Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92432 (KAR)
MANOHAR v. BIBIBATUL AND ORS
MFA/200877/2022 · 2025-10-15
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92432 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92432 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#!$!%!! !!%%
&'( )* !!%% +
&'(
)
*
!"#
$
%
%
& !$'#(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"#
)
!"#
&
* &
)* $! & &
()
&
% + % ' ($ "
$ ($ )
+)
*
) !"#
%
%
&
- 3 -
!"#
$
!"#
)
!"#
&
*
&
$* &
)
& &
()
&
& % ' ($ "
&
$ ($ )
& &
&
%
&# ,
&
&
%
-
- 4 -
$ -
./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 $
3.8. /==./>8 /0. :<>.1 /4/<782 23. ?5146.72 /71/@/011/2.1 ' ($ "=/88.1;A23.11<2<97/> <820<B2 /71 .88<978 514. /71 9290 BB<1.72 >/<68 0<;57/>9<?/A/=50/<7 9$ (9:$ ) ) 3. :/B28 9: 23. B/8. /0. 23/2 97 ' )$ ) @3<>. 23.B>/<6/72@/8 =09B..1<74<7 58 ;./0<74 0.4<820/2<97 9!$"&!(, :096 /6C3/71< 29 <?/=50 /8 / B9715B290 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. ;58 10<D.7 <2 <7 / 0/83 /717.4><4.726/77.0/71>982B97209>9D.023.8/6./71 1/83.1 29 2.6=9 ;./0<74 9!$'#( =/0C.1 97 23. >.:2 8<1. 9: 23. 09/1 /8 / 0.85>2 9: @3<B3 B>/<6/72 8582/<7.140<.D958<7?50<.8 , 3.0.:90. 3. :<>.1 / B>/<6 =.2<2<97 ;.:90. 23. 0<;57/> B>/<6<74 B96=.78/2<97 9: 8, ! 3. 0<;57/> B978<1.0<74 23. .72<0. .D<1.7B. 97 0.B901
- 5 -
B/>B5>/2.1 B96=.78/2<97 9: 8(#,$(! /71 /8 23.0. @/8B9>><8<97;.2@..758/71.6=9;./0<74.4 9!$'#( =/0C.1 97 23. >.:2 8<1. 9: 23. 09/1 23. ></;<><2A<8:<E.1;9239723.58/7123..6=9<7
23. 0/2<9 9: # , 52 /8 23. B>/<6 /4/<782 0.8=971.72 9)!<D<8<97/>97209>>.0@/84<D.75=<23/8/@/01.1/ B96=.78/2<97 9: 8) ( ! @<23 <72.0.82 /2 #F =/ :09623.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>0./><8/2<97
440<.D.1;A23.8/<1?5146.72/71/@/0123. 7850/7B.96=/7A9:23.2.6=9205BC3/8=0.:.00.1 & 9$ (,'$ ' 1<8=52<74 G5/7256 /8 @.>> /8 ></;<><2A @3.0./823.<7?50.1B>/<6/72@39<8/B9715B290<7 58 3/8 =0.:.00.1 & 9$ "(($ $$ B3/>>.74<74 23. G5/72569:B96=.78/2<97/8@.>>/8></;<><2A #
3. /==.>>/72 <7
& 9$ (,'$ ' ! 7850/7B. 96=/7A 6/<7>A B972.71.1 23/2 23. 2.6=9 @/8 =/0C.1 97 23. >.:2 8<1. 9: 23. 09/1 @<23952 /7A <71<B/2908 /71 23. /BB<1.72 9BB500.1 97>A 15. 29 23. 7.4><4.7B.9:23.10<D.09:23.;58;520.8=971.72
- 6 -
9) @/8 .E97.0/2.1 :096 23. ></;<><2A 7 E$ <2 @/8 82/2.1 23/2 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. ;58 10<D.7 <2 <7 / 0/83 /71 7.4><4.726/77.0/711/83.123.9::.71<74D.3<B>.@3<B3 @/8=/0C.19723.>.:28<1.;901.09:23.09/1/71B3/04. 83..2@/8:<>.1/4/<782;92323.10<D.08/71<2839@823/2
3. @/8 / 6/?90 B9720<;5290 /71 0.8=971.72 9) 3/8 /16<22.1 23/2 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. ;58 B95>1 792 8.. 23. =/0C.1 D.3<B>. 3. 23.90A 9:
<8 29 ;. /==><.12<8:5023.0B972.71.123/223.0<;57/>.00.1<7 40/72<74
23. 6.1<B/> .E=.78.8 29
23. 257. 9: 8#"'$(! 239543 8 ((#"! @/8 />0./1A 0.<6;508.1/7123.0.:90.23.B>/<6/728/0..72<2>.197>A :90 8" (! 29@/018 6.1<B/> .E=.78.8 /71 2358 0.G5.82.1:90691<:<B/2<979:23.<6=547.1?5146.72 ( <7B. 23.
