- 1 - ! " #$" #$ $% "" &%' ( ! " #$% # ! # &'&() $* * ! " # # ! # &'&() Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $* $ ) ! " # # ' ! " #' # $ ' ! + ! #(( # ! # ' ( ! #( # ! # ' % ! # ) # + &$,!&$$,, ! #) ' - 3 - + * (- $ ' !- % ++ %$ + & ) ***$ $!**$ ) ) + +) . + + ) # # / ) 012 / )) $ # / ) 345 066708 9127: 7;<4=1 %$ => <37 =<=: 734;875;<,37:7410><7::7>7::72<=05?<37;<@>=: 53=:< 305 A771 >4872 AB <37 159:01;7 =C601B ;308871D41D <37 E92DC71< 012 0F0:2 20<72 ***$ 605572AB<37714=:4G48)92D7012) +012 7CA7:=> 308H441 =$!**$ - 4 - * +0;<5 D4G41D :457 <= <37 >4841D => <37 066708 A:47>8B 5<0<72 0:7 <30< =1 $*** 0< 0A=9< $' 6C F371 <37 27;70572 0I4C01 08=1D F4<3 345 A:=<37:&41&80F 3:4C7535!=060BB0F056:=;77241D05064884=1:427: =1C=<=:;B;87A70:41D:7D45<:0<4=1 =&$,!&$$,,>:=C <DB08<=308H437:427::4C753F05:4241D<375042 G734;87 0< 0 34D3 56772 012 41 0 :053 012 17D84D71< C0117:97<=<37:05301217D84D71<:4241D=><37:427: =><37G734;87<370;;4271<<==H680;750:7598<=><37 0>=:75042 0;;4271< <37 27;70572 595<04172 D:47G=95 41E9:475F053=564<084J7201259;;9CA72<=<3741E9:475 $ 37 ;804C01<5 >4872 0 67<4<4=1 9127: 7;<4=1 (( => <37 ;< 577H41D ;=C67150<4=1 >=: <37 270<3 => <37 27;7057208=1DF4<341<7:75< ' 6=1 57:G4;7 => 1=<4;7 <37 :756=1271< =5 012 * 06670:72 <3:=9D3 ;=91578 012 >4872 F:4<<71 5<0<7C71< 271B41D<370G7:C71<5C02741<37;804C67<4<4=1 - 5 - 1 <37 A0545 => <37 6870241D5 => <37 60:<475 <37 804C5:4A9108>:0C72<37455975012<37:70><7::7;=:272 <37 7G4271;7 37 :4A9108 AB 4C69D172 E92DC71< 012 0F0:230560:<8B088=F72<37;804C67<4<4=10123782<30< <37 ;804C01<5 0:7 71<4<872 <= 0 ;=C67150<4=1 => 5$$*$(!&08=1DF4<341<7:75<0<<37:0<7=>(K60 012 24:7;<72 <37 :756=1271< =* <= 276=54< <37 ;=C67150<4=1 0C=91< 08=1D F4<3 41<7:75< 741D 0DD:47G72<376:7571<066708305A771>4872 ( 37870:172;=91578>=:<37159:01;7=C601B305 :04572<37>=88=F41D;=1<71<4=15# 0 +4:5<8B 08<3=9D3 <37 ;804C01<5 ;804C <30< <37 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5*!& 67: C=1<3 05 0D:4;98<9:7 80A=9: A9< <37B 30G7 >04872 <= 59A5<01<40<7 <374:;804CF4<35966=:<41D2=;9C71<5=157L971<8B<37 :4A9108 305 05575572 <37 C=1<38B 41;=C7 05 67: <37 414C9C0D75;<,'37:4A910830505575572<37 1=<4=10841;=C7=><3727;70572055'%!&6C45=1 - 6 - <37 34D37: 5427 71;7 5=9D3< >=: :729;<4=1 => <37 ;=C67150<4=1 A 7;=128B 541;7 <37 ;804C01<5 30G7 1=< 75<0A845372 <37 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 <37B 0:7 1=< 71<4<872 >=: ;=C67150<4=1<=F0:25?