Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92421 (KAR)
SHREEDEVI v. JEEVANKUMAR AND ANR
MFA/201147/2021 · 2025-10-29
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92421 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92421 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$! % &!$! % &!#&' #
! !$$
(')
*
!"
#
$ %
"
&
' &
"
!"
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
('
)
"!"
#
$"*+
' %
'
'
",($"% '
"- %'
.-" " ' '
'
%
& ' &
""!" .-" !"
'
'
/",-.!! &
.0 /(,!!!!! &
"0
'
&
1
1
- 3 -
& $ 1
%
23/ 455647 89:6; 6<=3>9 ",($"% >? =26 >=>; 623<76/<="-$26;6394?=6;;6?6;;6:=>4/@=26<=A?>; /2>;=%24/B669?376:BC=2645567749=B639D4DD;36E6:BC =26F8:DG69=49:4H4;::4=6:""!"54//6:BC=26 ::7 693>; 3E37 8:D6 49: ' 3:4; 39 >.-" !"
'4<=/ D3E39D ;3/6 => =26 ?3739D >? =26 455647 B;36?7C/=4=6:4;6=24=>9!!"4=4B>8=-(!5G =26 :6<64/6: 4FI8G4; 39 >.-" !" H269 =26 :6<64/6:H4/5;><66:39D3948=>B64;39D;6D3/=;4=3>9> ( ,- =>H4;:/ 24GB>7 E3774D6 => 4==69: =26 ?89<=3>94=24GB>7E3774D64==24==3G6=26:;3E6;>?=26 48=> H4/ :;3E39D 39 4 ;4/249:96D73D69= G4996; :86 => >E6; /566: 48=> ?677 :>H9 39 4 ;3E6; / 4 ;6/87= >? =26 4?>;6/43: 39<3:69= :6<64/6: 4FI8G4; 39F8;6: D;36E>8/7C 49:/8<<8GB6:=>=2639F8;36/
- 4 -
( 26<743G49=/?376:456=3=3>989:6;6<=3>9".. >? =26 <= /66I39D <>G569/4=3>9 ?>; =26 :64=2 >? =26 :6<64/6:47>9DH3=239=6;6/=
9 /6;E3<6 >? /8GG>9/ =26 ;6/5>9:69= > 45564;6: =2;>8D2 <>89/67 49: ?376: H;3==69 /=4=6G69= :69C39D =26 4E6;G69=/ G4:6 39 =26 <743G 56=3=3>9
26 ;6/5>9:69= >" :3: 9>= 45564; B6?>;6 =26
;3B8947 39 /53=6 >? /6;E3<6 >? 9>=3<6 49: 269<6 26 H4/ 574<6: 6J 54;=669<6/>8D2=?>;:3/G3//47>?=2656=3=3>9
9=26B4/3/>?=265764:39D/>?=2654;=36/=26 743G/
;3B8947?;4G6:=263//86/49:=26;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=26 6E3:69<6
26 <743G49= 39 >;:6; => 5;>E6 =26 <4/6 G>=26;>?:6<64/6:3/6J4G396:4/&"49:D>=G4;I6:
:><8G69=/ 94G67C J" => J- 9 B6247? >? ;6/5>9:69=/ 9/8;49<6 >G549C 6J4G396: 3=/ >??3<347 4/ &" 49:
3:4; H4/ 6J4G396: 4/ & 49: D>= G4;I6::><8G69=/94G67CJ"=>J,
26743G/ ;3B8947BC=263G58D96:F8:DG69=267:=24=
- 5 -
=264<<3:69==>>I 574<6 >9 4<<>89= >? ;4/2 49:96D73D69= :;3E39D>?=26>??69:39DE623<76BC3=/:;3E6;4/4;6/87=>? H23<2=26:6<64/6:/8/=4396:39F8;36/49:/8<<8GB6:=> =2639F8;36/
26
;3B8947?8;=26;267:=24==26<743G49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 <>G569/4=3>9 >? /",-.!! 47>9D H3=2 39=6;6/= 4= =26 ;4=6 >? .0 54 49: :3;6<=6: =26 ;6/5>9:69= >" => :65>/3= =26 <>G569/4=3>9 4G>89= 47>9D H3=2 39=6;6/= 639D 4DD;36E6: BC =26 /4G6 =23/ 45564724/B669?376:
. 26764;96:<>89/67?>;=26<743G49=24/;43/6: =26?>77>H39D<>9=69=3>9/ 4% '3;/=7C2624/<>9=69:6:=24=4/>9=26:4=6>? 4<<3:69= 49: =26 :6<64/6: H4/ 64;939D /!!!! 56;
G>9=28==26
;3B894724/4 6:=269>=3>94739<>G6 >?=26:6<64/6:4//.!!! H23<23/>97>H6;/3:6 B% 6<>9:7C 26 24/ <>9=69:6: =24= 4/ 56; =26 F8:DG69= >? =26 >9AB76 85;6G6 >8;= 39 =26 <4/6 >? - 6 -
64<2 >? =26 <743G49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: ?>; <>G569/4=3>9 >? / !!!! 89:6; =26 264: >?@7>//>?7>E649:4??6<=3>949:<>9/>;=38GA
9 ;6/56<= >? 734B373=C 26 24/ /8BG3==6: =24= 6E69 =2>8D2=26:;3E6;>?=26>??69:39DE623<76H4/9>=24E39D E473:49:6??6<=3E6:;3E39D73<69<639/8;6:24/E3>74=6:=26 5>73<C<>9:3=3>9/49:=269/8;49<6>G549C3/9>=734B76 =>54C<>G569/4=3>99;6/56<=>?<743G49=3/<>9<6;96:
=26 9/8;49<6 >G549C 24/ => 54C =26 <>G569/4=3>9 4G>89= H3=2 73B6;=C => ;6<>E6; ?;>G =26 >H96; >?
