Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92461 (KAR)
RAMAREDDY v. SHIVARAYA
CRL.RP/200080/2024 · 2025-07-17
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92461 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92461 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #$"%
$%
&'( &)*+
'&** ,
! !"#$
! ! ! !$$
% &'( $ ) * %
"
% % +(*'+*++ ,& +* ! "
%
"
**+*+ ,( +*++ ! " ! )
% %% ! &%! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%% )
-!"
-!"
$
./01 02 !"/3/ 4./05.1 6,758.4 9,0 :;. 0.<282,5 =.:2:2,5.0,5./==./089,0:;.0.8=,51.5:
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
- 3 -
./05.1 "71?. 25 :;. %208: ==.44/:. ,70: ;./01 :;. /0?7A.5:8,9:;.=/0:2.8/51,50./==0.62/:2,5,9:;.A/:.02/4 ,5 0.6,01 @B :;. 6,5821.0.1 E71?A.5: 1/:.1 **+*+ 128A288.1:;./==./4
!.25? 970:;.0 /??02.<.1 @B :;. 8/A. /6678.1 28 @.9,0. :;28,70:
02 !"/3/ 4./05.1 6,758.4 9,0 :;. 0.<282,5 =.:2:2,5.0 6,5:.51.1 :;/: :;. ,0/4 .<21.56. ,9 :;. /6678.1 >;, >/8 .C/A25.1 /8 ) /51 1,67A.5:8 =4/6.1 ,5 0.6,01 <21. C8:,;/<.5,:@..5=0,=.04B6,5821.0.1@B:;.4./05.1 02/4 /?28:0/:. /51 8/21 .<21.56. >/8 8799262.5: .5,7?; :, 1284,1?. :;. =0.87A=:2,5 /</24/@4. :, :;. 6,A=4/25/5: 751.0 .6:2,5&',9:;..?,:2/@4.58:07A.5:86:
( ;.0.9,0. :;. ,01.0 ,9 6,5<26:2,5 /51 8.5:.56. ;/8 .51.1 25 A286/002/?. ,9 E78:26. /51 8,7?;: 9,0 /44,>25? :;. 0.<282,5=.:2:2,5
256. 4./05.1 6,758.4 9,0 :;. 0.8=,51.5: 28 /@8.5: :;28 ,70:=.078.1:;.A/:.02/4,50.6,01A.:2674,784B25:;.42?;:
- 4 -
,9 :;. 0.<282,5 ?0,7518 /51 /0?7A.5:8 =7: 9,0:; ,5 @.;/49 ,9 :;.0.<282,5=.:2:2,5.0 ' 5 :;. 6/8. ,5 ;/51 2887/56. ,9 6;.D7. 128;,5,70 :;.0.,9 <21. C8 /51 + /51 82?5/:70. ,9 :;. 0.<282,5 =.:2:2,5.0,5CA/03.1/8C /$285,:25128=7:. * ,=B ,9 :;. 4.?/4 5,:26. 28 A/03.1 /8 C&/51=,8:/4 0.6.2=:28A/03.1/8CC28:;./?0..A.5:=4/6.1,5 0.6,01@B:;.6,A=4/25/5::,8;,>:;/::;.0..C28:.1/4.?/44B 0.6,<.0/@4.1.@:
8 /?/258: :;. A/:.02/4 =4/6.1 ,5 0.6,01 @B :;. 6,A=4/25/5: /6678.1 :,,3 :;. 0.8=,582@242:B ,9 0.@7::25? :;. =0.87A=:2,5/</24/@4.:,:;.6,A=4/25/5:751.0.6:2,5&',9 :;..?,:2/@4.58:07A.5:86:
+ );24.8,1,25?0.<282,5=.:2:2,5.0 /6678.1?,:.C/A25.1 ;2A8.49 /8 ) 5 :;. .C/A25/:2,5256;2.9 /6678.1 ;/8 1.=,8.1 :;/: 6,A=4/25/5: 28 / :,:/4 8:0/5?.0 /51 8, /48, ;28 A,:;.0:28/48,1.=,8.1@B;2A:;/::;.0.285,:0/58/6:2,5 >2:;:;.6,A=4/25/5:/:/5B?2<.5=,25:,9:2A./51;.;/85,: ?2<.5/5B6;.D7.:,:;.6,A=4/25/5:/88.6702:B
- 5 -
& . ;/8 /48, 1.=,8.1 :;/: >;.5 ;. /42?;:.1 :;. @78 /: .</170?/@788:/51;.4,8::;.6;.D7./51:;.0.9,0.;.;/8 25:2A/:.1 :;. 8/A. :, ;28 @/53.0 <2F :/:. !/53 ,9 B8707 .</170?/!0/56;/51?2<.5258:076:2,58:,8:,==/BA.5:. 970:;.0 1.=,8.1 :;/: ,5 **++* ;. ;/8 ?2<.5 ;28 4/51 :, 0!A@.13/02?/A/:,:;..C:.5:,9*60.8/51870<.B 57A@.0,9:;.8/214/5125 +
: 28 ;28 970:;.0 1.=,82:2,5 :;/: ;. 1,.8 5,: 35,> :;. 6,A=4/25/5:/51:;.0.>/85,:0/58/6:2,5/8=.0C/51;. ;/85,::/3.58***** /84./8./A,75:9,0674:2</:25?:;.
