- 1 - !"# $"%"" && '&(&) * !"# $ % & " !' !"# ( ' "" ("! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ) !"# ) !"# (' !"# ! () !"# ) ( !"# (# !"# ' * )' ' ""! ") " # - 3 - " ") $ % & + " + & + , + - & (' (( )) ((# + !((# # ((" -& # ((" + ++ . !((#- & + . + + + . - 4 - %" /0123342501678494:82:; <'640:=2==>04?4867 ;/4 @A8=B4:; 2:8 84C>44 82;48 !((# 321148 0: < # ((" 67 ;/4 <A>; <9 ;/4 880;0<:25 4:0<> 0?05A8=40@2723A>D/4>40:29;4>>494>>48;<21;/4E;>025 <A>;F 9<> 6>4?0;7G H/0C/ 01 C<:90>B48 67 ;/4 @A8=B4:; 2:8 84C>44 82;48 (' (( 321148 0: <)) ((# <: ;/4 9054 <9 880;0<:25 01;>0C; 2:8 4110<:1 A8=4 0@2723A> D/4>40:29;4> >494>>48 ;< 21 ;/4 E90>1; 2334552;4 <A>;F9<>6>4?0;7G ( /4 26<?4 1A0; 0: < # ((" 90548 67 ;/4 3520:;0991 >413<:84:; <1" 2:8 ( /4>40: 144I0:= >45049 <9 32>;0;0<:2:81432>2;43<114110<:A6@4C;B2;;4><91A0;01 ;/49<55<H0:=3><34>;7642>0:= <("B421A>0:="! 2C>41# =A:;21<9 0@@2>=0?0552=40I<;225AI0@2723A>2 01;>0C; # /4 C214 <9 ;/4 3520:;0991 01 ;/2; 3520:;099 2:8 8494:82:; <1" ;< ) C<:1;0;A;48 0:8A A:80?0848 92B057 - 5 - 2:8 ;/4 1A0; 3><34>;7 01 ;/40> 2:C41;>25 @<0:; 92B057 3><34>;7 /2; <:4 0>0B2552332 H21 ;/40> 92;/4> 2:8 8494:82:; <) 01 ;/40> B<;/4> 0>0B2552332 /28 3A>C/2148 ;/4 1A0; 3><34>;7 A:84> 2 >4=01;4>48 8448 <9 1254 9<> ?25A2654 1254 C<:1084>2;0<: 9;4> /01 84B014 3520:;0991 2:8 8494:82:; <1" ;< ) 64C2B4 4:;0;548 9<> 4JA251/2>40:;/41A0;3><34>;7<H4?4>8494:82:; <" 0: C<55A10<: H0;/ ;/4 >4?4:A4 <990C025 /28 =<; /01 :2B4 BA;2;48 0: ;/4 >4?4:A4 >4C<>81 ?084 <) ( C520B0:= ;/2; 0>0B2552332 /28 >450:JA01/48 4:;0>4 4K;4:; <952:80:7 <("B421A>0:="!2C>41# =A:;210:/01 92?<A>494:82:; <"808:<;/2?42:73>44K01;0:=>0=/; <?4>;/41A0;3><34>;74012880C;48;<628?0C412I0:= A:8A4 28?2:;2=4 <9 ;/4 12B4 /01 :2B4 640:= BA;48 0: ;/4>4?4:A4>4C<>814/28C>42;482925148448<912540: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; < 2504:2;0:= ;/4 3><34>;7 ;< ;/4 4K;4:;<9 2C>41494:82:; < 0:9A>;/4>2:C4;/4>4<9 /28 C>42;48 2:<;/4> 8448 <9 1254 0: >4134C; <9 ;/4 12B4 3><34>;7 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; <' 0:C4 >4JA41; <9 - 6 - 3520:;09919<>32>;0;0<:H21640:=2?<08483520:;099190548;/4 3>414:;1A0; A0; 2=20:1; 8494:82:; <1( ;< ! 01 801B01148 21 :<; 3>41148 494:82:; <1" 2:8 ) ;< ' 23342>48 494:82:; <1 2:8'C<:;41;48;/41A0;679050:=H>0;;4: 1;2;4B4:; 494:82:; <1 2:8 ' 28B0;;48 ;/4 >452;0<:1/03 64;H44: 3520:;0991 2:8 8494:82:; <1" ;< ) 84:048 ;/4 3520:; 2?4>B4:;1 ; 01 C<:;4:;48 ;/2; ;/4 3520:;09912>4>4JA0>48;<90541A0;9<>C2:C4552;0<:<98448<9 1254 4K4CA;48 67 8494:82:; <" 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; < 2:88494:82:; < 0:92?