Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92479 (KAR)
MOHAMMED ARIF ALEEM v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
WP/203537/2025 · 2025-11-17
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92479 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92479 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$%
&%'!%!%
()!*
! "
# $%&
! '
! ( ) )
) ) * ! ) ! ) $
% ($
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!* ) ! $
) ) $
! ) ! $
**' ) ! +
! )% ! % ! ! * ) $ $
!' $ ) ! ! $
! ) ! - 3 -
( ! ) ! ' $
' ! ) ! ( $
) ) % ) )! ! $
$ $
'** ! $ ) !!!! , ! ! + - ! "
# %
' +&
$ '' ''+
&
- 4 -
$ , !*'!' +
'!'' - , !!('!' '
(
'!'(' - '
'!'(' !+ '!'( -. & $
/ ((
0 ( ,
$
1%
#1% &
2343456478295:23;475<:3722=46>95??5@46>:2?429 A& 77<2 A @:4359 B2:345:A:4 C<A7;46> 3;2 4DE<>62F 5:F2:FA32F !*'!'46 4?25
+
'!'' EA772F 8G :27E56F263 5 A7 E2: 662H<:2
B5672C<263?G723A74F23;24DE<>62F5:F2:FA32F !!('!' EA772F 8G 3;2 '6F :27E56F263 46 EE2A? (
'!'('A7E2:662H<:2A6F D<3A3456 5:F2: 46 5'
'!'(' FA32F !+ '!'(EA772F8G:27E56F26357 A6F A7E2:662H<:2. 8& 77<2@:4359DA6FAD<7F4:2B346>3;2:27E56F263 A<3;5:43G 35 D<3A32 3;2 6AD2 59 3;2 E23434562:
756/746 :27E2B3 59G5((
0 D2A7<:46> ( AB:2 ><63A7 A3 A>A6A;A??4 I4??A>2 C A6F 473 A?A8<:A>4
- 5 -
' A72 59 3;2 E23434562: 47 3;A3 ?A6F 82A:46> G5((
0 D2A7<:46> !( AB:27 ! ><63A7 743<A32F A3 A>A6A??4 4??A>2 A?A8<A>4 A?<= A6F 473:4B3 5:4>46A??G 82?56>2F35562;A74D822$
5G2F4GA6;2EA772F A@AG ?2AI46> 82;46F 95<: 7567 6AD2?G G2F 8F<? J4J G2F <?AD A755? G2F <?AD <7724682 A6F G2F <?AD A8228 ;A3 3;24: 6AD27 @2:2 D<3A32F 46 3;2 :2I26<2 :2B5:F7 G2F 8F<? J4J 3;2 94:73 756 EA772F A@AG ?2AI46> 82;46F ;47 @492 A6F 94I2 B;4?F:26 6AD2?G &G2F84FK22K'&G2FAK4F(&G2F;A?4FK22K & G2FA A94GA <?3A6A A6F & G2FA %AD4?A <?3A6A G2F %AD4?A <?3;A6 47 3;2 @492 59 3;2 E23434562: ;2:246 ;247A?7526343?2F95:7;A:2463;2E:5E2:3G59;A74D822 3;:5<>;;2:9A3;2:46B23;27A4FG2F%AD22?A<?3;A6A EA772F A@AG ?2AI46> 82;46F E23434562: A6F 3@5 7567 6AD2?G5;ADD2F :9A6 D34GAJA6F5;ADD2F D:A6 3;A33;2E23434562:A6F;473@57567A:226343?2F95:7;A:2 46 3;2 E:5E2:3G 3;A3 82?56>2F 35 G2F %AD4?A <?3;A6A 5@2I2:746B23;2E:4IA32:27E56F2637;AI265346B?<F2F
- 6 -
;2:6AD2463;2:2I26<2:2B5:F777<B;3;2E23434562: E:292::2FA6AEE2A?8295:23;277473A635DD4774562:46 E:5B22F46>7 46 EE2A? 5 (
'!'(' ;A3 8G 5:F2: FA32F!!('!'3;277473A635DD4774562::2K2B32F3;2 AEE2A? :2?2>A346> 3;2 E23434562: ;2:246 35 AEE:5AB; 3;2 B5DE23263 5<:3 59 ?A@ 722=46> EA:343456 A6F 72EA:A32 E577277456 59 3;2 ?A6F 246> A>>:42I2F ;2 E:292::2F A :2I42@ E2343456 8295:2 3;2 2E<3G 5DD4774562: G 26F5:72D263FA32F !*'!'3;22E<3G5DD4774562:
B5694:D2F 3;2 5:F2: 59 3;2 77473A63 5DD4774562: A6F :2?2>A32F 3;2 E23434562: ;2:246 35 B4I4?
5<:3 35 722= EA:343456 A6F 273A8?47; ;47 :4>;3 A6F 3;2:2A932: 35 722= AEE:5E:4A32:2D2FG>>:42I2F8G3;27AD23;2E23434562: 478295:23;475<:3 ( 2A:F2:<72F3;2:2B5:F7
;2E23434562:B?A4D735823;2;<78A6F59G2F %AD4?A <?3;A6A 47 BA72 47 3;A3 ;47 @492 G2F %AD4?A <?3;A6A ;AF 46;2:432F ;2: 7;A:2 46 3;2 E:5E2:3G 3;A3 5:4>46A??G82?56>2F35;A74D822A6F?A32:A??5332F353;2
- 7 -
7;A:259;2:9A3;2:46B23;2E23434562:47B?A4D46>7;A:2 46 3;2 @49217 E:5E2:3G <634? 3;2 F232:D46A3456 59 3;2 7A4F 7;A:2 47 DAF2 ;47 :2C<2737 95: 46B?<7456 59 3;2 7AD2 46 3;2:2I26<2:2B5:F7;AI28226F2B?462F8G3;2A<3;5:43427 3 47 7226 3;A3 3;2:2 AEE2A:7 35 ;AI2 8226 A 7<43 46 5 !!+
** 3;A3 ;AF 8226 94?2F AD56>73 3;2 B;4?F:26 59 AG2F 8F<? K4K 42 3;2 748?46>7 59 G2F %AD4?A <?3;A6A @492 59 3;2 E23434562: 6 @;4B; %AD4?A <?3;A6A 3;2 @492 59 E23434562: ;A7 8226 7;5@6 A7 F2926FA635;27A4F7<43;A7B<?D46A32F46EA7746>59 3;2946A?F2B:2256'!!* **!;2E:5E2:3G@;4B;4765@ 75<>;33582B?A4D2F463;2E2343456476537<8K2B3DA332:
59 3;2 7A4F 7<43 5 2HE?A6A3456 47 95<:3; B5D46> 46 3;47 :2>A:F
6 3;2 ?4>;3 59 3;2 A95:27A4F A7E2B3 59 3;2 DA332:3;475<:3F5653722A6G4::2><?A:43G463;25:F2:7 EA772F 8G 3;2 77473A63 5DD4774562: B5694:D2F 8G 3;2 2E<3G 5DD4774562: F4:2B346> 3;2 E23434562: ;2:246 35
- 8 -
722= AEE:5E:4A32 :2D2FG 46 3;2 DA662: =65@6 35 ?A@ 8295:2AB5DE23263B4I4?5<:3
272:I46> 7<B; ?482:3G 59 273A8?47;46> ;47 :4>;3 343?2A6F26343?2D26346:27E2B3593;2E:5E2:3G65@8246> 75<>;38G3;2E23434562:E234345647
!+) (%!%* '
4735 ?5'