4/51@.4,5?25?:,:;.6,A=4/25/5:
587==,0:,9;286,5:.5:2,58/6678.1;/8=0,176.16,=B ,9:;.0.=4B1/:.1*'*+*/8C/51/635,>4.1?A.5: /8C&
. ;/8 /48, 1.=,8.1 :;/: G8:,= =/BA.5:H 258:076:2,58 ?2<.5@B;2A28<.0292.1@B:;.@/53/51.51,08.A.5:;/8@..5 2887.1<21.C6678.1A/03.1;288:/:.A.5:,9/66,75:
/8 C /51 6,=B ,9 :;. 8/4. 1..1 /51 ,:;.0 0.4/:.1 1,67A.5:8/8=.0C8:,
- 6 -
( 5 :;. 60,88.C/A25/:2,5 /6678.1 ;/8 1.=,8.1 :;/: 25 :;. B./0 +* ;. ;/8 ?2<.5 * /60.8 ,9 ;28 4/51 :, 0!A@.13/02?/A//510.6.2<.18&&**** !7:;. ;/8 5, 1,67A.5:8 :, 87@8:/5:2/:. :;. 8/A. . /1A2:8 :;. 82?5/:70. 25 C' . /1A2:8 :;/: 751.0 C' ;. ;/8 /?0..1 :, 8.44 * /60. ,9 4/51 :, 211/AA/ ) , 214/==/ 0.821.5:,9.</170?/
. /1A2:8 :;/: 211/AA/ 28 /6D7/25:.1 :, ;2A /51 211/AA/ 28 1,25? 6,,42. >,03 25 .</170?/ <244/?. . /1A2:8 :;. 82?5/:70. 9,751 25 C >;26; >/8 A/03.1 /8 C /$
' ;./@,<..<21.56.288,7?;::,@.0./==0.62/:.125:;. 42A2:.1 0.<282,5/4 E7028126:2,5 @B :;. 4./05.1 6,758.4 9,0 :;. 0.<282,5=.:2:2,5.025:;280.<282,5=.:2:2,5
+* 5 876; 0./==0.62/:2,5 ,9 :;. A/:.02/4 .<21.56. ,5 0.6,012:2860B8:/464./0:;/::;.0.285,128=7:.>2:;0.?/01:, C/5182?5/:70.9,751:;.0.25
+ :28:;.:;.,0B,90.<282,5=.:2:2,5.0 /6678.1:;/:;.4,8:
:;. 6;.D7. /51 :;.0.9,0. 2887.1 258:076:2,58 :, :;. @/53 :,
- 7 -
G8:,= =/BA.5:H : 28 =.0:25.5: :, 5,:. :;/: 5, 6,A=4/25: :, =,426. 28 4,1?.1 0.?/0125? 4,88 ,9 6;.D7. ;. @/53 .51,08.A.5: 28 5,: =0,<.1 @B .C/A2525? :;. /7:;,0 ,9 :;. @/53.51,08.A.5:
++ %70:;.0 2: 28 8.::4.1 =02562=4.8 ,9 4/> /51 0.D720.8 5, .A=;/828:;/:G8:,==/BA.5:H258:076:2,586/55,:@./6:.17=,5 @B:;.@/53.0754.88:;./A,75:A.5:2,5.125876;6;.D7.28 3.=:/8@/4/56.25:;./66,75:,.8:/@428;:;.8/A.:;.0.28 5,A/:.02/4=4/6.1,50.6,01@B:;./6678.1
+& %70:;.0 0.<282,5 =.:2:2,5.0 /1A2:8 :;/: ;. 28 /6D7/25:.1 >2:; 211/AA/ ,A=4/25/5: 28 5,5. ,:;.0 :;/5 :;. 8,5 ,9 211/AA/>;26;281.52.1@B/6678.1%70:;.0;./1A2:8:;. 82?5/:70. ,5 C .?/44B 0.6,<.0/@4.1.@: 64/2A.1@B :;. 6,A=4/25/5:28@/8.1,5C);.5:;.0.<282,5=.:2:2,5.0 ;/8/1A2::.1C/4:.05/:2<.:;.,0B=7:9,0>/01@B;2A:;/:
6,A=4/25/5: /51 211/AA/ /0. :,:/4 8:0/5?.08 28 5,: .8:/@428;.1 25/8A76; /8 25 ;28 60,88.C/A25/:2,5 ;. 6/:.?,026/44B /1A2:8 :;/: 211/AA/ 28 /6D7/25:.1 :, ;2A /51 :;.0.>/8/:0/58/6:2,5@.:>..5;2A8.49/51211/AA/
- 8 -
+ /325? 5,:. ,9 :;.8. 6,5:0/126:,0B 8:/:.A.5:8 A/1. ,5 ,/:;>;.0.25/6678.1;/81.=,8.19/48.4B:;28,70:28,9:;. 6,5821.0.1 ,=252,5 :;/: :;. ,0/4 /51 1,67A.5:/0B .<21.56. =4/6.1,50.6,01@B:;./6678.1>/85,:8799262.5:.5,7?;:, 1284,1?. :;. =0.87A=:2,5 /</24/@4. :, :;. 6,A=4/25/5: 751.0 .6:2,5&',9:;..?,:2/@4.58:07A.5:86:
+ 66,0125?4B:;.,01.0,96,5<26:2,50.6,01.1@B:;.02/4 ,70: 6,5920A.1 @B :;. %208: ==.44/:. ,70: 5..18 5, 25:.09.0.56. + /<25? 8/21 :;78 2: 28 5,:26.1 :;/: :;. 4./05.1 02/4 /?28:0/:. ;/8 2A=,8.1 925. ,9 8(*** ,9 >;26; 8(**** 28 ,01.0.1 :, @. =/21 /8 6,A=.58/:2,5 :, :;.
6,A=4/25/5:/51@/4/56.87A,98*** :,>/0181.90/B25? .C=.58.8,9:;.:/:. +(
256. :;. 28 =02<B :, :;. =/0:2.8 /51 5, :/:. A/6;25.0B 28 25<,4<.1 ,01.025? 8*** :,>/018 1.90/B25? .C=.58.8,9:;.:/:.6/55,:@.6,75:.5/56.1254/>
+ 66,0125?4B 25 <2.> ,9 :;. 9,0.?,25? 12867882,5 :;. 9,44,>25? - 9 -
2$ 02A25/4.<282,5.:2:2,528
22$ );24.A/25:/2525?:;.6,5<26:2,5,9:;.0.<282,5 =.:2:2,5.0 /6678.1 9,0 :;. ,99.56. =7528;/@4. 751.0 .6:2,5 & ,9 :;. .?,:2/@4. 58:07A.5:8 6: 925. ,01.0.1 @B :;. 02/4 ,70: 6,5920A.1 @B :;. %208:
==.44/:. ,70: 28 0.176.1 90,A 8(*** :, 8(****
222$ 5:20.925./A,75:,98(**** 28,01.0.1 :,@.=/21/86,A=.58/:2,5:,:;.6,A=4/25/5: 2<$ 2A. 28 ?0/5:.1 9,0 :;. =.:2:2,5.0 :, =/B :;. 6,A=.58/:2,5/A,75::244&8:7?78:+*+ <$ !/4/56.87A,98*** ,01.0.1:,@.=/21:, :;.:/:.:,>/0181.90/B25?.C=.58.828;.0.@B8.: /821. <2$ %/2470. :, =/B :;. 925. /A,75: 2A=028,5A.5:
,01.0.1 @B :;. 02/4 ,70: 6,5920A.1 @B :;. %208: ==.44/:.,70:8:/5180.8:,0.1/7:,A/:26/44B <22$ .?28:0B 28 120.6:.1 :, 0.:705 :;. 02/4 ,70:
.6,018 9,0:;>2:; 9,0 288725? A,1292.1 6,5<26:2,5 >/00/5: -+ &%*
" 36A 28:,4,( #