Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92438 (KAR)
SHARIF AND ANR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200186/2022 · 2025-08-01
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92438 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92438 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! "! #$!%!$$
$&&
'
()&*+
(!!*,
-
! "#
$
%
"&
! "#
'(( )%(*
(
(
((
! #
'(
)%
(*
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
((
")$* (((( (
% ##$#$$ ( %
( $!# $#! ((
(
$#)*)$*)* ( &! (( ( $!# $#! %
(( %
+%
% $ )(+%
* ,,-./01.230$435/,4262./1$!#17$#! 1389/746/1789/6/2:3/00048413264.8:4,8230/..413. %-0;/402:.48843;282.2<2=26>232:/4?5-;343;89/ @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 230 1:0/: 17 ./38/3,/ 028/0 ##$#$$ ,13<4,843; 89/? 71: 89/ 177/3,/. 5-34.92A6/ -30/: /,8413. $# )A* 44)* 17 89/ 2:,184, :-;. 230 (.>,918:154, -A.823,/. ,8 &! B71: .91:8 C89/ ( ,8DE230./38/3,43;81-30/:;1:4;1:1-.4?5:4.13?/3871:
- 3 -
13/ ?1389 230 81 52> 2 743/ 17 .#### /2,9 F489 0/72-68./38/3,/ $ :4/7 72,8. 17 89/ ,2./ 2. ?20/ 1-8 A> 89/ 5:1./,-8413 2:/ 8928 ($ :/,/4</0 ,:/04A6/ 4371:?28413 :/;2:043; 8:23.51:828413 17 ;23@2 71: ./6643; 89/ .2?/ 81 89/ ;/3/:26 5-A64, 3 89/ A2.4. 17 .-,9 ,:/04A6/ 4371:?284139/5:1,//0/08189/.518278/:4371:?43;94. 94;9/: 1774,/:. 2. 5/: G($ 230 ./,-:/0 89/ 2H/88/0 774,/: ( ,,-./0 1 F2. ,2-;98 :/09230/0 3 94.5/:.1326./2:,94389/5:/./3,/1789/2H/88/0774,/:
( 230 89/ 430/5/30/38 F483/../. (. I 230 774,426 F483/.. ( 48 F2. 71-30 8928 9/ F2. 43 51../..41317 ##;:2?.1723@2F94,9F2../4H/0-30/:
89/ ?292H2: G( 9/ 4371:?238 746/0 89/ 74:.8 4371:?28413 2. 5/: G(" 3</.84;28413 F2. 9/60 230 48 F2. 71-30 8928 2,,-./0 1 920 5-:,92./0 89/ ,138:2A2304/23@27:1?2,,-./01$9/:/71:/89/ 74326:/51:8,2?/81A/746/02;243.82,,-./01.230$
- 4 -
9/ 6/2:3/0 2;4.8:28/ 811= ,1;34H23,/ 17 89/ 177/3,/ 230 .-??13/0 89/ 2,,-./0 9/ 2,,-./0 255/2:/0A/71:/89/:4261-:823056/20/0318;-468>230 ,624?/081A/8:4/0
" 9/ 5:1./,-8413 /G2?43/0 (. 81 & ;18 ?2:=/0G.(81#23040/38474/043.-551:817
48. ,138/38413 ,,-./0 1. 230 $ 92</ 0/34/0 266 89/ 43,:4?432843; ?28/:426. 2<2462A6/ 13 :/,1:0 A-8 92</ 318 ,91./3 81 6/20 23> /<40/3,/ 43 .-551:8 17 89/4: 0/7/3,/ 9/ :426 1-:8 278/: 82=43; 4381 ,13.40/:28413 266 89/./ ?28/:426. 13 :/,1:0 ,2?/ 81 89/ ,13,6-.413 8928 89/ 5:1./,-8413 4. .-,,/..7-6 43 5:1<43; 89/ ;-468 17 89/ 2,,-./0 A/>130 :/2.132A6/ 01-A8 ,,1:043;6> 89/ 4?5-;3/0 @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 230 1:0/: 17 ./38/3,/ ,2?/ 81 A/ 52../0 /43; 2;;:4/</0 A> 89/ .2?/ 2,,-./01.230$2:/A/71:/894.1-:8
/2:0 :4 23@2> (2846 6/2:3/0 ,1-3./6 71: 89/255/66238.230:4%2?202:9292A-00436/2:3/04;9
- 5 -
1-:8 1</:3?/38 (6/20/: 71: 89/ :/.5130/38 (/:-./0 89/?28/:426.13:/,1:0 I 3 <4/F 17 89/ :4<26 ,138/38413. -:;/0 A> 6/2:3/0,1-3./671:A18989/52:84/.89/514388928F1-60 2:4./71:?>,13.40/:284134. > 23.F/: 81 89/ 2A1</ 51438 4. C
D71:89/71661F43; !! 8 4. 89/ ,138/38413 17 89/ 5:1./,-8413 8928 2,,-./01F2.71-304351../..41317;23@2A/43; ## ;:2?.F94,99/9205-:,92./07:1?2,,-./01$71:89/ 5-:51./ 17 ./6643; 89/ .2?/ 81 89/ ;/3/:26 5-A64, 230 89/:/A> 89/> 92</ ,1??488/0 89/ 177/3,/. 5-34.92A6/ -30/:/,8413.$#)A*23044)*17(,815:1</894.
