- 1 - !" # $!%!&!! !!&& '() * ! " # $ %% !!! &!!! " # '( !! ! )$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' *&# $ ' ' ) !!! ' !*! % ' ' ) + % ,-./01,-.234,5067897016:/,6 1:6 -;;,-< :6 8:<,/ -2-:560 01, =3/24,50 -5/ ->-./ /-0,/ !!! ;-66,/ 9? 01, //:0:75-< ,5:7. :@:< 3/2, -5/ :=-?-;3.- :5 7!*78! % & 1, 8-A06 78 01, A-6, -., 01-0 75 ! ! >1:<, 01, A<-:4-50 >-6 .,03.5:52 8.74 7<-;3. -80,. A74;<,0:75 78 1:6 ;.:@-0, >7.B 75 4707.A?A<, 9,-.:52 .,2:60.-0:75 7 & !*! 01, /.:@,. 78 01, .3AB 9,-.:52 ,2 7 ! /.7@, :0 :5 1:21 6;,,/ -5/ .-61 -5/ 5,2<:2,50 4-55,. -5/ /-61,/ -2-:560 01, - 3 - A<-:4-50C64707.A?A<,/3,07>1:A11,6360-:5,/2.:,@736 :5=3.:,6 % 1,.,87.,01,:5=3.,/A<-:4-50-2,/&?,-.6 8:<,/ - A<-:4 ;,0:0:75 9,87., 01, .:935-< A<-:4:52 A74;,56-0:75786!!!!!!1,.:935-<A756:/,.:52 01, ,50:., ,@:/,5A, 75 .,A7./ 2.-50,/ A74;,56-0:75 78 6 **&!! >:01 :50,.,60 -0 DE ;- 8.74 01, /-0, 78 ;,0:0:75 0:<< .,-<:6-0:75 -5/ /:.,A0,/ .,6;75/,50 7 563.-5A,74;-5?07/,;76:001,6-4, 22.:,@,/9?01,6-:/=3/24,50-5/->-./01, :5=3.,/ A<-:4-50 1-6 ;.,8,..,/ 01:6 -;;,-< :5 >1:A1 :0 :6 A750,5/,/ 01-0 01, -47350 ->-./,/ 9? 01, .:935-< :6 :5-/,F3-0, 1, -;;,<<-50 >-6 -2,/ * ?,-.6 , 6360-:5,/:5=3.?0701,6;:5-<A7./-5/-6;,.01,,@:/,5A, 78 0.,-0,/ /7A07. -5/ /:6-9:<:0? A,.0:8:A-0, 1, 6360-:5,/ E/:6-9:<:0?0701,>17<,97/?93001,.:935-<,..,/:5 0-B:52 01, 6-4, -0 E 17321 1, >-6 ,-.5:52 6 !!! ;,. 47501 01, .:935-< ,..,/ :5 0-B:52 1:6 - 4 - :5A74,-06%!!!;,.475011,.,87.,.,F3,60,/87. ,51-5A,4,507801,A74;,56-0:75 6 ;,. G%>735/ A,.0:8:A-0, 01, -;;,<<-50 1-66360-:5,/01,87<<7>:52:5=3.:,6 $ &-5/%,.0,9.-639<3G-0:75 $ 74;735/8.-A03.,%,.0,9.- &$ 74;.,66:758.-A03.,%,.0,9.- 6 ;,. 01, ,@:/,5A, 78 )7A07. 01, -;;,<<-50 6360-:5,/ E/:6-9:<:0?07 01, >17<,97/? 1, .:935-< 1-6 0-B,5 &./ 78 E -6 E 930 -/4:00,/<? 1, 6360-:5,/ :5=3.? 07 01, 6;:5, 6 ;,. 01, ,@:/,5A, 78 01, 7A07. 01, -;;,<<-50 6360-:5,/ 8.-A03., 78 % ,.0,9.- 1,.,87., 01:6 73.0 8:5/6 :0 .,-675-9<, 07 ,51-5A, 01, /:6-9:<:0? 07 !E 17321 -;;,<<-50 60-0,/ 01-0 1, >-6 ,-.5:52 6 !!! ;,. 47501 1, 1-6 570 8:<,/ -5? :5A74, ;.778 1,.,87., -6 ;,. 