- 1 - ! "# $ % #&& # "$ #& # $ ' ( ) % % ! *+ ' % *% *+ ) % ! $ ! " Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " , % - .$ " "% # # # ! /01 233425 01 60547 825509: 09;<41=0>9=/4 ?<7:@49= 297 2A2B7 72=47 , 09 >.$ 321147 CD =/4 490>B 0E05 <7:4 297 >@@0110>94B 6>B @35>D44-1 >@34912=0>9 2= 27:0B A/4B4CD =/4 8520@ 34=0=0>9A21701@01147 42B7 B0%44B29:><72 25032=05 542B947 8><9145 23342B09: 6>B 23345529=1$8520@29=1 297 B0 B<3212:2B 2=05 542B947 8><9145 23342B09: 6>B B413>9749=>1297F B0%44B29:><7225032=05542B9478><9145A0=/ 255 E4/4@4984 1<C@0==47 =/2= =/4 74842147 A21 A>BG09: 21B2@2%07D<=B2=0907/0<974BB413>9749=>1297 - 3 - 09 B41348= >6 /2923<B B2@2 298/2D2= 4 A21 2 C055 >5548=>B >9 C4/256 >6 B413>9749= > 7047 7<B09: =/4 8><B14 >6 4@35>D@49= 88>B709:5D =/4 2335082=0>9 144G09: 8>@34912=0>9 <974B =/4 @35>D@49= >@34912=0>98= . 3>914BE084>69>=084B413>9749=>1297 23342B47 =/B><:/ =/40B 8><9145 297 60547 =/40B 1=2=4@49= >6 >C?48=0>91 749D09: =/2= =/4 23345529= 01 29 4@35>D44 A>BG09:<974B=/4@297A21?<1=7018/2B:09:/017<=D21 292:49=297292:49=8299>=C44;<2=47=>294@35>D44 88>B709:5D1><:/==>701@011=/48520@34=0=0>9 /4B0C<925/216B2@4709=/46>55>A09:011<41# ! ""# ! " # ! # $ % & # '()*++,-, +! . ## ##! # # "## # " / " " # - 4 - N " 1 # 1 2" ! 1 + 13 & /4B0C<925 291A4B4709011<41 > 297 09 H94:2=0E4-2973B>844747=>701@011=/48520@34=0=0>9>9 =/4 :B><971 =/2= =/4B4 01 9> ?<B25 B452=0>91/03 04 29 4@35>D44 297 4@35>D4B C4=A449 =/4 74842147 297 B413>9749=>1297F548=B080=D>@329D , = 01 =/01 ?<7:@49= 297 2A2B7 321147 CD =/4 B0C<925 A/08/ 01 825547 09 ;<41=0>9 09 =/01 233425 CD =/4 8520@29=1/01><B=/2E09:/42B7=/4542B9478><91456>B =/4 32B=041 6B2@47 =/4 6>55>A09: 1<C1=29=025 ;<41=0>9 >6 52AA/05427@0==09:=/01233425# # & /" # -4513 - 5 - + 1 34B =/4 8520@ 34=0=0>9 =/4 74842147 A21 A>BG09: 21 B2@2 %07D<= B2=0907/0 <974B /2923<B B2@2298/2D2=<974BB413>9749=>12974A21 7018/2B:09: /01 6<98=0>9 21 2 C055 8>5548=>B >9 C4/256 >6 B413>9749=>1297I/0C0=&A/08//21C449011<47 CD B413>9749= > 8542B5D 1/>A1 =/2= =/474842147A21 A>BG09: <974B =/4@ 21 B2@2 %07D<= B2=0907/0 297 /4 7047 09 29 2880749= >88<BB47 >9 +, A/054 7018/2B:09:/0114BE084A/08/8542B5D1/>A1=/2==/4B4012 B452=0>91/03 >6 4@35>D4B 297 4@35>D44 /><:/ =/4 542B9478><914523342B09:6>B=/4548=B080=D>@329D/21 =2G49 8>9=49=0>9 =/2= 21 34B I* :B44@49= =/4 74842147 A21 A>BG09: 21 29 2:49= 297 288>B709:5D /4 8299>= C4 4;<2=47 => 29 4@35>D44 <974B B413>9749= >1297F548=B080=D>@329D=>CB09:/0@A0=/09=/4 746090=0>9 >6 H4@35>D44- <974B =/4 @35>D441 >@34912=0>98= B0%44B29:><72 25032=05 542B947 8><9145 CB><:/= => =/4 9>=084 >6 =/01 ><B= =/2= =/4 A>B57 - 6 - H@292:09: 2:49=- 7460947 <974B 48=0>9 ! 6! 6! >6 =/4 @35>D441 >@34912=0>9 8= A/4B409 =/4 746090=0>9 8542B5D 1/>A1 =/2= 29 2:49= A/> /21 C449 233>09=47 => 28= >9 C4/256 >6 >B 28=09: 21 =/4 B43B4149=2=0E4 >6 29>=/4B 34B1>9 6>B =/4 3<B3>14 >6 82BBD09:>91<8/>=/4B34B1>9-1=B274>BC<109411829C4 8>91074B47 21 29 4@35>D44 297 8>E4B47 <974B =/4 @35>D441 >@34912=0>9 8= /><:/ =/474842147A21 =4B@47 21 29 2:49= <974B I F :B44@49= =/4 84B=06082=4 011<47 2= I& C>=/ 8>9?