Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92503 (KAR)
SHREE LAKSHMI DEVELOPERS v. SMT.MEERA D/O LATE BHEEMRAO AND ORS
RFA/200083/2016 · 2025-07-22
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92503 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92503 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$!$$$%&
#$!$
"" ' ("'')
'%
"" *' ("'')
'
%
!! "
#
$%
&%
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
& ! ''%%%
! ($&&
'
&% ! ! $ )
! &
$
$ ! %'*
&
! ! ! '
%**''%
- 3 -
)
! $
! +
!! ! $
! $
*
) '&
%'
! %$)
)! )! '
+
% ! ! '
- 4 -
**&%' )
'
' ! %$*
$
%,
! ! $
! ! %
! - . *$'*
&
)! ! '%
! - !! -
*$'*
! " ! /
! - 0
- '0
!! - /$0
-
&0 %/&#
- 5 -
-
!!-
*& - ! ! - !! !) &
%& ! )
%
& -
! -) +
*'
% ! ! ! '$
%**''%
!! "
#
$%
&%%
($$
%
&
- 6 -
! ''%%% ! ($&&
'
&% ! ! $
) ($$%
($$%
$
! &
($$%
&
$ ! %'*
($$&
! - 7 -
"! - 0
! - 0 !! - $/& %/'#
-
!!-
*& - ! , - ! ! ! !! ) &
%&! % - -
. ) -
! -
- -- !! !! ! -
-
- )
+
-
!! - )
$
%%$ - ! )
1 )
2
1 )
+!$
"! . )
#
- 3 %&%&4567898778:;<:898=:>=?3 ' >=:- 3 %'%&;<:898=:>=?3 &>55>4@4=A?B8 CD:AE8=? >=: :8F788 :>?8: &
%& 4=
3 % 3= ?B8 94@8 39 ?B8 ::4?43=>@ 8=437 4G4@ )D:A8>@>;D7>A4"B8784=>9?877898778:?3>5H?74>@3D7?I 9375B37?#
- 8 -
%
D4? 588J4=A 6>7?4?43= >=: 586>7>?8 635585543= >=:?B8F3D=?87F@>4E94@8:;<:898=:>=?35 >=:$K>5 :8F788: ;< ?B8 ?74>@ 3D7? >K>7:4=A 6@>4=?499 :898=:>=? 35 >=: $ 8>FB &?B 5B>78 4= ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 9D7?B87 :8F@>78: ?B>? ?B8 C34=? :8G8@36E8=? >A788E8=? :>?8: %'
%' 45 =3? ;4=:4=A D63=?B85B>7839?B86@>4=?499:898=:>=?35 >=:$
'
B85D4?673687?485>78:85F74;8:>5D=:87
!"#$%
"&'( ") *+
,
%
- .( / - 0 ,, , 1
23- 42/ +5
, 2/ +*
26%,5
,
-
,
. 7
8 / % 59 6 5!3( ,
/ ,
-
$*:
,
;
,
.
