- 1 - !" # $%#&'()*#'' + !"#$% & ' ( ) * !"#$% & ' + ' )) ( %,!') ( ( - $#$#% % #$- ( ( ( ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( . " ' .) /0 122033145 60748 5/0 9*:23174145 74 *% #$- *4 5/0 ;730 *; 5/0 301<40= 7>73 ?=80 + ( 7@1A12?<1 B;*< C/*<5 D5/0 <713 *?<5EF 7C 7:2?847485/0@?=8:045=150=- $#$#%19G?7557485/0 <0C2*4=045199?C0= ;*< 5/0 *;;0490 2?47C/1630 ?4=0< 0957*4 -%! *; 08*571630 4C5<?:045C 95 -!!- B;*< C/*<5D5/0 95EF # (195C *; 5/0 91C0 74 6<70; 1<0 5/15 5/0 1220331459*:23174145 /1= ;730= 5/0 2<7>150 9*:231745 74 *- #$-, 60;*<0 5/0 <713 *?<5 18174C5 5/0 <0C2*4=045199?C0= 13308748 9*::7CC7*4 *; 5/0 *;;0490 2?47C/1630 ?4=0< 0957*4 -%! *; 95 5 7C 5/0 9*450457*4 *; 5/0 9*:23174145 5/15 /0 7C 1 6?C740CC:14 14= H1C ;1:7371< H75/ 5/0 199?C0= /04 5/0 199?C0= - 3 - <0G?0C50= ;*< /14= 3*14 /0 /1= 3045 14 1:*?45 *; C-"$$$$ 99?C0= /1= 18<00= 5* <021A 5/0 C1:0 H75/74 1 C/*<5 C214 *; 57:0 /04 5/0 9*:23174145 =0:14=0=619I5/01:*?455/0199?C0=7CC?0=9/0G?01C 20< J- ;*< C-"$$$$ /04 5/0 9/0G?0 H1C 2<0C0450=;*<0491C/:0455/0C1:0H1C=7C/*4*<0=H75/ 14 04=*<C0:045 D74C?;;797045 ;?4=CE 74 5/0 199*?45 *; 5/0 199?C0=308134*5790H1C7CC?0=5*5/0199?C0=9133748 ?2*4 /7: 5* <021A 5/0 9/0G?0 1:*?45 /0 C1:0 H1C C0<>0=*45/0199?C0=0/1=7CC?0=<023A4*579051I748 ?45041630=0;04900/1C4*5<0217=5/09/0G?01:*?45 14= 5/0<06A 9*::7550= 5/0 *;;0490 2?47C/1630 ?4=0< 0957*4 -%! *; 95 99*<=7483A /0 <0G?0C50= 5/0 <713*?<55*51I09*847K1490*;5/0*;;049014=5*74757150 308131957*4 % /0 <713 *?<5 5**I 9*847K1490 *; 5/0 *;;0490 14=<087C50<0=5/091C074 *% #$-/0199?C0= /1C 12201<0= 60;*<0 5/0 <713 *?<5 2301=0= 4*5 8?735A 14=9317:0=5*605<70=4*<=0<5*2<*>0/7C9*450457*4 - 4 - 5/0 9*:23174145 0J1:740= /7:C03; 1C - 14= 8*5 :1<I0= JC- 5* , /0 199?C0= /1C =0470= 133 5/0 749<7:7415748 :150<713C 1>1731630 *4 <09*<= 0J1:740= /7:C03;1C-14=8*5:1<I0=JC-5*-$/0<713 *?<51;50<51I748745*9*4C7=0<157*41335/0C0:150<713C*4 <09*<= 91:0 5* 5/0 9*493?C7*4 5/15 5/0 199?C0= 7C C?990CC;?3 74 <06?55748 5/0 30813 2<0C?:257*4 ?4=0< 0957*4 -% *; 5/0 95 14= 199*<=7483A 21CC0= 5/0 7:2?840= @?