,138/3841389/5:1./,-8413/G2?43/0(.24081A/89/
- 6 -
430/5/30/38F483/..71:89/./4H-:/?292H2:-89/92. 318.-551:8/089/,2./1789/5:1./,-8413 ! ($ 4. 89/ 4371:?238 F91 :/,/4</0 ,:/04A6/ 4371:?28413:/;2:043;2,,-./01A/43;4351../..41317 23@22305:1,//0/08189/.518278/:4371:?43;94.94;9/: 1774,/:.2.5/:G($94.F483/..92.7-66>.-551:8/081 89/,2./1789/5:1./,-8413230.828/089282,,-./01 F2. ,2-;98 :/0 9230/0 230 ## ;:2?. 17 23@2 F2. ./4H/0 7:1? 94? -30/: 89/ ./4H-:/ ?292H2: G( / 26.1 .5/2=. 2A1-8 610;43; 17 89/ 74:.8 4371:?28413 2. 5/:
G(" </3 891-;9 894. F483/.. F2. ,:1../G2?43/0 28 6/3;89318943;92.A//3/64,48/07:1?94?8104.A/64/</94. </:.413 & (4.89/(164,/13.82A6/F912,,1?5234/0 ($2889/84?/170:2F43;./4H-:/?292H2:G((
"4.89/23189/:./4H-:/?292H2:F483/..81G(946/ ($.-551:8/089/,2./175:1./,-8413A-8("92.318 4?462:6>(F914..828/081A/5:/./382889/84?/17 0:2F43;G(2304..2408192</A:1-;9889/F/4;943;
- 7 -
?2,943/92.318.-551:8/089/,2./175:1./,-841384. 81A/3184,/08928/</3891-;9(.$230F/:/,:1.. /G2?43/0 28 6/3;89 A> 89/ 6/2:3/0 ,1-3./6 71: 89/ 2,,-./0318943;92.A//3/64,48/07:1?89/? # ( 4.89/2H/88/0774,/:43F91./5:/./3,/ 89/5/:.1326./2:,91789/2,,-./0F2.,130-,8/0/92. 7-66> .-551:8/0 89/ ,2./ 17 5:1./,-8413 F489 :/;2:0 81 ./2:,9230./4H-:/1789/,138:2A2307:1?2,,-./01 (I 4. 23189/: ./4H-:/ ?292H2: F483/.. 81 G( F91 7-66>.-551:8/089/,2./175:1./,-8413(!4.89/(164,/ 774,/: F91 :/;4.8/:/0 89/ (& 4. 89/ 3</.84;2843;
774,/: F91 :/,/4</0 89/ :/51:8 2. 5/: G(# 230 746/0 74326 :/51:8 2?56/ 17 ,138:2A230 ./4H/0 -30/:
G( F2. /G2?43/0 28 89/ 828/ 1:/3.4, ,4/3,/ 2A1:281:> 204F262 /3;26-:- 230 48 92. :/.5130/0 51.484</71:89/5:/./3,/17,2332A4.);23@2*
9/?28/:426.:/7/::/0812A1</,6/2:6>04.,61./ 89282,,-./01F2.71-304351../..41317,138:2A230 4/ 23@2 F/4;943; ## ;:2?. 9-. 89/ 5:1./,-8413 4. - 8 -
.-,,/..7-6 43 5:1<43; .-,9 ;-468 17 2,,-./0 1 A/>130 :/2.132A6/01-A8 $ 8 4. 89/ ,138/38413 17 89/ 5:1./,-8413 8928 2,,-./0 1 5-:,92./0 89/ 23@2 7:1? 2,,-./0 1$ G,/58 89/ .2> 17 ($ 89/:/ 4. 318943; 13 :/,1:0 81 ,133/,8 2,,-./0 1$ 81 89/ 177/3,/ 43 J-/.8413 0?488/06>31,138:2A230F2../4H/07:1?89/51../..413 172,,-./01$389/2A./3,/1723>,1;/38?28/:42681 ,138/30892848F2.2,,-./01$F91.16089/,138:2A230 812,,-./012?1789/1543413892889/5:1./,-8413