))9
7
< 6
8/
- 9 -
6
"
8 ) /
, +--
/ ,
-
$ * :
,=
B89>E4@<68:4A78845>5D=:87 B88E7>3":48:#
"B>E7>3#">7<>=ED7?B<#"B>=?>;>4#"8JB>#"887>#"D:B47#
"89 #"89 %#"89 #"89 $#"!@9 #"89 '#
$
B8 6@>4=?499 KB3 45 ?B8 :>DAB?87 39 :8F8>58:
B88E7>3 "B88E58=7>3# 4=5?4?D?8: > 5D4? 937 6>7?4?43= >=: 586>7>?8 635585543= 4= 78568F? 39 ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >78 ?B8 ;73?B875 >=: :898=:>=?535 >=:$>78B87545?875 ?45>G8778:?B>? ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 K878 3K=8: ;< :8F8>58:
B88E7>3 KB3 6>558: >K>< 3=
% @8>G4=A ;8B4=:?B86@>4=?499>=::898=:>=?35 ?3$>5B45@8A>@ B8475 ? 45 >G8778: ?B>? 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?< 4 8 4?8E 3 B3D58;8>74=A3 %54?D>?8:4=
3 '&*45 ?B8 58@9 >FLD478: 673687?< 39 :8F8>58: B88E7>3 >=: B8 B>5 6D7FB>58: ?B8 5>E8 3D? 39 B45 3K= 4=F3E8 -D7?B87
- 10 -
?B83?B87@>=:8:673687?485>78F@>4E8:?3;8?B8>=F85?7>@ 673687?485>FLD478:;<B88E7>3?B73DAB4=B874?>=F8>=: 5DFF85543= ? 45 >G8778: ?B>? >9?87 :8E458 39 B88E7>3 :898=:>=?35 ?3'ED?>?8:?B847=>E854=?B878G8=D8 78F37:5 >=: 8M8FD?8: > C34=? :8G8@36E8=? >A788E8=? :>?8: %'
%' K4?B :898=:>=? 3 & :8674G4=A ?B8 6@>4=?499 39 B87 @>K9D@ 5B>78 -D7?B87 4? 45 >G8778: ?B>? :898=:>=?3 &?B878>9?87673F88:8:K4?B?B8F3=5?7DF?43= 3=4?8E3 39?B85D4?5FB8:D@8673687?485 ?45>G8778:
?B>? ?B878 45 =3 6>7?4?43= >E3=A ?B8 @8A>@ B8475 >=: ?B>? 5B8>=:?B83?B87@8A>@B8475>788=?4?@8:937&?B5B>784= ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 >=: 937 :8F@>7>?43= ?B>? ?B8 C34=?:8G8@36E8=?>A788E8=?45=3?;4=:4=AD63=B87
&
898=:>=?5 8=?878: >668>7>=F8 B3K8G87 :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >=: & :4: =3? 94@8 ?B847 K74??8= 5?>?8E8=? 898=:>=?3 ?B8545?8739?B86@>4=?49994@8:
K74??8= 5?>?8E8=? K4?B ?B8 F3D=?87F@>4E 5D6637?4=A ?B8 6@>4=?499.5F3=?8=?43=?B>??B85D4?673687?485>78?B8C34=? 9>E4@<673687?485>=:F@>4E4=AB87&?B5B>78 898=:>=? - 11 -
3 $ >=3?B87 545?87 >@53 94@8: K74??8= 5?>?8E8=? K4?B > F3D=?87F@>4E 54E4@>7@< >5587?4=A B87 8=?4?@8E8=? ?3 &?B 5B>78
= ?B8 ;>545 39 ?B8 6@8>:4=A5 ?B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 97>E8:=8F855>7<455D85 4-
66
,,6,
! ,) -,6
6
> 4
, 8
)&)! ,
, , -
66( ,6,
! , )> 4 -
66( ,6,
)
, ! -,6 -6 > ! 4
, ,8>=
B8 ?74>@ 3D7? ;>58: 3= ?B8 37>@ >=:
:3FDE8=?>7<8G4:8=F8>774G8:>?>F3=F@D543=?B>? 4
?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 >78 ?B8 =F85?7>@ )34=? ->E4@< 673687?485 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=?35 ?3$
- 12 -
44
?B86@>4=?499>=::898=:>=?5>788=?4?@8:937&?B 5B>78 4= ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 >=: ?B8 C34=?