=8:045 19G?755748 5/0 199?C0= 0748 188<70>0= 6A 5/0 C1:0 5/0 9*:23174145 7C 60;*<0 5/7C *?<5 01<=<71C1>1I7<14301<40=9*?4C03;*< <7 :60I1< 301<40= 9*?4C03 ;*< 5/0 122033145 9*:23174145 01<40= 9*?4C03;*< 5/0 199?C0= <0C2*4=045<0:1740=16C04514=/0/1C4*51==<0CC0=/7C 1<8?:045C74C2750*;87>748C?;;797045*22*<5?475A0490 /7C 1<8?:045 7C 51I04 1C 473 0<?C0= 5/0 :150<713C 7493?=7485/0<713*?<5<09*<=C - 5 - 4>70H*;5/09*450457*4C?<80=6A5/0301<40= 9*?4C03;*<5/01220331455/02*7455/15H*?3=1<7C0;*<:A 9*4C7=0<157*47C A14CH0<5*5/016*>02*7457C745/0D E ;*<5/0;*33*H748 " 57C5/09*450457*4*;5/09*:231741455/15/0 7C16?C740CC:0414=/0I4*HC5/0199?C0=0/1=87>04 /14=3*14*;C-"$$$$ 5*/7:*H1<=C<021A:045*; 5/0C1:05/0199?C0=/1=7CC?0=5/09/0G?01C20<J- ;*< C-"$$$$ 4 2<0C045157*4 5/0 9/0G?0 H1C =7C/*4*<0=1C5/0<0H1C74C?;;797045;?4=745/0199*?45*; 5/0 199?C0= >04 5/*?8/ 30813 4*5790 H1C 7CC?0= 5/0 199?C0=/1C4*5<0217=5/09/0G?01:*?456?5/1=7CC?0= 5/0 <023A 51I748 ?45041630 =0;0490 14= 5/0<06A /0 /1C 9*::7550= 5/0 *;;0490 2?47C/1630 ?4=0< 0957*4 -%! *; - 6 - 9599*<=7483A5/09*:23174145<0G?0C50=5/0<713 *?<5 5* 51I0 9*847K1490 *; 5/0 *;;0490 14= 5* 74757150 308131957*4 , 4 *<=0< 5* 2<*>0 /7C 9*450457*4 5/0 9*:231741450J1:740=/7:C03;1C-14=<0750<150=5/0 9*450457*4C 1C 51I04 74 5/0 9*:231745 ?<748 9<*CC 0J1:74157*4757CC?880C50=5*5/0H7540CC5/1541:0*; 5/0199?C0=7C4*51:0C/75413376?575H1C1<1C/?<1: /144122175413370C5150=5/155/0199?C0=H1CI4*H4 5* /7: 1C 1:0C/ 7541337 14= /0 /1= 7CC?0=5/0 9/0G?0 J-57CC5150=6A5/0H7540CC5/155/0C78415?<0*45/0 9/0G?0 7C 5/15 *; 5/0 199?C0= J- 7C 5/0 <090725 504=0<0= 5* - =?<748 9<*CC0J1:74157*4 14= 5/0 H7540CC /1C 1=:7550= 5/0 C1:0 *H0>0< /0 /1C C5150= 5/15 H<75748 *4 J- 7C 4*5 74 /7C /14=H<75748 5 7C C?880C50= 5* 5/0 H7540CC 5/15 5/0 C78415?<0 ;*?4= *4 J- 7C 4*5 ;1:7371< 5* 5/0 C78415?<0 *; 1<1C/?<1: /1441221 7541337 /0 H7540CC C5150C 5/15 75 7C 5/0 C78415?<0*;5/0199?C0=1:0C/7541337 - 7 - ! 