- 1 - !!" !#$ % & "'"(""! ""(( )$* ""(( )$* ! ! " #$% & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " #$% ' ' (! ' # &&& %%)&( # ! * ! * #$% & ' #$% '&+ #)&&&& - 3 - ' ' (! ' !)# , ' # &&& %%)' &( ' ' - '! ./ 011/02 34 ' 5&6&&& 78 9./ 4:;<04=/ 5>1048 04? 9./ 011/02 34 ' 5&&%%&& 78 9./ =203>049 0</ 0@034:9 9./ :0>/ A;?@>/49 04? 0B0<? ?09/? &&& 10::/? 78 9./ /435< 3C32 ;?@/ 04? # ;??/73.02 DE5< :.5<9F<37;402GH34 5%%)&( & ./ E0=9: 5E 9./ =0:/ 34 7<3/E 0</ 9.09 =203>049 0@/? !! 8/0<: >/9 B39. 04 0==3?/49 54 )!& 04? :;:9034/?@<3/C5;:34A;<3/:/E32/?=203>1/9393547/E5</ 9./ <37;402 =203>34@ =5>1/4:09354 5E :&&# - 4 - E<5>9./</:154?/49:./<37;402=54:3?/<34@9.//493</ >09/<302: 0C032072/ 54 </=5<? 0B0<?/? 0 :;> 5E :%# B39. 349/</:9 09 I 1/< 044;> E<5> 9./ ?09/ 5E 1/939354 9322 </023J09354 04? ?3</=9/? 4:;<04=/ 5>1048951089./=5>1/4:09354 ! @@<3/C/?789./:03?A;?@>/499./011/22049# 4:;<04=/ 5>1048 .0: 1</E/<</? 9./ 011/02 =549/4?34@ 9.09 9./ >/?3=02 </=5<?: 04? /C3?/4=/ 5E 9./ =203>049 :.5B 9.09 .3: .04? 3: 0>1;909/? >3?#9.3<? E5</0<> 7;9 9./ =203>049 .0: 459 2/? 048 >/?3=02 /C3?/4=/ 04? 9./ <37;402B39.5;904870:3:=0>/959./=54=2;:3549.099./ =203>049.0::;:9034/?I?3:0732398959./B.52/75?8 B.3=. 3: 459 =5<</=9 9 3: E;<9./< =549/4?/? 9.09 9./ 5B4/<5E9./C/.3=2/011/0</?7/E5</9./<37;4029.<5;@. =5;4:/2 04? ?/43/? 9./ 230732398 203>049 C35209/? 9./ 9/<>:04?=54?39354:5E9./1523=8./</E5</=5;4:/2E5< 9./ 4:;<04=/5>1048</K;/:9/?E5<>5?3E3=093545E9./ 3>1;@4/?A;?@>/4904?0B0<?10::/?789./<37;402 - 5 - 6 /34@ 0@@<3/C/? 78 9./ :03? A;?@>/49 04? 0B0<? 9./ 011/22049#=203>049 02:5 1</E/<</? 04 011/02 ://L34@ /4.04=/>/49 5E =5>1/4:09354 0B0<?/? 78 9./ <37;402 9 3: =549/4?/? 9.09 9./ =203>049 B0: ?534@ 0@<3=;29;<02 B5<L 04? 0>1;909354 5E <3@.9 .04? B.3=. </:;29: I E;4=935402 ?3:0732398 9 3: 02:5 =549/4?/? 9.099./<37;4025;@.995.0C/0??/?6I95B0<?:25:: 5E E;9;</ 1<5:1/=9: 0: 1/< 9./ =3909354 34 9./ =0:/ 5E 9 3: 02:5 =549/4?/? 9.09 9./ =5>1/4:093540B0<?/?789./<37;402;4?/<59./<./0?: 340?/K;09/ 04? 9.;: </K;/:9/? E5< /4.04=/>/49 B39. &I349/</:91/<044;> $ /0<?759.9./10<93/:04?1/<;:/?9./>09/<302 0C032072/54</=5<? ?>399/?28 9./ =203>049 .0: 459 2/? 048 >/?3=02 /C3?/4=/ 95 0::/:: 9./ ?3:0732398 : 1/<5;4? /<93E3=09/ 04? 3:=.0<@/ ;>>0<8 9./ <3@.9 E5</0<> 3: 0>1;909/?:1/<=./?;2/# 0<9 =20;:/65E9./ - 6 - 5<L>/4G:5>1/4:09354=9)&!E5< 5::5E0.04?5< 5E9./9.;>704?E5;<E34@/<:5E54/.04?5<0>1;909354 E<5>7/25B93152/=<04549./1/<=/490@/5E25::5E/0<434@ =010=398 09 I ./ <37;402 =54:3?