>09=5D 297 8542B5D 1/>A1=/2==/><://4A21233>09=4721292:49=C<=/4 A217018/2B:09:/016<98=0>909=/4=B274>BC<10941104 =/4 8>5548=0>9 >6 4548=B080=D C055 >9 C4/256 >6 B413>9749= >1 297 * 548=B080=D >@329D 8>@41 A0=/ =/4 746090=0>9>6 ! 6!>6=/4@35>D441>@34912=0>98= 297 01 29 4@35>D44 >6 B413>9749=1 * 8>B3>B2=0>9 /4 B0C<925 /21 8>@@0==47 29 4BB>B 09 9>= 8>91074B09: =/41421348=1>6=/4@2==4B413480255D=/4746090=0>9<974B 48=0>9 ! 6! >6 =/4 @35>D441 >@34912=0>9 8= - 7 - 4984 =/01 ><B= 01 >6 =/4 >3090>9 =/2= =/4B4 01 2 ?<B25 B452=0>91/03 >6 4@35>D4B 297 4@35>D44 C4=A449 B413>9749=>1297297=/474842147 0984 =/4 @2==4B 01 >6 =/4 D42B + 12@4 01 8>91074B476>B7013>125>98520@091=427>6B4@29709:A0=/ =/48>9149=>6C>=/=/4542B9478><914588>B709:5D011<4 > 01 291A4B47 09 H94:2=0E4- CD =/4 B0C<925 A/08/ B4;<0B41 8>91074B2=0>9 10984 0= 01 2 8520@ 34=0=0>9 60547 <974B =/4 @35>D441 >@34912=0>9 8= /4 2880749= /2E09:>88<BB4709=/4D42B+=/4098>@460I47<974B =/4 28= 01 1.$* 3@ A/08/ 01 9>= 7013<=47 CD =/4 542B9478><914523342B09:6>B=/4B413>9749=1F548=B080=D >@329D88>B709:5D=/4098>@421=2G492=1.$* 01?<1=2973B>34B09840=0128214>6742=/J>6=/4 098>@4 01 => C4 747<8=47 A/054 8258<52=09: 8>@34912=0>9 =>A2B71 5>11 >6 743497498D 25>9: A0=/ =/4 233B>3B02=4 628=>B/474842147A212:47+D42B121>9=/472=4>6 /01742=//43B>34B628=>B2335082C5401H,-297=/4 12@4 01 8>91074B47 88>B709:5D =/4 8>@34912=0>9 - 8 - =>A2B71K>11>643497498DL012A2B7472=1.+$* .I, I$! /423345529=1F8520@29=1 2B4 49=0=547 6>B 1<@ >6 1$* =>A2B71 H<94B25 I349141- 88>B709:5D 23345529=1$8520@29=1 2B4 49=0=547 6>B2=>=258>@34912=0>9>61.&+$*A0=/34B@0110C54 09=4B41= >B =/4 6>B4:>09: B421>91 =/4 1<C1=29=025 ;<41=0>9 >6 52A 291A4B47 09 94:2=0E4 297 09 62E><B >6 8520@29=12972:2091==/44548=B080=D8>@329D2973B>8447 =>3211=/46>55>A09:# 0! /42334250155>A47*9*2B=M 00! /4 ?<7:@49= 297 2A2B7 72=47 , 09 >.$ 321147 CD =/4 490>B 0E05 <7:4 97 >@@0110>94B 6>B @35>D44-1 >@34912=0>9 27:0B /4B4CD 291A4B09: 11<4 > 01 14= 21074 297 12@4 01 291A4B47 09 - 9 - 2660B@2=0E4 09 62E><B >6 8520@29=1 297 2:2091= B413>9749=>1297F548=B080=D>@329D 000! 11<4 > 01 291A4B47 H32B=5D 2660B@2=0E4- />5709:=/2==/423345529=1$8520@29=12B449=0=547 6>B 2 1<@ >6 1.&+$* <3441 ><B 2G/1 A49=D 0I =/><1297 0:/=D B<3441 >95D! A/08/ 1/25582BBD09=4B41=2==/4B2=4>6J34B299<@ 09 =4B@1 >6 48=0>9 . =/4 B413>9749= F 8>B3>B2=0>901502C54=>32D09=4B41=2==/4B2=4>6 J 34B 299<@ 72D1 6B>@ =/4 72=4 >6 2880749= =055 =/4 49=0B4 8>@34912=0>9 01 743>10=47/42@><9=>68>@34912=0>9>B74B47 1/255C4743>10=47CD=/4B413>9749=>1297 A0=/09 10I A44G1 6B>@ =/4 72=4 >6 B48403= >6 8>3D >6 =/01 >B74B C46>B4 =/4 233B>3B02=4 B0C<925 0E! 3>9 743>10= CD B413>9749= >1 297 23345529=149=0=547J428/25>9:A0=/288B<47 - 10 - 09=4B41=2972@><9=1=2=471<3B2C4B454214709 =/40B62E><B>93B>34B0749=06082=0>9 ! 01=>#5>#,