- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ "" %& ' !"# $ % & ' ' % ( & ( ' ) * (( + !,# % & $ % & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( - - ( . - ( "" - .,.#" - - ( - ( .,.#" #.# - - ( - /( ' - ( - - ( ' - ( /( - ( ' ( 0 ( 0 ( - $ % 0 ( & 123456171238149:;8<17=:35612>>177285 - 3 - . 6?< :;35 62< ?<<;14 8:5?91 2@2?8<5 561 31<>:84185 284 31<>:84185 1237?13 31>31<18514 563:;@6 9:;8<17 284 72513 561 9:;8<17 315?314 =3:A 561 92<1 61312=51356131<>:841854?48:518@2@128B9:;8<17 6?< 2>>127 ?< =?714 2@2?8<5 561 4?<A?<<27 := >15?5?:8 =?714 ;8413 195?:8 := ?84; 233?2@1 95 =:3 4?<<:7;5?:8:=561A233?2@142514"#.## 61 =295;27 A253?C := 92<1 := 561 2>>177285>15?5?:813 D1=:31 561 3?27 :;35 ?8 :.,.#" ?< 5625 D:56 := 561A A233?14 :8 "#.## 284 561312=513 <61 624 E:?814 A253?A:8?27 6:A1 8 561 <2?4 F147:9G D:56 := 561A 62H?8@ 2 42;@6513 284 27<: D:56 := 561A 231 7?H?8@ 25 28@27:31 >>177285 62H?8@ 8:5?914 561 >19;7?23 825;31 := 561 31<>:84185<?891<61;<145:>?9G;>I;23317<F?566?A284 :DE195?8@ 6?< >23185< 284 :5613 31725?H1< F6: 9:A1< 5: 28@27:31 1<>:84185 8:5 :87B ;<14 5: I;23317 F?56 >15?5?:8131H18I;1<5?:8?8@6?A2<5:F6B61;<145:527G - 4 - F?56 6?< F:A28 9:7712@;1< 6:;@6 61 53?14 5: 9:8H?891 61356256162<D118F:3G?8@?82A;75?825?:8279:A>28B 27:8@F?56@::48;AD13:=F:A189:7712@;1<2846162< 5:527GF?56561A?89:88195?:8F?566?<>3:=1<<?:8274;5B 284 31<>:8<?D?7?5B D;5 <61 ?< 8:5 9:8H?8914 61 31<>:84185 D1?8@ 2 F:A28 := 8233:F A?84 41H17:>14 <;<>?9?:8 5625 561 >15?5?:813 ?< 62H?8@ <:A1 G?84 := 31725?:8< F?56 6?< F:A18 9:7712@;1< 284 56;< 31725?:8< D15F118 561 >15?5?:813 284 31<>:84185 <523514 D19:A?8@ <532?814 42B DB 42B 8:5 :87B 561 31<>:84185 41H17:>14 62D?5 := 712H?8@ 561 6:;<1 284 315;38?8@ 5: 613 >23185*< 6:;<15:<52B?8@=:3A:856<5:@15613F?56:;59:A?8@D29G 5:561A253?A:8?276:A1 " 61>15?5?:813A28B5?A1<2>>3:29614613284 31I;1<514 613 5: 9:A1 D29G 5: A253?A:8?27 6:A1 284 31<>:84185 31=;<14 5: 9:A1 D29G 284 @2H1 563125 := 7:4@?8@9:A>72?85 , 5 ?< 27<: 9:8518414 5625 28962B25 F2< 27<: 6174:8##.#"25 ?423284<6127<:2>>3:29614561 - 5 - 1F :F8 :7?91 525?:8 ?423 :8 #.#" D;5 561 >:7?91 4?4 8:5 31@?<513 561 9:A>72?85 284 24H?<14 613 5: @156134?<>;51<155714563:;@617413A1AD13<:=D:56561 =2A?7B D;5 <61 4?4 8:5 2@311 1891 561 >15?5?:813 @:5 ?<<;145618:5?91:8..#5:E:?86136;<D284D;5 <614?48:55;38;>1891615::G561419?