- 1 - !"# $ % & && '#( ) ! " #$ % &'#"$" &'#$" ( ")"$$) " ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "*) "! $""$ *+ $"* , % " -./011203./142524426789-2:30.;0<90=0.</9 9-2>6=;2<90<60?04660926$""$10//26.< @*+ $"* 78 9-2 2<.@4 .A.3 >6=2 0<6 0/0A0B0380< 5@4 /-@49 C9-2 94.7><03D! /22B.<= 2<-0<:2;2<9@59-2:@;12</09.@< -2.<E>426:30.;0<90=26$8204/?@4B.<=0/ @12409@4 .< 0=-;@42 ;.3B .048 0<6 204<.<= 0 />; @5 /"$$$$ & ;29 ?.9- 0::.62<9 @< "*$$"* 0<6 />552426 =4.2A@>/ .<E>4.2/ 2 9@@B 94209;2<9 .< 9-2 @/1.90325.326:30.;129.9.@<725@429-294.7><03/22B.<= :@;12</09.@<@5/"$$$$$ &03@<=?.9-.<9242/95924 - 3 - :@</.624.<= 9-2 2<9.42 2A.62<:2 @< 42:@46 9-2 94.7><03 0?046260/>;@5/#*""+$ &03@<=?.9-.<9242/9099-2 4092 @5 FG 124 0<<>; 54@; 9-2 6092 @5 129.9.@< 9.33 9-2 6092@54203.H09.@<2.<=0==4.2A26789-2/0.6>6=;2<9 0<6 0?046 9-2 :30.;0<9 142524426 9-2 142/2<9 011203 /22B.<=2<-0<:2;2<9@59-2:@;12</09.@<0?04626789-2 94.7><03 ) <9-2 142/2<9011203 .9 ./ :@<92<6269-099-2 :30.;0<9 2I0;.<26 9-2 @:9@4 -2 @:9@4 .//>26 6./07.3.98:249.5.:092?-.:-./;04B2609I""/1249-2 6./07.3.98 :249.5.:092 9-2 6@:9@4 0 26 9-2 6./07.3.98 @5 9-2:30.;0<909)'G7>99-294.7><03-0/90B2<@<38"$G -2:30.;0<9?0/06;.9926.<9-2@/1.903@<"*$$"* 0<66./:-04=26@<#$)$"*2?0/-@/1.903.H265@4)* 608/ -2 :30.;0<9 />/90.<26 ;>39.132 =4.2A@>/ .<E>4.2/ -20;@><9/=40<926><6246.55242<9-206/789-294.7><03 042 @< 3@?24 /.62 0<6 <@ 0;@><9 ./ =40<926 ><624 9-2 -2063@//@50;2<.9.2/->/-242J>2/9/5@42<-0<:2;2<9 @59-2:@;12</09.@< - 4 - # 2046 9-2 04=>;2<9/ @5 9-2 3204<26 :@></23/ 54@;7@9-/.62/ -@>=- -2 ?0/ ?@4B.<= 0/ @12409@4 .< 0=-;@42 .3B 0.48 0<6 204<.<= 0 />; @5 /"$$$$ & -2-0/<@95.3260<8.<:@;214@@59@14@A2-./.<:@;2< A.2?@59-2=>.623.<2/.//>26789-204<090B090922=03 24A.:2/>9-@4.989-2.<:@;2@59-2:30.;0<95@49-28204 $"* ./ 9@ 72 90B2< 09 /"$$ & -2 94.7><03 -0/ 4.=-938 90B2< 9-2 .<:@;2 @5 9-2 :30.;0<9 09 /"$$ & ?-.:- <226/ <@ .<9245242<:2 -2 :30.;0<9 2I0;.<26 9-2 @:9@4 / 124 9-2 ?@><6 :249.5.:092 9-2 :30.;0<9 />/90.<26 @;1 540:9>42 3259 ;26.03 ;033@>/ ?.9- 6./3@:09.