>9<9:76:=567;<5@ ; 05<8B ;=15427:41D <37 0D7 012 0G=;0<4=1 => <37 27;70572 <37 =G7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A910845=1<3734D37:5427 4<3 <37 0A=G7 ;=1<71<4=15 <37 870:172 ;=91578 5=9D3<<=088=F<37066708 % 7:;=1<:0<37870:172;=91578>=:<37;804C01<5305 :04572<37>=88=F41D;=1<71<4=15# 0 +4:5<8B <37 ;804C01<5 0557:< <30< <37 27;70572 F05 0D720A=9<$B70:50<<37<4C7=><370;;4271<0123020 C=1<38B41;=C7=>5*!&050D:4;98<9:780A=9:37 :4A9108 305 :4D3<8B :78472 96=1 <37 ;30:< 6:760:72 AB 0:10<0H0 <0<7 7D08 7:G4;75 9<3=:4<B 37:7>=:7 <37 C=1<38B 41;=C7 05575572 AB <37 :4A9108 5'%!& 45 E95<012:705=10A87 - 7 - A 7;=128B 05 67: <37 80F 8042 2=F1 AB <37 =1@A87 96:7C7 =9:< 41 <37 ;057 => )" * +! 41 ;0575 F37:7 <37 27;70572 F05 578>& 7C68=B72=::7;74G720>4I725080:B010224<4=1=>'K=> <37 75<0A845372 41;=C7 <=F0:25 ?>9<9:7 6:=567;<5@ 45 F0::01<72 F371 <37 27;70572 F05 A78=F <37 0D7 => ' B70:5 37 5042 6:41;4687 45 :4D3<8B 0668472 <= <37 6:7571< ;057 ; 05<8B =1 066:7;40<4=1 => =:08 012 2=;9C71<0:B 7G4271;7 012 ;=15427:41D <37 0D7 012 0G=;0<4=1 => <37 27;70572 <37 =G7:088 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A910845E95<012:705=10A87 4<3 <37 0A=G7 ;=1<71<4=15 <37 870:172 ;=91578 5=9D3<>=:245C45508=><37066708 70:2 <37 870:172 ;=91578 >=: <37 60:<475 012 67:9572<37E92DC71<0120F0:2=><37:4A9108 - 8 - , <451=<4124569<7<30<27;705720I4C01247241<37 :=02 <:0>>4; 0;;4271< =;;9::72 =1 $*** 297 <=:053 01217D84D71<2:4G41D=><37=>>71241DG734;87AB4<52:4G7: 37 ;804C01<5 ;804C <30< <37 27;70572 F05 70:141D 5*!& 67: C=1<3 =F7G7: <37B >04872 <= 6:=29;7 01B5966=:<41D2=;9C71<5<=59A5<01<40<7<374:;804C1 <370A571;7=>6:==>=>41;=C7012;=15427:41D<370D7=> <37 27;70572 F7 0:7 => <37 =6414=1 <30< <37 1=<4=108 41;=C7 => <37 27;70572 ;01 A7 05575572 =1 <37 A0545 => <37 ;30:< 6:760:72 AB <37 0:10<0H0 7D08 7:G4;7 9<3=:4<B ;;=:241D8B <37 :4A9108 305 :4D3<8B 05575572 <37C=1<38B41;=C7=><3727;705720<5'%!& 37 ;=C67150<4=1 0F0:272 AB <37 :4A9108 =1 <37 =<37:370250:7E95<012:705=10A87 * 1<37:7598<<37>=88=F41D=:27:45605572# - 9 - 0 3706670845 A 37 E92DC71< => <37 804C5 :4A9108 45 ;=1>4:C72 ; 37 159:01;7 =C601B 45 24:7;<72 <= 276=54< <37;=C67150<4=10C=91<08=1DF4<341<7:75<0< (K 67: 0119C >:=C <37 20<7 => >4841D => <37 ;804C67<4<4=1<488<3720<7=>:7084J0<4=1F4<3410 67:4=2=>54IF77H5>:=C<3720<7=>:7;746<=>0 ;=6B=><345E92DC71< 2 37 0C=91< 41 276=54< 45 =:27:72 <= A7 <:015>7::72<=<37:4A9108 ,- &"' $ ,- & $% ' $ 45< =#8 =#