<?:85:=?712 >31<185>15?5?:8F?56:;528B:561327513825?H1 8 31<>:8<1 5: 56?< >15?5?:8 31<>:84185 2>>12314 284 =?714 F3?5518 <5251A185 418B?8@ 561 2771@25?:8< A241 ?8 561 >15?5?:8 284 31<>:84185 9:85184 5625<6127F2B<53?145:A2G161371H17D1<55:31<?41F?56 >15?5?:813D;5561>15?5?:813?<244?95145:D2462D?5<7?G1 @2AD7?8@ 159 284 4;1 5: F6?96 61 27F2B< A185277B284 >6B<?9277B5:35;31<56131<>:841854;3?8@613<52B:8561 24H?91 := 6?< A:5613 <?<513 284 :5613 =2A?7B A1AD13< 61 31<>:84185 62< 5:7132514 277 6?< >6B<?927 284 A18527 5:35;31 ?8 :3413 5: 9:85?8;1 613 A233?14 7?=1 F?56 561 >15?5?:813 ;5 561 >15?5?:813 6?A<17= 62< 43?H18 :;5 561 31<>:84185 =3:A 6?< 6:;<1 DB 2<<2;75?8@ 613 5618 561 - 6 - 31<>:84185 62< 7:4@14 561 9:A>72?85 2@2?8<5 561 >15?5?:813 D;5561 >15?5?:813 62< A282@14 561 >:7?91 8:5 5: 31@?<513 561 92<1 2@2?8<5 561A 61 A2?8 ?85185?:8 := 561>15?5?:813?<56255::D52?8561419311:=4?H:3912845: @?H1561A18527284>6B<?9275:35;315:56131<>:84185 -;35613>15?5?:813<;DE195146135:6232<<A185 284 62< 8:5 @?H18 28B A2?85182891 =3:A 561 4251 := 43?H?8@ 613 :;5 =3:A 561 A253?A:8?27 6:;<1 : A28B 5?A1< 561 >23185< := 561 31<>:84185 284 31<>:84185 613<17=284174137B>13<:8<62H12>>3:29614561>15?5?:813 28431I;1<5146?A5:52G1D29G56131<>:84185D;5614?4 8:5 277:F 561 31<>:84185 284 41<13514 613 1891 >15?5?:813?<8:5185?5714=:328B317?1=2<972?A14 61 3?27 :;35 62H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561 2H13A185< := >15?5?:8 2< F177 2< 561 :DE195?:8 <5251A185 =?714 277:F14 561 >235?1< 5: 7124 1H?41891 15?5?:813 @:5 6?A<17= 1C2A?814 2< ' 284 @:5 A23G14 56311 4:9;A185< 2< C 5: C 284 27<: 1C2A?814 561 F?581<<1< 284 :8 561 :5613 6284 56:;@6 31<>:84185 - 7 - 1C2A?814 613<17= ?8 96?1= 1H?41891 4?4 8:5 <;DE195 =:3 93:<<1C2A?825?:8 # 61 3?27 :;35 62H?8@ 52G18 8:51 := 561 A2513?27 2H2?72D71 :8 319:34 284 27<: >235?9;7237B 9:8<?413?8@56124A?<<?:8:8561>235:='4;3?8@561 9:;3<1:=93:<<1C2A?825?:8F6?9662<D1181C5329514?8 >232@32>6 : 284 27<: 312<:8< 231 @?H18 ?8 >232@32>6 :.9:8<?413?8@56124A?<<?:8< 56254;3?8@5619:;3<1 := 93:<< 1C2A?825?:8 ' 9251@:3?9277B 24A?5514 5625 31<>:84185 714 613 7?