92. 7246/0 81 5:1</ 89/ ;-468 17 2,,-./0 1$ A/>130 :/2.132A6/ 01-A8 71: 89/ 271:/.240 177/3,/. 230 9/ 4. /38486/071:2,J-48826
92</ ;13/ 89:1-;9 89/ 4?5-;3/0 @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 230 1:0/: 17 ./38/3,/ 52../0 A> 89/ :426 1-:8 9/ :426 1-:8 92. 5:15/:6> 255:/,428/0 89/ ?28/:426.13:/,1:0230,13<4,8/02,,-./01A-84892. ,1??488/0 23 /::1: 43 ,13<4,843; 2,,-./0 1$ F4891-8 89/:/A/43;23>?28/:426438928:/;2:0
- 9 -
" 9/ 43,40/38 920 1,,-::/0 0-:43; $# 230 2,,-./0 1 F2. 43 ,-.810> 71: 2 5/:410 17 02>. 0-:43;43</.84;2841313.40/:43;89/72,88928136>.?266 J-23848> 17 23@2 F2. 71-30 43 94. 51../..413 6/34/3,> ?2> A/ .91F3 43 94. 72<1-: /2:3/0 ,1-3./6 71: 89/ 255/66238. .-A?48. 8928 2,,-./0 1
92. 26:/20> 0/51.48/089/743/2?1-3817.####
3<4/F1789/04.,-..413?20/2A1</2?17 89/15434138928F946/,1374:?43;89/,13<4,8413172,,-./0 1 71: 89/ 177/3,/. 5-34.92A6/ -30/: /,8413. $# )A* 44 )* 17 89/ ( ,8 6/34/3,> ?2> A/ .91F3 F946/ ./38/3,43; 94? 1F/</: 89/ @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 52../02;243.82,,-./01$A>89/:4261-:84.642A6/81 A/./82.40/ I ,,1:043;6>23.F/:89/2A1</5143852:86>43 89/2774:?284</2305:1,//08152..89/71661F43;
)4* 9/255/264.
- 10 -
)44* 9/ @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 028/0 ##$#$$ 52../0 43 561$!# $#! A> 89/0048413264.8:4,8230/..413.%-0;/ 402: .48843; 28 2.2<2=26>23 2. 2;243.8 2,,-./014.9/:/A>,1374:?/0 )444* 1F/</: 89/ 1:0/: 17 ./38/3,/ 52../0 2;243.82,,-./014.?10474/02.-30/: )2* ,,-./0 1
4. ./38/3,/0 81 -30/:;1.4?56/4?5:4.13?/3871:2 5/:4101702>.2308152>2743/ 17 .#### 43 0/72-68 81 52> 743/ 9/ .9266 -30/:;1 7-:89/: 4?5:4.13?/38 71: 2 5/:410 17 # 02>. 71: 89/ 177/3,/ 5-34.92A6/ -30/: /,8413 $#)A* 44)* 17 ( ,8 )A* ,,-./014./38486/071:./8177 )4<* 9/ 4?5-;3/0 @-0;?/38 17 ,13<4,8413 230 1:0/: 17 ./38/3,/ 52../0 A> 89/ :426 1-:8 2;243.82,,-./01$4. - 11 -
)<* 13./J-/386> 2,,-./0 1$ 4. 2,J-488/0 17 89/ 177/3,/ 5-34.92A6/ -30/: /,8413. $#)A* 44)*17(,8 )<4* 43/ 2?1-38 0/51.48/0 47 23> .9266 A/ :/7-30/0 81 2,,-./0 1$ 13 0-/ 40/38474,28413 /;4.8:> 4. 04:/,8/0 81 ./30 A2,= 89/ :426 1-:8 :/,1:0. 2613; F489 ,15> 17
894. @-0;?/38 71: 4371:?284132303//07-62,8413
!.+ ($$* %
4.8161" (