Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9247 (KAR)

SIDDAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/200347/2025 · 2025-02-06

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " !# #$ % &'"' ( ) ! " # $% ! & & ' $ ((( ! ((! ) ( ! ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - $ ! * + ' )( ! $$ + ( ! , ! ( & $ ! $ ! ! ! ( ! - 3 - ) $$ + ! ! + ! & )( ! * & + ! ! " # & ' & - $& &$ % + !! !!* + ! ( !(! $ * * $ + !)( !(! $ - 4 - + . ' ' ! /0 1023234506 70358 2/0 6093:052 4; 6<= <5>/<?<2/322<1@6358<9@8@6<A@B <3>/@639263>239 70;460 2/39 4@62 >/<AA058358 < 5423>0 :<20: !)( !(! 399@0:7?2/0609145:052 4164149358<=0023584;2/0 =0=7069 4; 2/0 <5>/<?<2 45 (!!(! 24 >4593:06 < =423454;54>45;3:05>0 ! /01023234506>45205:92/<2/0C<90A0>20:<9 <6093:0524;2/01<5>/<?<245( (!(!) 0>45205:0: 2/<22/4@8//0906D0:2/01<5>/<?<2C32/<AA/@=3A32?<5: 35208632? 94=0 :3986@52A0: =0=7069 4; 2/0 1<5>/<?<2 /<:9@7=3220:<601609052<234545! ( !(!60E@092358 2/0 609145:052 4 24 >45D050 < =002358 4; 54 >45;3:05>0 4C0D06 2/0 609145:052 4 C/4 /<: 54 64A0241A<?352/0164>00:35894;54>45;3:05>0/<:=<:0 05:4690=0529 45 2/0 601609052<2345 900=358 <9 3; 2/0 601609052<2345C<9;3692;3A0:70;4602/0609145:052 4 - 5 - C/4 >0623;30: 2/0 9385<2@609 4; 2/0 =0=7069 /0 601609052<2345 C<9 2/060<;206 1A<>0: 70;460 2/0 609145:052 4 0 2/060;460 >45205:9 2/<2 2/0 3=1@850: 164>00:3589 35D4AD358 2/0 609145:052 4 39 3=164106 <5: 542 35 >4=1A3<5>0 C32/ 2/0 &<65<2<B< <5>/<?<2 <F #42345 4; 445;3:05>0 <8<3592 2/0 :/?<B9/< <5: 1<:/?<B9/< 4; 6<=< <5>/<?<2% @A09 4; ,, #/05>0;462/ 60;0660: 24 <9 G @A09 ,,H% /0 1023234506 >45205:9 2/<2 35 93=3A<6 >36>@=92<5>09 < 446:35<20 05>/ 4; 2/39 4@62 35 + 4!() * !(! /<:E@<9/0:2/05423>060906D358A37062?242/0=0=7069 24 =4D0 < ;609/ 601609052<2345 /0 1023234506 2/060;460 16<?92/<22/03=1@850:5423>070902<25<@8/2 ) 0<650:>4@590A;462/01023234506603206<20:2/0 <74D0 >4520523459 <5: 94@8/2 24 E@<9/ 2/0 3=1@850: 5423>0399@0:7?2/0609145:052 4 06 >4526< 2/0 A0<650: ::32345<A 4D065=052 :D4><209@7=3220:2/<2=060>0623;?3582/09385<2@60945 46= 4 9@7=3220:7?2/0=0=70697?2/0609145:052 - 6 - 4:409542>/<5802/05<2@604;2/0601609052<2345<5: :409542 160F@:3>0 2/06093:0524; 2/01<5>/<?