=26 >??69:39D E623<76 9 /855>;= >? 23/ <>9=69=3>9 26 24/ ;6736:>9=26F8:DG69=>?>9AB7656J>8;=39=26<4/6 >? !"
#$%&' ' (!)" * +& +, !" )#$%&';65>;=6:39-.49:39=26<4/6>?%/ !"('' &!0%)+!1(+(#%"'2%33//!" )#$%&';65>;=6:3945*67
, 64;96: <>89/67 45564;39D ?>; 9/8;49<6 >G549C24/;43/6:=26<>9=69=3>9/+
- 7 -
4% '3;/=7C 6E69 =2>8D2 =26 <743G49= 24/ <743G6:
=24==26:6<64/6:H4/64;939D/!!!! 56;G>9=2=26 /4G63/9>=6/=4B73/26:BC=26<743G49=BC5;>:8<39D49C :><8G69=/
26;6?>;6 =26
;3B8947 24/ ;3D2=7C 4 6:
=269>=3>94739<>G6>?=26:6<64/6:4//.!!! 5G
B% 6<>9:7C 26 24/ <>9=69:6: =24= <>9/3:6;39D =26 4D6 49: 4E><4=3>9 >? =26 :6<64/6: =26 >E6;477 <>G569/4=3>9 4H4;:6: BC =26
;3B8947 3/ F8/= 49: ;64/>94B76
<% 23;:7C 26 24/ <>9=69:6: =24= 39 ;6/56<= >? 734B373=C 3= 3/ 9>= 39 :3/58=6 =26 :;3E6; >? =26 >??69:39D E623<76H4/9>=24E39DE473:49:6??6<=3E6:;3E39D73<69<6 39<6 39/8;6: 24/ E3>74=6: =26 5>73<C <>9:3=3>9/ =26 9/8;49<6>G549C3/9>=734B76=>54C<>G569/4=3>9
26 ;3B8947 24/ ;3D2=7C 6J>96;4=6: =26 9/8;49<6 >G549C 69<626/>8D2=?>;:3/G3//47>?=26455647
64;: =26 764;96: <>89/67 ?>; =26 54;=36/ 49:
56;8/6:=26F8:DG69=49:4H4;:>?=26
;3B8947
- 8 -
- =3/9>=39:3/58=6=24=:6<64/6:4FI8G4;:36: 39=26;>4:=;4??3<4<<3:69=><<8;;6:>9!!":86=> ;4/2 49:96D73D69= :;3E39D >? =26 >??69:39D E623<76 BC 3=/ :;3E6;B64;39D;6D3/=;4=3>9>( ,-
"! 26 <743G49= 24/ <743G6: =24= =26 :6<64/6:
H4/ 64;939D /!!!! 56; G>9=2 8= =26C 24E6 9>= 5;>:8<6: 49C :><8G69=/ => 5;>E6 =26 39<>G6 >? =26 :6<64/6:9=264B/69<6>?5;>>?>?39<>G6=269>=3>947 39<>G624/=>B64 6:/56;=26D83:67396/3//86:
BC =26 4;94=4I4 =4=6 6D47 6;E3<6/ 8=2>;3=C =26 39<>G64=/!!! 5G?>;=264<<3:69==4I69574<639 =26C64;!"24/=>B6=4I6939=><>9/3:6;4=3>9 !024/ =>B64::6:>94<<>89=>??8=8;65;>/56<=/39E36H>?=26 74H 743: :>H9 BC =26 >9/=3=8=3>9 69<2 >? =26 85;6G6 >8;=39=26<4/6>? 8 2 9
9
77
28/ =26 G>9=27C 39<>G6 <>G6/ => /""!! $/!!! J !0%
- 9 -
"" =3/ 455;>5;34=6 => :6:8<= " (;: >?=26 39<>G6 >?=26:6<64/6:=>H4;:/56;/>9476J569/6/49:;6G43939D 4G>89=24/=>B6=4I694/23/<>9=;3B8=3>9=>=26?4G37C 26:6<64/6:H4/4D6:4B>8=C64;/4==26=3G6>?=26 4<<3:69=49:G87=35736;45573<4B76=>23/4D6D;>853/@"A 28/ =26 <743G49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: => <>G569/4=3>9 >? /"."!! $/""!!K"K"K (% >9 4<<>89= >? @7>//>?:6569:69<CA