<A><98494:82:; <'/2; ;/4 0>0B2552332 /28 >450:JA01/48 ;/4 1A0; 3><34>;7 0: 92?<A><98494:82:; <"0:0;14:;0>4;7H/0C/01C4>;09048 A:84> <) ( 0>0B2552332 321148 2H27 90?4 742>13>0<>;<9050:=<9;/41A0;A>0:=/015094;0B4/4/28 :<; JA41;0<:48 <> C/2554:=48 ;/4 >4?4:A4 4:;>041 /4 3520:;0991 H0;/<A;JA41;0<:0:=;/4 BA;2;0<: 4:;>041 C2::<; B20:;20:;/41A0;4:C41<A=/;9<>801B01125<91A0; >025<A>;9>2B48;/49<55<H0:=011A41 - 7 - ! ! " #$ % $ & ' ! ! ( ' " ! ) (( " ! * ! 520:;099 <" 4K2B0:48 21 " 2:8 4K/060;48 10K8<CAB4:;K1";<!494:82:; <'4K2B0:4821 " 2:8 4K/060;48 :0:4 8<CAB4:;1 21 K1" ;< ' >025<A>;2:1H4>4811A4 <1"2:80:;/42990>B2;0?4 2:8 11A4 <1( ;< 0: ;/4 :4=2;0?4 2:8 C<:14JA4:;57 84C>448;/41A0;211<A=/;9<> ) 40:= 2==>04?48 8494:82:; <' 3>494>>48 >4=A52>2334250: <)) ((#649<>4;/4<A>;<9;/4 - 8 - 880;0<:25 01;>0C; A8=4 0@2723A> <:1084>0:= ;/4 =><A:81A>=48;/4>40:;/490>1;2334552;4C<A>;9>2B48;/4 9<55<H0:=3<0:;19<>0;1C<:1084>2;0<: + , ! $ ( % + , ! ' - ! ! " ( ' " ! &+ , ! ( " )+ ! " ! . ) - , , / + ! , 0 0 ( ( " # *+ 2:8<:>4233>4C02;0<:<94?084:C42:1H4>483<0:; <1" ;< 0: :4=2;0?4 2:8 C<:14JA4:;57 801B01148 ;/4 233425 - 9 - C<:90>B0:= ;/4 @A8=B4:; 2:8 84C>44 321148 67 ;/4 ;>025 <A>; 40:=2==>04?48;/43520:;09912>4649<>4;/01<A>; <A:145 9<> ;/4 2334552:; >40;4>2;0:= ;/4 =><A:81 A>=48 0: ;/4 B4B<>2:8AB <9 233425 1A6B0;;48 ;/2; ;/4 ;>025 <A>; 2:8 ;/4 90>1; 2334552;4 <A>; /2?4 =><11574>>480::<;233>4C02;0:=;/4>4?4:A44:;>041?084 <) ( H/0C/ C2;4=<>0C2557 4?084:C4 ;/4 >450:JA01/B4:; 4994C;48 67 ;/4 92;/4> 0>0B2552332 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; <" /4>467 8494:82:; <" 64C2B4;/4261<5A;4<H:4><9;/41A0;3><34>;70:C4;/4 1A0; 3><34>;7 <>0=0:2557 645<:=48 ;< 0>0B2552332 /4 /28 4?4>7>0=/;;<8013<14<9;/412B421/48410>48520:;0991 640:= ;/4 82A=/;4>1 2>4 :<; 4:;0;548 ;< ;/4 1/2>4 0: ;/4 3><34>;710:C4;/412B41;2:81;>2:194>>488A>0:=;/45094 <90>0B25523320:92?<A>8494:82:; <"/2;8494:82:; <"0:4K4>C014<9/01261<5A;4>0=/;/281<58;/43><34>;7 0:92?<A><98494:82:; < 2:4K;4:;<9 2C>41H/<0: ;A>: 4K4CA;48 8448 <9 1254 C<:?470:= ;/4 1208 4K;4:; <9 2C>41 <9 52:8 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; <' 1 1AC/ - 10 - 8494:82:; <' /21 64C<B4 261<5A;4 <H:4> <9 ;/4 3><34>;7 ' +A>;/4> ;/4 ;>025 <A>; 2:8 ;/4 90>1; 2334552;4 <A>; /2?4 :<; 3><;4C;48 ;/4 0:;4>41; <9 8494:82:; <' H/< 01 6<:2 9084 3A>C/214> <9 ;/4 1A6@4C; 3><34>;7 /4>49<>4;/41A61;2:;025JA41;0<:<952HH<A582>0149<> C<:1084>2;0<:4:C4144I19<>;<255<H;/4233425 " / 542>:48 C<A:145 >0 2>48:2> 4887H/</214:;4>48C2?42;<>1A6B0;1;/2;6<;/;/4 ;>025<A>;2:8;/490>1;2334552;4<A>;<:92C;12:8<:52H /2?4 C<B4 ;< ;/4 C<:CA>>4:; 90:80:= 2:8 C<:C5A10<: <9 2554=48 >450:JA01/B4:; 8448 :<; /2?0:= 644: 3><?48 2:8 