- 1 - !" #$% %% &'( ) !" #$# %&'&() ) #* " %#)%## *& " %&'&( " + (#(*)() ) ""$# " " (,,)()( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )()()# " " % )()()# (,,)()( % " ) )()& " - " . " / / 0 '$ 123 455647 23 82769 4:42;3< <16 4=4>9 ?8 <16 >2@A;47 2; ?(,,)()( 94<69 )()()) 543369 @B <16 992<2?;476;2?>2C27A9:64;9 474@A>4:28?>31?>< -<16>2@A;47. ) ;DA>69 E742F4;< 4:69 #' B64>3 F6< =2<1 4; 4EE296;< ?; ) ()(, 4;9 82769 4 E742F 56<2<2?; E742F2;: E?F56;34<2?;?83) ((((%16>2@A;4748<6>E?;3296>2;: 6;<2>66C296;E6?;>6E?>9:>4;<694;4F?A;<?83)&((((% =2<12;<6>63<4<<16>4<6?8*G56>4;;AF8>?F94<6?856<2<2?; <277>647234<2?; # ::>26C69 @B <16 3429 ?>96> <16 ;3A>4;E6 ?F54;B5>686>>69<1234556474;9F42;7BE?;<6;<69<14<<16 - 3 - E742F 56<2<2?; 23 82769 A;96> 6E<2?; *# ?8 <16 E< ; ) ()(, <16 E742F4;< =43 9>2C2;: 4<4 ;92E4 23<4 E4> @64>2;: >6:23<>4<2?; ?%#)%## 16; <16 E4> =43 2; 8>?;<?8?C<2:1E1??7 47H16947?>>B@64>2;:>6:23<>4<2?; ?%#)%'(*=43F?C2;:2;8>?;<?8<16E4>169>2C6>?8 <167?>>B3A996;7B4557269@>4H63434>63A7<<169>2C6>?8<16 E4> 943169 <16 7?>>B 4;9 3A3<42;69 2;DA>263 4;9 <16 4556774;< 3128<69 <? <16 1?352<47 1A3 <16 E742F4;< 143 82769 4; 45572E4<2?; A;96> 6E<2?; *# ?8 <16 E< 16 4EE296;< ?EEA>>69 ?;) ()(, 43 3AE1 <16 4F6;9F6;< 3A@3<2<A<69 E<#)?8 ?<?>612E763E<F6;9F6;<E<)(,8?>31?>< -<16E<.2;=12E1E145<6>266E<2?;&=2<16886E<8>?F (( )()) ?8 <16 E< 34B3 >6:4>92;: :>4;<2;: ?8 E?F56;34<2?; ?8 3&(((((% 2; E436 ?8 964<1 ?> 3)&((((%2;E436?8:>26C?A31A><4;92<23;?<45572E4@762; <123 E436 16 ?F5742;< " 4;9 E14>:6 3166< =43 82769 4:42;3<<16E742F4;<43<164EE296;<?EEA>>69?;7B9A6<?123 ;6:72:6;E6 4;9 <1A3 >6IA63<69 <16 E?A>< <? 36< 43296 <16 DA9:F6;<4;9>6IA63<698?>F?9282E4<2?;?8<16?>96> - 4 - ;?<16> E?;<6;<2?; >42369 @B <16 ;3A>4;E6 ?F54;B 23 <14< <16 9>2C6> 3<4<69 <14< 16 =43 64>;2;: 3 ((((% 56> F?;<1 43 3AE1 3E169A76 23 ;?< 45572E4@76 4;9<1656<2<2?;2<367823;?<F42;<42;4@76 & 64>9<164>:AF6;<3?8@?<132963 * 9F2<<697B<16E742F56<2<2?;2382769A;96>6E<2?; *#%?8<16 E<433AE1<16E742F4;<3;669;?<<?5>?C6 <14< <16 9>2C6> =43 >431 4;9 ;6:72:6;E6 2; 9>2C2;: 43 <16 4EE296;<?EEA>>69@BA36?8F?<?>C612E76 $ 3<1645572E4<2?;2382769A;96>6E<2?;*#?8<16 E< <16 2;E?F6 23 <? @6 <4H6; 43 56> 3E169A76 EE?