>A788E8=? :>?8: %'
%' 45 =3? ;4=:4=A D63= ?B8 5B>78 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499 :898=:>=?535 >=:$
;< ?B8 CD:AE8=? >=: :8F788 :8F788: ?B8 5D4? 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499
*
8>7: @8>7=8: F3D=58@ >668>74=A 937 ?B8 >668@@>=?5>=:?B878563=:8=?5
8>7=8:F3D=58@>668>74=A937?B8>668@@>=?54= - 3 %&%&5D;E4?5?B>??B8>668@@>=?5K878=3? >9937:8: 5D994F48=? 36637?D=4?< ?3 F3=?85? ?B8 5D4? ? 45 >7AD8:?B>??B8<F3D@:=3?67858=??B847:898=F837>::DF8 ?B8478G4:8=F8;<8=?874=A?B8K4?=855;3M ?45F3=?8=:8: ?B>??B459>4@D78?394@8K74??8=5?>?8E8=?B>5:478F?@<@8:?3 ?B8:8F788;84=A6>558:<
K4?B3D?F3=54:87>?43=39 ?B847F3=?8=?43=39?B89>F?56>7?4FD@>7@<KB8?B87?B85D4? - 13 -
5FB8:D@8 673687?485 K878 >=F85?7>@ 37 58@9 >FLD478: 673687?485
8>7=8:F3D=58@>668>74=A937?B8>668@@>=?4= - 3 %'%& K3D@: >7AD8 54E4@>7 A73D=:5 ? 45 5D;E4??8: ?B>? :898=:>=? 3 & ?B8 >668@@>=? B8784= B>5 8=?878: 4=?3 > C34=? :8G8@36E8=? >A788E8=? K4?B :898=:>=?35 ?3'>=:4=G85?8: 5D;5?>=?4>@>E3D=?4= F3=5?7DF?4=A>6>7?E8=?54=4?8E3 39?B85D4?5FB8:D@8 673687?485 B8>668@@>=?5?>?85?B>?B8B>:;88=>55D78: ;< :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' ?B>? ?B8< K3D@: >E4F>;@< 58??@8 ?B8E>??87K4?B?B86@>4=?499>=:B453?B87545?875 8@<4=A 3= ?B858 >55D7>=F85 :898=:>=? 3 & 7897>4=8: B4E58@9 973E >F?4G8@< 6>7?4F46>?4=A 4= ?B8 5D4? 673F88:4=A5 ? 45 9D7?B87 5D;E4??8: ?B>? :D8 ?3 ?B45 78@4>=F8 >=: @>FJ 39 36637?D=4?< ?3 67858=? B45 F>58 ?B8 4E6DA=8: CD:AE8=? >=::8F788F>E8?3;86>558:K4?B3D?9D@@>:CD:4F>?43=3= E874?5 3?B ?B8 >668@@>=?5 67><8: ?B>? ?B8 E>??87 ;8 78E>=:8: ?3 ?B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 937 9785B F3=54:87>?43= 673G4:4=A >= 36637?D=4?< ?3 94@8 K74??8= 5?>?8E8=? @8>:
- 14 -
8G4:8=F8 >=: ?B8 5D4? ;8 >:CD:4F>?8: 3= E874?5 4= >FF37:>=F8K4?B@>K
%
3 8
( @8>7=8: F3D=58@ >668>74=A 937 ?B8 78563=:8=?5 K3D@: F3=?8=:
?B>? ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=? 35 >=: $ ;84=A ?B8 :>DAB?875 39 :8F8>58:
B88E7>3 >78 ?B8 F36>7F8=87 39 3= 4=:D D=:4G4:8:
9>E4@< >=: ;< G47?D8 39 4=:D DFF85543= "E8=:E8=?# F? %$ >=: >5 B8@: ;< ?B8 68M 3D7? 4= ?B8 F>58 39
? $ :>DAB?875>788=?4?@8:?38LD>@5B>784=?B8F36>7F8=>7< 673687?485 ;< ;47?B ? 45 F3=?8=:8: ?B>? :898=:>=? 35
?3 ' >=: & K878 :D@< 587G8: >=: 8=?878: >668>7>=F8 4= 5D4??B73DABF3D=58@>58>7@<>53='
%$4=78568F? 39 :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >=: ;< :898=:>=? 3 & 3= %$
%& 8564?87867858=?>?43=?B73DABF3D=58@?B8< B>G89>4@8:?394@8K74??8=5?>?8E8=?37?>J8>=<5?865?3 :898=:?B85D4? 1 (2020) 9 SCC 1
- 15 -
'
?45F3=?8=:8:?B>??B8?74>@3D7?673F88:8:?3 >:CD:4F>?8?B8 5D4?3=?B8;>54539 ?B86@8>:4=A5>=:?B8 E>?874>@ 6@>F8: ;< ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: 74AB?@< B8@: ?B>? ?B8 6@>4=?499 45 8=?4?@8: 937 &?B 5B>78 4= ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485>=:?B8C34=?>A788E8=?:>?8:%'
%'K>5 8M8FD?8: K4?B3D? ?B8 F3=58=? 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=?