=1 F?56 6;<D284 25 28@27:31 284 1H18 F618 <;@@1<5?:8 F2< A241 5625 <61 F2< 27F2B< 3124B 5: D1 F?56 6?A 284 561 <2?4 2771@25?:8 F2< 418?14 284 27<: 9251@:3?9277B 24A?5514 5625 8: 9:A>72?85 F2< @?H182@2?8<5613=:3A2G?8@2771@25?:8284<;DE195?8@6?A =:393;175B284?8>232@32>68:27<:52G188:51:=561 <2A12849:A1<5:5619:897;<?:85625561F:34)93;175B* 62< 8:5 D118 41=?814284 ?562< D118 ;<14 ?8 31725?:8 5: 6;A28 9:84;95 :3 6;A28 D162H?:3 5 ?< 561 9:84;95 ?8 31725?:8 5: :3 ?8 31<>195 := A253?A:8?27 4;5?1< 284 - 8 - :D7?@25?:8< 284 561 <2A1 ?< 8:5 D118 >3:H14 284 61891 4?<A?<<14561>15?5?:8 1?8@2@@3?1H14DB561<2?4:3413 282>>127?<=?714D1=:3156?<:;35 61A2?89:85185?:8:=5612>>177285>15?5?:813 9:;8<17 ?< 5625 561 3?27 :;35 9:AA?5514 28 133:3 ?< 8:5 >3:>137B9:8<?413?8@5611H?418912H2?72D71:8319:34284 27<: ?5 =2?714 5: 52G1 8:51 := 561 =295 5625 31<>:84185 56:;@6 1C2A?814 613<17= D;5 8:5 <;DE19514 5: 93:<< 1C2A?825?:82842>235=3:A56251H?41891:='<!. 284F13127<:8:59:8<?413142849:AA?551428133:3?8 ?8H:G?8@561:==1891;8413195?:8%&%2&:=561?84; 233?2@195 %6131?8 2=51331=133145: 2< )561 95*& 284?5 31I;?31<?8513=131891 . 6171238149:;8<17=:35612>>177285?8<;>>:35 := 6?< 23@;A185 61 317?14 ;>:8 561 E;4@A185 31>:3514?8 284 :8*D71 >1C :;35 9:8<?413?8@ 561 92<1 := >19?27 233?2@1 95 " ?1 195?:8 . F6?71 @3285?8@ 317?1= - 9 - ?8H:G14 35?971 . := 561 :8<5?5;5?:8 := 84?2 284 561 <2A1?<27<:4?<9;<<14?8>232@32>6 : 123814 9:;8<17 =:3 561 2>>177285 27<: 317?14 ;>:8 561 E;4@A185 := 31>:3514 ?8 ;>31A1 :;35 ! " F6131?8 4?<9;<<?:8 F2< A241 F?56 31@234 5: 561 93;175B ?< 9:8913814F6252A:;855:293;175B2@2?8<56;<D2848 562592<1>15?5?:8F2<=?714;8413195?:8%&%2&:=561 95 62H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561 >3?89?>71 72?4 4:F8 ?8 561 E;4@A18528427<:561@3:;84<F6?9662H1D118;3@14?8 5612>>127A1A: 61 >:?85 5625 F:;74 23?<1 =:3 9:8<?41325?:8 := 56?<:;35231F615613561 32?7:;359:AA?551428133:3 ?84?<A?<<?8@561>15?5?:8=?714;8413195?:8%&:=561 ?84; 233?2@1 95J 284 F615613 ?5 31I;?31< 28B ?8513=131891:=561:;35J " 2H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561 @3:;84< ;3@14 ?8 561 2>>1272<F177561>3?89?>2772?44:F8?8561E;4@A185284 27<: 9:8<?413?8@ 561 A2513?27 :8 319:34 ?5 ?< 561 92<1 := - 10 - 561 2>>177285>15?5?:813 D1=:31 561 3?27 :;35 5625 DB ?8H:G?8@?8195?:8%&:=56195282771@25?:8?<A241 562525561?8?5?27<52@156131F1319:34?27284561B62>>?7B 7?H145:@15613 ;531<>:84185F2<7?H?8@?8 28@27:31284 27<: <61624>19;7?23825;31 284;<145:>?9G ;>I;23317 F?566?A284:DE195?8@6?