>92;:7B <16 2;E?F6 ?8 <16 4556774;< E4; @6 E?;82;69 <? 3 ((((%56>4;;AF3<164556774;<=434:69#'B64>3 <16 FA7<25726> 23 <? @6 <4H6; 43 -*. 3 56> <16 ?A;9 6><282E4<6 <16 4556774;< 3A3<42;69 ?C6> 8>?;<47 #J) 3F477 ?C6> ;?36 4;9 @7A;< 2;DA>B ?8 768< 31?A796> 4>6 :>26C?A32;;4<A>66=43473?6J4F2;69<16?E<?>4;9<16 ?E<?> 233A69 9234@272<B E6><282E4<6 A;96> J, =16>62; 16 3<4<69 <14< <16>6 23 96C24<69 ;4347 365<AF @274<6>47 1B56><>?51B?8;4347<A>@2;4<634;9<16>623965>63369@>29:6 - 5 - ?8 <16 ;?36 4;9 <16>6 23 ?79 8>4E<A>6 ?8 ;4347 @?;6 96C24<69 ;4347365<AF1B56><>?51B?8<16;4347<A>@2;4<63169?E<?> 43363369<169234@272<B43*(G<?$(G<?<164886E<6954><4;9 <?<16=1?76@?9B9234@272<B4<&G<?)(G ' 6;E6 2;C26= ?8 <16 4@?C6 923EA332?; <123 ?A>< 82;932<>643?;4@76<?<4H6<169234@272<B43$(G4343363369@B <16?E<?>EE?>92;:7B#>9?8<1634F6E?F63<?)#G3 16F6<=2<14EE296;<2;<16B64>)(,123;4<2?;472;E?F623<? @6 <4H6; 43 3#)&(% 56> F?;<1 16>68?>6 <16 7?33 ?8 8A<A>664>;2;:E454E2<BE?F63<?/ 3 ((((%J*J)#GK3 $)((% , 16 4556774;< =43 1?352<472L69 8?> <1>66 94B3 ?;3296>2;:<16;4<A>6?82;DA>26356>2?9?81?352<472L4<2?;4;9 ?<16>>676C4;<84E<?>3<123?A><82;932<>643?;4@76<?:>4;<4; 4F?A;< ?8 3&(((% 8?> 542; 4;9 3A886>2;: 4;9 7?33 ?8 4F6;2<263 4;9 3&(((% 8?> <>4;35?><4<2?; 6J<>4 ;?A>231F6;<4;9F692E476J56;363 - 6 - ( ; 477 <16 <?<47 E?F56;34<2?; E?F63 <? 3,))((%=2<12;<6>63<4<<16>4<6?8*G56>4;;AF8>?F <1694<6?856<2<2?;<277>6472L4<2?; 16 4=4>9 543369 @B <16 >2@A;47 23 F?928269 43 A;96>/ *+,- ./0120 - ?33?88A<A>62;E?F6 $)((% )42;4;93A886>2;:4;97?33?84F6;2<263 &(((% #>4;35?><4<2?; 6J<>4 ;?A>231F6;< 4;9 F692E476J56;363 &(((% 1+3 " " 4 EE?>92;:7B <16 E742F4;< 23 6;<2<769 8?> 4 >69AE69 E?F56;34<2?; ?8 3$$)((% 43 4:42;3< 3)&((((% 4=4>969@B<16>2@A;47 ) ;<16>63A7<<168?77?=2;:?>96>23543369/ 2 1645564723 - 7 - 22 16E742F4;<236;<2<7698?>4<?<47E?F56;34<2?;?8 3$$)((% =2<1 2;<6>63< 4< <16 >4<6 ?8 *G 56> 4;;AF8>?F<1694<6?856<2<2?;<277>6472L4<2?; 222 635?;96;< % ;3A>4;E6 ?F54;B 23 92>6E<69 <? 965?32< 3$$)((% =2<1 2;<6>63< 4< <16 >4<6 ?8 *G=2<12;F?;<18>?F<1694<6?8<123?>96> 2C ; 3AE1 965?32< <16 4556774;< 23 56>F2<<69 <? =2<19>4= <16 6;<2>6 4F?A;< 47?;: =2<1 2;<6>63< 4EE>A69?;2< -,4 &%( $ 23< ?/7 ?/) /