01<40= 9*?4C03 ;*< 5/0 199?C0= C?880C50= 5* - 5/15 *4 #--##$- 5/0 199?C0= /1= 9*:0 5* 5/0 C/*2 *; 5/0 9*:23174145 2?<9/1C0= 1<57930C H*<5/ C- 217= 91C/ *; C 14= 5*H1<=C 5/0 6131490 *; 1:*?45 *; C-$$$$ /0 /1= 7CC?0= 1 9/0G?0 0 /1C 2301=0= /7C 784*<1490 16*?5 5/0 5<14C1957*4 5 7C 13C* C?880C50= 5* 5/0 H7540CC 5/15 *4 5/15=1505/0199?C0=/1=30;5/7C618745/0C/*2*;5/0 9*:23174145 14= 5/0 9*:23174145 /1= C5*304 5/0 9/0G?0 301; H/79/ 7C 1C 20< J- 150< /0 /1C ;7330= 5/0 C1:0 14= :7C?C0= 75 /0 H7540CC /1C =0470= 5/0 C1:0 14= C5150= 5/15 5/0 199?C0= /1= 87>04 /7: 5/0 9/0G?0 1;50< ;7337487514=/0/1C4*5H<7550414A5/748*45/09/0G?0 J, 7C 5/0 <023A 7CC?0= 6A 5/0 199?C0= <0;0<<748 5* /7C 41:0 1C 1<1C/?<1: /1441221 7541337 *H0>0< 75 7C 20<574045 5* 4*50 5/15 5/0 199?C0= 40>0< =0470=5/15/0H1C13C*I4*H41C1:0C/754133745/0 9*:231745 /0 7C <0;0<<0= 5* 1C 1:0C/ 7541337 14= 5/0 C1:0 H1C 40>0< =7C2?50= 6A 5/0 199?C0= 4 5/0 *5/0< - 8 - /14= /0 12201<0= 60;*<0 5/0 <713 *?<5 <02<0C0450= 6A /7C 1=>*9150 J 7C 5/0 30813 4*5790 1==<0CC0= 5* 1:0C/75413375/0C1:0H1C1990250=6A5/0199?C0=5* H/79//0/1=87>04<023A1C20<J, -$ 4 5/0 <023A 4*5790 5/0 199?C0= =0470= 6*<<*H748 *; 14A 1:*?45 ;<*: 5/0 9*:23174145 5 7C 9*4504=0= 5/15 5/0 199?C0= 91:0 5* 5/0 C/*2 *; 5/0 9*:23174145 H75/ 1 91C/ 618 ;*< 5/0 2?<2*C0 *; 8055748 G?*5157*4 ;<*: 5/0 1350<415*< 5* 7<3*CI1< *:214A /0 9*:23174145/1=87>045/0G?*5157*4*4$"-$#$- 150< 5/0199?C0=30;55/0C/*2*;5/09*:23174145A:7C51I0 /030;55/091C/6185/0<075C03;;50<C*:057:0/091:0 619I14=9*330950=/7C91C/61814=H/04/0<0907>0=5/0 308134*5790/091:05*I4*H5/155/0199?C0=/1=C5*304 9/0G?0 301; ;<*: 5/0 9/0G?0 6**I I025 74 5/0 91C/ 618 14= :7C?C0= 5/0 C1:0 *H0>0< 75 7C 20<574045 5* 4*50 5/155/0199?C0=40>0<=0470=075/0</7C41:01C1:0C/ 7541337*<5/0C78415?<0;*?4=*45/09/0G?0J- - 9 - -- /0 199?C0=/1C C50220=745* H7540CC6*J 14= =02*C0=1C-45/01;;7=1>75CH*<45*6A5/0199?C0= 74 370? *; 0J1:74157*4749/70; /0 C5150= 5/15 /0 /1= 40>0< 51I04 /14= 3*14 ;<*: 5/0 9*:23174145 4*< /1= /0 7CC?0= 5/0 9/0G?0 J- *H0>0< =?