Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92419 (KAR)
THE CHIEF ENGINEER AND ANR v. THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER,
MSA/200213/2021 · 2025-12-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92419 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92419 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$ %%
&' (
! "
#
$ $
!$$
%
&
'(! '
( ! &
'%)! '
&
'%%! '
*
&$ '%)!'
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+
$$,&
'%)!' &-, " #
%
!- $
. $$
%+"
$
( "
# ! ,
-$
,! -
+& ' &+& /
/$!$
$
! -$ ,
'
$' /$-$$
$ 012344536127890575:5;1<13=152751:>3>>=15?5@78 905AB@>C5:93:@D=@5=@395@+43225@1:
D+& D: 905 ;165 D; 905 @@191D:36 129=1<9 3637B=3>1E05=51:3;95==5;5==5@9D32905F44566395DB=9G ;D= 7=5?198H
78 I01<0 905 44566395 DB=9
I0165 43=968 366DI1:>905344536
032CD@1;15@905AB@>C5:93:@3I3=@ @395@*43225@1: D+(&%D:905;165 D;5:1D=1?16-B@>5
63:@E05=51:3;95==5;5==5@9D32905
- 3 -
F5;5=5:<5DB=9G;D=7=5?198H5:03:<1:>905<DC45:2391D:
3CDB:9 1: =5245<9 D; 905 3<JB1=5@ I59 63:@ ;=DC 2
*
&45=3<=59D2*
+
(&45=3<=5
B7A5<9C3995=D;9053<JB12191D:1290563:@1: 8 D(&% C532B=1:> 3<=5 %% >B:932 219B395@ 39 -3I361 ?1663>5 D; 63:@ 936BK
3637B=3>1 @129=1<9 I01<0 I323<JB1=5@;D=9054B=4D25D;C3=A3=DA5<91:95=C2D;
:D91;1<391D:@395@)122B5@B:@5=5<91D:( "D;
9053:@<JB12191D:<9
)(E05=51:3;95==5;5==5@9D32 905F<9
)(F;D=7=5?198H0545<1363:@<JB12191D: ;;1<5=03@43225@9053I3=@@395@;1L1:>905 C3=K59?36B5D;9054=D45=98392
&45=3<=53:@ D: =5;5=5:<5 B:@5= 5<91D: D; 905 <9
)(
905 5;5=5:<5DB=95:03:<5@905C3=K59?36B5D;90563:@9D 2
*
& 45= 3<=5 ?1@5 D=@5= @395@ * 1:
D+(&%:;B=905=344536
90544566395DB=9 =5681:> B4D: 905 AB@>C5:9 3:@ 3I3=@ 43225@ 1:
D+&* 5:03:<5@ 905 C3=K59 ?36B5 D; 905 63:@ 9D 2*
+
(&45=3<=5
- 4 -
% 05653=:5@<DB:256;D=9053445663:922B7C192 9039 905 3I3=@ 9039 I32 43225@ 1:
D+&* 78 ;1L1:>905<DC45:2391D:*
+
(&45=3<=5D;I5963:@ 032755:431@3:@23912;15@78905=524D:@5:92&<631C3:92 3:@ 905=5 032 755: :D <03665:>5 9D 905 23C5 53=:5@ <DB:256 0DI5?5= 2B7C192 9039 905 DB=9 I0165 5:03:<1:> 905 <DC45:2391D: 032 93K5: 905 =395 D; @5 52<36391D: 39 %M 45= 3::BC I01<0 032 9D 75 M 36<B6395@ 32 2B<0
905 <DC45:2391D: 4383765 IDB6@ 75 *
+
(&1:2953@D;*
(%
+ ( 53=:5@<DB:256;D=9053445663:92=5681:>B4D: 905 AB@>C5:9 @395@ +( 43225@ 1:
1: 905 <325 D; ?22B7C19290399054=525:9 <32512<D?5=5@78905231@D=@5=
1:I01<09012DB=9032 =5@B<5@ 905 =395 D; <DC45:2391D: ;=DC *
+
(& 9D *
(%
+&1:?15ID;905AB@>C5:943225@1:905<325 D; ! " #$% ?2 & '( )* #$! 1: )
- 5 -
+ ,
- ,. I05=51: 905 3<JB12191D:
I32 B:@5= 905 D91;1<391D: @395@ ( ;D= 905 21C163=4B=4D252219B395@1:90521C163=?1663>552B7C192 9039 21:<5 905=5 I32 @1;;5=5:<5 D; D:5 853= 759I55: 905
D91;1<391D: 2B7A5<9 C3995= D; !
<325 2B4=3" 3:@ D91;1<391D: 2B7A5<9 C3995= D; 231@ 344536
M @5 52<36391D:I32>=3:95@905=578=5@B<1:>905<DC45:2391D: 431@3237D?5
5 2B7C192 44566395 DB=9 1:2953@ D; 93K1:> M @552<36391D: 03@ 93K5: D:68 %M @552<36391D: 3:@ 9039 1; <DC45:2391D: 3I3=@5@ 78 905 44566395 DB=9 12 =5@B<5@ 78 93K1:> M @552<36391D: 4B=4D25 D; ;161:> D;
905 344536 IDB6@ 75 25=?5@ 5 ;B=905= 2B7C192 9039 905 <DC45:2391D: 3I3=@5@ 1: $ D%&( 032 36=53@8 755: 431@ 3:@ 23912;15@ 3:@ 23C5 032 39931:5@ ;1:36198 * 53=:5@ <DB:256 ;D= 905 =524D:@5:9&<631C3:9 @D52 :D9 @124B95 905 3;D=5231@ ;3<9B36 3245<9 D; 905 C3995=1:<5905D=@5=1:$ D%&(1243225@
- 6 -
1:=5245<9D;905?5=823C5 D91;1<391D:@395@) 1:=5245<9D;90563:@I01<012219B395@1:-3I361?1663>5 63:@36BK
3637B=3>1129=1<9
9012DB=9@D:D92553:8 =532D:9D@1;;5=;=DC905=395D;<DC45:2391D:3I3=@5@1: $ D%&( + :9039?15ID;905C3995=
905;D66DI1:>'
1" 0534453612'/ 11" 05 =395 D; <DC45:2391D: 12 CD@1;15@ 3:@ =5@B<5@ ;=DC *
+
(& 9D *
(%
+ 4383765I1903662939B9D=875:5;192
9 12 C3@5 <653= 9039 1; 905=5 75 3:8 @5638 78 =524D:@5:9&<631C3:9 1: 4=5;5==1:> 905 344536 75;D=5 905 44566395 DB=9 905 23C5 20DB6@ 75 5L<6B@5@ ;D= <36<B6391D:D;1:95=529D:905<DC45:2391D:
)* &' $
$ 129 D'6 D' 9'4K