" 9 4::3=3>9 =26 <743G49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: => <>G569/4=3>9>?/"!!! >94<<>89=>?@7>//>?6/=4=6A 49: <>G569/4=3>9 >? /"!!! >9 4<<>89= >? @?896;47 6J569/6/A
"( >9/3:6;39D =26 <>G569/4=3>9 4H4;:6: BC =26 ;3B894789:6;=26>=26;264:/3/F8/=49:;64/>94B76
" 9 =26 39/=49<6 <4/6 ;6/5>9:69= > 24/ 5;>E6: =24= =26 :;3E6; >? =26 >??69:39D E623<76 H4/ 9>= 24E39DE473:49:6??6<=3E6:;3E39D73<69<64/>9=26:4=6>?
=26 4<<3:69=
26 ;6/5>9:69= > 3/ 9>= 734B76 => 54C
- 10 -
<>G569/4=3>9 => =26 56=3=3>96;/ :G3==6:7C =26 /43: E623<76H4/39/8;6:H3=2;6/5>9:69=>9E36H>?=26 74H 743::>H9BC=26>9AB7656J>8;=39
<4/6 $/85;4%=269/8;49<6>G549C=>54C=26<>G569/4=3>9 4H4;:6: BC =26 =;3B8947 => =26 56=3=3>96;/ 4= =26 ?3;/= 39/=49<6H3=2473B6;=C=>;6<>E6;=26/4G6?;>G=26>H96; >?=26E623<76394<<>;:49<6H3=274H
"
28/=26<743G49=/4;669=3=76:=>=26?>77>H39D <>G569/4=3>9 +,-./012. 3.4-542-5-.1 -04/ +3.12. (/) >//>?:6569:69<C
"."!! '896;476J569/6/
"!!! >//>?6/=4=6
"!!! >//>?<>9/>;=38G !!!! 106 7 7
". 9=26;6/87==26?>77>H39D>;:6;3/54//6:
- 11 -
4% 264556473/0668-42.,051 B% 26 F8:DG69= >? =26 743G/
;3B8947 3/ G>:3?36: <% 26 <743G49=/ 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 =>=47 <>G569/4=3>9 >? /
7 79 4/ 4D439/= /",-.!! 4H4;:6: BC =26 ;3B8947 :% 26 9/8;49<6 >G549C 3/ :3;6<=6: => :65>/3= =26 <>G569/4=3>9 4G>89= 47>9D H3=2 39=6;6/= 4= .0 54 ?;>G =26 :4=6 >? ?3739D >? =26 <743G 56=3=3>9 =377 =26 :4=6 >? ;6473L4=3>9 H3=239 4 56;3>: >? /3J H66I/ ?;>G =26 :4=6 >? ;6<635= >? <>5C >? =23/ F8:DG69= 49: ;6<>E6; =26 /4G6 ?;>G ;6/5>9:69= >" 3B6;=C 3/ ;6/6;E6: => ;6/5>9:69= > => ;6<>E6; =26 <>G569/4=3>9 4G>89= ?;>G ;6/5>9:69= >"394<<>;:49<6H3=274H
- 12 -
6% 9 E36H >? =26 >;:6; :4=6: -"!! 54//6:BC=23/>8;==26<743G49=/4;69>= 69=3=76: ?>; 39=6;6/= >9 =26 69249<6:
<>G569/4=3>9 ?>; =26 :674C6: 56;3>: >? ((:4C/39?3739D=26455647
!49 ($!) &
!49 (#&' #) &
3/=>"7>,