/<34@ 9./ :03? =./?;2/ .0: 0::/::/? I ?3:0732398 .5;@. 2/0<4/? =5;4:/2 E5< 9./ 4:;<04=/ 5>1048 5115:/: 9./ :0>/ 9.3:5;<9E34?:45</0:54349/<E/</B39.9./:0>/ ( /939354/< :909/? 9.09 ./ B0: /0<434@ :# 1/< >549. 7;9 ./ .0: 459 E32/? 048 34=5>/ 1<55E : 9./ 0==3?/49 3: 5E 9./ 8/0< & 0: 1/< 9./ =.0<9 3::;/? 78 9./ "0<4090L0 909/ /@02 /<C3=/: ;9.5<398 9./ <37;402 .0: <3@.928 90L/4 34=5>/ 5E 9./ =203>04909 :%($# 1/< >549.04? <3@.92801123/? 9./ >;293123/< 5E FG 0: =203>049 B0: 0@/? !! 8/0<: 09 9./ 93>/ 5E 0==3?/49 5B/C/< 0?>399/?28 39 3: =0:/ 5E 0>1;909354./4=/6I5E:%($#:!$#3:95 7/ 0??/? 95B0<?: E;9;</ 1<5:1/=9: 0: 1/< 9./ =3909354 </23/? 78 9./ =5;4:/2 E5< 9./ =203>049 04? 9.;: 9./ 95902 34=5>/ =5>/: :&&$# 1/< >549. ==5<?34@28 9./ - 7 - =203>049 3: /49392/? E5< 25:: 5E E;9;</ /0<434@ =010=398 0: ;4?/< :&&$#M&MMIN:6&# % ./=203>049B0:0?>399/?349./.5:13902E5<( ?08: 04? ;4?/<B/49 :;<@/<3/: 04? 90L/4 E5225B ;1 9</09>/49 ./</E5</ 9.3: 5;<9 E34?: 39 </0:54072/ 95 0B0<? 04 0>5;49 5E:#E5< 1034 04? :;EE/<34@ 04? :# E5< 9<04:15<909354 099/4?049 04? /M9<0 45;<3:.>/49 =.0<@/: 55L34@ 95 9./ 409;</ 04? :/<35;:4/:: 5E 34A;<3/: 9./ =203>049 >3@.9 459 .0C/ 099/4?/? 048 B5<L 092/0:9 E5< >549.: ./4=/ ./ 3: /49392/? E5< :$&$# E5< 25:: 5E 34=5>/ ?;<34@ 203? ;1 1/<35? 5B/C/< 9./ <37;402 .0: 0B0<?/? 0 :;> 5E :(&# E5< >/?3=02 /M1/4:/: 04? 0 :;> 5E :$# E5< 25:: 5E 0>/4393/: B.3=. 4//?: 45 349/<E/</4=/ ) ./ =5>1/4:09354 0B0<?/? 78 9./ <37;402 3: >5?3E3/?0:;4?/< - 8 - 2 5 /0?: B0<?789./ <37;402 B0<?789.3: 5;<9 03404?:;EE/<34@ :$# :# & /?3=02M1/4:/: :(&# :(&# ! 5:: 5E E;9;</ /0<434@=010=398 :%# :6&# 6 <04:15<909354 /M9<0 45;<3:.>/49 04? 099/4?049 =.0<@/: # :# $ 5::5E0>/4393/: :$# :$# 5:: 5E 34=5>/ ?;<34@ 203? ;1 1/<35? ## :$&$# 5902 :%# :(6$%# ./</B3227//4.04=/>/495E:$$)(# 93::;7>399/?9.099./ 4:;<04=/5>1048.0: 02</0?8 ?/15:39/? $I 5E 9./ =5>1/4:09354 0>5;49 0B0<?/?789./<37;402 49./</:;299./E5225B34@5<?/<3:10::/? 3 ./ ' 5&6&&& E32/? 78 9./ 4:;<04=/ 5>1048 3: 04? 9./ - 9 - ' 5&&%%&& E32/? 78 9./ =203>049 3: 33 ./ =203>049 3: /49392/? E5< 9./ /4.04=/?=5>1/4:093545E:(6$%#B39. 349/</:9 09 I 1/< 044;> E<5> 9./ ?09/ 5E 1/93935493229./?09/5E</023J09354 333 ./ 4:;<04=/ 5>1048 3: ?3</=9/? 95?/15:399./70204=/5E=5>1/4:093540>5;49 0254@ B39. 349/</:9 B39.34 54/ >549. E<5> 9./ ?09/5E9.3:A;?@>/49 3C 4 :;=. ?/15:39 9./ =203>049 3: 1/<>399/?95B39.?<0B9.//493</0>5;490254@ B39.349/</:90==<;/?5439 +, )(""!* '! 3:95 25 %6