<748 090:60< #$- H/04 /0 /1= 6004 5* 5/0 C/*2*; 5/0 9*:23174145 14= 2?<9/1C0= 1<57930C H*<5/ C-$$$ 217= 91C/ *; C$$$ 14=7CC?0=9/0G?0;*<C-$$$$ 030;55/0 91C/ 618 H75/ 5/0 9/0G?0 6**I 74 5/0 C/*2 *; 5/0 9*:23174145150</09*330950=5/0C1:0;50<<090725*; 5/0 30813 4*5790 /0 91:0 5* I4*H 5/15 5/0 9*:23174145 /1=C5*3045/09/0G?0301;14=:7C?C0=5/0C1:0?<748 9<*CC0J1:74157*4H7540CC1=:5750=5/15J"5/02*C513 19I4*H30=80:045601<C/7CC78415?<0>1I1315/41:1;730= *4 /7C 60/13; 14= =02*C757*4 601<C /7C C78415?<0C *H0>0< /0 =0470= 5/15 J- 601<C /7C C78415?<0 5 7C ;*<5/0;7<C557:05/0199?C0==0470=5/0C78415?<0;*?4= *4J-14==7C2?50=5/0C1:0 - 10 - -# ?<7489<*CC0J1:74157*4757CC5150=5/151;50< <090725 *;5/030813 4*5790 H/04 /0 91:0 5* I4*H 16*?5 5/0:7C?C0*;9/0G?06A5/09*:23174145/0/1=4*5;730= 14A 9*:231745 18174C5 5/0 9*:23174145 5 7C C?6:7550= 5/15 J# 7C 5/0 21CC6**I H/79/ =*0C 4*5 C514= 74 /7C 41:0 0 C5150C 5/15 75 603*48C 5* /7C H7;0 0 13C* C?6:75C 5/15 J-$ <0;0<C 5* 5/0 0J5<195 *; A *-$! -*;180H1=7>733180C514=748745/041:0 *; 199?C0= H/0<074 15 9*3?:4 *-- 74=79150C 5/0 3*14 *651740=6A/7: -% /0 *<13 14= =*9?:0451<A 0>7=0490 23190= 60;*<0 5/0 *?<5 =7C93*C0C 5/15 0>04 5/*?8/ 5/0 9*:231741457CC?0=5/0308134*57901==<0CC0=5*1:0C/ 7541337 5/0 C1:0 H1C 1990250= 6A 5/0 199?C0= H75/*?5 14A =0:?< 14= /0 7CC?0= 5/0 <023A 74 5/0 41:0 *; 1<1C/?<1: /1441221 7541337 *H0>0< 74 5/0 <023A 4*5790 5/0 199?C0= 40>0< =0470= /7C 41:0 1C 1:0C/ 75413374*<=7=/09*4504=0=5/155/09/0G?074G?0C57*4 =*0C 4*5 601< /7C C78415?<0 >04 =?<748 9<*CC - 11 - 0J1:74157*4 *; - 5/0<0 7C 4* C2097;79 =04713 *; 5/0 C78415?<0;*?4=*4J-/730;737485/01;;7=1>7574370? *; 0J1:74157*4749/70; 199?C0= =0470= 5/15 J- 601<C /7C C78415?<0 *H0>0< 5/0 199?C0= /1C 4*5 C*?8/5 ;*< <0;0<<748 5/0 9/0G?0J- ;*< /14=H<75748 0J20<5 /0 199?C0= 1=:75C 5/15 J" 2*C513 19I4*H30=80:045 5/0 >1I1315/ ;730= *4 /7C 60/13; 14= 5/0 =02*C757*4C 601< /7C C78415?<0C ; 5/*C0 1=:7550= C78415?<0C 1<0 9*:21<0= H75/5/0C78415?<0;*?4=*4J-759144*560C17=5/15 5/0 C78415?