- 1 - !"# ## $ % & ! " # $ % ! &!! %% ! % %% '%% (%% ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %%%%$ $ * %+ +## !+ "+ $ $ +!!! +!! % % % $, * %+ +"## "+" () % +!" * % ** * %%%% +! ' % ($ *) * * "() * * %% % % * $ % $ * ## # % % % * * $ & - 3 - %% * $ , , - $ % " ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 3<8/==./><8:<>.1/4/<78223./?/019:23.0<;57/> <7 9#! # =/88.1 ;@ 23. .7<90 <A<> $514. /71 /2/8/A/B/>@/7(:9083902C23.0<;57/>D) 7./B836/76.2?<23/7/EE<1.7297## /711<.1<8 <:.E3<>10.7/7123.6923.09:23.E>/<6/72 :<>.1/E>/<6=.2<2<97E>/6<74E96=.78/2<979:8! + 3. 0<;57/> /:2.0 E978<1.0<74 .72<0. 6/2.0</> 97 0.E901 40/72.18 +/223.0/2.9:#F=.0/7756:09623. 1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>0./><G/2<97 440<.A.1;@23.8/<1901.023<8/==./><8=0.:.00.1 <7 ?3<E3 <2 <8 E972.71.1 23/2 23. /==.>>/72 ?/8 ./07<74 8 + =.0 69723 ;52 23. 0<;57/> 3/8 2/B.7 23. 8/6. 8"! +=.0697232<8:5023.0E972.71.123/223.>9889: E978902<56 40/72.1 <8 97 >9?.0 8<1. /71 23. <72.0.82 <8 29 ;. 40/72.1/223.0/2.9: F=.0/7756 - 4 - ! 39543 <2 <8 82/2.1 23/2 >/B836/7 ?/8 /4.1 ! @./08?90B<74/8/%922.0/71./07<748 +=.069723 3.3/8792:<>.1/7@<7E96.=099:.6.2?<23/7/EE<1.7297 ##8=.023.45<1.><7.89:23./07/2/B/2/2..4/> .0A<E.8 52390<2@ 3<8 792<97/> <7E96. <8 29 ;. 2/B.7 /8 8"! + =.0 69723 ?3.0.<7 23. 0<;57/> 3/8 2/B.7 23. 8/6. 0<432>@ /71 23. 65>2<=><.0 <8 29 ;. 2/B.7 /8 C#D . <8 .72<2>.1 :90 F 29?/018 :5250. =098=.E28 /8 =.0 23. E<2/2<97 0.=902.1 <7 /71 23 <8 29 ;. 1.15E2.1 29?/018 3<8 =.0897/> .H=.78.8 EE901<74>@23.>9889:1.=.71.7E@E96.829, I("!JF)HH#H 23KL"# + # *<082/==.>>/72<8.72<2>.1:908 +571.023. 3./1>9889:E978902<56/==.>>/729829!/0..72<2>.1:90/7 /69572 9: 8 + ./E3 29?/018=/0.72/> E978902<56 /71 /==.>>/72 9# <8 .72<2>.1 :90 8 + 29?/018 :<></> E978902<56 /71 23.@ /0. />89 .72<2>.1 :90 /7 /69572 9: 8 +571.023.E97A.72<97/>3./18 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 5 - " 7 />> 23. 292/> E96=.78/2<97 E96.8 29 8! +?<23<72.0.82/2#F=.0/7756:09623.1/2.9: =.2<2<972<>>0./><G/2<97 3. E96=.78/2<97 /?/01.1 ;@ 23. 0<;57/> <8 691<:<.1/8571.0, '()*+,-'.*(/0. ,1./ 9889:.=.71.7E@ 8 "# + 9889: 82/2. 8 ! + 9889:*57.0/> H=.78.8 8 ! + 988 9: E978902<56 /71 :<></> E978902<56(8H#) 8 # + * 23 EE901<74>@ 23. E>/<6/728 /0. .72<2>.1 :90 / 292/> E96=.78/2<979:8! +/8/4/<7828 +/71 .72<2>.1 :90 .73/7E.1 E96=.78/2<97 9: 8" + ?<23 <72.0.82/223.0/2.9:#F=.0/7756 723.0.85>223.:9>>9?<74901.0<8=/88.1, <) 3./==./><8 <<) 3. E>/<6/728 /0. .72<2>.1 :90 23. 292/> E96=.78/2<979:8! +?<23<72.0.82/2#F =.0/7756:09623.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>23.1/2.9: 0./><G/2<97 - 6 - <<<) .8=971.72 + 7850/7E. E96=/7@ 3/8 />0./1@ 1.=98<2.1 23. /69572 /?/01.1 ;@ 23. 0<;57/> 23.0.:90. 0.8=971.72 M 7850/7E. 96=/7@ <8 1<0.E2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. .73/7E.1 E96=.78/2<97 9: 8" + ?<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. 9: #F .N5/>>@?<23<769723:09623.1/2.9:23<8901.0 <A) 785E31.=98<2/==.>>/729/>97.<8=.06<22.1 29?<2310/?23./69572/>974?<23<72.0.82/EE05.1 97<2 *)3 $#% " <829,>9,