35 >=: $ 45 =3? ;4=:4=A D63= ?B8E ? 45 5D;E4??8: ?B>? ?B8 CD:AE8=? >=: :8F788 6>558: ;< ?B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 45 CD5?4948: >=: :385 =3? K>77>=? >=< 4=?879878=F8;<?B453D7? >G4=AB8>7:?B8@8>7=8:F3D=58@>668>74=A937 ?B86>7?485?B8634=??B>?>74585937F3=54:87>?43=45 4 @ ,
, ,8
, . - %
. 68 . 6
8
,88 8 68
>= $
7:87 5B88? 39 ?B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 789@8F?5 ?B>? :898=:>=?35 ?3'>=:&K8786@>F8:<
=>= >66@4F>?43= 94@8: ;< :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' ?B8 <
- 16 -
37:87 K>5 58? >54:8 >=: :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' K878 7867858=?8: ;< F3D=58@ 3= '
%$ -D7?B87 ?B8 < 37:87 >A>4=5? :898=:>=? 3 & K>5 58? >54:8 >=: :898=:>=? 3 & K>5 687E4??8: ?3 F3=?85? ?B8 5D4? ;< >= 37:87 :>?8: %$
%& 898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >=: & 8=?878: >668>7>=F8 ?B73DAB ?B847 F3D=58@ >5 8>7@< >5 3= '
%$ >=: %$
%&
8564?8 ED@?46@8 36637?D=4?485A4G8==3K74??8=5?>?8E8=?5K87894@8: B8 >668@@>=?5 B>: >= 36637?D=4?< ?3 94@8 K74??8= 5?>?8E8=? ;D?F3=5F43D5@<9>4@8:?3:353 898=:>=?35 ?3'>=:& :4: =3? 588J >=< 8M?8=543= 39 ?4E8 37 687E45543= ?3 94@8 ?B847K74??8=5?>?8E8=?;8<3=:?B85?46D@>?8:?4E8 >K45 K8@@58??@8:?B>?H?4E8@4E4??394@8K74??8=5?>?8E8=?D=:87 7:87 D@8 39 ! 45 :478F?37< >=: =3? E>=:>?37< I B83D7?3=78>53=5?3;878F37:8:F>=8M?8=:?B8?4E8 @4E4?;8<3=:?B8*:><5A7>F868743:>5K8@@ ?45>@53 K8@@58??@8:?B>?H4=3=@<8MF86?43=>@>=:7>78F>5855DFB ?<68398M?8=543=5B>@@;8673G4:8: ?5B3D@:=3?;8F3E8
- 17 -
73D?4=8 E>==87 ?3 A7>=? 8M?8=543= >5 4? E>< 785D@? 4= E45D58>=:F>=;8D58:>5>6>7?39:8@><?>F?4F5 I &
B868M3D7?4=?B8F>5839 ! " ! # $ % & -$B8@:>?6>7>3 %>5D=:87 A8 + ( 8
- , 6 B, ?AAA 5 - %8 +, %
. .
