- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %&' %() '%(( * !"# $ %& " !"# %& " !"# ' Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"# ( $! !"# ) %( & * ( * ( ! # $ (((( " " +,-.( !"# ) %(( * / * $& * '!$ *% & $! *( 0 ## $#$ ( $#$' 1 - 3 - * 2#$#$$ * ** ( ''$ ' #' #" #2'2 * ( * * ( $ 0 2#$#$$ * * * * 3( 45.6+78958.6.6+76:;<94,=>.8-67?4@>8-54-87.:479 :6;?67=: 4::46?67= .>8 +-98- +A 8B6:6+74? +,-. 54::89 67 -? + $#$' @>8-867 .>8 8B6:6+74? +,-. 4??+@89 .>8 -8B6:6+7:8..67=4:698.>8+-98-+A?84-7894=6:.-4.84CC85.67= D(E-85+-.479.>8F4..8-@4:-8F6..89;4CG.+.>8-64?+,-. .+.4G8C+=76H47C8+A.>8+AA87C8:4796::,85-+.8:. $ 8C+79 -8:5+7987. @>+ 6: .>8 F+.>8-67?4@ +A A6-:.58.6.6+78-?+9=894C+F5?467.+7$'$$#$$4??8=67=.>4. :>8 @4: F47>479?89 479 5><:6C4??< 4;,:89 ;< .>8 A6-:. 58.6.6+78-94,=>.8-67?4@ 479 >8- A4F6?< F8F;8-: +7 #2$#! ,-:,47. .+ -8=6:.-4.6+7 +A C-6F8 67 -6F8 +2#$#$$ .>8 7B8:.6=4.67= AA6C8- ,798-.++G 67B8:.6=4.6+7 - 4 - 479 A6?89 4 D(I -85+-. 8C+79 -8:5+7987. ?+9=89 4 5-+.8:. F8F+ 479 .>8 :@+-7 :.4.8F87. +A .>8 C+F5?46747. 479 @6.78::8: @8-8 8J4F6789 ;< -8:5+7987. +$C+F5?46747. 84-7894=6:.-4.8>4B67=8J4F6789.>8:@+-7:.4.8F87.479 .>8:.4.8F87.:+A.>8@6.78::8:A+,79.>4.4;8?4.89C+F5?467. 6:A6?89@6.>+,.96:C?+:67=C+FF6::6+7+A+AA87C8479.>8-8A+-8 .>8D(E-85+-.@4:4CC85.89479.>85-+C88967=:@8-8=6B874 C?+:,-8 >8 :8C+79 -8:5+7987. 4::46?67= .>8 +-98- +A .>8 4=6:.-4.8 5-8A8--89 4 8B6:6+7 >8 8B6:6+74? +,-. >4: >+@8B8--8B8-:89.>8+-98-+A.>84=6:.-4.8479.>8F4..8-6: 7+@ -8F6..89 ;4CG .+ .4G8 C+=76H47C8 A+- .>8 +AA87C8 5,76:>4;?8,798-8C.6+7:''$ ' #' #"#2 -849@6.>8C.6+7'2+A79647874?+98!"# ' 84-9 .>8 ?84-789 C+,7:8? A+- .>8 58.6.6+78- ?84-789C+,7:8?A+-.>8-8:5+7987. +$479?84-7896=>+,-. +B8-7F87.?8498-A+-.>8.4.8 (8A+-8 .>6: +,-. 49B8-.: .+ .>8 C4:8 +7 >479 6. 988F: 6. A6. .+ 8J.-4C. .>8 -8?8B47. 5+-.6+7 +A .>8 C+F5?467. @>6C>-84C>894:,798- - 5 - #2$#! ! K $ % & ! " # $ %& ' ( )$ ' *+ ( , -./0.1, , 2 3456 ( / 7" 8" /0.1 ( 9 : 7" ;8 56 1<& 56 ( &=> ? @56 , :ABC D EF> ( G# D H >( & IJ , " ?KL7$ @(MN OCP); *, -. /0.1 56,& ', 2 34$ 1< :ABC D EF> " , "' H I' " *=QR @ S KT & U1 )V )W,>$& HJQ:X;& 2 & Y >Z B %H 56[\L& Q \" K * *F]P^K@# H I * MN OCP ); % )NQ _` 56 S ' ,a % =Q& Z J b <C & -H & , * , -. 3MN <C & `c >Sd d H & ,e * & 4 *d b !"# " >6: +,-. 4?:+ 988F: 6. A6. .+ 8J.-4C. .>8 78J. -8?8B47. 5+-.6+7 @>6C> @+,?9 >4B8 4 96-8C. ;84-67= +7 .>8 5-8:87.5-+C88967=::4F86:8J.-4C.89 L'#$#2 $% & $# ' ()* +, S ^- 5 S K ] 1f g& -H;' + ?$ ['HhP - 6 - * & -H;' & 56+D *+ > i4= .#j ] 1f g& -H; >i4= >S ,1< k 9 l09 lh%C+7:87.6B+-C8& .5=Q"j& - + DF *+mGJH "& `c *n c - o NQ % S .D #### *+ .#j * -*+ ####+ & - .5=Q & ;j& - ; , # % ' nC MXc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