<0 *4 J- 7C 1 ;*<80= *40 0 =*0C 4*5 805 14AC?22*<5;*<5/0=0;049051I04151603150=C51806A =04A748/7CC78415?<0*4J- - /04 5/0 199?C0= 1=:75C 5/15 5/0 9/0G?0 J-603*48C5*/7C614I199*?4574757133A=*0C4*5=04A /7C C78415?<0 ;*?4= 5/0<0*4 14= =0470C 75 *43A H/04 /0 H1C 0J1:740= 1C - 14= *4 9*:21<7C7*4 *; 5/0 C78415?<0;*?4=*4J-H75/5/01=:7550=C78415?<0C*; 199?C0= =* 4*5 ;74= 14A C?6C51490 74 C?9/ =0;0490 51I04 6A 5/0 199?C0= 4=0< C?9/ 97<9?:C51490C 5/0 - 12 - 2<0C?:257*4 ?4=0< 0957*4C --! 14= -% *; 95 H*?3= 1<7C0 74 ;1>*?< *; 5/0 9*:23174145 14= 18174C5 199?C0= 5 7C 5/0 C05530= 2<*2*C757*4 *; 31H 5/15 5/0 2<0C?:257*4 ?4=0< 0957*4 -% *; 95 7493?=0C 5/0 2<0C?:257*4<081<=7480J7C50490*;5/0308133A04;*<901630 =065/06?<=04C/7;5C*45/0199?C0=5*<06?55/030813 2<0C?:257*4 >04 5/*?8/ 5/0 199?C0= H1C 9<*CC 0J1:740=-1530485/14=0J1:740=/7:C03;1C- /0/1C4*52<*616137K0/7C=0;04905019/C51807015 5/0 57:0 *; C04=748 5/0 <023A 4*5790 1C 20< J, H/730 9<*CC0J1:74748-14=H/730;737485/01;;7=1>7574370? *; 0J1:74157*4749/70; 5* 0J1:740 /7: 1C - 5/0 199?C0= 8*0C *4 7:2<*>748 /7C >0<C7*4 <081<=748 >7C75748 5/0C/*2*;5/09*:2317414514=301>7485/06185/0<05* 041630 5/0 9*:23174145 5* C5013 5/0 9/0G?0 301; 450<0C57483A0>041;50<9*:7485*I4*H16*?55/09/0G?0 J-2<0C0450=6A5/09*:2317414514=8*5=7C/*4*<0= 5/0199?C0= /1C4*5 9/*C045* ;730 14A 9*:231745 18174C5 5/09*:23174145;*<C50137485/09/0G?014=:7C?C7485/0 - 13 - C1:0 /0 <01C*4 1CC7840= 6A 5/0 199?C0= 5/15 15 5/15 57:0 5/0<0 H1C =031A 14= 5/0<0;*<0 /0 /1= 4*5 ;730= 5/0 9*:2317459144*5601990250=74>70H*;5/0C0<7*?C40CC*; 5/013308157*4C:1=06A5/0199?C0= *2<?=045:14H733 I002G?7057;5/09*:23174145C5013C5/09/0G?0301;14= :7C?C0C5/0C1:06A;*<8748/7CC78415?<0C14=2<0C0450= ;*< 0491C/:045 1I748 C?9/ 749*4C7C5045 =0;0490 6A 5/0 199?C0= 75C03; H733 4*5 <06?5 5/0 30813 2<0C?:257*4 ?4=0< 0957*4 --! 14= -% *; 95 0957*4 --! *; 95 <17C0C5/0308132<0C?:257*474;1>*?<*;5/0/*3=0<*;5/0 9/0G?0<081<=7489*4C7=0<157*4=150*;5/09/0G?057:0 14=199025149014=1C5*5/004=*<C0:045C:1=05/0<074 A :0<03A <17C748 C*:0 =0;0490 H75/*?5 2<*61637K748 5/0 C1:0 H733 4*5 <06?5 5/0 30813 2<0C?:257*4C H/79/ 1<0 74 ;1>*?