6 %
%
, ,5 - 5 -&(6
- %, 6<,.8 ( 8 -- 8 @ ,
( C 8 , -
C6B6
- 6-% , + ( 8 + ,8 8@ , ,6,
C 8 ,-
C 6 A 8 < 6 + ( , 6 % ,
--=( 8
+ ,8 8
8@ ,
,6,
+ 6%
6-,
,
,
8 ,
.C6-
A8 + 6B,?AAA5 -
,
2 AIR 2005 SC 3353
- 18 -
5 - ( , 8 6 8 8
,
-, 668 % -,
,5 -B,?AAA(8 ,8 % -,
+ %
-- %,6,
6- %
+
6<. 6 , 6 & ,
. +,, B, ?AAA 5 - 8 B,?AAA5 -
6<. 6 . ,
.( 6 8
, 8 %, %
C 8 ,-
C 6= -
-.( 6 ( + 6B,?AAA5 - +,6
- 6&,
. 6-%
,8 . +
, ( % %
C 8- ,<, 6-%
8 , 8
<,, -. <8
--. , 8
4- <, ( ,
-- 6<,
- 6&,
.,8 6 8 <,
-- 6 -. , -. <8, --6. , 6<,.B,5 -=
-,$
- 19 -
B8 68M 3D7? 4= ?B8 F>58 39 '
$ ( 7
-
$>5B8@:>?6>7>35 ?3 $>5D=:87 )* , @8
, , 85 - 6B,6
, 8 <%8 + -
8,(% 6
+
8 , ,8 . ,
,
. A <8
-
( 8 . <, 6 6- % , 6,
. , & ,
.( 6, + ( <, %+(%
. , ,
--6.6 8
,
8D-6 , + D 6 + ,-
. 88 , , . ,6,
-
% 8 % +
-
.,
,
.,-
. -8 , 8 .,-
. - 6 -8 ( 886 - 8
,, . 88,@ . -
(6 .( 6 %8 %
-8, + . -
-
, 6 (@ ,.8 ,- .6
,@ %6,6, C < 6 .
, - -
,
3 (2005) 4 SCC 480
- 20 -
, % . +
. ,
-. % , -8 * B,
-.(8, -8,.B, 5 - ,,6, -, +-
% 6 +,
-,
C6 ,
6,68 , 6- %
, ,
6
% %
6
+
- 6 ,
, 6
8 8 < 6 6 . ,6,
6 8 %%,
. &,
.(
8
.( -,
, @ 6 ,-.6
C( ( % , 6 & ,
. <, < 8
-. . %
. 6
<8 ,6
,.,6,
,
- 8 ,, % . 8 6
8 A --, , 6 8, - 8, . B, 5 - 6 , %
-- %,
, 8
88 8 % <8
-( 88
, . . , 8 - 6 ,6,
,
8< % , 6@ 8( ,
+ @ 8% -, 88
,6 %
<,,
- 21 -
* 9
.C. ,&,
.6 6- % , % A @ ,8
- ,8 <8, %---, (
8
. ,,
,6,
8- ,
6 8
. 8
,
. - 66,
+( ,8
- 868
, 8 . +,8 ,, 6
8
,88 8 6
+8
$
<,%
-8 C< 6
8 +88
. %
6 ,, , %8 , < ** < 6
-- -. . %
. 6 <8
,6
8 ,,%( % + 6 . . ( . 8 A 8
(
-- ,6,
, C < 6%8 6, 8
6-
<. -8
6 ,6,
8 - 8 . 8 6 , - 2 $ , ,6, 6 C
. < 6 @ 6 C(
, $ 8
-
66 6 ,-
. ,8 +88 , *+ %+(
@
8C 6 -
8
-
, , % <8
+
8 6 8, - 8 -
,.B,5 -
-- -
,
- 22 -
,
6
<8 ( , 6 6
8 .