/==.>>/72 <7 & 9$ "(($ $$ ! B>/<6/72 <8 /7 .6=>9A.. 9: 3. 4/D. 5= B>/<6 /4/<782 23. <D<8<97/> 97209>>.0 9: 23.<0 .=/026.72 /71 6/1. B>/<6 97>A /4/<782 23. 9@7.0 /71 <7850.0 9: 23. 2.6=9 205BC . 82/2.1 23/2 23. B9720<;5290A 7.4><4.7B. - 7 -
9: 23. ;58 <7 23. 0/2<9 9: # F <8 29 ;. 8.2 /8<1. 3. 2.6=9205BC@/8=/0C.19723.6<11>.9:23.09/1@<23952 <71<B/2<97 9: /7A ><4328 . @/8 /4.1 , A./08 /71 8582/<7.1 :0/B250. <7?50<.8 /71 23. B96=.78/2<97 571.0
23. 3./1 H=/<7 /71 85::.0<74I <8 6./40. <7B. 3. 8=.72 8 ! 29@/018 6.1<B/> .E=.78.8
23. B96=.78/2<9740/72.129@/0186.1<B/>.E=.78.8<89723. >9@.08<1.&5023.079/69572@/840/72.129@/018>988 9: :5250. ./07<748 /71 >988 9: ./07<74 150<74 >/<1 5= =.0<91 3. B96=.78/2<97 /@/01.1 ;A 23. 0<;57/> <8 <7/1.G5/2. 3.0.:90. 0.G5.82.1 :90 .73/7B.6.72 9: B96=.78/2<97
"
3. 6/77.0 9: /BB<1.72 839@8 23/2 23. B>/<6/72@/820/D.>><74/8B9715B290<7;58/7123. 10<D.09:23.;5810<D.7<2<7/0/83/717.4><4.726/77.0 /71 >982 B97209> 9D.0 23. ;58 /71 23.0.;A 1/83.1 23. 2.6=9;./0<74.49!$'#(=/0C.19723.>.:28<1. 9:23.09/1;52<2@/8=/0C.1@<23952<71<B/2<979:><4328 /718<47/>8
- 8 -
' ./07.1 B9578.> :90 23. /==.>>/72 <7 & 9$ (,'$ '!<7850.09:23.2.6=9205BC/045.123/2 23.2.6=9@/8=/0C.19723.>.:28<1.9:23.09/1/71792 97 23. 6<11>. 9: 23. 09/1 /8 82/2.1 ;A 23. B>/<6/72 /71
23. 7.4><4.7B. <8 97 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. ;58 8 85B3 23. B9720<;5290A7.4><4.7B.<80<432>A/88.88.1/8# , /71<2 7..1879<72.0:.0.7B. 90.9D.023.B3/04.83..2<8:<>.1 /4/<78210<D.089:;92323.D.3<B>.8 ./07.1 B9578.> :90 23. /==.>>/72 <7 & 9$ "(($ $$JB>/<6/720.><.15=97.B2<979:23. 5>.8 9: 23. 9/1 .45>/2<978 '"' @3<B3 0./18 /8 :9>>9@8
! ! ! - 9 -
!"#$
! !!"
"
" % & '
! "
"
!" ! ! " # " # !" # $
- 10 -
. B972.71.1 23/2 6.0. =/0C<74 9: 23. D.3<B>. 97 23.7/2<97/>3<43@/A<28.>:<8792=.06<88<;>.885B323. .72<0. 7.4><4.7B. <8 97 23. 82/2<97.1 2.6=9 @3<B3 @/8 =/0C.1@<23952<71<B/2<979:><4328 ./>890.><.15=9723.?5146.729:23.97I;>. 5=0.6. 9502 <7 !! ()
) ;.2@..7 *+ /71 , ! - & . / 0 1/2.1' '$ $,<7@3<B3<2@/83.>123/2/BB<1.72@/8 9BB500.1 15. 29 23. 89>. 7.4><4.7B. 9: 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. 9::.71<7482/2<97.1205BC@3<B3@/8=/0C.1<723.6<11>. 9: 23. 09/1 2 <8 792 23. B/8. 9: 23. 0.8=971.728 23/2 =/0C<74><43289:23.82/71<74D.3<B>.@.0.979023.0.@/8 /7A 923.0 <71<B/2<97 97 23. ;/BC8<1. 9: 23. D.3<B>. 82/71<749723.09/129.7/;>.23.B96<74D.3<B>.298.. 23.82/71<74205BC $ D.7<723.=0.8.72B/8.23.2.6=9205BC@/8 82/2<97.19723.>.:28<1.9:23.09/1;5279=/0C<74><4328 @.0.8@<2B3.1973./BB<1.729BB500.1/2(,=68 85B3 23.0.