<>23185<28427<::561331725?H1< 9:A?8@ 5: 561 28@27:31 284 27<: <;<>195?8@ 561 >15?5?:813 ?= 561 2>>177285>15?5?:813 527G< 5: 28B F:A18 9:7712@;1<F6:231F:3G?8@?8561<2A19:A>28B28461 F2< F:3G?8@ ?8 A;75? 825?:827 9:A>28B 27:8@ F?56 @::4 8;AD13 := F:A18 9:7712@;1< 7<: 561 31<>:84185 41H17:>14 2 62D?5 := 8:5 315;38?8@ 561 6:;<1 F6181H13 <61;<145:H?<?5613>23185276:;<1 , 61<2A1F2<418?14DB=?7?8@561<5251A185:= :DE195?:8< DB 561 31<>:84185 284 A2?8 9:85185?:8 F2< 52G18 562556:;@6 <61 53?14 5:7?H1 F?56 6?A D;5 61F2< 244?95145:D2462D?5<7?G1@2AD7?8@1594;15:F6?9661 27F2B<<;DE195?8@613=:3A18527284>6B<?9275:35;31 61 3?27 :;35 62H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561 A2513?27 2H2?72D71 :8 - 11 - 319:34 >235?9;7237B ?8 >232@32>6 : 1C5329514 561 24A?<<?:8:=561'284F6131619251@:3?9277B24A?5 56252=513561A233?2@16?<F?=1?131<>:84185E:?814561 A253?A:8?27 6:A1 25 ?423 284 27<: 9251@:3?9277B 24A?5< 5625<6181H13:DE195145:31<?4127:8@F?566?A25 ?423 7<: F618 561 I;1<5?:8 F2< >;5 5: 6?A 5625 F615613 61 624@?H1828B9:A>72?85F618<61<523514<;<>195?8@6?A 2846127<:9251@:3?9277B24A?5<56256162<8:5@?H1828B 9:A>72?85 2@2?8<5 6?< F?=1 F618 <61 <523514 <;<>195?8@ 6?<9:84;95'618561<124A?<<?:8<F13152G188:51:=DB 561 3?27 :;35 284 F618 561 <>19?=?9 2771@25?:8 F2< 27<: A2415625<61<523514<;<>195?8@6?A2D:;5F61861;<14 5: 527G 2D:;5 561 F:A18 9:7712@;1< 8: <;96 9:A>72?85 F2< 27<: @?H18 2H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561<1 24A?<<?:8< ?8 4152?7 4?<9;<<14 ?8 >232@32>6 :. 284 27<: 61 9251@:3?9277B24A?5<?856193:<<1C2A?825?:8562561@2H1 :87B 561 8:5?91 =:3 18=:39?8@ 561 9:8E;@27 3?@65< 284 8:5 =:3 4?H:391 D;5 61 624 ?8H:G14 561 >3:H?<?:8< := ;8413 195?:8 %& := 561 95 >235 =3:A 5625 56131 ?< 97123 - 12 - 24A?<<?:8:8561>235:='5625<61F2<F:3G?8@?82 >3?H251?8<5?5;5?:82<512961328427<:24A?5<9251@:3?9277B 5625<6162<9:A1=3:A2@::4=2A?7B2845625613D3:5613 F2<27<:F:3G?8@2<24:95:3284A:561327<:F:3G?8@2< 2 5129613 284 <61 >;3<;14 613 14;925?:8 1 27<: 9251@:3?9277B 24A?5< 5625 <61 81H13 972?A14 28B A2?85182891=3:A6?A284>235?9;7237B562524A?<<?:8F2< 52G18=3:A561A:;56:='5625?8>232@32>6 :":= 561 >15?5?:8 <52514 561 <2A1 61 9251@:3?927 2H13A185< A241?8>232@32>6 :"5625>3?:35:=?7?8@:=56?<>15?5?:8 61 62< <52514 5625 <61 H:7;8523?7B 71=5 561 A253?A:8?27 6:A1 284 561312=513 <61 4?4 8:5 9:A1 D29G 284 561 >31<185 >15?5?:8 F2< =?714 :8 #.