01, 23:/,<:5,6 78 01, -.5-0-B-0-0,,2-<,.@:A,6 3017.:0?-61,4,0>:01 -5 -AA:/,50 75 ! ! 1:6 570:75-< :5A74, :6 07 9, - 5 - 0-B,5 -0 6!! ;,. 47501 1, 43<0:;<:,. 78 * -/7;0,/9?01,.:935-<:6=360-5/;.7;,.1,.,87.,01, <766788303.,,-.5:526A74,6076 &!!#6!!G G *G !E$ * 1,.:935-<1-6->-./,/-634786*!! 07>-./6 4,/:A-< ,G;,56,6 -5/ 01,., :6 57 /:6;30, .,2-./:5201,6-4,,5A,01:673.08:5/657.,-67507 :50,.8,.,>:0101,6-4, 1, -;;,<<-50 >-6 -/4:00,/ 07 01, 176;:0-< 75 !% ! -5/ /:6A1-.2,/ 75 ! ! -5/ 1, >-6 :5;-0:,50 87. 6:G /-?6 756:/,.:52 01, 5-03., 78 :5=3.:,6 -5/;,.:7/78176;:0-<:6-0:7501:673.08:5/6:0.,-675-9<, 072.-50-5-47350786!!!!87.;-:5-5/6388,.:52 6&!!!! 87. <766 78 -4,5:0:,6 -5/ 6&!!!! 87. 0.-56;7.0-0:75,G0.-573.:614,50-5/-00,5/-50A1-.2,6 D 1, -;;,<<-50 4:210 570 1-@, -00,5/,/ -5? >7.B -0 <,-60 87. - ;,.:7/ 78 01.,, 475016 /3, 07 01, :5=3.:,66360-:5,/1,.,87.,01:673.08:5/6:0.,-675-9<, - 6 - 072.-50-5-47350786 D!!#6!!G&$87.<766 78:5A74,/3.:52<-:/3;;,.:7/ ! ,5A,01,-;;,<<-50:6,50:0<,/87.01,47/:8:,/ A74;,56-0:7535/,./:88,.,501,-/6-69,<7> -:5-5/6388,.:52 6!!!! ,/:A-<,G;,56,6 6*!! .-56;7.0-0:75 ,G0.- 573.:614,50 -5/-00,5/-50A1-.2,6 6&!!!! 76678:5A74,/3.:52<-:/3;;,.:7/ 6 D!! 766788303.,,-.5:526 6 &!! 76678-4,5:0:,6 6&!!!! 70-< ,66->-./,/9?.:935-< 51-5A,4,50 6&&%!! 6 **&!! +" 136 01, -;;,<<-50 :6 ,50:0<,/ 87. ,51-5A,/ A74;,56-0:75 78 6 *&!! >:01 :50,.,60 -0 E ;,. -5534-5/01,.,87.,01,-;;,-</,6,.@,6079,-<<7>,/:5 ;-.0 501,.,63<001,87<<7>:527./,.:6;-66,/ #:$ ;;,-<:6-<<7>,/:5;-.0 #::$ 1, -;;,<<-50A<-:4-50 :6 ,50:0<,/ 87. 01, ,51-5A,/ A74;,56-0:75 78 6 *&!! >:01 :50,.,60 -0 - 7 - E ;,. -5534 8.74 01, /-0, 78 ;,0:0:75 0:<< 01, /-0, 78 .,-<:6-0:75 7>,@,. -6;,.7./,. /-0,/ !! 01, -;;,<<-50:6570,50:0<,/87.:50,.,6087.01,/,<-?,/;,.:7/ 78D/-?6:58:<:5201,-;;,-< #:::$ ,6;75/,50 7563.-5A, 74;-5? :6 /:.,A0,/ 07 /,;76:0 01, -87.,6-:/ A74;,56-0:75 -47350 >:01:575,475018.7401,/-0,7801:6=3/24,50 #:@$ 5 63A1 /,;76:0 01, -;;,<<-50 :6 ;,.4:00,/ 07 >:01/.-> 01, ,50:., -47350 -<752 >:01 :50,.,60 -AA.3,/ 75:0 +,- '&!! ) % :60 7 < 7D%