<2 35 <5? =<5506 <5: 2/060;460 2/0 3=1@850: 164>00:3589 ><5542 70902<25<@8/2 0>45205:92/<2352/0F@:8=05260A30: @1457?2/010232345062/0601609052<2345C<99@7=3220: 24 2/0 <5>/<?<2 0D0A41=052 ;;3>06 C/4 39 542 >4=1020522460>03D02/0601609052<2345<5:2/060;46035 2/<2>36>@=92<5>02/394@62/<:<AA4C0:2/0C63210232345 /0A0<650:>4@590A;462/0163D<20609145:0529 603206<20: 2/0 9@7=3993459 4; 2/0 A0<650: ::32345<A 4D065=052 :D4><20 <5: 9@7=3220: 2/<2 2/0 1023234506 C<9542160F@:3>0:35<5?=<55067?=060>0623;3><23454; 2/09385<2@6097?2/0609145:052 4 09@7=3220:2/<2 2/0 601609052<2345 C<9 35 ;<>2 1A<>0: 70;460 2/0 609145:052 435<>>46:<5>0C32/2/0 @A094; ,,<5: 2/060;460 2/060 39 54 06646 C<66<52358 35206;0605>0 C32/ 2/03=1@850:5423>0 /<D0 >4593:060: 2/0 9@7=3993459 4; 2/0 A0<650: >4@590A ;46 2/0 1023234506 <5: 2/0 A0<650: - 7 - ::32345<A 4D065=052 :D4><20 <9 C0AA <9 2/0 A0<650: >4@590A;46609145:052 4 * >41? 4; 46= 4 ;3A0: 7? 2/0 =0=7069 :39>A4909 2/<2 2/0 9<=0 C<9 ;3692 1A<>0: 70;460 2/0 <5>/<?<2 0D0A41=052 ;;3>06 C/4 D063;30: 2/0 9385<2@609 2/06045 <5: >0623;30: 2/<2 2/0 9385<2@609 70A4580:242/0=0=70694;2/01<5>/<?<2/060;46032 <110<69 2/<2 2/0 601609052<2345 C<9 1A<>0: 70;460 2/0 609145:052 4 <5: 2/060<;206 1A<>0: 70;460 2/0 609145:052 4 2 39 2/39 164>0:@60 4; 2/0 <5>/<?<2 0D0A41=052 ;;3>06 2/<2 2/39 4@62 244B 0I>012345 35 + 4!() * !(! <5: /0A: 2/<2 2/0 <5>/<?<2 0D0A41=052 ;;3>06 /<9 54 64A0 24 1A<? 35 2/0 54 >45;3:05>0 =42345 <5: 2/060;460 /0 39 542 05232A0: 24 =<B0<5?0526309452/046= 4 <5:2/045A?106945 C/43905232A0:24:494392/099392<524==399345065 2/<2 >36>@=92<5>0 < 446:35<20 05>/ 4; 2/39 4@62 <AA4C0: 2/0 C632 10232345 <5: E@<9/0: 2/0 5423>0 4; 54 >45;3:05>0 4C0D063260906D0:638/2242/0=0=706924 - 8 - =4D0 < ;609/ =42345 ;46 54>45;3:05>0 /060;460 2/0 ;<>29 35 2/39 ><90 <60 E@320 93=3A<6 24 2/0 ;<>29 35 + 4!() * !(! <5: <>>46:358A? 2/0 1023234506 39 05232A0: 24 2/0 9<=0 7050;32 2/<2 C<9 83D05 24 2/0 1023234506935+ 4!() * !(! 05>0 2/39 C632 10232345 39 /0 3=1@850: 5423>0 :<20: !)( !(! 399@0: 7? 2/0 609145:052 4 164149358 24 /4A: < =002358 4; 54 >45;3:05>0 <8<3592 2/0 1023234506 45 (!!(! 39 E@<9/0: 4C0D06 A37062? 39 60906D0: 24 2/0 163D<20 609145:0529242<B04@2<;609/=42345;4654>45;3:05>0 <8<35922/01023234506 , 0<650: ::32345<A 4D065=052 :D4><20 39 106=3220: 24 ;3A0 =0=4 4; <110<6<5>0 C32/35 < 10634: 4; 205:<?9;64=24:<? "*+ (') '! 392 4 A 4!