@< @5 3259 1092330 0<6 @< 3259 1@13.92403 5@// ?-.:- 042 =4.2A@>/ .< <09>42 -2 @:9@4 0 26 9-2 6./07.3.9809)'G9@9-2?-@327@687>99-294.7><03-0/ 90B2< "$G .</9206 @5 ")G -2425@42 9-2 3@// @5 5>9>42 .<:@;2:@;2/9@ /"$$ &K"K"'K")GL/'*'$ & - 5 - F -24.7><03-0/=40<926/$+*+$ &9@?046/ ;26.:032I12</2/0<6.9<226/<@.<9245242<:2 * -2 0112330<9 ?0/ 06;.9926 .< 9-2 -@/1.903 5@4 )* 608/ @</.624.<=9-2<09>42 @5.<E>4.2/0<6124.@6@5 -@/1.903./09.@< 9-./ @>49 5.<6/ .9 420/@<0732 9@ =40<9 0< 0;@><9@5/*$$$ &5@410.<0<6/>5524.<=/$$$ & 5@4 3@// @5 0;2<.9.2/ 0<6 /)$$$$ & 5@4 940</1@4909.@< 2I940<@>4./-;2<90<60992<60<9:-04=2/ ' -2 0112330<9 ;.=-9 <@9 -0A2 0992<626 0<8 ?@4B 09 320/9 5@4 0 124.@6 @5 9-422 ;@<9-/ 6>2 9@ 9-2 .<E>4.2//>/90.<26-2425@42-2./2<9.93265@40<0;@><9 @5 /)$*$ & /"$$ I )! 5@4 3@// @5 .<:@;2 6>4.<= 30.6>1124.@6 + -2 4.7><03 -0/ 03/@ =40<926 /"$$$$ & 9@?046/ 5>9>42 ;26.:03 2I12</2/ 0<6 .9 <226/ <@ .<9245242<:2 "$ 2<:29-20112330<9./2<9.93265@49-2;@6.5.26 :@;12</09.@<><6246.55242<9-206/0/723@? - 6 - 0.<0<6/>5524.<= /*$$$ & 26.:032I12</2/ /$+*+$ & >9>42;26.:032I12</2/ /"$$$$ & @//@55>9>42204<.<=/ /'*'$ & @//@5.<:@;26>4.<=30.6>1124.@6 /)$*$ & 40</1@4909.@< 2I940 <@>4./-;2<9 0<60992<60<9:-04=2/ /)$$$$ & @//@50;2<.9.2/ /$$$ & @903 2//0?04626784.7><03 <-0<:2;2<9 /FF')F$ & /#*""+$ & *+!+! & -2 </>40<:2 @;10<8 -0/ 0342068 621@/.926 9-2 0;@><9 0?04626 78 9-2 4.7><03 ->/ 9-2 0112330<9 ./ 2<9.93265@42<-0<:26:@;12</09.@<@5/"+*"*$ &?.9- .<9242/9 09 FG 124 0<<>; 0<6 9-2425@42 9-2 011203 62/24A2/9@72033@?26.<1049 "" <9-242/>399-25@33@?.<=@4624./10//26 .! 11203./033@?26.<1049 ..! -2 0112330<9 :30.;0<9 ./ 2<9.9326 5@4 9-2 2<-0<:26 :@;12</09.@< @5 /"+*"*$ & ?.9- .<9242/9 09 FG 124 0<<>; 54@; 9-2 6092 @5 129.9.@< 9.33 9-2 6092 @5 4203./09.@< - 7 - ...! 2/1@<62<9 @&</>40<:2 @;10<8 ./ 6.42:926 9@ 621@/.9 9-2 05@42/0.6 :@;12</09.@< 0;@><9 ?.9-.<@<2;@<9-54@;9-26092@59-./E>6=;2<9 .A! < />:- 621@/.9 9-2 0112330<9 ./ 124;.9926 9@ ?.9-640? 9-2 2<9.42 0;@><9 03@<= ?.9- .<9242/9 0::4>26 @<.9 *,- '& ( % ./9 @"3 @## &