#" 2H?8@ 52G18 8:51 := 277 561<1 24A?<<?:8< ?8 :3413 5: ?8H:G1 195?:8 %&:=561958:56?8@?<>72914:8319:341891 3?27 :;359:A1<5:5619:897;<?:856258:@3:;84<231A241 :;55:?8H:G1561>3:H?<?:85:@3285561317?1=2<<:;@65 123814 9:;8<17 2>>123?8@ =:3 561 2>>177285 A2?87B 317?1< ;>:8 561 E;4@A185 := 561 >1C :;35 : - 13 - 4:;D5 561 <2?4 E;4@A185 ?1 F6131?8>19?27233?2@195"195?:8. F2< 4?<9;<<14 F6?96 ?< >23? A2513?2 5: 195?:8 %& := 561 95 284 ?8 56?< E;4@A185 := 561 :8*D71 >1C :;35 ?8H:G14 35?971 . := 561 :8<5?5;5?:8 := 84?2 ?8 4?<9;<<?8@ 561 <2A1 ?8 4152?7 ?8 >232@32>6 : 284 56?< :;35 4:1< 8:5 62H1 <;96 >:F13< ;8413 35?971 . 284 561 <2?4 >:F13< 231 1C97;<?H17B H1<514 F?56 561 :8*D71 >1C :;35 : 4:;D5 561 7123814 9:;8<17 2>>123?8@ =:3 561 2>>177285 27<: 317?14 ;>:8 561 E;4@A185 := .#, F6131?8 27<: F6131 561 :8*D71 >1C :;35 4?<9;<<14 ?8 4152?7 ?8 2318432*< 92<1 31=13314 %<;>32& F6131?8 ?5 ?< 6174 5625 >13<?<5185 1==:35 =3:A 561 F?=1 5: 9:8<532?8 613 6;<D284 5: D1 <1>232514 =3:A 561 =2A?7B 9:8<5?5;51< 28 295:=93;175B5:@32854?H:39171H17?8@:=2D<:7;517B=27<1 2771@25?:8 F?56 31@234 5: 1C532 A23?527 7?=1 284 31>12514 563125< 5: 9:AA?5 <;?9?41 F:;74 27<: 2A:;85 5: A18527 93;175B2848:<;96?8@314?185<F131=:;84?856192<1:8 6284?8915612>>17728562<9251@:3?9277B24A?55145625 - 14 - F618 <61 <523514 <;<>195?8@ 6?< 9:84;95 F618 61 F2< 527G?8@27:8@F?566?<9:7712@;1<D;59712324A?<<?:8F2< @?H1856256162<8:5@?H1828B9:A>72?852@2?8<56?<F?=1 1?5613 5: 561 >:7?91 :3 28BD:4B 17<1 F?56 31@234 5: <;96 9:84;95?< 9:8913814 '618 <;96 24A?<<?:8 ?< H13B 97123 561 I;1<5?:8 := ?8H:G?8@ 561 >3?89?>71< 72?4 4:F8 ?8 561 E;4@A185 31=13314 %<;>32& 4:1< 8:5 23?<1 284 56?< E;4@A18527<:F?778:59:A1<5:5612?4:=5612>>177285 2H?8@ 9:8<?41314 561 A2513?27 :8 319:34 8: <;96 @3:;84< 231 A241 :;5 284 3?27 :;35 27<: 8:5 9:AA?5514 28B 133:3 284 9251@:3?9277B 4?<9;<<14 561 24A?<<?:8:8561>235:=5612>>1772852<F1772<<2A1?< 4?<9;<<14?8>232@32>6 :.2842843?@657B9:A1<5: 5619:897;<?:856252>>17728562<8:5A241:;528B@3:;84 5:?8H:G1195?:8%&'618<;96D1?8@56192<1F14: 8:5=?8428B@3:;845:?8513=131?8561=?84?8@<:=561 3?27 :;3528461891F128<F1314561>:?852<81@25?H1 - 15 - 8 H?1F := 561 2D:H1 4?<9;<<?:8< F1 >2<< 561 =:77:F?8@ 612>>127?<# 8H?1F:=5614?<>:<27:=561A2?82>>127>184?8@ ?85137:9;5:3B2>>7?925?:8<4:8:5<;3H?H1=:39:8<?41325?:8 () %" & $ () %& $ ?<5 :7 :