:6>?27 5? 9482682 B6C27 B92 * G72>BGG5>2>2H4>326825?:L:94C9482682
E2557C46:32268E5?3E4>5B73463E28:>2 5?
L> 72G5732C 46 !! " ## FE492 C2:946< F43E 3E2 C2;:6C 653482 4>>B2C =D 3E2 :B3E574342> 35 C2G5>43 3E2 263472 :772:7> 5? 9482682 ?22 ?57 3E2 GB7G5>2 5? 7262F:9 5? 9482682 B6C27 >B= B92 #,$ 5? B92 5? B92> / :3 G:7:<7:GE * E:>E29C:>B6C27 : * % # % #
% + $ +
$*
$ % + % # ! % # )
2 1* ,
$ 2 +
%
$ , 2 %
2 9 % +7, %
+ $% * %
# % # 1,
- 12 -
% * + * % 1
+%
# 1%
+* $ +
* )
, %% 2 #
1 %
+
%%* ;
2 1$*
<1+ $ %+
%
* % =
1 $ * $2 $ % , % 2
9 % %*% *: ! )
1 % +
2
+ $*
,
% %
$ $,$
* EB>2L26?57>22@46<7262F:95?9482682B6C27 >B= B92#,$5? B925? B92>/3E2G234345627E:> 352>3:=94>E3E:33E29482682F:>CB9D7262F2C?57G72L45B> D2:7>FE48E4>6533E28:>256E:6C
653E27 :>G283 5? 3E2 ;:3327 4> 3E:3 3E2 G234345627 E:> :GG75:8E2C 3E4> 5B73 :?327 9:G>2 5? , D2:7> E2 ?:3E27 5? 3E2 G234345627 E:> 3:@26 65 >32G> CB746<E4>94?234;2>22@46<7262F:95?94826823E5B<EE24> >3:32C 35 E:L2 G:>>2C :F:D 56 /
B8E :6 4657C46:32C29:D563E2G:735?3E2G23434562757E4>?:3E27 8:6653 =2 : <75B6C
B=7B92 # $ 5? B92 5? B92> / 72?2772C 35 :=5L2 72NB472> 7262F:9 :GG948:3456 =2
- 13 -
;:C2 F43E46 562 ;563E =2?572 2HG47D 5? 9482682 :972:CD <7:632C
:4C G2745C 5? 94;43:3456 8:6653 =2 ;:C2 46:GG948:=92 FE492 856>4C2746< 3E2 :GG948:3456 B6C27 >B=
B92#,$5? B925? B92>/6:6D8:>2653:?327 9:G>25?,D2:7>:>463E28:>2:3E:6C
/ 5<75B6C>;:C25B3243E27563E2?:83>5756 3E2 9:F 8857C46<9D G2343456 4> $ 53F43E>3:6C46<3E2C4>;4>>:95?3E2G2343456G2343456274> 2634392C 35 >22@ 4>>B:682 5? ?72>E 9482682 46 :8857C:682 F43E9:F
",- )&"&+ (! + 4>35
95
"