<8 79 =988<;<><2A :90 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. - 11 -
;5829792<B.23.205BC@3<B3@/8=/0C.19723.>.:28<1. 9: 23. 09/1 8 85B3 23<8 9502 :<718 23/2 23. .72<0. 7.4><4.7B.<89723.2.6=9205BC@3<B3@/882/2<97.197
23. >.:2 8<1. 9: 23. 09/1 @<23952 /7A <71<B/2908 /71 23. ></;<><2A:<E.19723.10<D.029/7.E2.729:# F<8 29;.8.2/8<1.9195;2B3/04.83..2@/8:<>.1/4/<782 ;92323.10<D.08/823.0.@/8B9>><8<979:;92323.D.3<B>.8 ;52 <7 D<.@ 9: 23. /;9D. 1<8B588<97 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 :<E 23. .72<0. ></;<><2A 97 23. 10<D.0 9: 23. 82/2<97.12.6=9 ) E# <8 23. %9571 .02<:<B/2. /BB901<74 29 @3<B323.B>/<6/728582/<7.123.:9>>9@<74<7?50<.8@3<B3 /0.40<.D958<77/250. 966<752.1:0/B250.=09E<6/>)0183/:2 2<;</:0/B250.0<4328<2. $ .46.72/>:0/B250.:<;5>/0<4328<1.83/:2
- 12 -
, 978<1.0<7423.7/250.9:<7?50<.88582/<7.1/71 23.20./26.72571.0497.23<89502:<718<20./897/;>.29 /@/01 / 856 9: 8 ! :90 =/<7 /71 85::.0<748* 8 ! :90 >988 9: /6.7<2<.8 /71 / 856 9:
8) ! :90 20/78=902/2<97 .E20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72B3/04.8
3. 0<;57/> 3/8 /@/01.1 / 856 9:
8#"'$(! :90 6.1<B/> .E=.78.8 7 23<8 0.4/01 >./07.1 B9578.> :90 0.8=971.72!7850/7B. 96=/7A B972.71.1 23/2 /8 =.0 E J .1<B/> .<6;508.6.72 .22.0 / 856 9: 8 ((#"! @/8 0.<6;508.1 29 23. B>/<6/72 3. B>/<6/72 /16<28 23. 8/6. <7 3<8 B0988! .E/6<7/2<97 3.0.:90. 23<8 9502:<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 40/7297>A8" (!29@/0186.1<B/>.E=.78.8 # 3. B96=.78/2<97 /@/01.1 ;A 23. 0<;57/> <8 691<:<.1/8571.0
- 13 -
> 9 ./18 @/01;A23. 0<;57/> @/01;A23<8 9502
7?50A =/<7 /71 85::.0<74 8 ! 8 ! $
.1<B/> E=.78.8 8#"'$(! 8" (! ) 0/78=902/2<97 .E20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72 B3/04.8 8$ ! 8) ! , 988 9: /6.7<2<.8 8 ! 8 ! 92/> 8(#,$(! 8)# (! 3.0.@<>>;.0.15B2<979:8,,((#"! ( 723.0.85>223.:9>>9@<74901.0<8=/88.1 < 923 23. /==./>8 /0. 1 ! <<
3. B>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 292/> B96=.78/2<979:8)# (!@<23<72.0.82/2 #F=.0/7756:09623.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>23. 1/2.9:0./><K/2<97
- 14 -
<<< 3. 7850/7B. 96=/7A <8 1<0.B2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. /:90.8/<1 B96=.78/2<97 /69572 />974 @<23 <72.0.82 @<23<7 97. 69723 :096 23. 1/2.9:23<8?5146.72 <D
7 85B3 1.=98<2 23. B>/<6/72 <8 =.06<22.129@<2310/@23..72<0./69572/>974 @<23<72.0.82/BB05.197<2
81! &%!! ( $
<829>9'