<*;5/09*:23174145/?C1:*;5/0*2747*45/15 5/0199?C0=/1C;1730=5*2<*616137K0/7C=0;04901C51I04 745/0<023A4*5790*<1CC?880C50=6A/7:H/730=02*C748 1C - 4=0< C?9/ 97<9?:C51490C /0 7C 371630 ;*< 9*4>7957*4 - 14 - - /1>08*405/*?8/5/07:2?840=@?=8:045*; 19G?75513 21CC0= 6A 5/0 <713 *?<5 /0 <713 *?<5 /1C <78/53A /03=5/15 5/0 199?C0= 1=:7550=5/0 9/0G?0 J- 1C75603*48C5*/7:14=75601<C/7CC78415?<0/0<0;*<0 5/0 30813 2<0C?:257*4 ?4=0< 0957*4C -% *; 95 H*?3=1<7C074/7C;1>*?<*H0>0<759*::7550=140<<*< 74/*3=7485/155/0199?C0=/1=<17C0=1=0;049014=5/?C <06?550= 5/0 30813 2<0C?:257*4 450<0C57483A 5/0 <713 *?<5 /1C 4*5790= 5/15 5/0<0 1<0 =7C9<0214970C 74 5/0 =0;049051I046A5/0199?C0=15019/C51806?574C2750*; 5/15 2<*900=0= 5* ;*<: 14 *2747*4 5/15 5/0 199?C0= 7C C?990CC;?374<06?557485/0308132<0C?:257*4/0<0;*<0 1: *; 5/0 *2747*4 5/15 5/0 7:2?840= @?=8:045 *; 19G?75513 21CC0= 6A 5/0 <713 *?<5 7C 0<<*40*?C 14= 5/0 C1:0 371630 5* 60 C05 1C7=0 14= 5/0 199?C0= 7C 371630 ;*< 9*4>7957*4 -" 01<=<081<=748C0450490 -, /09/0G?0J-7C=150=$!-##$-"1I748 745*9*4C7=0<157*45/0;195C14=97<9?:C51490C1:*;5/0 - 15 - *2747*4 5/15<01C*41630 1:*?45 *; C%$$$$$ 914 60 7:2*C0=1C;740*45/0199?C0= -! 4>70H*;5/016*>014CH0<5/016*>02*745 745/01;;7<:157>014=2<*900=5*21CC5/0;*33*H748 '7) /01220137C '77) /0 7:2?840= @?=8:045 *; 19G?75513 =150= - $#$#% 21CC0= 6A 5/0 7>73 ?=80 14= ( 180H1=7 7@1A12?<1 74 *% #$-7C/0<06A '777) *4C0G?0453A <0C2*4=045199?C0= 7C 9*4>7950= ;*< 5/0 *;;0490 2?47C/1630 ?4=0< 14= /0 7C C0450490= 5* 21A ;740 *; C%$$$$$ B?200C/<001I/*43AF5*60217=H75/74 $% :*45/C ;<*: 5*=1A 4 =0;1?355* 21A /0C/133?4=0<8*C7:2307:2<7C*4:045;*<1 20<7*=*;078/5:*45/C - 16 - '7>) ?5 *; 5/0 ;740 1:*?45 5* 60 217= 6A 5/0 199?C0=1C?:*;C#$$$$ 7C*<=0<0= 5* 60217=5* 5/0 9*:23174145122033145 1C 9*:204C157*4 087C5<A 7C =7<0950= 5* C04= 619I 5/0 <713 *?<5 <09*<=C 13*48 H75/ 9*2A *; 5/7C @?=8:045 ;*< 74;*<:157*4 14=400=;?31957*4;*<7CC?1490*;9*4>7957*4H1<<145 18174C55/0199?C0= ,( #' " 7C5 *-3 *-