-.4 -,
B,5 - ( 8 8,
,
. 6 ( ,8 . + ,
6 8 --
%=
-,$
BD5:898=:>=?35 ?3'>=:&3=?B8473K= F3=:DF?785D@?8:4=?B83D7?673F88:4=A<
(?B87845 =3673F8:D7>@4@@8A>@4?<=37>=<8MF86?43=>@>=:7>78F>58 45E>:83D?;<?B8>668@@>=?5
*
B8 @>K 45 K8@@ 58??@8: ?B>? E878 =3= 94@4=A 39 K74??8=5?>?8E8=?:385=3?G4?4>?8?B8:8F788495D994F48=? 8G4:8=F8 8M45?5 ?3 CD5?49< ?B8 CD:AE8=? B8 6@>4=?499 673:DF8:37>@>=::3FDE8=?>7<8G4:8=F8?3673G8?B>??B8 5D4?673687?485>78?B8>=F85?7>@C34=?9>E4@<673687?48539 ?B86@>4=?499>=::898=:>=?35 ?3$
%
B86@>4=?499A3?8M>E4=8:B8758@9>5! 5B8 F>?8A374F>@@< :86358: ?B>? 5B8 45 ?B8 :>DAB?87 39 B88E7>3 >=: ?B8 5D4? 673687?485 K878 3K=8: ;< ?B8 :8F8>58: B88E7>3 M ! 45 ?B8 JB>?> 8M?7>F? 39 4?8E
- 23 -
3 39 ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 4 8 B3D58 ;8>74=A 3 %937?B8<8>7%'?B8=>E839:898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >78 8=?878: M !% 45 ?B8 673687?< 8M?7>F? 39
3 '&* KB8784= B3D58 ;8>74=A 3 % E8>5D74=A '% 5LD>78 E8?875 "'& 5LD>78 988?# 45 54?D>?8: F@8>7@< 4=:4F>?85 ?B8 =>E8 39 B88E7>3 ?B8 9>?B87 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=? 35 ?3 $ M !' 45 ?B8 3;C8F?43= 5D;E4??8: ;< ?B8 6@>4=?499 78A>7:4=A ?B8 ?7>=598739673687?<4=?B8=>E839:898=:>=?35 ?3'4= 78568F?39B3D58;8>74=A3 %4= 3 '&* B8 =>E839:898=:>=?35 ?3'4=M !:385=3?:45F@358 >5?3B3K:898=:>=?35 ?3'>@3=8>FLD478:?B874AB?4= 78568F?394?8E3 39?B85FB8:D@8673687?4858MF@D:4=A ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=? 35 >=: $ KB8= 4=G>74>;@< ?B8 673687?< K>5 6D7FB>58: ;< B88E7>3 M ! >=: !$ >78?B878G8=D878F37:5687?>4=4=A?3?B84?8E35 %>=:' 39?B85FB8:D@8673687?485 B85>4:673687?485>A>4=5?>=: C34=?@<4=?B8=>E839:898=:>=?35 ?3' M KB4FB 45673:DF8:;< :898=:>=?3 $>@535B3K5?B>?4?8E
- 24 -
35 % >=: ' ?B8 >A74FD@?D78 @>=:5 >78 ?7>=598778: 4= ?B8 =>E8 39 :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' =?874=A ?B8 =>E8 39 :898=:>=?35 ?3'4=?B85D4?5FB8:D@8673687?485?3?B8 8MF@D543= 39 ?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=? 35 >=: $ 45 K4?B3D?>=<>;53@D?874AB? %
B8 58??@8: 6736354?43= 39 @>K 45 ?B>? ED?>?43= 8=?7<:385=3?F3=987>=<74AB??4?@8374=?8785?4=9>G3739 ?B868753=>=:?B8ED?>?43=8=?7<4=?B878G8=D878F37:45 3=@<937?B8945F>@6D76358 B868M3D7?4=?B8F>5839 , -.#/ & '$ -.#/ (* %
$( (
' (+
$
, ", 0 1$ 0 - / 23 4 ( 0
-
%
$ F3=54:878: ?B8 8998F? 39 ED?>?43= >=: 3;587G8: ?B>?