41;26501/48 0: ;/4 B2::4> I:<H: ;< 52H 67 8494:82:; <" /4>49<>4 8494:82:; <" C<A58 :<; /2?4 4K4CA;4 8448 <9 1254 90>1;57 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; < 2:8 8494:82:; < 0: ;A>: 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; <' 4 1A6B0;121>0=/;57;2I4:<A;<967;/4;>025<A>;2:8;/4 90>1; 2334552;4 <A>; 8494:82:; <' 4?4: 09 4:;0;548 9<> 2:7 1/2>4 ;/2; H<A58 64 >41;>0C;48 <:57 ;< ;/4 4K;4:; <9 - 11 - 1/2>4;/2;C<A5864255<C2654;<8494:82:; <"/4>49<>4 /41A6B0;1;/2;:<1A61;2:;025JA41;0<:<952HH<A582>014 9<>C<:1084>2;0<: "" 42>84>A148;/4>4C<>81 "( /4>401:<8013A;4<9;/492C;;/2;;/43><34>;7 H21 14592CJA0>48 3><34>;7 <9 0>0B2552332 H/< 01 ;/4 /A162:8 <9 8494:82:; <) 2:8 92;/4> <9 3520:;0991 2:8 8494:82:; <"3<:/0184B014/01H0948494:82:; <) 2:8 82A=/;4>1L3520:;0991 2:8 8494:82:; <" 640:= ;/4 C5211"/40>12>44:;0;5489<>4JA251/2>40:;/43><34>;70: ;4>B1<94C;0<: <9;/40:8AACC4110<:C; "# /01 640:= ;/4 92C;A25 2:8 54=25 3<10;0<: 8494:82:; <1 2:8 ' 0: ;/40> H>0;;4: 1;2;4B4:; /2?4 C<:;4:848 ;/2; 0>0B2552332 /28 >450:JA01/48 ;/4 1A0; 1C/48A54 3><34>;7 0: 92?<A> <9 8494:82:; <" 2:8 2 BA;2;0<:0:;/01>4=2>8H214994C;48?084 <) ( /A12CC<>80:=;<;/4B;/4>4H212C>42;0<:<9>0=/; ;0;542:80:;4>41;0:>4134C;<94:;0>41A0;3><34>;70:92?<A> - 12 - <9 8494:82:; <" : 9A>;/4>2:C4 ;< H/0C/ /4 /28 1<58 3<>;0<:<9;/43><34>;70:92?<A><98494:82:; < H/<0: ;A>:/281<58;/43><34>;70:92?<A><98494:82:; <' " /4 ;>025 <A>; 2:8 ;/4 90>1; 2334552;4 <A>; /2?4 84C50:48 ;< 2CC43; ;/01 ;/4<>7 <9 0>0B2552332 >450:JA01/0:=;/43><34>;70:92?<A><98494:82:; <"21 :<54=25572CC43;2654B2;4>0254?084:C4013><8AC48649<>4 ;/4 <A>;1 0=/;57 1< :7 C>42;0<: <> 4K;0:C;0<: <9 ;/4 >0=/;10:0BB<?26543><34>;7/21;<640:C<B3502:C4H0;/ 3><?010<:1 <9 4C;0<: ") <9 ;/4 4=01;>2;0<: C; >4JA0>0:= C<B3A51<>7 >4=01;>2;0<: ; 01 233><3>02;4 ;<>494> ;< ;/4 @A8=B4:;<9;/4<:F65434K<A>;0:;/4C214<9 ?1 L' ) " : ;/4 0:1;2:; C214 62148 <: ;/4 3A>3<>;48 BA;2;0<:4:;>7<9 <) (8494:82:; <1 2:8 ' C520B ;/2; ;/4 0>0B2552332 /28 >450:JA01/48 ;/4 3><34>;70:92?<A><98494:82:; <"/41208C<:;4:;0<: 0154=2557A:;4:2654 - 13 - "! <:4;/45411 0: ;4>B1 <9 4C;0<: <9 ;/4 >2:194><9><34>;7C;8494:82:; <' 2334552:;/4>40: 640:=;/43A>C/214><9;/43><34>;79><B8494:82:; < H/< 0: ;A>: /28 3A>C/2148 ;/4 3><34>;7 9><B 8494:82:; <" H<A58 64 4:;0;548 ;< ;/4 1/2>4 ;/2; 01 255<C2654 ;< 8494:82:; <" ") : 92C; ;/4 ;>025 <A>; H/054 2:1H4>0:= 11A4 <! 2; 32>2 (! /21 ;2I4: :<;4 <9 ;/01 2134C; <9 ;/4 B2;;4> " /01<A>;8<:<;1442:7=><A:81=0?0:=>014;< 1A61;2:;025JA41;0<:<952H334252CC<>80:=57 "' A8=B4:;2:884C>4482;48!((#321148 0: < # (("67;/4<A>;<9;/4880;0<:254:0<> 0?05A8=40@2723A>201C<:90>B48 +( '"") % 01; <"5 <##