?B8 ED?>?43= 39 673687?< 4= ?B878G8=D878F37:5:385=3?F78>?8=378M?4=AD45B85?4?@8 ?3 ?B8 673687?< =37 B>5 >=< 6785DE6?4G8 G>@D8 3= ?4?@8
4 (1996) 6 SCC 223 5 (2009) 5 SCC 591 6 (1997) 7 SCC 137
- 25 -
DFB8=?7485>7878@8G>=?3=@<937?B86D7635839F3@@8F?4G8 @>=:78G8=D8 BD5?B8ED?>?43=8=?7485:3=3?F78>?837 8M?4=AD45B3K=875B4674AB?53G87?B8673687?< B8>F?D>@ ?7>=5987 39 @8A>@ ?4?@8 B>668=5 ?B73DAB 78A45?878: :3FDE8=?5 =?B84=5?>=?F>58?B88=?7<39?B8=>E839 :898=:>=?35 ?3'4=?B878G8=D878F37:545=3??B73DAB >=<?4?@8:3FDE8=?>=:B8=F88=?7<39?B847=>E854=?B8 78G8=D878F37:5K3D@:=3?:4G85??B874AB?39?B86@>4=?499 4=?B85D4?673687?485
%%
M ! 45 ?B8 C34=? :8G8@36E8=? >A788E8=? ;< :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' 4= 9>G3D7 39 :898=:>=? 3 & 3= %'
%' 898=:>=?35 ?3'B>G4=A=3?85?>;@45B8:
?B847 8MF@D54G8 74AB? 3G87 ?B8 5D4? 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 ?BD5?B8C34=?:8G8@36E8=?>A788E8=?8=?878:4=78568F? 39 4?8E 3 39 ?B8 5FB8:D@8 673687?485 K4?B3D? ?B8 F3=58=?39?B86@>4=?499>=::898=:>=?35 >=:$45=3? ;4=:4=AD63=?B8475B>785
- 26 -
%'
B8 ?74>@ 3D7? 74AB?@< >558558: ?B8 8=?478 37>@ >=::3FDE8=?>7<8G4:8=F8>=:B8@:?B>??B85D4?5FB8:D@8 673687?485>78?B8>=F85?7>@C34=?9>E4@<673687?485>=:?B8 6@>4=?499 >=: :898=:>=? 35 >=: $ >78 8=?4?@8: 937 &?B 5B>78 8>FB ;84=A ?B8 :>DAB?875 39 ?B8 :8F8>58: B88E7>3KB3:48:4=?85?>?8>788=?4?@8:9378LD>@5B>78
B8 6736354?43= ?B>? ?B8 :>DAB?875 >78 8=?4?@8: ?3 8LD>@ 5B>78 45 ;< G47?D8 39 ?B8 4=:D DFF85543= ">E8=:E8=?# F? %$ >=: =3 @3=A87 >
4= @4AB? 39 ?B8 :8F4543=39?B868M3D7?4=?B8F>5839 5?>?8:
FF37:4=A@< ?B8 634=? 97>E8: 937 F3=54:87>?43=45>=5K878: 894=:?B87845=34=947E4?<37 4@@8A>@4?<4=?B8CD:AE8=?>=::8F78839?B8?74>@3D7?>=: K86>55?B893@@3K4=A
4
B8 8AD@>7 -475? 668>@5 >78 B878;<
- 27 -
44
B8CD:AE8=?>=::8F78839?B8?74>@3D7? :>?8: &
%& 4=
3 % 5?>=:5! 444
? 45 =88:@855 ?3 3;587G8 ?B>? :898=:>=? 35 ?3 ' >=: & >78 >? @4;87?< ?3 588J 8LD4?< 4= ?B8 94=>@ :8F788 673F88:4=A5 4= >FF37:>=F8K4?B@>K
,' ($$$%&) ! ,' ($) ! 45?3 @3